Claremont School Board, April 15, 2026

Regular board meeting with six of seven members present (William Madden absent). The vice chair reported that the board had decided, on a 5-2 vote on Monday, April 13, to negotiate a contract with Dr. Timothy Broadrick as the next superintendent; the chair read the interim business administrator's report of a $5,930,734 bank balance on April 10 and an estimated year-end deficit of $1 million to $1.6 million, down from $5 million; the interim superintendent described 61 completed and 11 pending Right-to-Know requests and more than $10,000 in legal bills; the board voted to have counsel review the by-laws for $3,000 to $5,000, met in nonpublic session for 17 minutes and approved the staff rehire list. The page is built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript, the agenda, the approved minutes, the March financial reports in the packet and Drive file metadata. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6)
Date
Wednesday, April 15, 2026 (agenda and approved minutes)
Start time
Agenda: 6:30 p.m. The chair calls the meeting to order at 0:00:05 of the recording. The approved minutes print the agenda's 6:30 PM headings but no separate call-to-order time; they record the nonpublic session from 7:40 to 7:57 p.m. and "Consent adjournment at 8:11pm". The recording's public portion (about 84 minutes, from 0:00:03 to the last word at 1:24:34) plus the 17-minute nonpublic session matches a 6:30 p.m. start and the minuted 8:11 p.m. adjournment. The nonpublic session occupies 18 seconds of tape, between 1:10:05 and 1:10:23.
Location
Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center, Claremont (agenda and approved minutes). Carried on CCTV Channel 8.
Recording
Cablecast: Claremont School Board - 4/15/26 (show 17323; the dialogue file's last row ends at 1:24:34, since the Cablecast API refuses this environment; the project's run notes record 5,103 seconds of tape for this show from an earlier API reading)
Minutes
4.15.26 Approved CSB Meeting Minutes (Google Doc in the 2026 Meeting Minutes folder; created 6:28 p.m. on April 15, 2026, last modified May 17, 2026; "Respectfully submitted by Noelle Kronberg, school board clerk")
Board composition
Seven members: Candace Crawford (chair), Michael Petrin (vice chair), Heather Whitney, William Madden, Loren Howard, Don Lavalette, Brian Rapp. Roll called by the clerk at 0:01:19: six present, Madden absent (approved minutes). The agenda lists two student board members; the chair says the student representative attends once a month and was not present.

Participants

Everyone heard or addressed on the recording. Spellings follow the agenda and approved minutes; where the dialogue file differs, both are shown. Students are not named on this page.
NameRoleParticipation
Candace CrawfordChairPresides. Reads by-laws 2.03 and 1.11 aloud (0:02:09, 0:02:40); recognizes the tech-center students (0:04:57); discloses the 5-2 superintendent vote (0:17:02); reads the business administrator's finance report (0:28:13 to 0:30:53); moves the nonpublic session up the agenda (0:19:18); says board members will fund staff appreciation personally (1:13:35); reports on the Unity withdrawal agreement (1:14:04).
Michael PetrinVice chair; SRVRTC subcommittee chair; superintendent search committeeReports the superintendent search (0:15:44); seconds the rehire list (1:11:01); says a three-school model is not on the table for next year (1:08:40); proposes a school-board educator-of-the-year award (1:22:18). The dialogue file labels him "Mr. Patron", "Mr. Peterson" and "Mr. speaker" in the chair's recognitions.
Heather WhitneyMember; chair of the ad hoc exploratory reconfiguration subcommitteeMoves the nonpublic session (1:09:53); seconds the by-laws review (0:57:49); presses on the deficit jump and the opening balance (0:32:25, 0:34:27) and on the count of true vacancies (0:46:26); reports a public folder for her subcommittee (1:16:09); states the 24-hour statutory notice rule (1:20:02).
Loren HowardMember; Policy subcommittee chair; ad hoc communicationsSeconds the nonpublic motion (1:09:54) and the return motion (1:10:26); asks for a 15-hour cap on the by-laws review (0:58:09); raises reusing the Bluff building (1:02:39); moves the rehire list (approved minutes); proposes filming subcommittee meetings (1:23:37).
Don LavaletteMember; Policy and Finance subcommitteesCorrects the April 1 draft minutes (0:20:42 to 0:25:01); seconds the consent agenda (approved minutes); asks that Right-to-Know costs be published (0:54:59); moves the by-laws review (0:57:22) and the return to public session (approved minutes; 1:10:23); notes an NHSBA Right-to-Know session (1:21:42); moves adjournment (1:24:25). The chair calls him "Mr. LaValley" at 1:12:31.
Brian RappMember; Policy and Capital Improvements subcommitteesClarifies his April 1 remark on empty classrooms (0:25:17); moves the consent agenda (approved minutes); asks about the self-contained program placements (1:01:14); opposes revisiting Bluff (1:07:16); votes against the by-laws review (approved minutes); abstains on the rehire list as to his wife's nomination (approved minutes; the dialogue file leaves the sentence at 1:11:45 unidentified).
William MaddenMemberAbsent (approved minutes). The chair refers to "Mr. Madden's point" on testing at 0:38:19.
Noelle KronbergSchool board clerkCalls the roll (0:01:19, 1:09:58, 1:10:31); answers the minutes corrections (0:21:07); signs the minutes.
Kerry KennedyInterim Superintendent, SAU 6Reports anticipated vacancies (0:43:43), the Right-to-Know workload (0:51:41) and the realignment (0:59:52); presents the rehire list; reminds families of the early-release day (1:23:06).
Dr. Michael HerringtonPrincipal, Stevens High SchoolReports testing opt-outs among juniors and the diploma of distinction (0:36:16) and the SAT preparation course (0:39:55). ASR renders the surname "Harrington".
Michelle HerringtonDirector, Sugar River Valley Regional Technical CenterIntroduces the student ambassador program (0:08:20). ASR renders the surname "Harrington".
Students (six)SRVRTC student honoree and five student ambassadorsRecognized from 0:04:57; two ambassadors describe their programs (0:12:35, 0:13:15). Names are in the dialogue file and the minutes; this page does not repeat them.
Camron LownieCitizens' comments, Ward 2Teacher and family business owner; asks the district to announce the last day of school (0:26:33). The minutes spell the first name "Cameron".
Matt AngellSenior Comptroller / Interim Business AdministratorNot present ("on vacation this week", 0:18:07); his written finance report is read by the chair.
UnidentifiedVarious13 dialogue rows, mostly short acknowledgements; the consent-agenda motion and second are captured in one unidentified row at 0:25:59 (the minutes name Rapp and Lavalette).

