Participants
Everyone heard or named in this excerpt. Spellings follow the agenda and draft minutes; where the dialogue file or a later district record differs, both are shown. Kevin Tyson, an applicant for the seat, maintains this project; see the footer.
| Name | Role | Participation |
| Heather Whitney | Chair | Presides; reads counsel's correspondence (0:00:35) and Sprague's letter (0:02:16) into the record. Seconds Petrin's motion to return Sprague both times (0:04:32, 0:43:41). Opposes Lavalette: "being the president of the union is it is is a biased position to have come from." (0:39:10). Votes against the Lavalette and reopening motions and for Sprague (draft minutes). |
| Michael Petrin | Vice chair | Moves to return Sprague (0:04:20) and again after the other motions fail (0:43:21): "Not of any sort of backroom deal or any sort of solicitation." (0:42:52). Votes against Lavalette and reopening, for Sprague (draft minutes). |
| Arlene Hawkins | Member; Policy subcommittee chair; SAU 6 board chair | Asks to reopen applications: "We are circumventing our own process." (0:04:42). Seconds the Lavalette motion and speaks for him (0:34:26, 0:36:20). Reads by-law 2.07 on abstentions aloud (0:47:02, 0:48:41). Votes for Lavalette and reopening, against Sprague (draft minutes). |
| Candace Crawford | Member; Finance subcommittee chair | Asks whether Sprague volunteered (0:12:13); prefers leaving the seat open: "I would recommend that we do nothing" (0:14:44). Moves to reopen applications (0:42:02). Votes for Lavalette and reopening, against Sprague; on tape: "By me I mean dissenting. But that was the rules." (0:46:31). |
| William Madden | Member | "I thought we had a solution, but if it wasn't unanimous, then I'm reluctant." (0:06:29). Asks whether Hawkins objects on precedent (0:16:17). Votes against Lavalette and reopening, for Sprague (draft minutes). |
| Loren Howard | Member | Against reopening (0:05:31). Moves to appoint Lavalette (0:34:20) and explains his view of the other applicant (0:34:31). Seconds the reopening motion (0:42:28). Abstains on the Sprague motion (0:43:53). Votes for Lavalette and reopening (draft minutes). |
| Matt Angell | Senior Comptroller / Interim Business Administrator, SAU 6 | Keeps time on public comment: 15 seconds. (0:25:50). Took the roll at this meeting per the draft minutes. |
| Don Lavalette | Ward 2 resident; applicant for the seat | Speaks from the floor (0:21:35 to 0:22:58): "You had a process. You went through the process." (0:21:57); "So either decide to fill it with Mr. Tyson me, or don't fill it." (0:22:30). The draft minutes spell him "Lavallette"; the dialogue file and the project roster "Lavalette"; the ASR renders him "Lavallée", "Lovett", "Lava", "Laval" and "Lobos". The motion to appoint him failed 3-3. |
| Kevin Tyson | Applicant for the seat; this project's maintainer | Recognized by the chair (0:29:01); speaks about his candidacy and Education Options (0:29:10 to 0:31:21). No motion to appoint him was made. See the footer disclosure. |
| Matt Bean | Citizens' comments, Ward 1 | Self-identifies (ASR "Matt Beam", 0:23:03). Opposes returning Sprague and supports Lavalette (0:23:56); speaks against the other applicant's association with "a group that likes to direct families from going away from public schools" (0:24:21). |
| John Cloutier | NH state representative, Ward 1 | Introduces himself and Claremont's other legislators, noting Representative Wayne Hemingway in the room (0:26:08). |
| Cameron Lowney (draft minutes); labeled Camron Lownie in the dialogue file | Citizens' comments, Ward 2 | "It is the most smoke filled room thing I can imagine." (0:28:10). After the vote asks that the next by-law sentence be read (0:47:58). The project has not settled the surname spelling; both renderings are shown. |
| Sherry Williams | Citizens' comments, Ward 1 | Asks the board to choose between the two applicants (0:32:36): "I implore you to make a decision as a board between these two, these two people, because they're both qualified and will bring incredible help." Spelled "Sherry" in these draft minutes. |
Named but not present on this excerpt: Frank Sprague, former member, whose letter the chair reads; Jim O'Shaughnessy, the district's counsel (named Mr. O'Shaughnessy at 0:00:04), whose advice the chair reads; an unnamed "school board Association attorney" cited by Crawford (0:13:58); Representative Wayne Hemingway, present per Cloutier. Clerk Noelle Kronberg is named in the draft minutes as their author.
