Claremont School Board, November 20, 2024

Regular meeting, six of seven members present. The board accepted a consent agenda that included minutes of the unrecorded November 14 special meeting, went into a brief nonpublic session, heard the superintendent's report and an update on the three instructional coaches, and ratified the teachers' (SREA) contract with 2.5% cost-of-living increases in each of two years, without counsel present and without the contract in the public packet. The page is built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript, the agenda, the packet and the approved minutes. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board
Date
Wednesday, November 20, 2024
Start time
Agenda: 6:30 p.m. Called to order at 0:00:05 of the recording. The approved minutes record "Consent adjournment at 7:41pm"; the tape reaches adjournment at 0:56:31, 56 minutes in. The nonpublic session occupies 0:11:59 to 0:12:24, 25 seconds of tape. Read against the spoken clock references (the chair asked counsel at 719 and he joined at 0:53:15), and assuming the agenda's 6:30 p.m. call to order, the 7:41 p.m. adjournment implies roughly 14 minutes missing from the tape, which fits a nonpublic session of that length removed from the recording. That is a reconstruction; the minutes give no nonpublic times. The dialogue transcript runs 0:56:37.
Location
Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center, Claremont (agenda). Carried on CCTV Channel 8.
Recording
Cablecast: School Board Meeting 11/20/24 (show 16157; the Cablecast API refuses this environment, so the extent is taken from the last dialogue row, 0:56:37)
Minutes
9. Approved CSB meeting minutes 11.20.24; the draft, 11.20.24 DRAFT CSB meeting minutes.pdf, was filed in the December 4 packet and created in Drive December 3, 2024. See flag 3. Clerk Noelle Kronberg present and called both roll calls.
Board composition
Seven members. Present per the approved minutes: Heather Whitney (chair), Frank Sprague (vice chair), Candace Crawford, Arlene Hawkins, Bonnie Miles, Michael Petrin. Absent: Whitney Skillen. The agenda masthead lists student members Miles Sheehan and Lilly Clark; neither is heard and the minutes do not record them.

Participants

Everyone heard or recorded in the minutes. Spellings and attendance follow the agenda masthead and the approved minutes; where the dialogue file's label differs, that is noted. Unidentified voices stay unidentified.
NameRoleParticipation
Heather WhitneyChair; member of the board's negotiating teamPresides. Takes the consent agenda without a vote ("Seeing no opposition", 0:01:48). Describes the SREA settlement: extra-duty pay raised, "the cola this year is going to be for this for 25 and 26 and 26 to 27. It's two and a half. Two and a half." (0:45:45); paraprofessional pay as a board goal (0:45:57); a higher mentor stipend (0:46:45). Declares the agreement "documented October 30th, 2024, has been ratified." (0:52:38). Asks why the open coaching position sits at the elementary level (0:31:04, 0:33:07).
Frank SpragueVice chair; Finance Committee chairReports the previous day's Finance Committee session: "It's televised" (0:39:14, 0:39:36). On the contract: "We can't make changes." "Would that be a. Violation of the rules." (0:51:42, 0:51:45). Seconds the ratification (0:52:31). Reports he and a Unity member met the superintendent on his goals (0:44:04).
Candace CrawfordMember; Capital Improvements chairAsks whether the contract can absorb a change of health insurer after a 15% increase (0:48:13). Moves ratification: "Ratify the contract negotiated by the team." (0:52:27). Reports a capital-improvements spreadsheet received from the superintendent that day (0:38:46).
Michael PetrinMemberMoves the nonpublic session: "Make a motion to go into nonpublic prayer. RSA nine one. Dash a colon three." (0:11:36). Seconds the return to public session (0:12:32). Asks whether teachers who do not seek coaching will ever be assigned it (0:22:38).
Bonnie MilesMemberMoves to leave nonpublic ("We come out of nonpublic smiles", 0:12:29; smiles is her surname, per the minutes). Suggests more students write Veterans Day cards (0:09:46). "I read it this afternoon and I have no questions." on the contract (0:52:18). Moves to adjourn (0:56:34).
Arlene HawkinsMemberSeconds the nonpublic motion (minutes). Asks how coaching meetings are distributed (0:18:18) and the coach's curriculum split (0:33:50); asks whether the state must pass a federal grant through (0:36:52).
Whitney SkillenMemberAbsent (approved minutes). Named on tape as the third board negotiator (Miss Gillan, 0:45:09).
Noelle KronbergBoard clerkCalls the roll and both nonpublic roll calls (Miss Cronenberg, 0:11:45; Noel, 0:12:36); signs the minutes.
Chris PrattSuperintendentSuperintendent's report, school by school (0:02:03): middle school "26 out of school suspensions" (0:06:49), which he attributes to "a higher level of accountability than in past years" (0:07:08). Grant for social outreach "about at $115,000 over 4 or 5 years", later "115 to $125,000 a year" (0:34:34, 0:36:39), on hold pending federal action (0:34:59). On health insurance during bargaining: unions "are usually open to discussion if it's a cost savings" (0:49:54).
Mike KoskiAssistant SuperintendentPresents the coaching data (0:13:33); "we're working with the willing" (0:18:31); the elementary coach is split "0.6 curriculum director 0.4. Elementary coach" (0:33:57). Disposal of an unrepairable keyboard (0:37:21). Catches the wrong minutes date on the consent agenda, "because I have to send this set of minutes to the state for a report" (0:50:24).
Mary HenryBusiness AdministratorDraft budget "That's my job for tomorrow." (0:40:32). On the contract naming SchoolCare: "It's up to them to not, you know, the union to see if they're willing to do anything." (0:48:54).
Matt UptonDistrict counselJoins by video after the vote (0:53:15): "I think it's a really fair contract." (0:53:24).
UnidentifiedVarious14 of 346 rows (4.0%), plus 7 rows labeled Multiple (the pledge and roll responses). No member of the public spoke ("Seeing no citizens to comment", 0:01:48).

