Claremont School Board, January 21, 2025

Board meeting at which five of seven members moved the four FY2026 warrant articles to the February 1 deliberative session after correcting the draft warrant at the table, sealed a nonpublic session for seven years, funded an NH Listens candidate forum up to $750 and created an exploratory committee on student opportunities. Built from the dialogue transcript, the approved minutes and the posted warrant. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board
Date
Tuesday, January 21, 2025
Start time
6:30 p.m. (agenda as reproduced in the minutes). Called to order at 0:00:00 on the recording; the chair calls it the “special Claremont meeting.” Nonpublic session 6:34 to 7:42 p.m. (minutes); the recording passes from the vote to enter (0:04:34) to the motion to come out (0:05:25) in under a minute, so the session itself is not recorded. Consent adjournment 8:18 p.m. (minutes). The recording runs 0:41:48 by the last transcript row; with the 68-minute nonpublic session added, that fits the minuted 6:30 start and 8:18 adjournment.
Location
Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center (minutes)
Recording
Cablecast: School Board Meeting 1/21/25 (runs 0:41:48 by the last transcript row, nonpublic session excluded; the Cablecast API refused this environment)
Minutes
14. Approved CSB meeting minutes 1.21.25; draft copy 1.21.25 DRAFT CSB meeting minutes.pdf (in the 2/5/25 packet folder). No packet folder and no separately posted agenda were found; the agenda survives inside the minutes.
Board composition
Seven members; five present, Candace Crawford and Whitney Skillen absent (minutes)

Participants

Everyone in the record. Name spellings and attendance follow the approved minutes; transcript renderings that differ are noted.
NameRoleParticipation
Heather WhitneyBoard chairPresides; moves both agenda additions (0:02:05, 0:02:55); explains the NH Listens request (0:01:13); assigns deliberative-session roles (0:31:37) and confirms subcommittee assignments (0:36:18). Seconds the NH Listens motion (minutes).
Frank SpragueVice chairSeconds both agenda additions (minutes); moves to fund the NH Listens forum and raises the cap to $750 (0:07:04, 0:07:23); seconds the motion moving the warrant to the deliberative session (minutes).
Arlene HawkinsMemberMoves the nonpublic session (0:04:24); seconds the seal (0:05:56); proposes and moves the exploratory committee (0:11:17, 0:12:29).
Michael PetrinMemberSeconds entry to and exit from nonpublic (minutes); moves the seven-year seal (0:05:53); seconds the exploratory committee (0:13:05); moves Articles 1 to 4 to the deliberative session (0:26:38). The transcript renders him Mr. Patron and Mr. Peterson.
Bonnie MilesMemberMoves to come out of nonpublic (0:05:29); reports Capital Improvements items: the Stevens roof, playgrounds at Bluff and Disnard (0:38:18).
Candace CrawfordMemberAbsent (minutes). Assigned to present Article 3 at the deliberative session by phone (0:33:06).
Whitney SkillenMemberAbsent (minutes). Assigned to move restriction of reconsideration of Articles 1 and 2 (0:32:28).
Miles Sheehan, Lilly ClarkStudent board members (masthead in the minutes)Not recorded in the roll and not heard.
Noelle KronbergSchool board clerkCalls the roll on the nonpublic votes (0:04:34, 0:05:32); signs the minutes.
Chris PrattSuperintendent, SAU 6Proposes his new Superintendent's Advisory Council as the venue for the exploratory work (0:13:07, 0:14:26).
Mary HenryBusiness Administrator, SAU 6Distributes the draft warrant (0:20:34); concedes the Article 1 seat error (0:21:15); will ask the Department of Revenue Administration about the wording (0:26:01); on submitting and posting the warrant (0:30:10); Capital Reserve balance (0:39:45). Several of her turns sit in other speakers' clusters; the CSV attributes them from the minutes.
UnidentifiedTwo brief questions about past childcare arrangements0:35:44, 0:35:55.