Agenda
Items from CSB Agenda 11.5.25.pdf; agenda wording is quoted from that document. This excerpt contains only item III.6. Dispositions are from the recording, checked against the draft minutes.
| Taken up | Item | Agenda text / disposition |
| 6:30 p.m. (agenda) | I-II. Call to order; general business; citizens' comments; superintendent's and financial reports; follow-up items | Not in this excerpt (show 16951). The draft minutes record Gary Merchant and Don Lavallette speaking on the vacancy process during the opening comment period, and the chair saying people could speak when the item came up. |
| Not in excerpt | III.1-5. Nonpublic session under RSA 91-A:3, II(k); program of studies; sale or lease of buildings; superintendent and business administrator search committee | Not in this excerpt. The draft minutes record the nonpublic session from 7:35 p.m. to the return at 8:08 p.m. |
| 0:00:04 | III.6. Vacant School Board Seat | Agenda: "Vacant School Board Seat (Discussion, Vote or Consensus)". (1) Petrin moves to return Sprague, Whitney seconds (0:04:20, 0:04:32); the chair defers the motion for discussion and comment and it is never voted. (2) Howard moves to appoint Don Lavalette, Hawkins seconds (0:34:20, 0:34:26): fails 3-3 (0:40:05); draft minutes: for Howard, Hawkins, Crawford; against Madden, Petrin, Whitney. (3) Crawford moves to reopen applications, Howard seconds (0:42:02, 0:42:28): fails 3-3, same division (draft minutes). (4) Petrin moves again to return Sprague, Whitney seconds (0:43:21, 0:43:41): carries 3-2; draft minutes: for Madden, Petrin, Whitney; against Crawford, Hawkins; "Abstaining: Loren Howard". See flag 1 and flag 3. |
| Not in excerpt | III.7. SchoolCare update; subcommittee reports; IV. Other business; V. Future dates; VI. Adjournment | Not in this excerpt (show 16951). The SchoolCare update was added to the agenda at its approval (draft minutes). |
Discussion timeline
Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/16958 SchoolBoardVacancy110525.mp4.CSV) and link into the excerpt recording.
| Time | Topic | What was said | Flags |
| 0:00:00 | Spliced cold open | "I have no gavel, so I'm going to use my knocker today." This line opens the full meeting (show 16951) and was spliced ahead of the vacancy item. | |
| 0:00:04 | Counsel's advice read into the record | Whitney: "Two meetings ago we had a failed vacancy appointment." She says she sent counsel's correspondence to the board and reads from it: "he said the lorry [law] directs the board to fill the vacancy and he provided the RSA, which is RSA 671 colon 331 [RSA 671:33]" (0:00:35); "My advice vice is at the board to try to fill the vacancy at the next meeting, because that is what the law requires." (0:01:07); "There are more than five months until the election in March, and that is too long to leave the post vacant. He also said that the law that he cited is not a controlling law." (0:01:28). | OBSERVATION POSITIVE |
| 0:02:16 | Sprague's letter | Read by the chair: "I am writing to formally request reinstatement to the Claremont School Board." ... "I am not interested in a competitive process, as I have been chosen overwhelmingly by my constituents in multiple city elections, and I will stand on my record as a board member." (0:03:29). | OBSERVATION |
| 0:03:50 | First motion to return Sprague | Petrin: "It'd be a valid decision to put him back into that position for the remainder of the term, since he was elected to that position." "And then in March, the voters get to speak again. So I would make a motion to reinstate Frank Sprague, to the Claremont School Board." (0:04:20). Whitney: "I'm all second." and defers the motion for discussion (0:04:32). | OBSERVATION |
| 0:04:42 | Reopen or decide | Hawkins: "We are circumventing our own process." "I do not feel that we are at an impasse. We had one meeting. It was a tie." (0:05:08). Howard: "I think we should vote on this tonight and either get somebody or don't get somebody." (0:05:31). Madden: people "intimated that it looks like a back room, cigar filled smoke." (0:06:29). Petrin cites Sprague's experience (0:07:04). | |
