Claremont School Board, August 18, 2021

Regular meeting two weeks before school opened. The board approved the elementary and middle school handbooks, held the Stevens High School handbook for a transcript section, adopted an amended 2021-22 COVID-19 decision-making matrix by roll call (four yes, one abstention, one no), debated a $20,000 vaccination-incentive motion that was never voted, and approved a list of staff nominations. Built from the Claremont Community Television (CCTV) / Claremont Community Media Center (CCMC) recording’s dialogue transcript; no agenda, packet or minutes survive in the district’s online shares. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6)
Date
Wednesday, August 18, 2021 (the board approves its “August 4th, 2021” minutes, and a motion refers to the plan “as of 818 2021” at 1:38:27; MAP.md section 149 and the Cablecast title agree)
Start time
Not stated in available records. Called to order at 0:00:20; adjournment vote at 3:02:01. The dialogue transcript runs 3:02:08.
Location
Not stated in available records. The superintendent says “we have an early childhood center here” (2:58:39).
Recording
Cablecast: School Board live on 8/18/21 (transcript length 3:02:08; run time from the Cablecast API not retrieved, because the API refuses requests from this environment)
Minutes
None located. MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting (neither district share holds a year folder older than 2022; the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023; checked 9/26/26). The minutes were approved with an amendment on September 1, 2021 (September 1 page).
Board composition
Seven members; six present. Michael Petrin absent. Nicholas Stone sits by appointment of June 2, 2021 (project roster); Carolyn Towle died in office in May 2021.

