Claremont School Board, March 17, 2021

First meeting after the March 9, 2021 election: the clerk and two members (one new, one returning) were sworn in, Frank Sprague was re-elected chair, the board heard a superintendent's report on a CARES-funded summer program and a federal technology grant, and voted to give the superintendent authority to reopen schools for "maximum in-person learning" for the fourth quarter. The page is built from the Claremont Community Television (CCTV) / Claremont Community Media Center (CCMC) recording's dialogue transcript; no agenda, packet or minutes survive in the district's online shares. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6)
Date
Wednesday, March 17, 2021 (the board approves "the minutes from March 3rd, 2021" at 0:44:15; MAP.md section 141 and the Cablecast title give 3/17/21)
Start time
Not stated in available records. The recording opens on the Pledge of Allegiance (0:00:03); the superintendent presides until the chair is elected (0:00:45); adjournment motion at 1:35:38, with the last roll-call answer at 1:36:55. The dialogue transcript runs 1:37:24.
Location
Not stated in available records. When the board schedules its retreat the superintendent asks whether members "want to be in here", at the Teal Lantern or at the community center (1:13:39), so the meeting room is a third place; the Cablecast recording does not name it.
Format
Hybrid, as far as the recording shows: the chair asks whether anyone is "in the queue" for citizens' comments (0:45:26), and the record has raised hands and a muted microphone (0:52:25, 1:11:17). Which members, if any, joined remotely is not stated. The meeting fell during the COVID-19 state of emergency, when Emergency Order #12 relaxed RSA 91-A:2, III's physical-quorum rule.
Recording
Cablecast: Claremont School Board Meeting of 3/17/21 (transcript length 1:37:24; run time from the Cablecast API not retrieved)
Minutes
None located. MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting: neither district share holds a year folder older than 2022, and the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023 (checked 9/26/26).
Board composition
Seven members: Frank Sprague (re-elected chair), Heather Whitney, Michael Petrin, Carolyn Towle, Rob Lovett Jr., and Steven Horsky and Joshua Lambert, welcomed as new members after the March 9 election (0:00:45, 0:41:28: "It's great having Steve back. And Josh welcome."). Lovett arrives during the superintendent's report (0:32:48). Lambert has no attributed row in the transcript.

