Claremont School Board, August 21, 2019

Regular meeting a week before school opened: the board received the Claremont School District's fiscal 2016 audit report, with fiscal 2017 and 2018 still under audit and an abatement of IRS penalties expected; heard that Richard Seaman would start as business administrator on October 2; elected 33 new teachers; approved the 2019-20 calendar; moved the student discipline policy JICD to second reading; appointed Alex Herzog to the CCTV board; and tentatively approved the student handbooks it had received that day. The page is built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript; no agenda, packet or minutes survive in the district's online shares. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board
Date
Wednesday, August 21, 2019
Start time
Not stated. The chair calls "the school board meeting of August 21st, 2019 to order" at 0:00:47; the superintendent says the administrative team met "at 330 to 6:00, right, right here" just before (0:14:38), so the board met after 6:00 p.m. Adjourned at 1:28:59. The dialogue transcript runs 1:30:41. No nonpublic session was held.
Location
Not stated in available records; the room is the one the administrators had used that afternoon (0:14:38).
Recording
Cablecast: SCHOOL BOARD meeting 8-21-19 (show 10506; transcript length 1:30:41)
Minutes
None located. MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting: neither share holds a year folder older than 2022, and the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023 (checked 9/26/26). The board approved these minutes at its next meeting, on September 4, 2019.
Board composition
Six of seven present. The clerk's roll (0:01:29) reads Jason Benwell here. [Benware], Rob Lovett Jr., Michael. Patron. [Petrin], Heather Whitney, Carol Ann toll [Carolyn Towle] and Frank spike [Sprague]. Vice chair Rebecca Zullo is absent: "And Rebecca's not here" (0:11:46).

Participants

Everyone heard or addressed on the recording. Spellings follow the project's 2015-2023 roster where the transcript garbles a name; there are no minutes to check spellings against. Speaker labels come from the dialogue file and its attribution report.
NameRoleParticipation
Frank SpragueChairRuns the meeting ("It's hard to participate in the meeting and run it both.", 0:12:30); opens citizens' comments though they were left off the agenda; moves the tentative handbook approval himself (1:09:16); reports on the lead-free committee and the NHSBA resolution process.
Jason BenwareMemberCorrects the wording of the July 30 minutes (0:03:12); moves the discipline policy to second reading, the teacher slate and the donations; questions lost ID badges (1:03:42) and facility plans; says he once charged more for driver education than the new contract does (1:09:03). Transcribed Jason Benwell.
Carolyn TowleMemberAsks about dual enrollment and the competency grading system; asks whether the audit is "somewhat of a forensic audit?" (0:34:38); received the handbooks only that day (1:06:03); proposes a capital improvement member on the budget committee; accepts the NHSBA delegate role (1:24:09).
Rob Lovett Jr.MemberPresents the capital improvement program list and LED lighting proposal (1:14:27 to 1:20:05). Voice assigned by elimination (medium confidence).
Michael PetrinMember; chair, SAU 6 BoardSuggests a press release once the IRS penalties are resolved (0:33:21); seconds the donations; plans the next SAU 6 agenda with the superintendent (1:26:02). Voice assigned by content (medium confidence). Transcribed Michael. Patron.
Heather WhitneyMemberAnswers the roll (0:01:29); named as one of the three board members on the capital improvement committee (1:16:03). No speaking turns are attributed to her; the attribution report suggests some unidentified agenda remarks may be hers.
Rebecca ZulloVice chairAbsent (0:11:46).
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Reports on the strategic plan committees, the audits and IRS penalties, the business administrator hire, teacher hiring and handbooks.
Donna MagoonAssistant superintendent, SAU 6Presents the draft student discipline policy JICD (0:08:41 to 0:12:55).
Steven MossCurriculum team, SAU 6Presents the Dartmouth Science Education Partnership Award program for the middle school (0:37:32 to 0:46:37).
Brynn KaneInduction and mentoring program, SAU 6Presents new teacher week and the mentoring program (0:51:33 to 1:00:45).
Jeff SmallDirector of technology, SAU 6Presents barcoded student ID badges (1:01:50 to 1:05:07).
Patricia BarryPrincipal, Stevens High SchoolAnswers questions on the high school handbook draft (1:07:19 to 1:11:31). The chair calls her Pat; surname from the roster (medium confidence).
Mary WoodmanSchool district clerk and recording secretaryCalls the roll; explains how she recorded the July 30 motions (0:04:30).
UnidentifiedVarious96 of 580 dialogue rows (16.6%), including the agenda motion, the calendar motion, the second to the CCTV appointment and the abstention on the July 30 minutes ("I abstain. I was not here.", 0:05:37). No member of the public speaks (0:07:28).

