Claremont School Board, October 18, 2023

Regular meeting with five of seven members in the room. The board accepted a $6,000 Schwab Charitable donation after a public hearing, voted to retain up to $424,000 of year-end fund balance after the business administrator said the FY2022 audit had only just started, approved a two-year athletic-fields license with the City of Claremont, and adopted a letter of support for career and technical education. The page is built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript, the posted agenda and packet, and the approved minutes. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6)
Date
Wednesday, October 18, 2023
Start time
6:30 p.m. scheduled (agenda). The chair calls the meeting to order at 0:00:16 and declares it adjourned at 1:42:45. The minutes record no clock times beyond the agenda's. No nonpublic session was held.
Location
Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center, per the agenda and minutes
Recording
Cablecast: Claremont School Board 10/18/23 (the transcript runs 1:42:53; run time from the Cablecast API not retrieved, the API refuses requests from this environment)
Minutes
16. CSB Meeting Minutes 10.18.23 (approved November 1, 2023); draft copy draft CSB Meeting Minutes 10.18.23.docx.pdf in the 11/1/23 packet
Board composition
Seven seats, all filled: Heather Whitney (chair), Frank Sprague (vice chair), Arlene Hawkins, Candace Crawford, Whitney Skillen, Bonnie Miles, Jennifer Gallagher. No roll call was taken on tape; the chair says only that "we're fortunate enough to have a quorum this evening" (0:00:41). Five members are heard. Gallagher was absent (chair at 1:33:49; minutes) and Miles was absent (the approved November 1 minutes: "Bonnie Miles was not present at the last board meeting on 10.18.23").

Participants

Everyone in the record. Name spellings follow the agenda and minutes. Speaker labels come from the dialogue file; where the minutes name a speaker the file leaves unidentified, the row says so.
NameRoleParticipation
Heather WhitneyChairCalls the meeting to order (0:00:16), runs the consent agenda and donation hearing by "no objection", reports on the October 11 self-evaluation retreat (1:19:14), asks for an audit status (1:15:06) and a budget timeline for November 1, and says the student-representative seat is unfilled (1:40:54).
Frank SpragueVice chair; NHSBA delegateMoves acceptance of the donation (0:02:14); asks what to tell city councilors about keeping $424,000 (1:10:11); argues there was a fields budget line (1:23:36); reads the CTE support letter (1:30:41); reports on the NHSBA delegate assembly (1:34:13).
Arlene HawkinsMember (also SAU 6 board chair)Asks the superintendent to write measurable student-achievement growth into his goal (0:11:11), which he agrees to amend; questions VLACS supervision and the book machine; asks whether retained funds need a hearing before use (1:11:24). The minutes record her as seconder of the CTE letter.
Candace CrawfordMemberAsks about parent programs and a PTO (0:44:21); suggests downtown storefronts and the old community center for the alternative program; moves fund-balance retention (1:12:29), the fields license (1:26:38) and the CTE letter (1:31:59).
Whitney SkillenMember; policy subcommittee chairAsks for outcomes, a timeline and a written procedure for the budgeting goal (0:16:07, 0:19:17); asks what blocks a late bus; reports on the policy subcommittee's operating plan under policy BG (1:28:02). Heard 21 times, but the minutes list her neither present nor absent.
Jennifer GallagherMember; curriculum and ad hoc disruptive-behaviors chairAbsent. "Unfortunately, Jennifer Gallagher is unable to attend this evening." (1:33:49); the minutes list her absent.
Bonnie MilesMember; capital improvement chairAbsent per the approved November 1 minutes, which correct the record at the consent agenda. Never heard on this recording. The October 18 minutes list her neither present nor absent.
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Presents three district goals and the River Valley Community College nursing pathway (0:02:44); says the district has had "$13 million of extra federal grant money" to wind down (0:17:09); presents the athletic-fields license (1:22:18); raises the Goshen tuition meeting on December 18.
Mary HenryBusiness administratorRecommends retaining up to $424,000 because the audits are incomplete (1:07:26); reports FY2021 audited and FY2022 "just got started" (1:16:09); gives the fields line history and actuals (1:24:18).
Ben NesterDirector of Special EducationReports six candidate locations for the alternative program (1:00:08).
Mike KoskiAssistant superintendentNamed by Romeo and Tempesta. The minutes record that "Assistant Superintendent Koski speaks about a 3 year plan" under the curriculum report; the dialogue file leaves that voice (1:29:44) Unidentified.
Frank RomeoPrincipal, Claremont Middle SchoolCMS update: two seventh-grade vacancies covered by half-year VLACS courses (0:21:55), answers to the board's written questions on behavior alignment, cell phones, deans and student centers, late bus and the book vending machine.
Courtney SteeleClaremont Middle School staff (VLACS registrations)Explains VLACS enrollment and supervision (0:24:51): "At this point, I have registered all but one student".
Lydia; Andrew (surnames not spoken)CMS staff named by the principalRomeo credits them with the cell-phone data (0:34:18). Not separately heard.
Chelsea WeatherfordRecording secretarySigns the minutes ("Submitted by Chelsea Weatherford"); the chair asks members to send questions for the next meeting "to Chelsea with a CC to Mike" (1:39:48).
UnidentifiedVarious44 of 647 rows (6.8%), mostly assents, the Pledge and spoken ayes, plus a voice heard from 1:28:27 to the end (see Koski above).
Citizens' commentsNone"Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak to the board in this session?" No one did (0:01:06, 0:01:33); no one spoke at the donation hearing.