Agenda

Items from the agenda as reproduced in the approved minutes (no separately posted agenda was found), with the time each was taken up on the recording and its disposition.
Taken upItemAgenda text / disposition
0:00:00I. Call to order and Pledge (6:30 p.m.)Called to order and Pledge led by the chair.
0:00:32II. Roll callMinutes: present Hawkins, Miles, Petrin, Sprague, Whitney; absent Crawford, Skillen. The roll responses are audible but not separable on the recording.
0:00:43II.a.1 Amendments and final approval of agendaTwo additions. Chair's motion to add the NH Listens forum, Sprague second, no opposition (0:02:05); chair's motion to add Hawkins' exploratory committee, Sprague second, no opposition (0:02:55). Minutes record both movers and seconders.
0:03:17II.a.2 Minutes approval, 1.7.25“If I have no opposition, we can consent. Approve.” Then “Seeing no opposition will accept the minutes” (0:03:39). Minutes: “Consent approval, minutes accepted.” No motion or vote; see flag 4.
0:03:39II.b Citizens' commentsThe chair invites comment on non-agenda items under policy BEDH; nobody comes forward. Minutes: “none.”
0:04:16III.1 Nonpublic session, RSA 91-A:3Minutes reproduce the agenda item as “Non-public meeting session 91-A: 3 (c)” with the text of RSA 91-A:3, II(c). Hawkins moves, Petrin seconds (minutes), at 6:34 p.m.; roll call, all present in favor (0:04:34). Out at 7:42 p.m. on Miles' motion, Petrin second, roll call (0:05:29). Seal for seven years on Petrin's motion, Hawkins second, roll call (0:05:53). See flags 1 and 2.
0:06:07III.2 NH Listens candidate forum (added)Sprague moves to empower the administration to work with NH Listens and release up to $750 from the School Board line; Whitney seconds; voice vote, all present in favor (0:11:04). The chair will cancel if only two candidates file for two seats (0:10:17).
0:11:17III.3 Exploratory committee (added)Hawkins moves to create an exploratory committee on maximizing student opportunities; Petrin seconds (0:13:05); voice vote, all present in favor (0:20:10). Membership and charge not set.
0:20:18III.4 FY2026 budget approval for deliberative session (discussion/vote)Warrant handed out at the table (0:20:34); Article 1 corrected to two seats; punctuation in Article 2 queried. Petrin moves Article 1 as amended and Articles 2 to 4 to the deliberative session (0:26:38); Sprague seconds (minutes); voice vote, “Seeing none opposed. Motion passes” (0:31:19). Minutes: “all present voting in favor.” See flags 3 and 5.
0:31:37Deliberative-session preparationPresenters and motions assigned; moderator Pope's rules and 8:15 a.m. dry run; childcare question; subcommittee roster confirmed.
0:38:18IV. Other businessMiles' Capital Improvements report; the Capital Reserve does not cover the rest of the Stevens roof; Miles to bring a list to the next meeting.
0:41:32VI. AdjournmentAdjourned by consent. Minutes: “Consent adjournment at 8:18pm.”