Agenda

Items from CSB Agenda 11.20.24 (3) (1).pdf; agenda wording is quoted from that document. Dispositions from the recording, checked against the approved minutes. The chair reordered items while waiting for counsel.
Taken upItemAgenda text / disposition
0:00:05I. Call to order, pledgeAgenda: "6:30 PM Call to Order and Pledge of Allegiance". Roll call (0:00:31).
0:00:44II.a Consent agendaAgenda: "Minutes Approval- 10.2.24 & 11.14.24". Accepted "Seeing no opposition" (0:01:48), no vote. At 0:50:24, 49 minutes later, the assistant superintendent points out the October date should be 10.16; it is "noted and changed" with no new vote. The approved minutes record the approval as "10.16.24 & 11.14.24" and Koski's correction. See flag 4 and flag 5.
0:01:48II.b Citizens' commentsNone.
0:02:03III. Superintendent's reportSummary of the written November report: HR coordinator starting December 2, enrollment, attendance and discipline by school, open counseling positions (0:09:22). See flag 7.
0:11:16IV.1 Nonpublic sessionAgenda heads it "Non-Public Meeting Session RSA 91-A: 3" and prints the text of exemption (a). Petrin moves, Hawkins seconds (minutes); roll call by the clerk (0:11:45). Return: Miles moves, Petrin seconds; roll call (0:12:29, 0:12:36). Minutes: "No need to seal the minutes". See flag 2.
0:12:46IV.3 Instructional coachesTaken ahead of IV.2 while counsel was unavailable. Discussion only.
0:34:23IV.4 Grant award to improve social outreach and servicesDiscussion only.
0:37:08(IV.4a) Instrument disposalAgenda: "Instrument Disposal (Discussion/Vote)", printed without its own number ("This agenda was, modified multiple times, so the number did not get there"). Disposed of by consent, no vote (0:37:53).
0:38:18IV.5 Subcommittee reportsCapital Improvements scheduling; Finance Committee report on the November 19 session (0:39:14); ad hoc communications (0:44:04).
0:44:52IV.2 SREA contract ratification (Exhibit A)Agenda: "SREA Contract Ratification (Discussion and Vote) (Exhibit A) Matt Upton, Esq. SAU 6". Exhibit A is not among the six documents in the packet folder. Presented by the chair and vice chair; counsel absent until after the vote. Crawford moves, Sprague seconds (0:52:23, 0:52:31); voice vote, no opposition (0:52:35). See flag 1.
0:52:56VI. Future datesBoard December 4 and 18; budget hearing January 2, 2025; strategic plan roll-out November 21 (0:54:36).
0:56:31VII. Adjournment"If there's no objection, I'd like to adjourn." Minutes: "Consent adjournment at 7:41pm".

