Claremont School Board, September 15, 2021

Regular meeting with the chair participating remotely and the vice chair presiding. After a long statement by the presiding member, the board took a roll-call vote on a motion to remove the Fish Tank program and temporarily reinstate Reading Wonders in the elementary schools, then disputed whether that vote had decided the motion; it also adopted public comment on every action and discussion item and heard the new assistant superintendent’s curriculum-mapping plan. Built from the Claremont Community Television (CCTV) / Claremont Community Media Center (CCMC) recording’s dialogue transcript; no agenda, packet or minutes survive in the district’s online shares. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6)
Date
Wednesday, September 15, 2021 (set at the September 1 meeting for two weeks later, see the September 1 page; MAP.md section 151 and the Cablecast title agree)
Start time
7:00 p.m., stated on the recording at the call to order (0:02:18). Adjournment vote at 1:48:55. The dialogue transcript runs 1:49:13.
Location
Not stated in available records.
Recording
Cablecast: School Board live on 9/15/21 (transcript length 1:49:13; run time from the Cablecast API not retrieved, because the API refuses requests from this environment)
Minutes
None located. MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting (neither district share holds a year folder older than 2022; the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023; checked 9/26/26).
Board composition
Seven members. Frank Sprague (chair) participated remotely; Heather Whitney presided. Rob Lovett Jr.’s attendance is not established by the recording. At least five members were in the room (Whitney, Horsky, Lambert, Petrin, Stone).

Participants

Everyone heard or named as present in the recording. Names follow the project’s 2015-2023 roster and the speaker attribution report for this recording, since no minutes survive; transcript renderings are noted where they differ.
NameRoleParticipation
Heather WhitneyBoard member and vice chair (project roster); presidesPresides in the chair’s absence from the room: “you guys know I don't do this a lot” (0:00:37); calls the meeting to order (0:02:18); moves to reinstate Reading Wonders and remove Fish Tank and explains why at length (0:44:14 to 0:59:20); proposes the voice vote on the public-comment motion (1:44:44); answers Yes. on the roll call (1:25:48).
Frank SpragueChair (participating remotely)Joins by video or audio link: “I think you're muted Frank” (0:35:35). Suggests capping special education at 18 or 19 (0:36:12); on Fish Tank, “either due to, subterfuge or incompetence” (1:18:03); supports per-item public comment and a timekeeper (1:40:28, 1:42:19); questions whether the earlier roll call decided the motion (1:45:04). His roll-call answer is an unidentified Yes. after the clerk calls his name (1:25:43).
Steven HorskyBoard memberMoves the agenda with an added citizens’-comments item (0:03:32, 0:04:35); seconds the minutes (0:05:32); speaks for the Fish Tank motion (0:59:49); says “This board was lied to” (1:00:52); seconds the public-comment motion (1:43:56); asks for the policy within 30 days (1:47:38); moves to adjourn (1:48:48).
Michael PetrinBoard memberAsks that public comment and a nurses’ testing report reach the next agenda (0:03:38, 0:04:00); moves the September 1 minutes (0:05:27); asks about the Newport tech-center agreement and the restructuring timeline (0:40:48, 0:42:31); calls Fish Tank’s use “I find it to be unacceptable.” (1:05:43); calls the question (1:24:37); answers Yes. (1:25:33).
Nicholas StoneBoard memberSeconds the amended agenda (0:04:50); reads the curriculum expectations as directing use of Fish Tank (1:03:40); seconds the call of the question, “Second call.” (1:24:59); moves per-item public comment (1:42:59, 1:43:39); seconds adjournment (1:48:54).
Joshua LambertBoard memberDefends Fish Tank as a tool: “No one was lying to us.” (1:01:47); “We saw their eye ready scores skyrocket after implementing Fish Tank.” (1:03:02); “the only people that made it political was this board” (1:19:28); answers No. on the roll call (1:25:23, 1:25:24); posts agendas on Facebook (1:48:04).
Rob Lovett Jr.Board memberAttendance not established. His name is called at the opening roll with no answer captured (0:03:03); he has no attributed rows; during the roll-call vote, where his name would fall, a voice asks Is that absent? (1:25:28).
Mary WoodmanSchool district clerk and recording secretaryCalls the roll (0:03:03, 0:03:09) and the roll-call vote (1:25:13 to 1:25:47), at first reading Lambert as absent (1:25:13).
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Superintendent’s report on COVID-19 cases and the district dashboard, enrollment, the restructuring forum and schedule work (0:07:40 to 0:33:33); on Fish Tank, “this needs immediate attention” (1:12:42); agrees agenda items should be more specific (1:46:45).
Dr. Mary Ellen JaneiroAssistant Superintendent, SAU 6 (curriculum)“As someone who is now six weeks into the district”, presents a curriculum-mapping plan (1:26:11 to 1:37:56), maps targeted “hopefully by the 1st November” (1:36:31).
Michael DemersCitizens' comments, Ward 3“Michael Demers, Ward three.” Asks that curriculum changes, especially any touching critical race theory, be “very public”… and opposes the vague agenda item “curriculum update”… (0:05:54, 0:06:28).
Unidentified audience memberPublic (name not given)“Finding the agenda was a real interesting puzzle.” “I had to call your office twice.” (1:46:58, 1:47:03).
Jeff SmallDirector of Technology (runs the slides; named on the audio setup)Named in passing (0:00:56, 0:07:40); no attributed rows.