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/16286 SchoolBoard-012125.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:00Call to orderThe chair opens “the January 21st 25 special Claremont meeting of the Claremont School Board.” The approved minutes head it as a regular board meeting with a 6:30 p.m. agenda.OBSERVATION
0:01:13NH Listens requestWhitney: NH Listens “used to run on a grant. Now they no longer have a grant”; they estimate “a little over $500 for travel expenses and possibly a hotel stay.”
0:02:28Hawkins' agenda request“I would like to add an agenda item to discuss an exploratory committee for, maximizing student opportunities.”
0:03:17Minutes by consent“If I have no opposition, we can consent. Approve.” The date is transcribed as “7251725”; the minutes give 1.7.25.OBSERVATION
0:04:16Into nonpublicChair: “Our first item on the agenda for discussion and action items is a nonpublic session per RSA 91” (0:03:39) and “Dash a colon three. Can I have a motion to move into nonpublic please?” Hawkins: “We move into nonpublic session. The RSA 91-A colon three second.” Roll call, all yes.MEDIUM
0:05:25Out of nonpublic; sealMiles moves to come out; Petrin seconds; roll call. Petrin: “Can I make a motion to seal the minutes for seven years?” (0:05:53). Hawkins seconds; roll call, all yes. No reason is stated.MEDIUM
0:07:04Candidate forum fundedSprague moves; the chair frames it as release of funds “up to $500”; Sprague: “Well, I'm going to say, 750” (0:07:23). Sprague recalls an earlier NH Listens forum at the Claremont Savings Bank Community Center and that he bought snacks with his own money (0:07:47).
0:08:57Earlier candidate formatsSprague: “We did something different a few years ago where we had, Kevin Tyson.” Then “Yeah, I interviewed for CCTV” (0:09:18). Hawkins recalls individual interviews and a forum that “got weathered out” (0:09:25). See the footer disclosure.
0:09:43Two seats, two candidates?Petrin: “if there's no more than two candidates, I don't see a reason to to do it.” Whitney: “If we only have two candidates, I will cancel” (0:10:17). She delegates the arrangements to staff because “I am not active during business hours usually” (0:10:27). Voice vote, all in favor (0:11:04).
0:11:17Exploratory committeeHawkins: prompted by “budget constraints and resource constraints, and how much the state does not properly fund education”; some schools lack room for programs while others have room; the group would “get data” and bring options to the community (0:11:45).
0:13:07Superintendent's Advisory CouncilPratt: “I recently formed the Superintendent's Advisory Council,” with “seven community members”; he could take two board members (0:14:56). Whitney asks how the committee would differ (0:14:08). Sprague would replace “opportunities” with access or equity (0:13:46).
0:16:38Reconfiguration and workloadPetrin: unequal opportunities between schools, room for a preschool program, and “it also brings back the reconfiguration. That was discussed several years ago” (0:16:58). He warns that subcommittees put “extra work” on the administration (0:18:33). Voice vote, all in favor (0:20:10).
0:20:34Draft warrant at the tableHenry hands out the warrant. Hawkins: “Three school board members was the third” (0:21:07); Henry: “It's only two. Okay, sorry about that. I copied it over from” (0:21:15). Members look for the default figure, “42,772,000” (0:24:05), on another page.OBSERVATION
0:24:53Question marks in Article 2Petrin and Sprague query two question marks in the Article 2 wording; the chair removes one (0:25:17); Henry: “I've got to ask the Dr. A” [the DRA] (0:26:01). Minutes: the wording is not hers and she must ask the DRA.
0:26:38Warrant moved to the deliberative sessionPetrin: “I'd like to make a motion to move. Article won the election of school district officials to the session as amended. So it reads two school board members,” then Articles 2, 3 and 4 (0:27:32). Second at 0:27:51. Vote: “Seeing none opposed. Motion passes to move art warrant articles one, two, three and four to the deliberative session” (0:31:19).POSITIVE
0:28:56Posting before the sessionWhitney: the moderator wants everything to be presented “on the website and available for public one week before.” Henry: she will submit to the DRA, the board signs, “and then we post” (0:30:10).POSITIVE
0:31:37Deliberative rolesMiles to lead the Pledge; Petrin Article 1; Sprague Article 2; Skillen to move to restrict reconsideration of Articles 1 and 2 with Miles seconding (0:32:28); Crawford Article 3, Hawkins Article 4 (0:33:06); Petrin to restrict reconsideration of 3 and 4 (0:33:21). Presenters get up to five minutes, then three as any voter (0:34:01).
0:35:20ChildcarePetrin recalls students volunteering childcare; Whitney: the session moved to Saturdays partly to avoid such conflicts.
0:36:18Subcommittee rosterSprague: vice chair, superintendent evaluation, SREA negotiation, ad hoc communication. Hawkins: SAU [6] board representative, Curriculum chair, CAA negotiator, Policy (0:36:42). Miles: SRVRTC visioning, Capital Improvement, Policy (0:37:04). Petrin: Capital Improvement, SRVRTC visioning, chair of ad hoc communications (0:37:28).
0:38:18Capital itemsMiles: the Stevens roof can wait a year per Mr. Holt; playgrounds at Bluff and Disnard need replacing; money “can be taken from the trust” (0:39:27). Henry: the trust holds about “160 because of the interest” (0:39:45); Whitney: “So we don't have enough to finish the Stevens High School roof” (0:39:48).

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid. They are not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule or document it rests on, and a reader should check the cited source and the recording before relying on it.