Participants

Everyone heard or named as present in the recording. Names follow the project’s 2015-2023 roster and the speaker attribution report for this recording, since no minutes survive; transcript renderings are noted where they differ.
NameRoleParticipation
Frank SpragueChairRuns the meeting. Questions the high school staffing list, reading from an email he attributes to the Commissioner of Education about cost and enrollment trends (1:17:30); argues for county rather than city case rates (2:09:09, 2:10:06); moves to authorize $20,000 for COVID-19 vaccination incentives (2:37:42), which is never voted; answers Yes. on the matrix roll (2:19:10); the CSV gives him a No. at the end of the nominations roll (2:50:51).
Heather WhitneyBoard member (vice chair per the project roster)Seconds the agenda (0:02:15) and the elementary handbooks (1:00:23); calls the proposed matrix changes reasonable (0:18:21); asks the board to align with state guidance and to “nail as much down as we can tonight” (1:45:42); seconds Stone’s Claremont-rates motion for discussion (2:10:44); prefers incentives for adults over children (2:32:55, 2:34:46); announces the superintendent evaluation tool (3:01:40).
Steven HorskyBoard memberOpposes barring indoor spectators (0:20:12) and paying vaccine incentives: “I think that we shouldn't have to, to bribe people.” (0:44:34); moves the elementary and middle school handbooks (1:00:18, 1:01:48); asks for a policy-committee review of the new discipline law (1:20:36); moves the plan as of 8/18 and later withdraws (1:38:27, 1:54:29); abstains on the matrix (2:18:30); moves the nominations (2:48:53).
Joshua LambertBoard memberAsks whether the elementary handbooks need grading policies (0:59:13); reads a visitor as “someone who's coming during the school day” (1:42:16); opposes city-level thresholds as extra work (2:16:23); apparently seconds the matrix motion (the record shows only Josh okay. after the chair’s call for a second, 2:17:31); suggests non-cash incentives aimed at parents (2:36:09).
Rob Lovett Jr.Board memberMoves the agenda (0:02:11); corrects the August 4 minutes, which recorded him voting while absent (0:02:32); moves the spectator amendment (1:54:47); cites New York Times hospitalization figures (2:08:14); moves adoption of the amended matrix (2:17:16, 2:17:35); moves to adjourn (3:01:58).
Nicholas StoneBoard member (appointed June 2, 2021, per the project roster)Asks whether dropping underclass study halls leaves enough sections (1:24:17); proposes Claremont case thresholds instead of Sullivan County rates (1:53:21, 1:57:37, 1:59:14); moves that change and withdraws it (2:10:35, 2:16:52); votes no on the spectator amendment (1:56:10) and the matrix (2:19:03); questions use of CARES money (2:24:52); seconds the nominations (2:49:08).
Michael PetrinBoard memberAbsent. No answer when called at 0:01:19; the clerk records “Michael. Absent.” at 2:18:55.
Mary WoodmanSchool district clerk and recording secretaryCalls the opening roll (0:01:08) and the three roll-call votes (1:55:36, 2:18:10, 2:50:18). Her rows also hold some members’ answers (method note).
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Superintendent’s report of about 70 slides on COVID-19 data and the reopening matrix (0:05:51 to 0:53:14); proposes gift-card and raffle vaccination incentives paid from CARES money (0:42:05, 2:20:37); answers questions on staffing, nominations and elementary restructuring (2:42:22, 2:51:12).
Dr. Mary Ellen JaneiroAssistant Superintendent, SAU 6 (new)Introduced as “our new assistant superintendent” (0:59:28); describes her entry plan and career (1:28:12 to 1:34:28). The transcript renders her name “Mary Ellen Gennaro” and “Doctor general”; the spelling Janeiro follows the project roster, which cites the district’s minutes.
Nicole GordonStevens High School administratorPresents the Stevens handbook changes (1:02:37 to 1:04:36) and answers the chair’s staffing questions (1:06:46 to 1:11:50); describes a new state discipline law (1:12:28). Her exact title is not stated on the recording.
Frank RomeoPrincipal, Claremont Middle SchoolPresents the middle school handbook, including a move to a digital handbook (1:00:45).
Ben NesterDirector of Special EducationAsks to take part in work on the discipline law, saying special education directors expect more referrals (1:23:02). Not named at the microphone; the attribution rests on role content.
Ronnie (surname as transcribed, Irani, unverified)Lead nurse and COVID-19 coordinatorExplains her informal record of Maple Avenue staff vaccinations (0:40:29 to 0:41:27).
Unidentified (one or both interim elementary principals)Elementary administrationThe superintendent introduces “Nicole Bailey who was at Maple” and Christine Baker (0:57:21); an unidentified voice reports “There were no substantial changes as such.” (0:58:22). Principal Melissa Lewis is named as absent (0:57:54).
Michael DemersCitizens' comments (ward not stated)Asks for a public process before masks return (0:03:21 to 0:04:45). He introduces himself as “Michael Morris” in the transcript (0:03:18); the chair spells the name out for the clerk (0:04:59). Spelling follows the CSV and is not confirmed by a district document.
Jeff SmallDirector of Technology (runs the slides)Addressed as “if you go to the next slide, Jeff” and “Mr. Small” (0:09:56, 0:24:56); no attributed rows.

Order of business (reconstructed)

No agenda survives. The chair refers to “an agenda in front of us tonight” (0:01:31) and to lettered items; this order is reconstructed from his transitions.

