Claremont School Board Finance Committee, January 6, 2025
Televised working session of the board's three-member Finance Committee with the superintendent, business administrator, student services director and principals, the day before the board voted to send the FY26 budget to its public hearing. The committee worked from version six of the draft: $490,062 to be raised before the collective bargaining agreements, about $1,005,062 (5.78%) with the teachers' agreement, no money for preschool, $15,000 instead of $30,000 for high school summer school, and one middle school counselor position removed. No motion or vote was taken. The page is built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript; no agenda, notice, packet or minutes for this session were found. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.
Body
Finance Committee (also styled Finance Sub-Committee) of the Claremont School Board, a subcommittee of the Claremont School District board
Date
Monday, January 6, 2025. No date is spoken on the recording; the date comes from the Cablecast title and the file name. Crawford says the board meets "tomorrow night" (0:34:12), which fits the January 7 board meeting.
Start time
Not stated in any record found. The recording opens mid-discussion at 0:00:00, with no call to order, roll or statement of the time. It ends with "Adjourned." at 1:43:53. The dialogue transcript runs 1:43:56.
Location
Not stated in available records. The recording is a CCTV production; Crawford refers to "the transcription of this meeting" reaching the public (0:48:27).
Recording
Cablecast: School Board Finance Meeting 1/6/24 (show 16246; the gallery title prints 2024, the file name and the board's schedule say January 6, 2025; the Cablecast API refuses this environment, so the extent is taken from the last dialogue row, 1:43:56)
Minutes
None found in the district's public shares as of 2026-10-03. See flag 1.
Committee
Frank Sprague (chair, per the January 7 board agenda), Heather Whitney, Candace Crawford: all three are heard, so a quorum of the committee was present. Crawford leads most of the questioning; the dialogue file's role column describes her as presiding, which this page does not adopt because the opening of the session is not on the recording.
Participants
Everyone heard on the recording. Names and titles follow the January 7, 2025 agenda masthead and the project's roster notes; where the dialogue file's label differs, that is noted. No attendance list exists for this session.
Name
Role
Participation
Frank Sprague
Committee chair; board vice chair
Asks how many counselors CMS will have (0:58:01), what preschool actually costs once related services are counted (1:12:20), and for a presentation on how students are placed out of district: "This is very foreign to me." (1:33:49). Proposes a 1% cut calculation (1:21:34) and, to Pratt's question about further cuts, answers "Not yet." (1:22:56). Closes: "Yes. Adjourned." (1:43:55).
Candace Crawford
Committee member
Asks the group to agree on one copy among "about seven iterations" (0:04:45). Walks through what the $2.6 million increase includes and excludes (0:35:00 to 0:37:26). Proposes $15,000 for high school summer school (0:45:00). Tells staff the committee is "not cutting this budget" (0:48:27). Explains her vote against funding preschool (1:36:10). Closes: "I am comfortable with where we are for the presentation." (1:42:08).
Heather Whitney
Committee member; board chair
Reads the version-six total: "490062 for a 2.82% increase prior to all of the CBA." (0:07:37). Proposes replacing elementary student services coordinators with social workers plus one director of in-house special programs, "essentially revenue neutral" (0:15:45, 0:22:35). Argues against restoring preschool (1:37:43) and cites a $55,000 median household income (1:32:18).
Christopher Pratt
Superintendent
Raises the CMS guidance count (0:08:13) and the high school vending-machine fund (0:09:30); defends funding high school summer school (0:42:05); asks whether the committee wants another $150,000 cut (1:22:47); on rising costs (1:29:10). Thanks principals for taking "$1.5 million out of the budget" (1:42:32).
Mary Henry
Business administrator
Supplies version six and the default budget (0:05:09, 0:06:15). Gives the total with the teachers' agreement as "1,005,062, which is a 5.78%" (1:19:44) and says "the default is 90,000 more than the general budget right now." (1:23:20). "we've cut over 1.5 million already" (1:26:03).
Mike McCosker
Director of Student Services (dialogue file: Director of Special Education)
On the Bluff PRIDE behavior program ("Maybe 6 to 10." students, 0:02:13), related-service staff time at preschool (1:06:27), about 20 contracted service providers (1:10:50), and a contracted-services line that "got zeroed" (1:10:40). "Assumptions are very dangerous." (1:17:17).