| 0:07:32 | Chair on appointing | Whitney: "I don't like having to appoint somebody. It doesn't feel good, it feels political". Hawkins on precedent (0:08:05). Whitney: "We unfortunately, we have never had a policy related to this." (0:08:55); "I think we have 45 days from when the most believe that's for municipal purposes." (0:09:28); "I find this appointment process a dirty process." (0:11:12). | OBSERVATION |
| 0:12:13 | How the letter came about | Crawford: "Did Mr. Sprague volunteer for this position?" Whitney: "I called Mr. Sprague personally, and I asked him, do you know of any candidate that you would think that would be appropriate to come up" and "would do there any chance that you would do it?"; "And he said he would consider it. And then he sent me a letter." (0:12:34). | |
| 0:12:47 | Crawford's two options | "I was disappointed in Mr. Sprague for resigning at the time that he did". Whitney: "It's not controlling." Crawford: "Correct. It is not controlling. So it is not binding." (0:13:50). An NHSBA attorney said seats had stayed open "more than the 45 days" (0:13:58). "I would recommend that we do nothing and, and wait until the voters vote" (0:14:44); otherwise reopen. | OBSERVATION |
| 0:15:34 | Pending motion; the statute's force | Whitney: "But we have to vote on something." (0:15:57). Crawford: "Well, you have a motion on the floor." (0:16:14). Hawkins: "the statute is not you will or else it's guidance." (0:16:32); "If I may it's our attorney said it is guidance." (0:16:43). | OBSERVATION OBSERVATION |
| 0:17:47 | Precedent | Hawkins: "suppose tomorrow I want to resign" and then ask to come back; Whitney: "But the board has the option to say no." (0:18:08). Whitney: "This was an extenuating circumstances" (0:19:06); "bring back a person to finish the term that he was elected to serve." (0:20:40). Opens public comment at "three minutes per speaker" (0:21:08). | OBSERVATION POSITIVE |
| 0:21:35 | Public comment: Lavalette | Recounts a former Claremont mayor who resigned and later sought to return ("So to say it never happened has happened."); the chair concedes (0:21:54). "You had a process. You went through the process. That's fine if you're deadlocked. But if you go back and hire somebody who quit." (0:21:57); "So either decide to fill it with Mr. Tyson me, or don't fill it." (0:22:30). | |
| 0:23:03 | Public comment: Bean | "I respect and like Mr. Sprague a lot. I voted for him repeatedly." "We have Mr. Lava and we have Mr. Tyson who came out of that process" (0:23:33). Supports Lavalette (0:23:56). Angell: 15 seconds. (0:25:50). | |
| 0:26:08 | Public comment: Cloutier | "I'm John Cloutier, Ward one and one of Claremont state representative." Lists Claremont's legislators and offers help "especially when trying to help Claremont and the Claremont School District, its time of crisis." (0:26:55). | |
| 0:27:28 | Public comment: Lowney / Lownie | "However, there was a process. It opened up, narrowed down to two people." "I think that deviating from the plan via a personally solicited getting someone to come back in is the wrong play." (0:28:10); "it looks yucky from the public perspective." (0:28:47). | |
| 0:29:10 | Public comment: Tyson | "Seemed like a backroom deal as it was going down, but I stuck with the process. I am not a professional educator." (0:29:32); "We are not in the business of getting people out of schools. We are in the business of getting information to parents." (0:30:24); "I have been trying to carry myself as an honorable man, which is what I was raised to be." (0:30:57). | |
| 0:31:27 | Public comment: Williams | "you were faced with a decision of two highly qualified individuals who bring different perspectives" (0:32:03); "I beg you to set aside their political leanings and your own political leanings" (0:32:36). | |
| 0:34:20 | Motion to appoint Lavalette | Howard: "I'd like to make a motion to appoint Don to the school board." Hawkins: "I'll second that motion." (0:34:26). Howard: "Kevin and I disagree on a lot. We're on a different board together." (0:34:31); "I don't want that to be misconstrued as the reason for why I voted the way I voted." (0:34:52); "I think that website is less neutral than they make themselves out to be." (0:36:03). Hawkins supports Lavalette "as a public educator committed to being an advocate for students and public schools" (0:37:41). | |