Items in the order taken up, with motions and votes as heard on the recording.
Taken upItemWhat happened
0:00:20Call to order, Pledge, roll callThe chair calls the meeting to order (0:00:20) and asks the clerk for the roll (0:01:04). The transcribed roll names Whitney (rendered “I have a witness here.”), Horsky, Lambert, Lovett, Petrin and Stone (0:01:08 to 0:01:19); Sprague answers for himself (0:01:27). Petrin is absent.
0:01:31AgendaA request worded as a motion, labeled for the superintendent, asks to move the principals up (0:01:50). Lovett: “I make a motion that we accept the agenda as presented.” (0:02:11); Whitney seconds (0:02:15); voice vote, no opposition heard (0:02:16).
0:02:16Minutes of August 4, 2021Lovett asks for one change: the minutes recorded him voting on a closing item although “I was not present” (0:02:32). Motion to accept “Minutes as amended.” (the words split between the chair and Horsky in the CSV, 0:02:49, 0:02:50); voice vote (0:02:52).
0:03:04Citizens' commentsOne speaker, Michael Demers, on masks (0:03:21); the chair responds (0:05:05) and closes comments (0:05:28).
0:05:51Superintendent's reportCOVID-19 data, the decision-making matrix adopted August 4 and proposed changes, staff vaccination data, a vaccination-incentive idea, and the back-to-school fair (0:05:51 to 0:53:14); questions follow (0:53:17 to 0:56:59).
0:57:02Elementary school handbooksHorsky: “I make a motion to approve the elementary school handbooks as a presented.” (1:00:18); Whitney seconds (1:00:23); voice vote (1:00:25).
1:00:45Claremont Middle School handbookHorsky moves approval (1:01:48); the chair: “Seconded by Nick Stone.” (1:02:06); voice vote (1:02:10).
1:02:21Stevens High School handbookQuestions on transcripts, community service and staffing. Horsky: “I'm not prepared to make a motion to approve until we get the transcript piece.” (1:23:38). The chair: “You're going to table the high school.” (1:26:40). No motion or vote to table is heard.
1:27:16Welcome of the new assistant superintendentDr. Mary Ellen Janeiro introduced (1:27:21) and speaks (1:28:12 to 1:34:28).
1:34:48Reopening plan reviewHorsky moves the plan “as of 818 2021” without the indoor-spectator ban (1:38:27); no second is heard and he withdraws it (1:54:29). Lovett moves that under substantial spread “spectators will be permitted so long as masks are mandatory and social distancing is observed” (1:54:47); no second is heard; roll call (1:55:36 to 1:56:10): Whitney, Horsky, Lambert, Lovett yes; Stone no; Petrin absent; the chair’s answer and the result are not heard. Stone moves Claremont rates (2:10:35), Whitney seconds (2:10:44); withdrawn (2:16:52). Lovett moves “that we accept the matrix as it was amended tonight” (2:17:16, 2:17:35); the second is heard only as the chair’s Second and. followed by an unidentified Josh okay. (2:17:31), apparently Lambert; roll call (2:18:10 to 2:19:18): Whitney, Lambert, Lovett, Sprague yes; Horsky abstains; Stone no; Petrin absent. Chair: “Yes. One abstention and one no.” (2:19:18).
2:19:40Vaccination incentives (raised under the back-to-school fair)Sprague moves “that we authorize the administration to encumber $20,000 to be reimbursed through CARES funds” (2:37:42); seconds from unidentified voices (2:38:05, 2:38:16); target widened to students, staff and families (2:38:12); motion restated as permission to implement (2:39:08). No vote is taken; the superintendent: “You'll have our plan for the next meeting.” (2:40:09). See Flag 2.
2:41:45NominationsQuestions on CARES-funded positions and a social studies position (2:41:53 to 2:48:39). Horsky moves “to accept the nomination of everybody on this list” (2:48:53); Stone seconds (2:49:08); roll call (2:50:18 to 2:50:51): Whitney, Horsky, Lambert, Lovett, Stone yes; Petrin absent; a final No. is labeled Sprague (2:50:51). No result is announced.
2:51:07Elementary school restructuring updateSuperintendent’s update: community forums, a board presentation, and budget work from November (2:51:12 to 2:53:17); questions on pre-K and staffing (2:53:41 to 2:59:22).
2:59:36Items for the next meeting; adjournmentRequests for a discipline-law update, Dr. Janeiro’s entry plan, nominations, a COVID-19 update and the superintendent evaluation tool (2:59:41 to 3:01:51). Lovett moves to adjourn (3:01:58); voice vote (3:02:01).