Frank Romeo
Principal, Claremont Middle School
Guidance returns to two (0:08:52); combined tech ed and computers (0:38:23); four teaching positions unfilled this year (0:50:13); enrollment "from 400 to 338" (0:51:39); counselor position removed while the person stays in the district (1:03:41); says losing preschool leaves "a huge gap" (1:35:42).
Melissa Lewis
Principal, Disnard Elementary
Describes the student services coordinator role and says a social worker is not a substitute: "you are comparing apples to potatoes." (0:23:08).
Mark Blount
Principal, Maple Avenue Elementary
Three district-wide life skills programs housed at Maple (0:04:36); his student services coordinator shares IEP meeting duties (0:23:48). Transcript: "Mr. Blunt".
Dr. Michael Herrington
Principal, Stevens High School
On the principal's discretionary fund from the vending machine (0:10:30) and on summer school: "To run it the way that it used to be was a $30,000. Does it need to be that way? No." (0:43:48); a bare-bones quote "maybe 15,000" (0:44:20).
Michelle Herrington
SRVRTC (dialogue file: Assistant Director; the December 9 visioning minutes: Tech Director)
On classroom space for the new teacher-training course (0:41:12) and on preschool as a lab classroom with Perkins funding (1:13:54).
Multiple
Committee members' assent
"Fine with me" on the $15,000 summer school figure (0:48:13); the voices are not separated.
Named, not present
Jennifer Maynard (speech-language pathologist), Jess McLeod (out-of-district coordinator)
Named by Sprague as carrying special-program duties (0:21:13). The district's own documents also spell the second surname McCleod; no spelling is adopted as settled.
Order of business (reconstructed)
No agenda was found. The item list below is reconstructed from the members' transitions on the recording.
Crawford's list: no SREA increase, no paraprofessional increase, no preschool; tech ed; the CMS dust collector; the SRVRTC teacher-training course; summer school.
Crawford "comfortable" for the presentation to the full board; Henry to make the discussed changes and list eliminations that evening (1:42:27); adjourned (1:43:53). No motion or vote at any point.
Whitney, mid-question, on district-wide special education salaries embedded in programs. Bluff's PRIDE behavior program: "Is a behavioral. Program program that was started in lieu of sending kids out of district." (0:01:44). Whitney: "it was almost $1 million worth of special add cost" allocated to Bluff (0:02:24).
Crawford: "can we all agree on the same copy to reference? I just want to make sure because there are about seven iterations here." Henry emailed version six "yesterday I think" (0:05:09). Crawford: "I don't print out 65 pages." (0:05:21).
Whitney: "490062 for a 2.82% increase prior to all of the CBA. So that does not include any of the CBA." Crawford's copy showed 628 (0:07:08); Henry: "after Heather spoke to me, I went in and I made some changes." (0:07:20). Pratt: "So it goes from 6.24 down to." (0:07:50).
Pratt asks where vending revenue goes if not to the senior celebration; Herrington: it covers class dues, Chromebook repairs and senior-trip help, "the whole purpose of of a discretionary principals fund" (0:10:55).
Whitney's proposal: "embed a social worker in every elementary school" and fund a director of in-house special programs from the coordinators' salaries (0:16:16). Lewis: "you are comparing apples to potatoes." (0:23:08); Blount agrees (0:23:48). Whitney: a coordinator's salary per day worked "rivals, the principal salary" (0:26:22). Crawford: "I think that we need to move on." (0:33:48).
Crawford: "it shows a $2.6 million increase in this current budget." Special education in two schools up about $1.5 million (0:35:18) and health insurance "1.5 million" (0:35:56): "$3 million that we had no control over." Not in the figure: the SREA increase, the paraprofessional increase, and "no money for preschool" (0:36:59, 0:37:26).
Henry: the $30,000 is "not there now." Pratt: without it "a drastic probably a dropout rate is going to increase tremendously." (0:42:29). Crawford: "I could live with $15,000 being in the budget for summer school, but that's as high as I'll go." (0:45:00). Assent: "Fine with me." (0:48:13).
Crawford: employees "might get panicked about, losing jobs"; "that is not our intent at all at this point. We're not cutting this budget." Pratt: "Mr. Romeo did have to cut people." (0:49:19); not all by attrition (0:49:38).
Romeo: "we are now operating down one science, one social studies, one English, one math." Enrollment "from 400 to 338" (0:51:39). Sprague: unified arts, PE and health "are all subject to minimum standards" (0:57:28).