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/16157 SchoolBoard112024.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:44Consent agenda"The items on this evening's consent agenda includes a final approval of the board agenda, and minutes approval from the meetings of 10 to 24 and 11, 1424." Counsel will join by Zoom when free (0:01:18). "Seeing no opposition. We're going to accept the items on the consent agenda." (0:01:48).OBSERVATION OBSERVATION
0:03:57Superintendent's reportStevens: "Over 1031 skills practiced primarily in grades ten and 11." Middle school: "Discipline is a little on the high side. 26 out of school suspensions of OSS. 17 bullying. Harassment incidents investigated." (0:06:49); the written report prints 7 investigated incidents. "this is just a higher level of accountability than in past years." (0:07:08).POSITIVE
0:09:46Veterans Day cardsMiles reports students made cards for veterans and hopes more will next year.
0:11:16Into nonpublicChair: "Our first item this evening as a nonpublic session for RSA 91-8 colon three, item a, a motion to." Petrin: "Make a motion to go into nonpublic prayer. RSA nine one. Dash a colon three." (0:11:36). Roll call (0:11:45); out at 0:12:29.MEDIUM
0:12:46Instructional coaches"the board approved two positions for instructional coaching last year." Koski: K to 2 students assessed in math (0:14:04); observation cycles "non evaluative only for instruction" (0:16:31). The packet's Instructional Coaching Impact Nov. 24.pdf reports 612 K-2 students assessed, 45 and 35 coaching meetings at the middle and high school.
0:21:45Coaching only the willingPetrin: "sometimes the people that don't seek it out are the ones that need it." (0:22:38). Koski: "We won't have us coaches assigned to people." (0:23:12). The elementary coaching post could not be filled: "We didn't have any qualified applicants." (0:22:22).
0:31:04Open elementary coaching postWhitney: "my fear is, is that our elementary school teachers tend to be the younger teachers and the newer teachers." (0:31:31). Pratt and Koski discussed internal candidates "around 4:00 today" (0:33:45).
0:34:15Waiting for counsel"Mr. Upton will be available in roughly 15 minutes."
0:34:34Social outreach grant"one out of the 6 or 8 districts to get the federal grant that filters through the state"; a coordinator and more social workers; on hold: "we're still waiting to see if they're going to if the feds are taken back that grant." (0:34:59).
0:38:46Capital improvementsCrawford received a capital-improvements spreadsheet from the superintendent that day; Whitney: "replenishing the Capital Reserve fund" (0:38:59).
0:39:14Finance Committee reportSprague: "We had our first meeting yesterday." "It's televised. It was televised." (0:39:36). Whitney: "There was a repeated echo of more social workers at the elementary school." (0:42:57) and full-time substitutes, "which may be a budget neutral move" (0:43:07). The November 19 session has no minutes of its own (see its page).
0:45:09SREA settlement describedWhitney: "There was some language cleanup within the contract just to make clarity. We've increased some additional duty pay, which was extremely outdated." Cost-of-living increases of 2.5% in 2025-26 and 2026-27 (0:45:45). Paraprofessional pay "have not been compensated well" (0:45:57). Mentor pay raised "in a meaningful way" (0:46:45). No total cost is stated.MEDIUM
0:48:13Health insurance and the contractCrawford: "the costs for health care has gone up 15%"; is the language "flexible enough"? Henry: "It's up to them to not, you know, the union to see if they're willing to do anything." (0:48:54). Pratt: unions "are usually open to discussion if it's a cost savings" (0:49:54).OBSERVATION
0:50:24Minutes date corrected after the voteKoski: "There's an error in the date of minutes that are being approved tonight." "it says 10 to 2024, and it needs to think to be 1016." "only making it over so closely because we have to submit it as evidence." (0:51:01).OBSERVATION
0:51:14Ratify without counsel"I asked him if he's available soon. At 719. He said in 15 minutes." Crawford: "I think the two of you have done a good job explaining it to us." (0:51:38). Sprague: "We can't make changes." (0:51:42). Pratt: "That were established? The ground rules?" (0:51:50).MEDIUM
0:52:23Contract ratifiedCrawford: "Ratify the contract negotiated by the team." Sprague: "I'll second." (0:52:31). "The agreement between the SRE and Claremont School Board, documented October 30th, 2024, has been ratified." (0:52:38). Upton, arriving: "I think it's a really fair contract." (0:53:24).MEDIUM
0:53:39Budget hearing and strategic planWhitney plans to tie the January 2 budget hearing to the strategic plan and the coaches' results; Pratt: "budget is tied for the strategic plan" (0:54:58); "there's no secrets" (0:55:54).