Participants

Everyone heard or named as present in the recording. Names follow the project's 2015-2023 roster and the speaker attribution report for this recording, since no minutes survive; transcript renderings are noted where they differ.
NameRoleParticipation
Frank SpragueBoard member; re-elected chair this meetingNominated by Towle (Greg in the transcript, 0:39:15) and elected by roll call; takes the chair at 0:40:44. Administers the clerk's oath (the transcript places the oath in his voice; the attribution report rates the reader as probable). Runs the agenda, retreat and subcommittee discussion; reports on SB 145 and SB 158 and on his contact with a state representative.
Heather WhitneyBoard member; nominated for a second office (most likely vice chair)Seconds the chair nomination and most motions; asks what share of students are on grade level (0:23:58) and about high school credit recovery (0:26:42); moves the amendment that becomes the reopening motion (1:04:32); proposes a "school board accountability committee" (1:14:22); moves to adjourn (1:35:38).
Michael PetrinBoard memberMoves approval of the agenda as amended (0:43:17) and of the March 3 minutes (0:44:15); asks about the April 12 start of the fourth quarter, busing and after-school clubs (0:57:47, 0:59:20); raises pay-to-play for all students (1:29:42).
Carolyn TowleBoard member (transcribed "Carolyn Tall/Toll")Nominates Sprague for chair (0:39:12); asks how Claremont's in-person rate compares with other districts (0:28:04); argues for a Sunday retreat (1:11:24); seconds the amended reopening motion (1:05:05); reports on Senate bills, NHSBA webinars and the 2021 policy update (1:18:51, 1:20:59).
Steven HorskyBoard member, returning after the March 2021 election (transcribed "Stephen Horsey")Moves to give the administration authority to reopen schools (1:03:48); urges any pay-to-play change take effect at the start of a school year (1:33:03); asks whether the needle exchange program ever delivered its "promised quarterly updates" (1:34:27).
Joshua LambertBoard member, new after the March 2021 electionWelcomed at 0:00:45 and 0:41:28; asked about the retreat date (1:12:15). No row is attributed to him.
Rob Lovett Jr.Board member (transcribed "Lord Lovat junior", "Beloved junior")Arrives during the superintendent's report (0:32:48); answers Yes on the agenda and reopening roll calls (0:43:44, 1:05:47).
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Presides until the chair is elected and conducts the officer election (0:38:50); gives the superintendent's report on athletics, COVID-19 data, staff vaccination, the strategic plan, the CARES-funded summer program and the federal technology grant (0:01:49 to 0:23:45); proposes the "maximum in-person learning" wording (1:04:02); previews competency-grading changes and pay-to-play (1:26:28, 1:28:28).
Donna MagoonAssistant Superintendent, SAU 6Gives the staff vaccination count (0:05:19); notes there was no standardized testing this year (0:24:38); reports clubs restarting (1:00:57); takes the needle exchange follow-up (1:34:13).
Richard SeamanSAU 6 finance administratorOne row: puts the funding Claremont stands to recover at "close to 400" (1:22:25). Attribution medium.
Jeff SmallSAU 6 Director of TechnologyRuns the slides ("Mr. Small", 0:01:49); explains the purpose of the technology grant (0:51:01 to 0:51:28). Attribution medium.
Mary WoodmanSchool district clerk and recording secretarySworn in as school district clerk (0:34:03); administers members' oaths (0:35:01); calls every roll.
Patrick AdrianCitizens' comments, Ward 1 (former board member)Self-identifies as "Patrick. Adrian work one" (0:46:07); asks why the grant was spent on smart boards and how the three districts will share resources (0:46:48, 0:47:27).
UnidentifiedVarious32 of 469 rows (6.8%): roll-call answers, the oath crosstalk and short interjections.

Order of business (reconstructed)

No agenda survives. The board had one, amended it on tape (0:42:54), and refers to "discussion action items and article D"; the clerk says she had not received it that morning (0:35:01). The order below is reconstructed from the presiding officer's transitions.

Items in the order taken up, with dispositions as heard in the recording
Taken upItemDisposition
0:00:03Pledge of AllegianceLed by the superintendent.
0:00:45Change in orderThe superintendent, "chairing the meeting right now", moves to his report because of "a little bit of a delay for the swearing in" (0:01:09); roll call and agenda are deferred.
0:01:49Superintendent's reportPresentation with slides; questions from Sprague, Whitney and Towle. No action.
0:32:31Oaths of officeMary Woodman sworn as "School district clerk" (0:34:03, 0:34:17); the clerk then swears in the new members (0:34:26, 0:35:01). Most of the members' oath is not captured: a single row runs from 0:35:01 to 0:38:49.
0:38:50Election of board officersChair: Towle nominates Sprague, Whitney seconds, roll call (0:39:32). Second office: "I can make a motion to nominate Heather Whitney" in the chair's voice (0:40:26), followed by "Chair nomination." (0:40:29) and a roll call (0:40:48); the office and the result are not stated. See flag 4.
0:41:48Roll call of attendanceTaken by the clerk; only two answers are captured.
0:42:48Approval of the agendaChair adds Towle's staff-development item. Petrin: "I make the motion to approve the agenda as amended." (0:43:17); Whitney seconds; roll call, every captured answer Yes (0:43:35 to 0:43:58).
0:44:02Minutes of March 3, 2021 ("our retreat")Petrin moves (0:44:15); "Seconded by Heather." (0:44:23); roll call, every captured answer Yes.
0:45:26Citizens' commentsThe chair checks the remote queue; Patrick Adrian (Ward 1) asks two questions on the technology grant, answered by Tempesta and Small.
0:51:53Discussion and action: fourth quarter, students back to schoolHorsky moves to give the administration authority to open school "as soon as possible" (1:03:48), Whitney seconds; Whitney's amendment gives the superintendent "the autonomy to open schools for maximum in-person learning within New Hampshire. Safety guidelines." (1:04:32); Towle seconds; roll call, every captured answer Yes (1:05:33 to 1:06:13).
1:06:24Scheduling the board retreatSet by consensus for Sunday, April 18, 10 a.m. to 1 p.m., at the community center (1:13:05, 1:13:47). No vote.
1:14:05SubcommitteesWhitney proposes an accountability committee; sign-ups deferred to the retreat. No vote.
1:18:40Staff development (added item)Towle's reports on legislation, webinars and the policy update. No action.
1:26:22Items for AprilGrading, pay-to-play and the needle exchange program raised for future agendas. No action.
1:35:13Good of the order; adjournmentWhitney moves to adjourn (1:35:38); roll call (1:35:47 to 1:36:55). No seconder is heard.