MEDIUM Seven-year seal voted with no statutory finding on the record

After the nonpublic session Petrin asked “Can I make a motion to seal the minutes for seven years?” (0:05:53); Hawkins seconded and the roll call was unanimous. RSA 91-A:3, III requires nonpublic minutes to be disclosed within 72 hours “unless, by recorded vote of 2/3 of the members present taken in public session, it is determined that divulgence of the information likely would affect adversely the reputation of any person other than a member of the public body itself, or render the proposed action ineffective, or pertain to terrorism” (statute text). The vote met the procedural half: it was a recorded roll call, in public session, and unanimous among the five present. Neither the motion nor the minutes (“Michael Petrin made a motion to seal the minutes for 7 years”) states which determination the board made. The session was entered under II(c), the reputation exemption, so a reputation finding is the likely basis, but the statute asks for the determination, not an inference from the agenda. Graded MEDIUM as a documentation gap.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, III (72-hour disclosure; seal only on a 2/3 determination; 2023, 189:1); approved 1.21.25 minutes

MEDIUM Motion to enter nonpublic session cited only RSA 91-A:3

RSA 91-A:3, I(b): “Any motion to enter nonpublic session shall state on its face the specific exemption under paragraph II which is relied upon as foundation for the nonpublic session” (statute text). On the recording the chair introduces “a nonpublic session per RSA 91” and “Dash a colon three” (0:03:39, 0:04:16), and the motion is “We move into nonpublic session. The RSA 91-A colon three” (0:04:24). Neither names paragraph II or a lettered ground. The agenda item, which survives only as reproduced in the minutes, cites “91-A: 3 (c)” and prints the text of II(c), so the board and the clerk had the ground before them; the minutes' citation itself omits the paragraph number. The roll-call requirement of I(b) was met. Graded MEDIUM: the statute puts the exemption on the face of the motion, and the motion as spoken does not carry it.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, I(b), II(c) (motion must state the exemption; reputation ground); approved 1.21.25 minutes

OBSERVATION No packet, and the warrant was corrected at the table before it was moved

No packet folder exists for this meeting in the district's 2025 Meeting Documents archive, which runs from 12. CSB Budget Public Hearing 1.15.25 to 13. CSB Deliberative Session 2.1.25, and the agenda survives only as reproduced in the approved minutes. The chair opened the meeting as a “special” meeting (0:00:00) while the minutes head it as a regular board meeting; no notice was found to settle which it was. The document the board acted on, the draft 2025 warrant, was handed out at the table (0:20:34). Members found that Article 1 listed three board seats instead of two (0:21:07) and debated punctuation in the Article 2 wording (0:24:53); the motion moved Article 1 “as amended” (0:26:38). A viewer could not see the text being voted, and the minutes describe the corrections without reproducing the final wording. The warrant later posted for the deliberative session (Drive file created January 28, 2025, the DRA form stamped January 22) shows two seats and prints the Board's recommendation as “(4) Yes (0) No” on Articles 2 to 4, while the minutes record all five members present voting in favor of the motion. RSA 32:5, V(a) requires only a notation of whether the governing body recommends an article, so the tally difference is noted, not flagged as a rule question.

Sources: 2025 Meeting Documents (Drive); 2025 Warrant (1).pdf; RSA 32:5, V(a) (notation of recommendation; 2024 codification)

OBSERVATION Minutes approved by “no opposition” although the agenda says a vote is required

The agenda reproduced in the minutes lists “Consent Agenda (vote required)” with the 1.7.25 minutes. The chair asked for no opposition and declared the minutes accepted (0:03:17, 0:03:39); the minutes record “Consent approval, minutes accepted.” Approval by unanimous consent is a common parliamentary practice and no statute requires a recorded vote on minutes, so this is noted as a departure from the agenda's own wording. The two agenda additions, by contrast, were moved and seconded, and the minutes name both movers and seconders. Adjournment was by consent (minutes: “Consent adjournment at 8:18pm”).

Sources: approved 1.21.25 minutes

POSITIVE Budget finalized after the hearing, on a recorded motion, inside the SB 2 calendar

The board held its budget vote six days after the January 15 hearing, as the chair announced there, on a motion whose mover (Petrin) and seconder (Sprague) the minutes record, as RSA 91-A:2, II requires (“The names of the members who made or seconded each motion shall be recorded in the minutes,” statute text). RSA 32:5, I directs the body to finalize the budget “after the conclusion of public testimony” (statute text), and RSA 40:13, II-a(d) requires warrants and budgets to be posted by the last Monday in January (January 27, 2025). The posted warrant's certification attests posting “on or before January 27,2025” (warrant text), and the board discussed meeting the moderator's request to post all session materials a week ahead (0:28:56). Every motion this night, including the two nonpublic transitions, has its mover and seconder in the minutes, and the nonpublic votes were by roll call.

Sources: RSA 40:13, II-a(d) (posting by the last Monday in January); RSA 91-A:2, II (movers and seconders; 2023 codification); 2025 Warrant (1).pdf

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page