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/11825 SchoolBoard081821.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

Main topics in recording order, with the most concrete statements first.
TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:03:21Citizens' comment on masksDemers: “I'm hearing that there's a discussion about bringing masks back to school this year”, and “the process of how that gets done should be more public”. The chair answers that the board knows “the difference between a recommendation and a requirement now” (0:05:05).
0:09:11Report: the adopted planThe plan presented August 4: “masks are optional except for busses”; three-foot distancing where possible (0:09:32). The superintendent says he cut the deck “down, I think a cool 70”.
0:12:42Report: matrix and proposed changesMinimal, moderate and substantial levels based on community spread (0:12:42). Proposed changes: a 14-day rather than 7-day window (0:13:28), seating charts for contact tracing instead of “cohorts gives people the willies” (0:14:13), and a bar on spectators at substantial spread, which he says “I personally don't agree with it” (0:14:41, 0:15:08).
0:18:24First reactionsWhitney: “It's data driven.” Horsky disagrees with barring indoor spectators (0:20:12); Sprague wants vaccination rates up: “We're one of the lowest in the state.” (0:21:37).
0:35:42Report: current case data“33 active cases today in Claremont” (0:35:42), “54% of that” of the county’s active cases (0:36:36); Claremont at “43.6%, percent, vaccinated” (0:37:59); for Sullivan County, on a slide whose measure is not read aloud, “We're now we're at 185.” (0:48:14).
0:40:29Staff vaccination recordsThe lead nurse says her Maple Avenue figures came from voluntary emails: “this was just an off the cuff kind of thing that I started doing” (0:40:29); copies of cards are kept “in a locked cabinet” (0:41:27).
0:42:05Incentive idea and objectionThe superintendent proposes incentives “using cares money, not taxpayer money” (0:42:05), estimating “maybe maybe $30,000 or something like that” (0:43:10). Horsky: “it's not local taxpayer money. It's from the federal level.” (0:43:52).OBSERVATION
0:55:19Enrollment and state aidThe chair explains that each student who leaves for VLACS full-time costs adequacy aid: “that's about $4,300” (0:55:46).
1:00:18Elementary and middle school handbooksBoth approved by voice vote (1:00:25, 1:02:10). Romeo describes a move to a digital handbook, printing “probably 75 copies” (1:01:07).
1:03:34Stevens handbook: privileges and serviceJunior privileges now need 12 community-service hours instead of 24 (1:03:34); senior privileges drop from 36 to 24, while the graduation requirement stays at “48 community service hours” (1:04:01).
1:05:04Transcripts under the new grading systemThe chair: “I didn't see a plan for how transcripts would be managed” (1:05:04); students will have “Competencies and then one year of letter grades” (1:05:37, 1:05:45). The handbook is held for a transcript section (1:26:46).
1:06:35High school staffing questionsQuestions on the career counselor, a new social studies position, a student assistance provider and a discipline program coordinator (1:06:35 to 1:11:50). The superintendent: “There are no new funded positions.” (1:16:21); the chair: “this is more money for sure” (1:15:49).
1:12:28New state discipline lawGordon cites “new discipline, sort of law coming down from the state” (1:12:28). Horsky asks that the policy committee take it up ASAP, with a presentation at the next meeting (1:21:03). The superintendent: “you can't have a kid out longer than the, the 10 or 20 days” (1:21:24).OBSERVATION