Order of business (reconstructed)

No agenda survives. The presiding member works from a printed agenda with lettered items (0:03:19, 0:04:35); this order follows the recording.

Items in the order taken up, with motions and votes as heard on the recording.
Taken upItemWhat happened
0:02:18Call to order, Pledge, roll call“I'd like to call the Claremont School Board meeting to order. It is currently 7:00.” (0:02:18). Roll (0:02:49 to 0:03:19): Horsky Here.; Lambert and Lovett called with no answer captured; Petrin (rendered “Michael Peacham here.”), Stone and Sprague here; Whitney here.
0:03:19Agenda, amendedHorsky moves the agenda (0:03:32); Petrin seconds and asks for public comment and a testing report on the next agenda (0:03:38). Horsky amends it so that “we will add to our action items under C citizens comments” (0:04:35); Stone seconds (0:04:50); voice vote, “Aye aye aye.” (0:04:56).
0:05:17Minutes of September 1, 2021Petrin moves (0:05:27); Horsky seconds (0:05:32); voice vote (0:05:34).
0:05:45Citizens' commentsMichael Demers, Ward 3, on curriculum transparency (0:05:54 to 0:07:10).
0:07:32Superintendent's reportCOVID-19 cases and dashboard, enrollment, the September 20 restructuring forum, and secondary schedule work (0:07:40 to 0:33:33); opening of schools (0:33:41 to 0:35:19); questions (0:35:42 to 0:43:53).
0:44:14Curriculum update (Fish Tank)Whitney moves “to temporarily reinstate reading wonders as a reading program for Claremont Elementary schools, and to direct the administration to investigate alternate reading programs”; “a yes vote would remove fish tank and reinstate reading wonders” (0:44:14, 0:44:41). Horsky speaks in favor (0:59:49 to 1:01:33); the second is not separately audible. Petrin calls the question (1:24:37); Stone: “Second call.” (1:24:59). Roll call (1:25:11 to 1:25:48); no result announced. Dr. Janeiro then presents her curriculum plan (1:26:05 to 1:37:56). See Flag 3.
1:38:37Citizens' comments processStone moves per-item public comment on “all action slash discussion items” with “a time limit of three minutes” and a chair-appointed timekeeper, general comment kept for non-agenda items, and referral to the policy committee (1:42:59, 1:43:39); Horsky seconds (1:43:56); “Temporary until a policy.” (1:44:06). Voice vote (1:44:56). See Flags 1 and 6.
1:46:21Other business; adjournmentAgenda specificity and the district web page (1:46:25 to 1:47:34); policy-committee timetable (1:47:38); restructuring update request (1:48:20). Horsky moves to adjourn (1:48:48); Stone seconds (1:48:54); voice vote (1:48:55 to 1:49:07).