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on November 20, 2024, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies. The board's by-laws (adopted June 5, 2024) are cited as the board's own rules, not as law, from the adopted copy in the June 5, 2024 packet.

MEDIUM The teachers' contract was ratified without being posted, without its cost stated, and before counsel arrived

The agenda lists "SREA Contract Ratification (Discussion and Vote) (Exhibit A)". The packet folder for this meeting holds six documents and no Exhibit A, so the public could not read the agreement the board ratified; a member said "I read it this afternoon" (0:52:18). The board's by-law 4.03(d) assigns posting "online any and all agenda materials not-exempt from public dissemination by RSA 91-A in conjunction with the posting of any board or committee agendas". On tape the terms are given in outline (2.5% cost-of-living increases in each of two years, higher extra-duty and mentor pay, paraprofessional raises, 0:45:09 to 0:46:45), but no dollar cost is stated for either year. Under RSA 273-A:3, II(b) "Only cost items shall be submitted to the legislative body" for approval, so the voters, not the board, would fund the cost items; the public record of the board's vote still carries no figure for them. The board chose to ratify before counsel, listed as presenter, could join (0:51:27 to 0:52:27). Graded MEDIUM as a process gap: the ratification itself is within the board's authority, and the approved minutes record mover, seconder and the main terms.

Sources: Agenda, item IV.2; Packet folder 8. CSB 11.20.24 (six documents); Claremont School Board By-Laws, 4.03(d) (adopted June 5, 2024); RSA 273-A:3, II(b) (cost items to the legislative body)

MEDIUM The nonpublic motion named no exemption, and the unsealed nonpublic minutes have not been found

RSA 91-A:3, I(b) requires a motion to enter nonpublic session to "state on its face the specific exemption under paragraph II", and the board's own by-laws (Appendix D) say "It is vital that a specific reference to one of these grounds be made on the record". The motion as spoken was "RSA nine one. Dash a colon three." (0:11:36), with no paragraph or letter. The chair's lead-in had said item a (0:11:16) and the agenda printed the text of II(a), which mitigates it; the approved minutes then record the motion as "RSA 91-A:3(a)", a citation without the paragraph that holds the exemptions. The roll call required by I(b) was taken (0:11:45). The minutes add "No need to seal the minutes", so RSA 91-A:3, III required those minutes to be public within 72 hours; the by-laws' Appendix D repeats that duty. No nonpublic minutes for this date have been found: the Meeting Minutes share's Unsealed Minutes folder was created January 13, 2025 and lists only 2025, 2026 and 2027 subfolders (checked October 3, 2026). The district website as it stood in 2024 cannot be inspected, so this is "not found", not "never released".