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/11390 SchoolBoard031721.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

Topics in the order discussed
TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:45New members; change of orderTempesta: "I'd like to welcome our new board members, Joshua Lambert and Stephen Horsey [Steven Horsky], with us tonight." The swearing-in is delayed, so the superintendent's report comes first.
0:02:18Athletics; COVID-19 trend"our bowling team is Division one champs" (0:02:18); basketball and hockey tournament showings. Case slides from January 26 against March 12: a lower infection rate and "The statewide vaccination for at least first dose up at 22%." (0:04:33).
0:04:58Staff vaccination"we have vaccinations scheduled for all staff. This Saturday"; asked for the count, Magoon answers 225. (0:05:19); "They're going to Dartmouth. Hitchcock." and "It is Moderna." (0:05:20). The governor's lifting of some quarantine measures is to be discussed at the next meeting (0:05:46).
0:06:21Strategic plan; hiringGoals set a year earlier, "and then everything stopped" (0:06:21); "again, our budget is approved" (0:07:41); "many retirements", online hiring fairs and interviews already scheduled (0:08:05); a governance-structure review with school councils (0:09:43).
0:10:44In-person ratios for the fourth quarter"we are almost 80% dead on in person. And we have been since February 1st." five days a week district-wide; principals are calling every remote family and "it could be over over 90% back" (0:12:51); bus loads and air purifiers under review (0:11:39).
0:16:54CARES-funded summer programWith the community center: "it's a six week summer program. And from 830 to 430", offered "completely free of cost, including pick up and drop off at the homes" (0:17:30); academics with a STEAM focus in the morning (0:18:03); "It's $10 a week or $25 for all six weeks" as a sign-up charge for the community center's overhead (0:19:25, 0:19:48); attendance expectations (0:20:30). Paid "through the cares, money" (0:27:38).OBSERVATION
0:21:01Federal technology grantWith Fall Mountain and Newport, SAU 6 "received the Russ Grant technology grant, from the feds" (0:21:01): "it's $1 million grant" for equipment, of which Claremont expects "approximately $450,000 worth of technology equipment" (0:21:38): 65-inch interactive boards with speaker-tracking cameras at "about 130" teaching stations (0:22:23). Sprague asks that it be clear the district is not paying; Tempesta: "This is free. This is federal money coming to us. In addition, outside of the budget." (0:23:01); then "we have a 10% match. So so basically 85% of this is, is free." (0:23:21). The two figures are as transcribed and do not reconcile.OBSERVATION
0:23:58Grade-level performanceWhitney: "What percentage of our students are functioning on grade level?" Tempesta: "we don't have a metric or anything right now" (0:24:17); Magoon: "There was no standardized testing this year." (0:24:38). Whitney: "I just have a high level anxiety about promoting kids that are not at grade level" (0:30:32); Tempesta: tutoring and summer programs, and "The cares money that we have so far is layered out for two years." (0:30:51).
0:26:42Credit recoveryThe middle school runs its own summer program in-house (0:26:50); "High schools program is completely credit recovery." with community service and field trips (0:27:15).
0:28:04Comparison with other districtsTowle asks how 80% compares; Tempesta: no state list yet, "I don't know of another place that's back as as full as we are. I think Newport's close." (0:28:37).
0:32:31Clerk sworn in; members sworn inSprague: "So now we're getting ready to square Mary [swear Mary] in. And then Mary shows where [swears] the new board members in." (0:33:01). Woodman answers "School district clerk." and I do. (0:34:03, 0:34:17). The clerk mentions she had not received the agenda (0:35:01); the members' oath is largely inaudible.
0:38:50Election of officersTowle: "I'd like to make a motion to nominate." "Greg [Frank] as the chairman of the board." Tempesta: "Motion was made by Carolyn, seconded by Heather, for the nomination of Frank Sprague to be chair." (0:39:32). Then "I can make a motion to nominate Heather Whitney." (0:40:26), "Chair nomination." (0:40:29) and a roll call answered "Yes, sure." and "Yes. A little." (0:41:13, 0:41:23).OBSERVATION POSITIVE
0:41:48Attendance; agenda; March 3 minutesRoll call of attendance (0:41:48). Agenda amended to add Towle's staff-development item (0:42:54) and approved on Petrin's motion, Whitney's second. The March 3 minutes ("That was our retreat.") approved on Petrin's motion, Whitney's second (0:44:15, 0:44:23). Each by roll call.MEDIUM POSITIVE