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/11886 SchoolBoard091521.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

Main topics in recording order, with the most concrete statements first.
TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:05:54Citizens' comment: curriculum transparencyDemers: “any significant changes in curriculum, particularly as it applies to the application of critical race theory, should be very public” (0:06:28); “I'm very much in favor of a very transparent public process” (0:07:10).OBSERVATION
0:13:23Report: COVID-19 cases“we had three more students at Stevens High School” that day (0:13:23); eight Stevens students in all (0:14:48); “one case in the district office” (0:15:54). The district posts a dashboard adapted from Fall Mountain’s (0:10:29); Unity will have a separate matrix (0:10:08).
0:17:08Report: enrollmentStevens has “571 students”, up 35, and “Every school is up students this year” (0:17:08).
0:18:11Report: restructuring forum and surveySummer forums drew “probably about 15 or 20 folks” for the elementary session (0:18:11); the next forum is “at Stevens High School from 6 to 730 on Monday” (0:19:21) (September 20 page); “none of this per se is is budget driven” (0:25:09).
0:31:23Report: secondary schedulesYear-long core courses could add “40 to 50% more time” (0:31:23); Newport’s schedule must be aligned for tech-center students (0:33:08).
0:36:12Chair (remote): special education age“I would be looking at capping, special ed at age 18 or 19” (0:36:12); “currently it's through age 21” (0:36:45); “I know there are federal regulations and such” (0:37:16). The superintendent replies that early intervention works best (0:37:27).OBSERVATION
0:40:48Tech center agreement and restructuring timingPetrin on the Newport tech-center agreement: the superintendent says “It's up soon.”… “It's up to ten years.” (0:41:00). Petrin: restructuring “Now it's looking like we're pushing that to 2324.” (0:42:50); the superintendent: “Not necessarily”… (0:42:54).
0:45:23Whitney: the case against Fish TankThe district’s 2021-22 expectations told elementary teachers to use Fish Tank “as a guide for what to teach during science and social studies” (0:45:23); the board had been told on July 21 that it was the reading program (0:45:50); a newer Reading Wonders edition met every EdReports gateway, she says (0:50:20); she quotes an article recommending “the strategy called camouflaging” (0:56:52); her conclusion: “It has a political activism mission” (0:57:42).OBSERVATION
0:59:49Board reactionHorsky, citing the July 21 recording: “this is not the Social Studies in Science program for Elementary education” (1:00:39); “This board was lied to” (1:00:52). Lambert: “No one was lying to us.” (1:01:47). Petrin: “I would hope it's an error, but it doesn't appear to be an error.” (1:05:43). These are members’ characterizations, not findings.
1:07:36Whitney on labelsShe refers to the state law on “divisive subjects being taught in school” (1:07:36) and says “I don't think you could you can put a label of critical race theory on this curriculum” (1:08:34), calling it instead “a political activist curriculum” (1:09:00).
1:10:35AdministrationThe superintendent: “I don't think we've had that robust conversation on either side” (1:11:22), but “this needs immediate attention” (1:12:42). Lambert: reverting would mean buying “an entire new curriculum for a school year that's already started” (1:15:13).
1:17:06The remote chairPetrin: “I just want to make sure we don't miss Frank.” (1:17:06); the presiding member asks “Frank, are you. Did you go away?” (1:17:34). Sprague: “how did we how did we get here?” (1:18:03).HIGH
1:24:37Question called; roll callPetrin: “I'd like to call the question and take a vote.” (1:24:37); Stone: “Second call.” Answers heard (1:25:11 to 1:25:48): an unidentified Yes. where the roll begins; Lambert No.; Is that absent? where Lovett would be called; Petrin Yes.; an unidentified Yes. where Stone would be called; an unidentified Yes. after the clerk calls Sprague; Whitney Yes. No result is announced.OBSERVATION
1:26:11Curriculum mapping planDr. Janeiro: “The gaps are huge.” (1:26:40); curriculum maps, then scope and sequence (1:28:19, 1:31:46); content-area curriculum councils across grade levels (1:35:33); “we don't have at the elementary levels, some of those solid social studies and science approaches” (1:32:32).
1:39:12Per-item public comment adoptedStone’s proposal (1:39:12, 1:39:44); Sprague would revisit it yearly at the retreat (1:40:28); Petrin prefers a written policy (1:41:33); Lambert: “I think three minutes is a general, widely used time frame” (1:42:36). On the vote: “Can we agree to a voice vote on this?” (1:44:44), “Roll calls. Okay. Voice vote is okay.” (1:44:53).HIGH POSITIVE
1:45:04Was the curriculum motion decided?Sprague: “the vote you took was the vote to, call the question” (1:45:04), “We didn't vote on the motion.” (1:45:32). Petrin: “It was never seconded motion.” (1:46:00). Sprague: “Oh okay. All right. Never mind then.” (1:46:02).OBSERVATION
1:46:58Finding the agendaAn audience member had to call the office twice to find the agenda (1:46:58, 1:47:03); the superintendent says the web page is “clunky, it's awkward” and being rebuilt (1:47:10); Lambert posts agendas on Facebook (1:48:04).OBSERVATION
1:48:48AdjournmentVoice vote; Stone: “Will call. I don't know if we need.” Sprague: “Nobody's going to objected.” (1:49:02, 1:49:07).HIGH