Agenda

Items from the posted agenda (CSB Agenda 10.18.23) with dispositions from the recording and the minutes.
Taken upItemAgenda text / disposition
0:00:16I. Call to order, PledgeAgenda: "6:30 PM Call to Order and Pledge of Allegiance". Minutes: "Meeting called to order by chair Heather Whitney."
0:00:41II. General business: roll call, consent agendaAgenda lists "Secretary Roll Call of Attendance of Board Members"; no roll was called. Consent agenda (agenda and 10/4/23 minutes) approved by "no objection" (0:01:06). The chair notes the retreat minutes are missing from the packet: "I don't see them, so we'll revisit them at a different time." Citizens' comments: none.
0:01:33III–IV. Public hearing: $6,000 donation from Schwab Charitable FundHearing opened and closed with no speakers. Sprague moves "to accept the Schwab Charitable Trust donation of $6,000. With thanks." (0:02:14); a second is heard but its speaker is not identified on tape; the minutes name Crawford. Accepted with no opposition (0:02:24).
0:02:44V. Superintendent report: district-wide goals 2023-24Three goals in the packet slide deck: weekly school visits, an improved budgeting process, regional partnerships (RVCC nursing). Board questions from Hawkins and Skillen; the superintendent agrees to amend goal 1.
0:20:35VI.1 Claremont Middle School update (Principal Romeo)Staffing and VLACS, then the written answers in "CMS Board Questions". Discussion only.
1:00:08VI.2 Alternative program location (Ben Nester)Taken up after the chair began item 3 and was reminded (0:59:51). Six options reported; no vote. The agenda's future dates schedule a January 2024 update.
1:07:26VI.3 Claremont District budget update / surplus (discussion and vote)Crawford moves to retain up to $424,000 (1:12:29), Sprague seconds; the chair calls the question by no objection and the motion carries on a voice vote with no opposition (1:17:38). Minutes: "Candace Crawford makes a motion to retain up to $424,000 for fund balance retention; seconded by Frank Sprague; all in favor via voice vote." Budget timeline set for November 1.
1:19:14VI.4 Self-evaluation retreat reportDiscussion. Board profiles on the website by January 2024; board goals to be printed on the back of agendas.
1:22:18VI.5 Non-exclusive MOU with the City for athletic fields (discussion and vote)The packet document is a two-year "LICENSE AGREEMENT" (September 1, 2023 to August 31, 2025), initial annual fee $30,000 with a 2% to 6% CPI escalator. Crawford moves, Sprague seconds (1:27:25); carried unanimously on a voice vote (1:27:34).
1:27:34VI.6 Subcommittee reportsCapital improvement: nothing. Policy: operating plan under policy BG. Curriculum: three-year plan (minutes: Koski). SRVRTC visioning: CTE support letter read (1:30:41); Crawford moves (1:31:59); the tape has both Hawkins and Sprague offering a second, the minutes name Hawkins; carried on a voice vote (1:33:24). Ad hoc disruptive behaviors: no update in Gallagher's absence.
1:34:00VII. Other businessNHSBA delegate assembly report (Sprague); volunteer sought for the Goshen tuition meeting, December 18; student representative still unrecruited.
1:39:48VIII. Future dates and agenda itemsQuestions for the November 1 presenters to go to the clerk in advance; the clerk position to be on the November 1 agenda (1:41:43).
1:42:45IX. AdjournmentBy no objection. Agenda time 8:30 p.m.; the minutes give no actual time.