| 0:37:53 | Chair opposes; vote | Whitney: "We are surrounded by educators." (0:38:18); "a school board should reflect its community more" (0:38:47). Vote: "Raise your hands. A we have a tie." (0:40:05); "Chair votes on everything as always." (0:40:33); "The the motion fails because we have a deadlock." (0:41:19). Draft minutes: 3-3, for Howard, Hawkins, Crawford. | POSITIVE |
| 0:42:02 | Motion to reopen applications | Crawford moves that "we need to open it to other candidates to come forward and present themselves at the next school board meeting." Howard seconds (0:42:28); hands raised (0:42:36); Hawkins: "So we are at an impasse." (0:42:45). Draft minutes: 3-3, same division. | |
| 0:42:52 | Second motion to return Sprague | Petrin: "There is no set process to to assigning someone to the vacant school board seat we have." "But right now I would like to again make the motion to reinstate Frank Sprague to the school board's seat." (0:43:21). Whitney: "I second." (0:43:41). Vote called (0:43:46). | MEDIUM OBSERVATION |
| 0:43:53 | The abstention | Howard: "I'm going to abstain doing that." Whitney: "Abstentions can only really be made if you have an objection." (0:44:04). Hawkins: "A person, a member can vote to abstain at any time." (0:45:15). Howard: "I don't think I'm legally obligated to say what it is." (0:44:49). Whitney: "you can use an abstention to throw a vote." (0:44:59); "That's what our bylaws are present and voting." (0:46:03). | MEDIUM |
| 0:46:22 | Result declared | Crawford: "So that means that the motion passes 3 to 2." Whitney: "Correct. The motion passes okay. And Mr. Sprague is appointed right." (0:46:24). Hawkins reads by-law 2.07 aloud: "Abstentions are counted, but have no bearing on the outcome of the vote." (0:47:02); at Lownie's request she reads its next passage, the NHSBA recommendation (0:48:41). | MEDIUM |
Items flagged for review
These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on November 5, 2025, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies. This page covers one agenda item; flags about the rest of the meeting belong to the page for show 16951.
MEDIUM The seat was filled by three of the six remaining members; whether that is the "majority vote" RSA 671:33 contemplates was not addressed
The motion to return Sprague carried with Madden, Petrin and Whitney for, Crawford and Hawkins against, and Howard abstaining (draft minutes; on tape 0:43:46 to 0:46:24). The board counted it as passing under its by-law 2.07, which the adopted by-laws word "shall be adopted by a majority vote of members present and voting" and illustrate with "7 members present, 2 abstain , 2 vote no, 3 vote yes the motion passes." The statute speaks differently. RSA 671:33, II(a) says "The school board shall fill vacancies occurring on the school board" and that the selectmen appoint "if the remaining members are unable, by majority vote, to agree upon an appointment." Three is not a majority of the six remaining members. RSA 21:15, I, a general rule of construction, gives "joint authority to 3 or more public officers" to "a majority of them"; read that way, an appointment needs four of six. Read the other way, as a majority of those voting, three of five suffices. The project's anchor notes treat both readings as open, and this page does not choose. The by-laws themselves yield to statute (by-law 2.15: "All laws of the State of New Hampshire ... shall take precedence over these rules"). On tape no member or counsel addressed which measure the statute uses; the chair said "If I'm wrong, I'm wrong." (0:44:44) about the by-law, and first told the board that abstentions "can only really be made if you have an objection" (0:44:04), which the adopted by-law does not say. Graded MEDIUM because the validity of the appointment turns on a statutory question the record leaves unexamined; the board's own count followed its written by-law.