Named but not present or not heard: Frank Romeo, Claremont Middle School principal (introduced as Mr. Rome, Principal Romeo, 0:36:20); Jamie Young (human resources); Richard Seaman (incoming business administrator); an interim business official called John (surname transcribed Aubin and Mr. Robin, unverified); Courtney Porter; Mayor Lovett (lead-free committee, 0:29:23); Alex Herzog and Pauline Pelletier (CCTV board).

Order of business (reconstructed)

No agenda survives. The chair refers to "an agenda in front of us tonight" (0:01:41) and to items by letter and packet; the list below follows his transitions.
Taken upItemWhat was said and done
0:00:47Call to order; Pledge; roll callSix present; Zullo absent.
0:01:41AgendaAmended to add a capital improvement program update, with papers on members' desks. Moved by an unidentified member "As amended."; seconded; approved by voice vote (0:02:26).
0:02:26Approval of minutesThe chair: "We have minutes in front of us from June 30th, 2019." The content is the July 30 meeting (see the timeline). Benware moves to "Accept the minutes, as amended." (0:05:23); second ("a second, Mike."); approved, one abstention (0:05:28, 0:05:37).
0:05:432019-20 school calendar"I'm gonna make a motion that we approve the the calendar as presented to us." (unidentified, 0:07:04); approved by voice vote (0:07:09).
0:07:18Citizens' commentsNot on the agenda; the chair opens the period anyway: "Not seeing any close to the comments." (0:07:28).
0:07:28First read: discipline policy JICD; review of policy JICBenware: "I move that. We move this to second read j I CD, to secondary." (0:12:10); second Towle (0:12:15); approved (0:12:30).
0:13:03Item C: CCTV board of directorsThe chair asks for "a nomination to appoint Alex to the CCTV board of directors." (0:13:03); seconded (unidentified, 0:13:44); approved (0:13:48): "Okay. Alex is official now."
0:13:56Strategic plan updateInformation and questions.
0:29:522016 fiscal audit report for the Claremont School District"Okay. 2016 fiscal audit report for Claremont School District." Discussion; no motion is heard.
0:36:05Dartmouth STEM grant informationPresentation; no action.
0:46:55New teacher nominations and vacanciesBenware moves to accept "33 people for higher in the Claremont School District." (0:50:34); second within his row; approved (0:50:44).
0:51:03New teacher orientation and mentoringPresentation; no action.
1:01:12New student IDs; point-of-sale swipe cardsPresentation; no action.
1:05:14Handbook approvalsThe chair moves to "preliminarily accept these versions of the handbooks so that they can be distributed, and then we'll approve them finally at our next meeting." (1:12:00); second Benware (1:12:22); approved (1:12:24).
1:12:24Acceptance of donations for the Back to School festivalBenware: "One of $250 from the Claremont Savings Bank and the other of $100 from the Claremont Police Association for the Back to school festival." (1:12:59); second Petrin (1:13:12); approved (1:13:16).
1:14:23Committee report: capital improvement programReport and discussion; no action.
1:21:30Future agenda items; for the good of the orderHandbooks next time; the NHSBA resolution process; the next SAU 6 meeting.
1:28:53AdjournmentMotion Benware, second heard in the same row; approved by voice vote (1:28:59).

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/10506 SchoolBoard082119.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording. Quotations are as transcribed; bracketed words are corrections, with the transcript's wording kept where the correction changes sense.