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/15357 SchoolBoard101823.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:41Quorum without a roll call; retreat minutes missing"Looks like we're fortunate enough to have a quorum this evening. So we're going to move forward with our consent agenda." On the retreat minutes: "there were minutes in the packet are supposed to be in the packet for our retreat. I don't see them, so we'll revisit them at a different time."MEDIUM MEDIUM
0:01:33Donation hearing and acceptanceHearing on "the donation from to the Claremont School District from the Swab Charitable fund, total of amounting $6,000"; no speakers. Accepted on Sprague's motion with no opposition at 0:02:24. The packet's Exhibit A reproduces the cheque.OBS POSITIVE
0:02:44Superintendent's goals; RVCC nursing pathwayGoal 1, weekly visits to all schools; goal 2, the budgeting process ("We have some new people in the business office"); goal 3, regional partners. RVCC slides: 292 nursing job postings in the region; high-school students could work in the hospital "at a wage of, you know, over $20 an hour."
0:11:11Hawkins asks for measurable goalsHawkins wants goal 1 to include "Measuring growth in student achievement and professional instructional practices in all the schools." Tempesta: "Have done goals my whole career. I can definitely amend the goal." (0:14:13)
0:16:07Budget-process goal; federal money endingSkillen asks what the budgeting goal will deliver and when. Tempesta: "we've had $13 million of extra federal grant money in the budget, and we have to make sure that we are exiting." (0:17:09) On tuition: "tuition is coming in at 16, 17,000". Skillen asks for a written "procedural plan or SOP" (0:19:17).HIGH
0:21:55CMS staffing and VLACSRomeo: two seventh-grade posts (math and science) still vacant and advertised; students split half-year between online VLACS and in-person classes "so that no one student will have either all online or all in person." Steele: "we are one of 18 schools in this same boat" (0:24:51).
0:32:07Board's written questions: behavior alignment, cell phonesHandbook alignment with Stevens since the summer; restorative practices adapted for "ten and 11, 12 years old". Cell-phone violations broken down by grade from the packet; Romeo is "not opposed to taking a look at" the high school's approach but wants a lesson attached (0:35:37).
0:40:05Late bus, reading, book vending machine"If we had a late bus, we would have so much more, just participation and activity in our building." Tempesta at 0:52:26: two additional drivers, and "we also used the Esser money to leverage two busses as well"; "it was the staffing and it was the, the fleet."
0:42:53"Properly staffing"Romeo: "we are short staffed in a number of places, including Paris" [paras], but fully staffed with special educators.
0:54:32Student centers and ineligibilityThe chair asks how student-center use is tracked. Romeo: ineligibility lists were "15 and 20" before the student centers and "four and five" after (0:56:57), "down to 1 or 2 students" now, in "a school of 375 kids".
1:00:08Alternative program locationsRVCC classrooms; Claremont Savings Bank space at "annual cost of about $25,000"; the charter-school building is full; two Pleasant Street storefronts at "around 13 to $1400" a month; space at Stevens. Sprague recalls the earlier program "subcontracted it to Ombudsman" in the Goddard Block (1:02:01).
1:07:26Fund-balance retentionHenry: the RSA is attached; the maximum "this year" is "The 424,000"; "You have to use the word up to". Her reason: "I'm going to recommend that only because of adits and what has been happening with those. They're not complete." "Yours is only 2.5%, even though the RSA allows up to five." (1:09:13)OBS
1:10:11"Why didn't you send 200,000 back?"Sprague: retaining $424,000 is "about 200,000 more than we usually do". Henry: "I'm very worried about those audits and what they may reveal. And if you don't have the funds, you will run into a deficit." Hawkins asks whether using the money needs a hearing and a vote (1:11:24).OBS
1:15:06Audit status"Right now 21 is done." The auditor's timeline for filing "with the state in that or the federal clearinghouse" is uncertain; "We just got started on 22." (1:16:09) "My biggest thing for that right now is reconciling grants." (1:16:14) FY2023 hoped for next year.HIGH
1:17:38Retention vote"The motion before us is to retain up to 424,000, in our fund balance for fund balance retention." Spoken Aye, no opposition.
1:19:14Retreat reportTwo evaluation tools, one from NHSBA; a statement of support for the technical center assigned to Sprague; board profiles on the website "for January 2024"; board goals on the back of the agenda.MEDIUM
1:22:18Athletic-fields licenseTempesta: a two-year term instead of six; "$30,000 for the maintenance of that. It is." "It's a good deal." "Even if we go the full 6%, it's 1800 a year additional". Henry: the fields line has held about $5,000; "The actual for last year was 30,000 we spent to the city, and the prior year was 14,275." (1:24:35) "We spent more than what we've budgeted."OBS
1:26:38License motionCrawford moves; the chair frames it as the "License agreement made between the city of Claremont, New Hampshire, and," with Sprague supplying "Claremont School District." Carried unanimously (1:27:34).OBS
1:28:02Policy subcommitteeSkillen: an operating plan to "operationalize that sentence" of policy BG letting the committee delegate policy revisions to other members, with a shared drive.
1:29:44Curriculum report"We're working on a three year plan, which hasn't been done in the long, long time". Speaker unlabeled in the dialogue file; the minutes attribute the report to Assistant Superintendent Koski.
1:30:41CTE support letter"Therefore, the Claremont School Board gives its full support to the continued growth of the River Valley Technical Center and wholeheartedly endorses the formal data driven process to evaluate existing offerings". Sprague had already "given a copy to the press" (1:30:37). The chair asks that it not be "completely prescriptive" (1:32:10). Approved by voice vote.
1:34:13NHSBA delegate assemblyOyster River named school board of the year; the Manchester sustainability resolution failed narrowly; a CHINS resolution may be developed with Monadnock for next year.
1:37:38Goshen tuition meetingDecember 18, a Monday at six. Tempesta: the Goshen contact "intimated that it might we might need a quorum"; he will clarify. Goshen has "85 kids in the town and they don't have any schools."
1:39:48Next meeting and student representativeA "very dense meeting" on November 1; questions to the presenters in advance. Stevens "is still searching for a volunteer" for student representative (1:40:54).