0:45:26Citizens' comments: Patrick AdrianAdrian (Ward 1) asks "why the district decided to focus that spending on what says smart boards" and about the joint letter's promise that the districts would "use the technology to share resources" (0:46:48, 0:47:27). Tempesta credits Fall Mountain's superintendent ("Laurie Landry" as transcribed) for the application, says "we were the only recipients in the state of New Hampshire" and that the districts "contracted with them to write the grant" (0:49:37). Small: "That's really what the Russ Grant was." (0:51:16).OBSERVATION
0:51:53Fourth quarter: who comes backData gathering continues; a list of high school students with hardships may get seats (0:52:51); "We're already down to the three feet in New Hampshire." (0:54:23). Sprague asks whether a returning student might attend a different school and says "it's not some kind of an end run to consolidate schools." (0:55:25). Fourth quarter begins "April 12th." (0:57:52); bus ridership "about, on average, I think 15 or so kids on a bus" (0:58:05).
0:59:20Clubs and activitiesPetrin presses for clubs such as Key Club and drama; Magoon: "Currently Key." "Club is virtual." and drama club at CMS "starts next week" (1:00:56 to 1:00:58).
1:01:15Reopening authority voteHorsky asks whether the board can decide "with five days before our meeting"; Petrin notes the next meeting is April 7 and school returns on the 12th (1:02:31). Tempesta: "if you wanted to make a motion to just give me the autonomy to do that" (1:02:55). Horsky: "I'll make the motion to give the administration the authority to open school as soon as possible." (1:03:48); Tempesta asks for "maximum in-person learning" within state safety rules (1:04:02); Whitney's amendment (1:04:32); Towle: "I will second your vote." (1:05:05); roll call (1:05:17 to 1:06:13). Sprague: "I'm glad we did that." (1:06:15).POSITIVE
1:06:28Board retreatSprague explains the retreat and its goal-setting, crediting the capital improvement subcommittee for having a plan "when the one time state money came in" (1:07:20); the budget subcommittee's goal of "a fiscal system with optimum transparency" (1:08:33). "I do not want to wrap the retreat into the April 5th meeting." (1:10:08). After weeknight and Sunday options: "Okay, so the 18, ten to 10 to 1." (1:13:05) "So be at the community center." (1:13:47).OBSERVATION
1:14:05SubcommitteesWhitney proposes "a school board accountability committee" so that "we don't have schizophrenic board activity as we churn through members" (1:14:22), including "a mechanism by which to easily look up every motion that was passed and every budgetary item or dollar expenditure was passed" (1:14:52). Sprague proposes subcommittee report-outs at board meetings (1:15:53) and says the budget subcommittee "needs during the day because we meet with the directors and the administrators during the actual school day." (1:16:49). Towle: the capital improvement committee is "Going to resurrect" (1:17:51).OBSERVATION
1:18:40Legislation and trainingTowle: two school-funding bills on the Senate floor, "It's SB 145 and SB 158" (1:19:12); NHSBA webinars on policy development, nonpublic sessions and collective bargaining (1:20:21); the 2021 special policy update, which Magoon will take to the policy committee (1:20:59, 1:21:37). Sprague: the bill is "the restoration of money that we are losing due to our, adequate daily membership and, free or reduced lunch money" (1:21:55); "I think it's Richard 300 and something." Seaman: "In our case. Yeah, close to 400." (1:22:21, 1:22:25); the budget treats it "as, as a deficit" (1:22:27).
1:23:41State school-funding studySprague on a Zoom forum about the state study: many believe New Hampshire students do fine, and he asked whether achievement data are disaggregated by town (1:24:06 to 1:25:46).
1:26:22Items for coming meetingsTempesta: "the proposal to remove the linkage of competencies from the grading system at middle and high", probably for May (1:26:28 to 1:27:31). Pay-to-play: Petrin asks about a fee for all students (1:29:42); Sprague contrasts "$800 for a stipend" with "$18,000 for, for new new uniforms this year" (1:32:18); Horsky wants any change to start with a new school year and sent to the policy committee (1:33:03, 1:33:44).
1:34:13Needle exchange programMagoon: the program's contact "were really busy with what's going on with Covid" (1:34:13). Horsky: "Have we had any of the promised quarterly updates?" Answer: No. (1:34:40). Horsky: "they obviously haven't followed through on a promise they made three years ago." (1:34:42). Magoon takes the follow-up.OBSERVATION
1:35:13AdjournmentWhitney: "I'd like to make a motion to adjourn." (1:35:38); the chair asks for a roll call; the last captured answer is Whitney's (1:36:55).POSITIVE