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, I(b), II(a), III; By-Laws, Appendix D; Approved 11.20.24 minutes, item IV.1

MEDIUM This meeting's draft minutes reached the public share on the eighth business day

RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes open to inspection "not more than 5 business days after the meeting". Counting from Wednesday, November 20, and excluding Thanksgiving (RSA 288:1), the fifth business day was Wednesday, November 27. The draft's Drive file was created December 3, 2024, in the packet folder for the December 4 meeting, the eighth business day. Graded MEDIUM under the project's severity rule: the minutes exist and are detailed, and Drive dates show when the public could read them online, not whether a copy was available at the SAU office earlier. For comparison, the November 14 special-meeting draft approved this night was posted November 20, within its five days.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2024 codification); RSA 288:1 (legal holidays); 11.20.24 draft minutes (Drive createdTime 2024-12-03)

OBSERVATION The consent agenda approved minutes by the wrong date and was corrected 49 minutes later without a vote

The posted agenda listed "Minutes Approval- 10.2.24 & 11.14.24"; the October 2 minutes had already been approved on October 16. The consent agenda was accepted "Seeing no opposition" (0:01:48), and only at 0:50:24 did the assistant superintendent note the date should be 10.16, because "we have to submit it as evidence" (0:51:01). The correction was "noted and changed" with no new vote, and the approved minutes fold it into the consent item as though it were made at the time. The chair also said the agenda "was, modified multiple times, so the number did not get there" (0:37:08), and the instrument disposal listed as "(Discussion/Vote)" was settled by consent. The by-laws' rule 2.10 describes consent items as moved "en masse, by consent"; no rule found requires a fresh vote for a clerical date correction, so this is an observation about the reliability of the record.

Sources: Agenda, item II.a; Approved 11.20.24 minutes, item II.a; By-Laws, 2.10

OBSERVATION The board approved, without comment, minutes of an unrecorded November 14 meeting that misletter its nonpublic exemption

The consent agenda approved draft CSB Meeting Minutes 11.14.24.pdf, a Claremont School Board meeting called to order at 8:16 p.m. on November 14, after the SAU 6 meeting in the same building. Five members were present; the meeting's only business was a nonpublic session from 8:19 to 8:59 p.m. The motion is recorded as "RSA 91-A: 3, II (a & d)", but the minutes then print the second ground as "(b) Consideration of the acquisition, sale, or lease of real or personal property", which is the text of II(d) under the wrong letter, cut before its qualifying clause ("which, if discussed in public, would likely benefit a party or parties"). The minutes record no vote to seal, so RSA 91-A:3, III required the nonpublic minutes to be public within 72 hours; none has been found. No recording of that meeting exists in the Cablecast gallery as checked by this project in August 2026, and MAP.md has no section for it. The draft itself was posted November 20, within five business days.

Sources: draft CSB Meeting Minutes 11.14.24 (Drive createdTime 2024-11-20); RSA 91-A:3, II(d) and III

OBSERVATION The contract was ratified knowing it names a health plan whose cost had just risen 15%

Crawford raised the 15% increase reported at the previous day's Finance Committee session and asked whether the contract's language could accommodate a change of carrier (0:48:13). The approved minutes record the business administrator noting the contract "does specifically say SchoolCare". The administration's answer was that the union might agree to reopen it if a change saved its members money (0:48:54, 0:49:54). That is a stated risk, accepted on the record, that the FY26 budget would carry; no rule is engaged.

Sources: Approved 11.20.24 minutes, item IV.2; Finance Committee, November 19, 2024

POSITIVE School-by-school attendance, truancy and discipline data published in the board packet every month

The written November Superintendent's Report in the packet gives each school's enrollment, absences, truancy and suspension counts, and for Unity the IEP and 504 totals, and the superintendent walked through them on camera, including a middle-school suspension count he called "a little on the high side" (0:06:49). No statute requires a monthly public report of this kind. The one discrepancy a reader should know: on tape the middle school's bullying and harassment investigations are 17, while the written report prints 7 (2 founded, 5 unfounded). The coaching report likewise came with a one-page data summary in the packet.

Sources: November Superintendent's Report; Instructional Coaching Impact Nov. 24

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page