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on October 18, 2023, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.

HIGH The FY2022 audit had "just got started" more than six months after the federal single-audit deadline

Asked how many audits were outstanding, the business administrator said "Right now 21 is done" (1:15:11) and of FY2022: "We're working. We just got started on 22." (1:16:09). She described the filing as one "with the state in that or the federal clearinghouse" (1:15:34) and named grant reconciliation as her biggest obstacle (1:16:14). The superintendent had just said the district carried "$13 million of extra federal grant money" in its budgets (0:17:09). Under the Uniform Guidance in force for FY2022, an entity that spends $750,000 or more in federal awards in a year must have a single audit, and the reporting package is due "within the earlier of 30 calendar days after receipt of the auditor's report(s), or nine months after the end of the audit period." For the year ended June 30, 2022 that was March 31, 2023; on October 18, 2023 the audit had only begun. Mitigation on the record: the business office was new (Tempesta: "We have some new people in the business office", 0:05:14), FY2021 was finished, and the administrator described a standing Zoom call with "the auditors and his team" (1:17:30). State law does not fix a deadline: RSA 21-J:19 is permissive as to timing, so the deadline this flag rests on is the federal one. The district's FY2022 federal expenditure total is not in this record; the clearinghouse reference and the ESSER figures are the basis for treating the single-audit rule as applicable.

Sources: 2 CFR 200.501(a) (2023 edition: single audit at $750,000 or more in federal expenditures); 2 CFR 200.512(a)(1) (2023 edition: nine months after period end); RSA 21-J:19 (audits by independent accountants; permissive as to timing)

MEDIUM No roll call, and the approved minutes account for only five of seven members and were never corrected for Miles

The agenda lists "Secretary Roll Call of Attendance of Board Members", but no roll was called; the chair said only that a quorum was present (0:00:41). The approved minutes read "Present: Heather Whitney, Frank Sprague, Candace Crawford, Arlene Hawkins Absent: Jennifer Gallagher". Whitney Skillen, who speaks 21 times on the recording and reports for the policy subcommittee, is in neither column, and so is Bonnie Miles. At the next meeting the board approved this set of minutes with the correction "Bonnie Miles was not present at the last board meeting on 10.18.23" (November 1 minutes), yet the copy in the Meeting Minutes share, last modified November 7, 2023, still omits Miles and Skillen. RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes to "include the names of members", and an attendance record built without a roll call is the likeliest cause of the gap. Two seconders also differ between the tape and the minutes: the donation's second is heard but not identifiable on tape (0:02:24), and for the CTE letter both Hawkins (1:32:03) and Sprague (1:32:08) offer a second while the minutes name Hawkins alone. Mitigation: every vote was unopposed, and five members are a quorum of seven, so no outcome turns on the gap.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2023 codification, in force from Oct. 3, 2023: minutes name members and the mover and seconder of each motion)

MEDIUM Minutes of the October 11 retreat were not in the packet and reached the public share ten business days after it