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer’s aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on September 15, 2021, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.

HIGH With the chair participating remotely, four of the five votes were taken by voice; RSA 91-A:2, III(e) required roll calls

The chair took part from outside the room: “I think you're muted Frank” (0:35:35), and the superintendent remarks how he sounds “in the studio to on that Bose speaker Sony system over there” (0:37:50) Petrin later mentions “I know we had some comments on the chat” and asks whether the chair was trying to join in (1:17:06). Under RSA 91-A:2, III, in the text in force from January 1, 2019 to October 2, 2023, remote participation is allowed "only when such attendance is not reasonably practical"; "Any reason that such attendance is not reasonably practical shall be stated in the minutes of the meeting"; the remote member "shall identify the persons present in the location from which the member is participating"; and "All votes taken during such a meeting shall be by roll call vote." (statute text, each). The governor’s Emergency Order #12, which had relaxed in-person quorum rules, lasted only for the COVID-19 state of emergency, and that emergency ended at midnight on June 11, 2021 (NHPR reporting), so the ordinary statute governed this meeting. Only the Fish Tank vote was by roll call (1:25:11). The agenda (0:04:56), the September 1 minutes (0:05:34), the public-comment motion (1:44:56) and adjournment (1:48:55) were voice votes; the board discussed the choice and settled on a voice vote: “Can we agree to a voice vote on this?” (1:44:44), “Roll calls. Okay. Voice vote is okay.” (1:44:53). No statement of why the chair could not attend in person, and no identification of anyone with him, is heard; the chair mentions his throat in passing (0:38:13), and the minutes that would hold a stated reason do not survive. The presiding member asked “Frank, are you. Did you go away?” (1:17:34) during the debate, so at least once the link’s connection was in doubt. Severity is HIGH because paragraph III(e) is mandatory and the record shows the votes were not taken as it requires. Mitigation: the one contested decision was taken by roll call, the voice votes were unanimous as far as the recording shows, and members visibly weighed the point.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, III(a), (c), (e) (2019 codification; source note ends 2018, 244:1; in force to Oct. 2, 2023); Emergency Order #12 (March 23, 2020), duration tied to the state of emergency; NHPR, June 10, 2021: state of emergency to expire (reporting)

MEDIUM No agenda, packet or minutes survive for a meeting that removed an elementary reading program

MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting; neither district share holds a year folder older than 2022. RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes naming members and persons appearing, describing final decisions and recording "The names of the members who made or seconded each motion" (statute text), open to inspection "not more than 5 business days after the meeting" (statute text). The MEDIUM limb applies: the board approved its September 1 minutes at this meeting (0:05:17 to 0:05:34), so minutes were being kept; none survives in a public share. Here the gap matters more than usual: whether the Fish Tank motion was seconded is not separately audible, the result of its roll call was never announced, the vote was later questioned on the record (Flag 3), and Rob Lovett Jr.’s attendance cannot be established from the recording. The minutes are also where RSA 91-A:2, III(a) puts the reason for the chair’s remote attendance (Flag 1).