Chronological topics with the most concrete material first.
TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:03:12How the July 30 minutes recorded the teacher moneyBenware reads the draft: "I made a motion to accept the amount of 205,000 for 16 for the fiscal year 2020 saw district for two additional teachers." [$205,416; SAU] He asks: "Is that what I did or did I did I make a motion to allocate that money to two teachers?" The superintendent reads the draft as two steps, "first to reduce it" and "then second to allocate it specifically towards the teachers". The clerk: "I have to include that information." and "It was in discussion that it was done." The chair: "I think you may have not mentioned a number, but I think it's implicit". The second accept is changed to allocate and the minutes are approved as amended, with one abstention: "I abstain. I was not here." (0:05:37).MEDIUM
0:06:00School calendarThe open question was a voting day and a February professional-development day; "you, you agreed upon it in concept but you hadn't formally approved it." Approved as presented (0:07:09).
0:07:28Citizens' comments left off the agendaThe chair: "Citizens. Comments. Sorry. It's not on the agenda. That's my bad. Not seeing any close to the comments. Note to self we need to put citizens comments in there."POS
0:08:11Discipline policy JICDMagoon: under the draft "a principal can suspend a student up to ten days" and can then refer to the superintendent's office for a long-term suspension, which "could then refer to the school board. None of that was in our current policy as written." The superintendent: "The, the policy adopted by the board was actually less than the state." Magoon: the draft adds due process, "Whereas the current policy does not speak on due process." Corrections: the short-term limit should read "not to exceed ten days". Moved to second read (0:12:10).OBS
0:13:03CCTV board"At this point in time, there's no one from the district on the board." Pelletier "has resigned"; Herzog is appointed. The chair: "That's been been trying to get that done all summer." The item had been tabled on July 30 so that it could be warned.
0:14:07Strategic plan committeesCommittees to revive or form: curriculum, health and wellness (student mental health, staff wellness, allergens), scheduling across the high school, middle school and tech center, technology (replacement cycles in the capital plan), safety, and college and career readiness.
0:20:39Dual enrollment and competency gradingTowle on dual enrollment: a student she knows "cut a whole semester off" and "That's. Tens of thousands". On grading, the superintendent: Claremont is "one of the few places that actually did those two things simultaneously" (competencies and a letter-grade correlation), and "if it's confusing the general public and a nuisance, we we have bigger fish to fry." A staff committee will review it.
0:28:55Lead-free committeeSprague and the superintendent sit on it; grant funding to repair playgrounds disturbed by pipe replacement. Sprague: "I don't think there's any really safe level of lead other than zero." He names "Mayor Lovett" as a committee member.
0:29:56Fiscal 2016 audit; IRS penaltiesThe superintendent: "you have the audit packet and a lot of the findings you had been apprized of"; the auditors are "still looking 17 and 18." From the district's attorney: "we can anticipate positively in abatement of the fees, maybe a waiving of all the fees." and "we're anticipating an abatement of the IRS penalties." Of the IRS: "They're years behind in a lot of audits, all over the place." Towle asks whether it is "somewhat of a forensic audit?"; the answer is no, but the auditors promised "if they see anything that's leading that way, they would let let me know right away". Sprague: "I think restoring some trust with the community". No motion.MEDIUM
0:31:17New business administrator"Richard Seaman who was a member of the school board and is a Claremont resident" will start "October 2nd" as business administrator and "assistant superintendent for for a finance in operations", full time. Until then "John, who is our interim person who's in three days a week" prepares "documentation ready for, for budget season and for negotiations."
0:33:18A press release on the penaltiesPetrin: once resolved, "put out a press release to kind of get ahead of this to make to be very transparent with the public". The superintendent agrees.
0:37:33Dartmouth STEM partnershipMoss: Dartmouth College and the Montshire Museum won a "Science Education Partnership award" from "the National Institute of General Medical Sciences for $1.3 million" for five years; four middle schools, Claremont the largest; "at no cost to Claremont, you know, Dartmouth is picking up the tab." Results will be tracked "without putting any particular student data in".
0:47:04Teacher election"So you just kind of approve the slate?" "33 new teachers when we printed this". Human resources processed "16 or so, 16 teachers in the last week"; "only 2 or 3 teaching positions" and "over, over ten paraprofessional positions" remain open. The board elects the 33 (0:50:44).
0:51:33New teacher weekKane: "it was 45 new staff members that we have with us this week" and "I have 27 mentors". On retention: "The last couple of years we've had a really big turnover." Local businesses supplied lunch, umbrellas, notebooks and bags. Towle asks how board members can meet the new teachers.
1:01:16Barcoded student IDsThe superintendent: an "outgrowth from the audit report and the findings in basically some of the gaps that we've had with controls over the, you know, the lunch program". Small: at elementary schools "somebody just put in a four my four digit pin, and it's not even my kids pin." The badge barcode "has their their Sassa number" [SASID, the state-assigned student identifier], "which will correspond to our power school"; it may later "unlock a door or latch the door" and run printing. Benware: "somebody loses one of those and anybody has access to the front door".OBS
1:05:18HandbooksTowle: "I received the handbooks today. Yeah. Via email." and "usually we have a policy of getting it a week ahead." The chair finds drafting notes in the high school book ("Ask Alex", "insert info"). The board tentatively approves them for printing before September 3, final approval at the next meeting. Benware: "I think further here on out, we'd like to get it a little earlier."OBS
1:08:16Driver education contractBenware: "So we've signed a contract with, Jumpstart." and "It's less. It's less money than I was charging seven years ago." The superintendent: "we also locked that in long term." No contract is in the record, and no board vote on it is on the July 30 or August 21 recordings.
1:12:35Festival donations$250 from Claremont Savings Bank and $100 from the Police Association, accepted on an item the chair read as "Acceptance of donations for the Back to School festival." The festival is "this Saturday from ten to noon".
1:14:27Capital improvement programLovett: "This is a rough order magnitude list"; priorities on "a scale of 1 to 4". LED lighting would "return its investment within 2 to 5 years". "myself, Carolyn and Heather are heading the committee from the school board perspective". Benware asks to settle the five-year facilities plan first. The goal, in Lovett's words: avoid "these large amendments that we have to keep making"; "True capital reserve fund."
1:19:26Who sits on the budget committeeTowle: someone from the capital improvement committee "should sit on the budget committee." Benware: "if you have one extra person from our board sitting there, we have to warn everything that we do, and we can't just meet on a on a Wednesday morning. We have to warn it." The chair: one of the other three would "recuse on that particular meeting".MEDIUM
1:22:29NHSBA resolutionsThe chair: the board has never used the School Boards Association's resolution process; there is "a November 2nd deadline". Towle: "Frank told me that he had nominated me" as delegate, with Sprague as alternate. To go on the next agenda.
1:26:02Next SAU 6 meetingPetrin and the superintendent are working on "the SO6 agenda" [SAU 6]. Thursday, September 5 is set tentatively. The chair: "we've really relied heavily on Claremont to meet the to meet the the, the quorum for those meetings." and asks for a feeler to Unity on attendance.