The October 11, 2023 self-evaluation retreat was a meeting of the board: its minutes record five members (Whitney, Skillen, Hawkins, Sprague, and Gallagher from 5:30 p.m.) with NHSBA counsel, 5:00 to 7:30 p.m., reviewing board goals. On October 18 the chair said those minutes were "supposed to be in the packet" and were not (0:00:41). They appear in the November 1 packet folder: the file Claremont School Board Self-Evaluation Retreat Meeting minutes 10.11.23 (1).pdf was created in Drive on October 25, 2023 (modified the same day), the tenth business day after the retreat. RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes to be "open to public inspection not more than 5 business days after the meeting", which for October 11 was October 18. The MEDIUM limb applies because the minutes exist and the delay is about a week, not an absence. Drive's created date shows when the public share received the file, not when the minutes were written, so the minutes may have been available on request sooner; nothing in the record says so. The retreat minutes record no location; this page did not search for a separate notice of the session.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2023 codification: five business days; business day defined); Retreat minutes 10.11.23 (Drive, created 2023-10-25)

OBSERVATION The fields license names SAU 6, not the district, and its first $30,000 fee was paid before the board approved it

The board moved to approve a license "between the city of Claremont, New Hampshire, and" the "Claremont School District" (1:27:02), and the minutes say the same. The packet document instead names as licensee "New Hampshire School Administrative Unit #6, a duly registered non-profit corporation", defines that party as "School District", and has the superintendent sign as "Duly authorized by majority vote of the: N.H. School Administrative Unit #6". Its term began September 1, 2023, before this vote, and it describes the $30,000 Initial Annual Fee as one "that the School District has already provided to the City". On tape the business administrator said the fields line had carried about $5,000 a year while "The actual for last year was 30,000 we spent to the city" (1:24:35) and "We spent more than what we've budgeted." The license does protect the district with a non-appropriation clause (paragraph 4c). No rule is cited because the record does not show which entity paid, from which appropriation, or whether the SAU 6 board ever voted on the document. The FY2023 expenditure and any transfer records under RSA 32:10, and SAU 6 minutes, would settle it.

Sources: SAU License for Athletic Fields (SMT Revisions August 22 2023) 2yr.doc.pdf; RSA 32:10 (transfers between appropriations; records open to citizens)

OBSERVATION Fund-balance retention: within the voters' 2.5 percent, but the base was described as FY2022's

RSA 198:4-b, II lets the district, "by a vote of the legislative body", authorize retention of year-end unassigned funds up to "5 percent of the current fiscal year's net assessment under RSA 198:5", and requires a prior public hearing before the money is spent. The business administrator's account was consistent with that: the voters had authorized 2.5 percent ("Yours is only 2.5%, even though the RSA allows up to five", 1:09:13), the motion should say up to, and the money cannot be touched without "a, public hearing and a vote of the board". She described the base, though, as "2.5% of the amount of money you had to raise in fiscal year 22" (1:09:55), where the statute measures against the current fiscal year's net assessment. The district's warrant article and the DOE-25 worksheet would show which figure was used. The stated reason, that incomplete audits might show "we've given back too much to the taxpayers" (1:08:42), is a reasonable caution and ties this vote to flag 1.

Sources: RSA 198:4-b, II (2023 codification; 2020, 38:25: 5 percent cap, legislative-body vote, hearing before expending)

OBSERVATION The packet publishes an image of the donation cheque with its bank encoding line

Exhibit A- Schwab Charitable Donation.pdf, posted in the public packet folder, reproduces the Schwab Charitable cheque with the drawee bank, cheque number and the machine-readable routing and account line. This page reproduces none of those numbers. The payer is a charitable fund rather than an individual, which lowers the risk, but the same class of exposure recurs in this corpus with individual donors. RSA 91-A:5, IV permits withholding "confidential, commercial, or financial information"; it does not require it, so this is a practice point, not a violation. A redacted copy or a transmittal letter would serve the hearing equally well.

Sources: RSA 91-A:5, IV (financial information may be withheld)

POSITIVE A public hearing for a $6,000 gift, and draft minutes posted on the fifth business day

Since July 18, 2023, RSA 198:20-b, III(b) has required only that unanticipated funds under $20,000 be posted "in the agenda" and noted in the minutes; a hearing is required at $20,000 or more. The board noticed the gift on the agenda, held a public hearing anyway (0:01:33), and voted acceptance in open session. Separately, the draft minutes of this meeting were created in the November 1 packet folder on October 25, 2023 at 3:57 p.m., inside the fifth business day after October 18, meeting RSA 91-A:2, II.

Sources: RSA 198:20-b, III (2023, 38:1, eff. July 18, 2023: hearing at $20,000 or more; agenda notice below); RSA 91-A:2, II

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page