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on March 17, 2021, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.

MEDIUM No agenda, packet or minutes for this meeting survive in any district share

MAP.md records no Drive material: the district's shares hold no year folder older than 2022, and the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023. This meeting swore in the clerk and two members, elected the chair and a second officer, and delegated the reopening decision to the superintendent, and the recording is now the only public account. RSA 91-A:2, II, in the text in force since January 1, 2019, requires minutes that include the names of members, persons appearing and a brief description of the subject matter discussed and final decisions, requires the names of the members who moved and seconded each motion to be recorded, and requires the minutes to be "open to public inspection not more than 5 business days after the meeting". This page applies the MEDIUM limb of the project's severity rule because the record mitigates the gap: the board approves the March 3 minutes on tape (0:44:15), the clerk is present and calls every vote, and an agenda existed and was amended (0:42:54), so a minutes routine was operating. What is missing is any public copy now. The movers and seconders the minutes had to carry are, on this recording, Petrin and Whitney for the agenda and the March 3 minutes, Towle and Whitney for the chair, and Horsky, Whitney and Towle for the reopening motion; the second officer's nomination and the adjournment have no seconder that the transcript captures.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification; source note ends 2018, 244:1, eff. Jan. 1, 2019; text in force until Oct. 3, 2023)

OBSERVATION A $450,000 federal equipment grant and a CARES-funded summer program are announced, with no acceptance step on this record; the grant was accepted on April 7

The superintendent reported that SAU 6, with Fall Mountain and Newport, had received a federal technology grant ("it's $1 million grant"), from which Claremont expects "approximately $450,000 worth of technology equipment" (0:21:38), and a six-week summer program paid for with CARES money (0:17:30, 0:27:38). He also said the grant carries "a 10% match" (0:23:21), which would be district money. RSA 198:20-b, I, as in force in 2021, lets a school board "apply for, accept and expend" unanticipated money "from a state, federal or other governmental unit or a private source" only where the district has adopted an enabling article, and ¶III(a) requires a prior public hearing, with seven days' newspaper notice, for $5,000 or more. Nothing on this recording shows a hearing or an acceptance vote for either. The next meeting answers part of this: on April 7 the superintendent told the board it should have been asked on March 17 to approve the grant, the grant was added on the night to that meeting's public hearing, and the board accepted $451,832 with a 15 percent match (see the April 7, 2021 page, flag 1, which examines that hearing's notice). Neither recording shows a hearing or acceptance for the CARES money. That is why this is an observation here. The documents that would settle the CARES question are the district's enabling article and any 2020 or 2021 hearing notice.