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on August 21, 2019, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.

MEDIUM The fiscal 2016 audit reached the board three years and two months after the year ended, with 2017 and 2018 still open

The agenda item was the "2016 fiscal audit report for Claremont School District" (0:29:52). Fiscal 2016 ended June 30, 2016. The superintendent said the auditors were "still looking 17 and 18" (0:29:56), and that the district expected "an abatement of the IRS penalties" (0:30:44). Later in the meeting he tied the new student ID system to "the audit report and the findings" on "controls over the, you know, the lunch program" (1:01:16). The record does not say what the IRS penalties were for. Under the Uniform Guidance, a district that spends $750,000 or more in federal awards in a fiscal year must submit its single-audit reporting package "within the earlier of 30 calendar days after receipt of the auditor's report(s), or nine months after the end of the audit period". For fiscal 2016 that is March 31, 2017. This page has not verified Claremont's fiscal 2016 federal expenditures, so it cannot say the threshold was crossed, and it grades the item MEDIUM as a control weakness rather than HIGH as a missed deadline. The schedule of expenditures of federal awards in the audit packet would settle it; the report reached the board about 29 months after that date. New Hampshire's audit statute, RSA 21-J:19, is permissive as to timing and is not the basis of this flag. In mitigation, the superintendent disclosed the backlog and the penalties publicly and twice (0:30:23, 0:33:50), the auditors had promised to report any sign that a forensic audit was needed (0:35:09), and a full-time business administrator was hired (0:31:17).

Sources: 2 CFR 200.512(a)(1) (2019 annual edition); 2 CFR 200.501(a) ($750,000 threshold); 2 CFR 200.110(b) (Subpart F applies to fiscal years beginning on or after December 26, 2014); 2 CFR 200.303(a) (internal control over federal awards)

MEDIUM No agenda, packet or minutes for this meeting survive in any district share, and the approval of the prior minutes shows why that matters

MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting: neither share holds a year folder older than 2022, and the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023. RSA 91-A:2, II, in the 2019 codification, required minutes including "the names of members, persons appearing before the public bodies, and a brief description of the subject matter discussed and final decisions", required that "The names of the members who made or seconded each motion shall be recorded in the minutes", and required inspection "not more than 5 business days after the meeting". This page applies the MEDIUM limb of the project's severity rule because the record mitigates the gap: a clerk took minutes, and the board approved them on September 4, 2019. The minutes approval at this meeting shows what the missing documents hold. The draft July 30 minutes recorded Benware as moving "to accept the amount of 205,000 for 16 for the fiscal year 2020 saw district for two additional teachers" (0:03:12), a sum and a fiscal year that his motion on the July 30 recording did not state (July 30 page); the board corrected one word and approved them (0:05:05, 0:05:28). The minutes, not the recording, are therefore where the dollar amount of the teacher reallocation was fixed, and neither set is public. The agenda the members held is also missing; several items they discussed were in a packet (0:05:43, 0:36:08, 1:05:18).