Sources: RSA 671:33, II(a) (board fills vacancies; selectmen if remaining members cannot agree by majority vote); RSA 21:15, I (joint authority goes to a majority of the officers); Claremont School Board By-Laws, adopted June 5, 2024, rules 2.07 and 2.15; 11.5.25 draft minutes (vote by name)
MEDIUM The draft minutes give no actual start or end time for the meeting
Since August 22, 2025, RSA 91-A:2, II has required minutes to include "the start time and end time of the meeting, and name of the person who produced the minutes." The November 5 draft minutes name their author ("Respectfully submitted by Noelle Kronberg, school board clerk") and record the nonpublic session's times (7:35 p.m. and 8:08 p.m.), but for the call to order and adjournment they carry only the agenda's scheduled headings, "I. 6:30 PM" and "VI. 8:30 PM Adjournment", with no entry beneath the adjournment heading. This excerpt cannot supply either time. MEDIUM: a documentation gap under a requirement in force for under three months, on minutes that are otherwise detailed (see flag 8).
Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (minutes contents; amended 2025, 112:1, eff. Aug. 22, 2025); 11.5.25 draft minutes
OBSERVATION The first motion to return Sprague was never voted, withdrawn or postponed while two other motions were taken
Petrin moved at 0:04:20 and the chair seconded at 0:04:32, then said she "deferred that" to hear from members and the public (0:16:06). Crawford and Hawkins pointed out that a motion was on the floor (0:16:14, 0:34:10); the chair and Petrin answered "We deferred." (0:34:14). The board then voted on Howard's motion and Crawford's motion, and Petrin made his motion a second time (0:43:21). The draft minutes record the first motion as "Motion deferred". By-law 2.07 provides "Another motion cannot be raised until all other motions are settled or adjourned" and lists postponing to a certain time among the motions that may be received while a motion is under debate. A by-law is the board's own rule, not statute, so this is an observation; the second motion's vote is the operative one.
Sources: Claremont School Board By-Laws, rule 2.07 (motions); 11.5.25 draft minutes
OBSERVATION "Reinstatement" is an appointment under RSA 671:33, and it runs only to the next district election
The letter, both motions and the draft minutes call the action a reinstatement ("Frank Sprague will be reinstated as the seventh Board member"). No statute cited on the record provides for reinstating a member who resigned; the board's power is to fill the vacancy by appointment, and RSA 671:33, II(a) states "Appointees of the school board shall serve until the next district election when the voters of the district shall elect a replacement for the unexpired term." Petrin said as much ("And then in March, the voters get to speak again", 0:04:20). The chair's description of the purpose, "to bring back a person to finish the term that he was elected to serve" (0:20:40), goes further than the statute: the appointment ends at the March 2026 election whatever remained of the original term.