1:17:30Chair reads the commissioner's emailFrom an email he attributes to the Commissioner of Education: “From 1995 until 2018, on an inflation adjusted basis, your costs have increased 85%, while the number of students has declined 23%.” (1:17:30). The chair: “I'm hypersensitive now to what looks like more staff” (1:17:59). The email is not in the public record.
1:28:12Dr. Janeiro introducedThirty years in Maine, New Hampshire and Massachusetts (1:28:39); an entry plan of being “very much going to be out and about” (1:29:15).
1:38:27Spectators: first motionHorsky moves the plan without the indoor-spectator bar (1:38:27); visitor versus spectator debated (1:40:26 to 1:42:32); Whitney: follow Dr. Chan’s recommendations (1:46:45).MEDIUM
1:54:47Spectator amendment, roll callLovett’s amendment (1:54:47); roll call (1:55:36 to 1:56:10). Answers heard: Whitney Yes, Horsky Yes., Lambert Yes., Lovett Yes., Stone No.; the chair’s answer and the result are not heard.MEDIUM POSITIVE
1:56:29Whitney: decide tonight“so that the administration can act independently and without having to consult with us” (1:56:29).OBSERVATION
1:57:37County or city thresholdsStone: minimal under 5% of Claremont, “which would be around 650 cases” (1:57:37). The superintendent cites counsel’s advice to stay within prevailing guidance (2:00:23, 2:00:53). Lovett cites New York Times data: “you're 75 times more likely to go to the hospital if you're not vaccinated” (2:08:14). Stone’s motion (2:10:35) is withdrawn (2:16:52).
2:17:16Matrix adopted as amendedLovett’s motion (2:17:16); Horsky abstains: “I don't believe I have enough information to vote properly” (2:18:30); Stone No. (2:19:03); chair: “Yes. One abstention and one no.”OBSERVATION POSITIVE
2:20:37Incentives: the plan describedGift cards “to a scale of about $25” (2:20:37); a raffle such as “something about a $1,000 for an adult” (2:23:15); total “capping that at 20,000 or $30,000” (2:23:54). Stone recalls that Richard (Richard Seaman, finance, per the project roster) had said CARES money could not be used (2:24:52). The superintendent: “we could find that in a $38 million budget” (2:27:31).OBSERVATION
2:32:55Incentives: who should be targetedWhitney: “incentivizing children makes me uncomfortable” (2:33:58); Stone favors donations (2:34:51); Lambert suggests posters and school shirts (2:36:09).
2:37:42Incentive motion, no voteSprague’s motion (2:37:42) is seconded by unidentified voices, amended to “Students, staff and families.” (2:38:12), and restated as permission to implement (2:39:08). Lovett: “No I don't know if I'm.” (2:39:39). Whitney suggests a plan instead; the chair: “We don't need a motion for that.” (2:40:05). Horsky wants it “legally vetted and very well written” (2:40:21). The chair moves on (2:41:45).OBSERVATION
2:41:53Nominations and the CARES questionTwo partial positions are CARES-funded: a nurse-leader stipend and part of a billing coordinator’s salary (2:42:22). The chair objects that “we've taken a 0.3, turned it into full time with benefits” (2:47:44). The superintendent credits an in-house program that replaced a contracted teacher “at a substantial savings” (2:49:30, 2:49:50).POSITIVE
2:51:12Elementary restructuringSeven teachers could be reassigned to keep classes “right around 17” (2:54:17); the preschool center would fold into an elementary school (2:54:41); “if it takes another year, it takes another year” (2:57:52).
3:01:58AdjournmentLovett moves to adjourn; voice vote (3:02:01). Chair: “Sorry it was so late.” (3:02:04).