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification; source note ends 2018, 244:1, eff. Jan. 1, 2019)

MEDIUM Members treated committee meetings as needing notice only when a board quorum attends

Lovett described the capital improvement committee, which "myself, Carolyn and Heather are heading", as holding meetings, with another "to be determined" (1:16:03), and Towle described its "last meeting" with the superintendent (1:18:39). Asked to put a capital improvement member on the budget committee, Benware objected: "if you have one extra person from our board sitting there, we have to warn everything that we do, and we can't just meet on a on a Wednesday morning." (1:20:36). The chair proposed that another member recuse from such meetings (1:21:01). Both answers rest on the idea that a committee's meetings need notice only when four of the seven board members attend. RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d), unchanged since 2008, defines a public body to include a school district's board "or any committee, subcommittee, or subordinate body thereof, or advisory committee thereto". A board committee is therefore a public body in its own right, with the notice and minutes duties of RSA 91-A:2, II, whatever the number of members present. The quorum count decides only whether the full board is also meeting. No notice or minutes of any capital improvement or budget committee meeting from 2019 survive. The severity is MEDIUM: the remarks describe a practice that would leave committee meetings unnoticed, but the record does not show how any particular committee meeting was noticed.

Sources: RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d) (2019 codification; source note ends 2008, 354:1); RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification)

OBSERVATION The district's existing discipline policy fell short of the suspension statute, by the administration's own account

Presenting the draft JICD, the assistant superintendent said the existing policy "just stated that we could only do ten days" with "no superintendent" and "no school board" (0:09:26), and the superintendent said "the policy adopted by the board was actually less than the state." (0:09:53). RSA 193:13, I, in the 2019 codification, lets the superintendent or a written designee suspend for up to 10 school days, and lets the school board or its written designee, "following a hearing", continue a suspension beyond 10 days; the designee for the longer suspension may be the superintendent but not the person who imposed the first 10 days. The draft described on tape, with a principal's short-term suspension, referral to the superintendent's office and then to the board, and new due-process language (0:09:00, 0:10:06), tracks that structure, provided principals act as written designees. The policy was moved to second reading (0:12:10) and adopted on September 4, 2019. This is an observation: the old and new policy texts are not in the record, so the page cannot compare them line by line.

Sources: RSA 193:13, I(a)-(b) (2019 codification; source note ends 2017, 12:1, eff. June 16, 2017)

OBSERVATION Student badges will carry a barcode of the state student identifier that links to the student information system

The technology director said the new badge "has their their Sassa number" [SASID], "which is only tied to them, which will correspond to our power school", that scanning it brings up the student's picture in the meals program, and that it may later be used for sign-in at the high school, printing and door locks (1:02:30, 1:02:52, 1:03:21). Benware worried about lost cards "floating around in the community" (1:03:42). Under the federal student-privacy rule, directory information "does not include" a student identification number, except that a student ID number may be treated as directory information "only if the identifier cannot be used to gain access to education records except when used in conjunction with one or more factors that authenticate the user's identity, such as a personal identification number (PIN), password or other factor known or possessed only by the authorized user". A badge worn in public displays whatever it carries. The record does not show whether the district designated badge numbers as directory information, what the barcode opens without a second factor, or what the meal-line scanners show to whom. The plan responds to an audit finding on lunch-program controls (1:01:16) and to students using other children's PINs (1:02:02), which are real problems. This is an observation, offered so the design can be checked against the rule.

Sources: 34 CFR 99.3, "Directory information" (2019 annual edition, revised July 1, 2019)

OBSERVATION Student handbooks reached members on the day of the vote

Towle said she received the handbooks by email that day and that "usually we have a policy of getting it a week ahead." (1:06:03, 1:06:23). The chair found drafting notes still in the high school handbook (1:07:02, 1:07:46). The board did not adopt them outright: on the chair's motion it accepted them "preliminarily" so that schools could print them, with final approval at the next meeting and the approved text to be posted online (1:09:30, 1:12:00). The superintendent called this "a very common practice because of the printing fees" (1:10:35). The one-week practice Towle cited is the board's own; no statute verified for this page sets one, so this is an observation. The board gave final approval on September 4, 2019.

Sources: Cablecast: SCHOOL BOARD meeting 8-21-19

POSITIVE The chair opened citizens' comments although the item had been left off the agenda

Moving to the policy items, the chair stopped: "Citizens. Comments. Sorry. It's not on the agenda. That's my bad." He opened the period, saw no one, and added "Note to self we need to put citizens comments in there." (0:07:28). New Hampshire's school-board public-comment statute, RSA 189:74, took effect on September 6, 2022, so in 2019 no statute required a comment period. Offering one when the printed agenda omitted it, and committing to restore it, exceeds what the law then required.

Sources: RSA 189:74 (source note 2022, 333:1, eff. Sept. 6, 2022; not in force in 2019)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page