Three counselors this year, two budgeted for FY25, three in the FY26 draft (1:02:52). Romeo: "Take away the position. That's a cost savings of taking away the position." (1:03:41); the counselor is kept elsewhere in the district. Henry later: "That's probably another 100,000." (1:26:57).
Related-service staff are budgeted district-wide (1:05:35). Sprague: "I'm trying to find out what pre-K costs." (1:12:20). About 20 contracted providers (1:10:50); a contracted-services number "got zeroed" (1:10:40). Pratt: the in-house program "Is that 500,000, right." (1:13:35). McCosker: staff would stay busy because "one way or the other, we have to provide those services." (1:17:37).
McCosker: "I said it a couple times in the email. I responded to you guys over the weekend." Crawford thanks him "for your many responses to emails over the holidays" (1:17:40).
Henry: "We ratified the 515." (1:18:14); $2.6 million increase less $2.1 million in new revenue is $490,000, plus 515 gives "1,005,062, which is a 5.78%, change increase." Rate effect: "$81.47 per 100,000" (1:19:57).
Henry: "the default is 90,000 more than the general budget right now." Whitney: "What I'm looking at is, is making it a wash between the default and all the Warren articles." (1:24:09). Henry prefers a gap "because it gives people a choice" (1:26:03); removing the counselor: "that's going to bring my default down" (1:27:35).
Pratt on education costs since 2001 (1:29:41). Crawford: New Hampshire "is 50th in all states for, support for education" (1:30:42). Whitney: "the median household income in Claremont is $55,000." (1:32:18).
Sprague asks for "a presentation on the protocols. And how does a kid get placed out of district?" (1:33:49); "I have never in that experience scene where dozens of kids are being placed out of district."
Romeo: "I think not having a pre K contradicts that." Crawford: "for me to justify spending 500,000, I can't do it" (1:36:40). Whitney: "our typical students that attended the preschool, when tracked through, scored lower than non attenders." (1:38:50); universal preschool estimated at "between 4 and 6 million a year" (1:39:36); "I will not support it unless we can do it. Universal." (1:41:30).
Crawford: "I am comfortable with where we are for the presentation." Whitney asks for "a printout of actually what was eliminated" (1:42:21); Henry will have it "this evening". Pratt: "to go any deeper. We're now going to break the bone and start getting into the marrow." (1:42:32).
These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on January 6, 2025, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.
HIGH A quorum of the Finance Committee met to settle the FY26 budget; no notice, agenda or minutes of the session were found
All three committee members are heard, so a quorum was present, and the business was squarely within the committee's charge: the final version of the FY26 budget the board received the next night (flag 2). RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d) makes the committee a public body ("or any committee, subcommittee, or subordinate body thereof, or advisory committee thereto"), so RSA 91-A:2, II required 24 hours' posted notice and minutes open to inspection within five business days. No notice, agenda or minutes were found: MAP.md records searches of the 2025 and FY 2025–26 meeting-document archives, both Meeting Minutes year folders and keyword searches (2026-08-23); this run added Drive searches for the date in four formats and for finance documents of that season (2026-10-03). The district's Claremont Finance Sub Committee folder could not be listed; its modifiedTime is December 1, 2025, eleven months later, so it cannot have held contemporaneous minutes even if it holds some now. The December 18, 2024 board agenda lists no January 6 session, and the only committee meeting announced on that board recording was a gathering over the Christmas period (see the December 18 page, flag 3). The recording itself starts mid-discussion, so it does not show a call to order, a start time or who was present when the session began. Graded HIGH under the project's severity rule: a public body met, no minutes exist in any district share searched, and nothing on the record says minutes exist elsewhere. Televising the session is a real mitigation of the secrecy concern, but it is not one of the rule's mitigating limbs, and RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes whether or not a meeting is recorded. A negative from Drive search is not proof of absence.
OBSERVATION Budget decisions were reached by consensus without a motion, and the only record of them is the recording
The committee took no motion or vote. Its direction was set by assent: $15,000 for high school summer school after Crawford's "that's as high as I'll go" (0:45:00) and "Fine with me." (0:48:13); removal of a middle school counselor position (1:03:41); no money for preschool (0:37:26); and readiness for the board presentation (1:42:08). An advisory committee has no authority to adopt a budget, and the board did vote the next night (January 7, 2025), so no rule requires a vote here. The concern is the record. The January 7 summary printed at 6:31 p.m. that evening shows $350,330 before the agreements, $139,732 less than the $490,062 read aloud here, and labels both figures 2.82%; nothing public explains the change between the two nights beyond the counselor and summer school items discussed here. Henry promised a list of what was eliminated "this evening" (1:42:27); no such list is among the January 7 packet documents.