Named but not present: Dr. Timothy Broadrick (superintendent candidate; the minutes and the transcript spell it "Broderick", the project follows his own signature), Melissa Lewis (joined the interviews), counsel Jim O'Shaughnessy, Unity board chair Rocco Ruggeri, and staff Jason Bonneville and Chelsea Weatherford.

Agenda

Items from 4.15.26 CSB Meeting Agenda; agenda wording is quoted from that document. Dispositions from the recording, checked against the approved minutes. The board amended the order on the floor (see the consent agenda row).
Taken upItemAgenda text / disposition
0:00:051. Call to orderPledge of Allegiance.
0:01:192. General businessAgenda: "Secretary Roll Call of Attendance of Board Members"; "Introduction of Miles Sheehan, Student Board member" (deferred to May because the student attends once a month); "Special recognition: SRVRTC Ambassadors" and a student honoree (0:04:57); "Meeting Procedures Reminder: Candace Crawford" (0:01:46); "Ad Hoc Leadership Search Subcommittee: Search Results Announcement by Mr. Petrin" (0:15:44).
0:17:32a. Consent agendaAgenda: "Amendments and Final Approval of Board Agenda", "Approval of Minutes: 4.1.26", "Approval of Manifest". Floor amendments: the pre-K cost comparison, the metal-detector item and the academy update moved to May; the nonpublic session moved ahead of the rehire vote (0:18:07, 0:19:18). Lavalette's and Rapp's corrections to the April 1 minutes (0:20:42, 0:25:17). Motion "to approve, as amended" and second at 0:25:59 (minutes: Rapp moved, Lavalette seconded); voice vote, no opposition heard (0:26:05); minutes: "all present voting in favor". The manifest is not mentioned on the recording, and the minutes leave "Approval of Manifest:" blank.
0:26:15b. Citizens' commentsOne speaker, Camron Lownie (Ward 2). The period runs about one minute; no one is turned away.
0:27:32c. Finance updateAgenda: "Finance Update (Report) Matt Angell, Senior Comptroller", with the March 31 revenue and expenditure reports attached. Read by the chair in Angell's absence; discussion follows. No vote.
0:35:57d. Follow-up itemsAgenda: "Anticipated vacancies", "Cost difference between preK proposal and current model" (moved to May), "Update on Right-To-Know requests folder on website", "Metal Detectors" (moved to May), "Diploma of Distinction", "SAT Prep Course". The high-school items are taken first at the interim superintendent's request (0:35:57); vacancies at 0:43:42; Right-to-Know at 0:51:32.
0:56:221. By-laws reviewAgenda: "By-Laws Review: Cost estimate from Jim O'Shaughnessy: Candace Crawford (Discussion/vote)". Lavalette moved (0:57:22), Whitney seconded (0:57:49); terms restated by the chair to require notice if the work runs past ten hours (0:59:08); voice vote (0:59:36); after the chair's call for those opposed, an unidentified voice answers (0:59:41). Minutes: "All present voting in favor with the exception of Brian Rapp who votes against".
0:59:522. Realignment updateReport by the interim superintendent; the board declines by consensus to study reusing Bluff (1:09:20). No vote.
1:09:273. Academy updateMoved to May (1:09:27).
1:09:278. Non-public session (moved up)Agenda: "Non-Public Session 91-a:3 II(b)". On tape the chair asks for a motion "under RSA 91 a three part two sets a C" (1:09:27); the minutes record the motion under "RSA 91-A:3,II(b)". Whitney moved (1:09:53), Howard seconded (1:09:54); roll call, all yes (1:09:58 to 1:10:05). Minutes: in at 7:40 p.m. Return: Lavalette moved, Howard seconded (1:10:23, 1:10:26); roll call, six yes (1:10:31 to 1:10:38); minutes: out at 7:57 p.m. No vote to seal the minutes is recorded. See flag 1.