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification)

OBSERVATION The roll call that removed Fish Tank was never announced, and the board later disagreed about what it decided

Whitney’s motion would “remove fish tank and reinstate reading wonders” (0:44:41), on a temporary basis while the administration investigates other programs (0:44:14). After debate Petrin said “I'd like to call the question and take a vote.” (1:24:37), Stone said “Second call.” (1:24:59), and the presiding member called for a roll call (1:25:03). Five Yes. answers and one No. are heard, with Lovett apparently marked absent, but no tally or result is stated (1:25:11 to 1:25:55). Twenty minutes later the remote chair argued the vote had only closed debate (1:45:04, 1:45:32); Petrin answered that his call “was never seconded motion” (1:46:00), and the board treated the roll call as the vote on the motion (1:46:02 to 1:46:11). The recording shows Stone’s second at 1:24:59, so the board’s own explanation does not match it. Under ordinary parliamentary practice a seconded call of the question is voted on before the main motion; whether a single roll call can be read as both is for the minutes and the board to say, and the minutes do not survive. The program in use was being replaced two weeks into the school year on this vote. Horsky’s statement that “This board was lied to” (1:00:52) and the chair’s “subterfuge or incompetence”… (1:18:03) are members’ characterizations; Lambert disputed them (1:01:47), and the July 21 recording they rely on is not part of this page.

Sources: recording only; no rule cited (Robert’s Rules of Order is the board’s chosen procedure, not law).

OBSERVATION A member of the public could not find the agenda, and the curriculum item was posted only as a two-word heading

Demers learned of the item only as “curriculum update”… on the agenda (0:06:28) and asked for a public process before any significant curriculum change (0:07:10); the item turned into a motion to remove a reading program (0:44:14). An audience member said “Finding the agenda was a real interesting puzzle.” (1:46:58). The superintendent agreed items should be “as detailed as we can be” (1:46:45). RSA 91-A:2, II in its 2019 codification requires notice of the time and place of a meeting posted in two appropriate places at least 24 hours ahead; it does not require a published agenda or a description of each item, so this is not a finding of a violation. It records that the public’s practical access to the business of this meeting was limited, which the board and administration acknowledged.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification; notice of time and place)

OBSERVATION The chair floated ending special education at 18 or 19; federal law sets the range and ties any exception to state law, not to a local board

The chair said that, if he were running things, “I would be looking at capping, special ed at age 18 or 19” (0:36:12), adding “I know there are federal regulations and such” (0:37:16). Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, "A free appropriate public education is available to all children with disabilities residing in the State between the ages of 3 and 21, inclusive" (statute text), and the obligation for ages 18 through 21 lifts only "to the extent that its application to those children would be inconsistent with State law or practice" (statute text). A cap at 18 or 19 is therefore a question of state law, not something a school board can adopt by policy. This page did not verify the New Hampshire provision. No motion was made; the remark is recorded because it was offered as a budget idea in a public meeting.

Sources: 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(1)(A)-(B) (FAPE ages 3 through 21; exception tied to state law or practice)

POSITIVE The board opened every action and discussion item to public comment, before any law required it

Acting on a resident’s September 1 request (September 1 page), the board voted to take public comment on each action and discussion item, three minutes per speaker, with a chair-appointed timekeeper, keeping the general comment period for non-agenda items and sending the rule to the policy committee (1:42:59 to 1:44:56); Horsky asked for the policy within 30 days (1:47:38). No New Hampshire statute in force in September 2021 required school boards to hold a public comment period at all; RSA 189:74’s minimum of 30 minutes took effect September 6, 2022. The practice therefore went beyond the legal minimum of its day. The vote itself was by voice while a member was remote (Flag 1).

Sources: RSA 189:74 (public comment, at least 30 minutes; 2022, 333:1, eff. Sept. 6, 2022), cited for its effective date only

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page