OBSERVATION The committee worked from emailed budget versions the public could not see, and members exchanged email answers over the holidays
Crawford counted "about seven iterations" (0:04:45); Henry emailed version six the day before, changed figures after a conversation with Whitney (0:07:20), and the copy two members held showed different totals (628 against 490, 0:07:08). None of the versions, the one-page summary or the default-budget sheet Henry brought (0:06:15) reached a public share before the board vote: the January 7 budget documents were uploaded the morning of January 8. Viewers of the broadcast heard page numbers and line references without the pages. McCosker said he had answered questions by email "over the weekend" and Crawford thanked him for "many responses to emails over the holidays" (1:17:07, 1:17:40). RSA 91-A:2-a, II provides that communications outside a meeting, "including, but not limited to, sequential communications", shall not be used to circumvent the chapter's purpose. Nothing on the tape shows the members deliberating with each other by email; the exchanges described are staff answering members' questions. Recorded as an observation.
OBSERVATION Preschool was removed on cost and outcome claims not documented in the record, while the services owed to identified children remain
The draft carries "no money for preschool" (0:37:26), which serves "23 identified" children and 20 typically developing peers (0:37:35). The cost basis was not settled on tape: Pratt put the in-house program at about $500,000 (1:13:35), Sprague said "I'm trying to find out what pre-K costs" because related-service salaries sit in district-wide lines (1:12:20), and McCosker said those staff would remain busy because "one way or the other, we have to provide those services." (1:17:37). Whitney's outcome claim, that typical attenders "scored lower than non attenders" (1:38:50), rests on data that is not in any document reviewed for this page. Federal special education law requires a continuum of placements and a placement decided by a group that includes the parents, at least annually, as close as possible to home (34 CFR 300.115(a), 300.116); the committee's discussion is consistent with keeping IEP services, and the January 7 minutes record the chair's assurance of "no reduction in services embedded in IEPs". Separately, removing preschool positions engages the default-budget rule, which reduces the default "by salaries and benefits of positions that have been eliminated in the proposed budget" (RSA 40:13, IX(b)); Henry applied that logic to the counselor (1:27:35) but the preschool positions were not discussed in default-budget terms. Recorded as an observation: the decision is within the board's discretion, and the documents that would test its premises are not public in this record.
OBSERVATION The default budget is described as tunable to the operating budget, three weeks after a different default was given to the board
On the December 18 board recording the default was given as $39,791,261 and expected to exceed the budget (see that page). Here Henry reports "the default is 90,000 more than the general budget right now." (1:23:20); Whitney's aim is "making it a wash between the default and all the Warren articles" (1:24:09); Henry says she would rather keep a difference "because it gives people a choice" (1:26:03). RSA 40:13, IX(b) fixes the default by formula from the prior year's operating budget, adjusted for debt service, contracts and obligations, one-time expenditures and eliminated positions; it is not a policy choice to be aligned with the proposed budget. Read in context, the remarks concern how the two totals will compare once the formula is applied, and Henry ties the change to a specific eliminated position (1:27:35). Recorded so the default-budget form presented at the January 15 hearing can be checked against these statements.
POSITIVE A televised working session with principals answering members directly, and a request for the placement protocols behind the largest cost driver
The committee held its last budget pass on camera with four principals, the Tech Center's director and the student services director in the room, and principals pushed back on the record: Lewis on social workers (0:23:08), Romeo on preschool (1:35:42), Pratt on summer school (0:42:05). Crawford addressed staff anxiety directly (0:48:27), and Pratt asked the committee on tape whether it wanted further cuts (1:22:47), so the public can see that none was requested. Sprague asked for a presentation on how students come to be placed out of district (1:33:49), which is the question that turns an uncontrollable-cost label into something the board can examine. None of this is required by law.
Not found: notice, agenda, packet or minutes for this session (MAP.md searches of 2026-08-23; Drive searches by date string and by finance documents of the season, 2026-10-03). The district's Claremont Finance Sub Committee folder (owner sau6webmaster; created October 27, 2022; modified December 1, 2025) could not be listed; MAP.md recorded it empty on 2026-08-23.