Sources: RSA 198:20-b, I and III (2019 codification; source note ends 2005, 188:1; $5,000 hearing threshold until 2023, 38:1)

OBSERVATION The needle exchange program's "promised quarterly updates" never reached the board

Horsky asked whether the board had received "any of the promised quarterly updates" from the syringe service program, and the answer was No. (1:34:27, 1:34:40); he said the program "obviously haven't followed through on a promise they made three years ago" (1:34:42). Since August 11, 2018, RSA 318-B:45 has barred a syringe service program from a drug-free school zone (school property and 1,000 feet around it, RSA 193-B:1, II) unless "the applicable district school board" grants an exception at the program administrator's request. The statute sets no reporting condition, so the updates were a term of the board's own exception, and the board learned on this night that it had gone unenforced. No rule-based defect is shown; the point is that the board's oversight of an exception only it can grant depended on reports it never received. The exception vote itself predates every record this page relies on. At the next meeting the administration reported that the program had left the hospital site in March 2020, and the board revoked the permission (see the April 7, 2021 page).

Sources: RSA 318-B:45 (2018 codification; exception sentence added by 2018, 254:2, eff. Aug. 11, 2018); RSA 193-B:1, II (drug-free school zone: school property and within 1,000 feet)

OBSERVATION The second officer election is not captured: office, mover and result are all unclear

After the chair vote, the transcript gives "I can make a motion to nominate Heather Whitney." in the voice the diarizer assigns to Sprague (0:40:26), then "Chair nomination." in the superintendent's voice (0:40:29), then a roll call with only two answers captured (0:41:13, 0:41:23). Whitney is recorded as vice chair from May 6, 2020 in the project's roster, so this was most likely her re-election as vice chair, but the recording states neither the office nor the result, and no minutes survive to supply them. No rule is shown to be broken; the record of who holds the board's second office for 2021-22 rests on inference.

Sources: Scripts/roster_2015_2023.md section 7 (project working file, not published; plain text)

OBSERVATION A daytime budget subcommittee and an April retreat: both are covered by the Right-to-Know Law

The chair described the budget subcommittee as meeting "during the actual school day" with directors and administrators (1:16:49), proposed regular subcommittee report-outs (1:15:53), and set a retreat of the full board for Sunday, April 18, at the community center (1:13:05, 1:13:47). RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d) makes "any committee, subcommittee, or subordinate body thereof, or advisory committee thereto" a public body, and a retreat at which a quorum discusses board business is a meeting under RSA 91-A:2, I. Each therefore needed 24 hours' posted notice and minutes. Nothing on this recording says those duties were skipped, and no share reaches back to 2021 to test it; the observation records what the duties were. Whitney's proposed accountability committee, with "a mechanism by which to easily look up every motion that was passed" (1:14:52), addresses the same need from the board's side. On May 5 the board approved minutes of the April 18 retreat (see the May 5, 2021 page).

Sources: RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d) (2019 codification; source note ends 2008, 354:1); RSA 91-A:2, I and II (2019 codification)

POSITIVE Every vote, including the officer elections and adjournment, was taken by roll call

With participation apparently partly remote, the board took each decision by a clerk's roll call: the chair election (0:39:25), the second officer (0:40:48), the agenda (0:43:25), the March 3 minutes (0:44:32), the reopening motion (1:05:17) and even adjournment (1:35:47). RSA 91-A:2, III(e) requires that "All votes taken during such a meeting shall be by roll call vote." when a member participates remotely, and the superintendent opened the officer election by saying "we're going to also need a voice, voice roll call" (0:38:50). The chair also checked the remote queue before closing citizens' comments (0:45:26). The transcript does not capture every member's answer on any roll call, so the tallies here are limited to the answers heard, all Yes.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, III(e) (2019 codification); Emergency Order #12 (March 23, 2020; physical-quorum waiver for the duration of the state of emergency, which lapsed June 11, 2021)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page