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer’s aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on August 18, 2021, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.

MEDIUM No agenda, packet or minutes survive, and the recording cannot supply several movers, seconders and results

MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting: neither district share holds a year folder older than 2022, and the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023. RSA 91-A:2, II, in the text in force since January 1, 2019, requires minutes that name members and persons appearing, describe the subject matter and final decisions, and state that "The names of the members who made or seconded each motion shall be recorded in the minutes." (statute text), open to inspection "not more than 5 business days after the meeting" (statute text). The MEDIUM limb of the project’s severity rule applies because the record mitigates the gap: the board approves its August 4 minutes on tape (0:02:16 to 0:02:57), and the minutes of this meeting were approved, with an amendment, on September 1 (September 1, 2021 page). They simply do not survive in any public share. The recording cannot stand in for them: the spectator amendment (1:54:47) has no audible second, and its roll call ends without the chair’s answer or an announced result (1:56:10, 1:56:25); the nominations roll ends with an unannounced result (2:50:51); the vaccination-incentive motion is seconded only by unidentified voices (2:38:05, 2:38:16); and the Stevens handbook is treated as tabled without a motion (1:26:40).

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification; source note ends 2018, 244:1, eff. Jan. 1, 2019)

OBSERVATION A $20,000 spending motion was moved, seconded and amended, then left without a vote

The chair moved “that we authorize the administration to encumber $20,000 to be reimbursed through CARES funds to, investigate and develop incentives for students in their families, for CARES for Covid vaccinations” (2:37:42). Unidentified voices seconded (2:38:05, 2:38:16), the motion was widened to staff (2:38:12) and then restated as permission to implement (2:39:08). Members disagreed about what it authorized (2:39:20 to 2:39:30), Lovett hesitated (2:39:39), the superintendent promised a plan for the next meeting (2:40:09), and the chair moved to nominations (2:41:45) with no vote and no withdrawal on the record. On September 1 the board voted to table incentives on the superintendent’s recommendation (September 1, 2021 page), which disposes of the idea but not of this motion as a parliamentary matter. Whether federal relief money could pay for incentives was also left open: Stone said that Richard (the district’s finance administrator, Richard Seaman, per the project roster) had told the board it could not (2:24:52), and the superintendent said, “That's my gut feeling on it.” (2:27:31). No statute examined for this page governs the handling of a pending motion; this is a note on the clarity of the record.

Sources: recording only; no rule cited.

OBSERVATION The adopted 2021-22 matrix was amended orally, and its final text is not in the public record

The board adopted “the decision making matrix for 2122 based off of how we've amended it tonight” (2:17:16). The amendments were made in discussion: the 14-day window (0:13:28), seating charts in place of cohorts (0:14:13), and Lovett’s spectator wording, whose own vote result was never announced (1:54:47, 1:56:10). The only written versions were in the board’s packet and on screen, neither of which survives in a public share. Whitney asked the board to decide “so that the administration can act independently” (1:56:29), but the motion as spoken does not say so. At the next meeting the minutes of this meeting were amended, at Whitney’s request, to record that the vote had empowered the superintendent to act on the matrix (September 1 recording; see the September 1, 2021 page). A reader cannot confirm from any public document what the board adopted or what authority it delegated.

Sources: recording only; no rule cited.

OBSERVATION The board was told of a new state discipline law and asked for a policy review; the follow-up is not in this record

The high school administrator described “new discipline, sort of law coming down from the state” that changes how the school handles in-school and out-of-school suspension (1:12:28), and the superintendent summarized it as limits on long exclusions (1:21:24). RSA 193:13, the suspension and expulsion statute, carries a source note ending "2020, 38:1, eff. July 29, 2020 and July 1, 2021" (statute text), so a change taking effect at the start of the 2021-22 school year is consistent with what the board heard. Its paragraph XI reads: "School boards and chartered public schools shall establish policies on school discipline that contain a system of supports and consequences designed to correct student misconduct and promote behavior within acceptable norms." (statute text). Horsky asked for a policy-committee review and a presentation at the next meeting (1:21:03); the chair asked for at least an email summary (2:59:41). Whether the district’s discipline policies were updated is not shown here, and this page does not determine which parts of the 2020 law took effect on which date.

Sources: RSA 193:13, XI and source note (current text, read 2026-10-03; source note ends 2020, 38:1, eff. July 29, 2020 and July 1, 2021)

POSITIVE Contested decisions were taken by roll call, with an abstention explained on the record

On the three contested items, the spectator amendment (1:55:36), the matrix (2:18:10) and the nominations (2:50:18), the chair asked the clerk for a roll call, so each member’s answer is on the recording. Horsky explained his abstention: “I don't believe I have enough information to vote properly” (2:18:30). RSA 91-A:2 in its 2019 codification requires roll-call votes only when a member participates remotely (paragraph III(e)), and no member is heard participating remotely at this meeting, so the practice goes beyond the statute. The record is still incomplete where the chair’s own answer or the result was not captured (Flag 1).

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, III(e) (2019 codification): roll-call votes required when a member participates remotely

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page