Sources: RSA 671:33, II(a) (appointee serves until the next district election)
OBSERVATION Members described the statute as "guidance" and "not binding"; its text says "shall fill", and the deadlines discussed are not in it
Counsel's correspondence, as the chair read it, said the law "directs the board to fill the vacancy" and also that it "is not a controlling law" (0:00:35, 0:01:28). Members then called it "not binding" (0:13:50) and "guidance" (0:16:32, 0:16:43). RSA 671:33, II(a) is mandatory in form, "The school board shall fill vacancies", and supplies its own consequence: if the remaining members cannot agree, "the selectmen ... shall appoint". For a city, RSA 21:28, I lets "selectmen" mean the mayor and aldermen, which is how counsel's warning about the City Council fits. The statute sets no time limit: neither the 45 days mentioned by the chair (0:09:28) and by Crawford (0:13:58) nor counsel's "at the next meeting" (0:01:07) appears in it. Counsel's letter itself is not in the packet, so the reader has only the chair's reading of it. The October 15, 2025 draft minutes show no vacancy item at the meeting between the tie vote and this one.
Sources: RSA 671:33, II(a); RSA 21:28, I ("selectmen" includes a city's mayor and aldermen); 10.15.25 draft minutes
OBSERVATION The chair solicited the returning member, and the board adopted no written process for filling the seat
Asked whether Sprague volunteered, the chair said she had called him to ask for names and asked whether he would serve himself (0:12:13, 0:12:34); Petrin later described the letter as "Not of any sort of backroom deal or any sort of solicitation." (0:42:52). Commenters and Madden called the arrangement a back room (0:06:29, 0:28:10). The chair said the board has "never had a policy related to this" (0:08:55), and Petrin said "The process needs to be better in the future." (0:43:21). No statute requires an application process for a board appointment, so this records the facts rather than a breach. It matters for reading the result: the board had already taken applications and heard candidates, and the person appointed came forward by letter after the chair's call, writing (as the chair read it) that he was "not interested in a competitive process" (0:03:29).
Sources: RSA 671:33, II(a) (no procedure prescribed); 11.5.25 draft minutes
POSITIVE Counsel's advice and the request letter were read into the public record, and the public was heard before any vote
The chair said she had shared counsel's correspondence with the whole board before the meeting and read its substance aloud (0:00:04 to 0:01:47), then read Sprague's letter in full (0:02:16 to 0:03:29). She opened the floor to the public on the item at three minutes per speaker before the board voted (0:21:08), and six people spoke, including both applicants. Policy BEDH and RSA 189:74 require a comment period at the meeting, not on each item; taking comment on the specific question before deciding it goes beyond that.
Sources: RSA 189:74 (public comment at board meetings); Policy BEDH (public comment and participation)
POSITIVE The draft minutes record every split vote by name, including the abstention, and were in the next packet on the fifth business day
RSA 91-A:2, II requires the names of movers and seconders, which the draft minutes give for all four motions. They also list each member's vote on the three divided votes, including "Abstaining: Loren Howard", on votes the board took by show of hands. The PDF copy in the November 19 packet was created November 13, 2025 at 8:19 a.m. Eastern (Drive metadata). Counting from November 5 and excluding Veterans Day, November 11 (RSA 288:1), that is the fifth business day, inside the statute's limit. The Google Doc was created at 6:33 p.m. on November 5, consistent with drafting during the meeting; that date shows when drafting began, not when the public could see it.
Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (movers and seconders; five business days); RSA 288:1 (legal holidays); draft CSB meeting minutes 11.5.25.pdf
Appendix: source files
Official and public sources
Project files
Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.
Laws and rules cited on this page
- RSA 671:33, II(a) (source note ends 2021, 42:1; 91:318): school board fills board vacancies; appointees serve to the next district election; selectmen appoint if remaining members cannot agree by majority vote
- RSA 21:15, I (2009, 260:1): joint authority of three or more officers goes to a majority of them
- RSA 21:28, I (2008, 183:1): "selectmen" may mean the mayor and aldermen of a city
- RSA 91-A:2, II (as amended 2025, 112:1, eff. Aug. 22, 2025): minutes contents including start and end time; movers and seconders; five business days
- RSA 288:1: legal holidays (November 11)
- RSA 189:74 (2022, 333:1): public comment at school board meetings
- District rules: Claremont School Board By-Laws 2.07 and 2.15; Policy BEDH.