1:10:384. Approval of staff for re-hireAgenda: "Approval of Staff for Re-Hire: Kerry Kennedy (Discussion/vote)". Motion "to accept the list as presented" (1:10:38); mover not audible on tape (minutes: Howard); Petrin seconded (1:11:01). Voice vote (1:11:36); one member abstains (1:11:45). Minutes: "all present voting in favor (Brian Rapp abstained from accepting the nomination of his wife)" and "The motion passed unanimously".
1:11:495. Teacher/staff appreciation weekAgenda: "May 4-8". Howard and Lavalette volunteer to organize; members to pay personally (1:13:35).
1:14:046. Unity withdrawal from SAU 6 updateReport by the chair; no vote.
1:15:347. Subcommittee reportsPolicy (no policies; four next time), reconfiguration ad hoc, SRVRTC, communications.
1:18:37Future dates; other businessPacket deadline and seven-day agenda practice; goal-setting meeting before May 20 (1:20:21); future items (1:21:10); NHSBA session; award ideas; early release.
1:24:17AdjournmentLavalette moves (1:24:25); the chair: "I don't even want a second." (1:24:26). Minutes: "Consent adjournment at 8:11pm".

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/17323 SchoolBoard041526.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:01:46Meeting procedure remindersThe chair reads by-law 2.03 on decorum and by-law 1.11 on subcommittee chairs: subcommittee minutes "must be recorded and available for public inspection on the SA website within five days of the meeting" (0:02:40); "We need five days before we get those minutes. No joke." (0:03:17). To the public: "School board meetings are held in public, but they are not a meeting for the general public. That means that we have work to do." (0:03:48); citizens' comments "are intended to be the topics that are not going to be covered on the agenda" (0:04:10); "If we're having a vote, we will open it up for discussion before we take the vote. It shouldn't be during public comments." (0:04:34). The minutes quote the by-law text, including its citation "per RSA 91-A:II" (a chapter with no section).
0:04:57Tech-center recognitionsA tech-center student nominated for the U.S. Presidential Scholars Program in career and technical education, one of five from New Hampshire (0:05:49); the SRVRTC director describes a pilot student-ambassador program and introduces five ambassadors (0:08:20, 0:12:00).
0:15:44Superintendent searchPetrin: the committee narrowed the field, the full board held second interviews, and the board decided to "work with our attorney to try to reach an agreement with Doctor Broderick to be our next superintendent." The chair: no contract signed yet; a background check remains; "the the minutes from our nonpublic from Monday night will be made public. They are public now." (0:16:35); "There were it was a 5 to 2 vote. That's and the two people voting against were Mr. Howard and myself." (0:17:02).POSITIVE
0:18:07Agenda changesPre-K cost comparison deferred because Angell is on vacation. Metal detectors deferred pending research on the original grant: "If we're not using them as described in the grant, we need to get rid of the equipment" (0:18:52). Academy update deferred; nonpublic session moved ahead of the rehire vote (0:19:18).
0:20:42April 1 minutes correctedLavalette asks for a commenter's name, his own surname's spelling, the school resource officer's name ("Can we put the name of the SRO in there please?", 0:21:22), who confirmed a contract term, the test score and percentage behind a high-school statement "So our minutes are robust?" (0:22:45), and the charter school's name. Rapp: "I'm pretty sure that I mentioned that those classes are set to be refilled with more of our class offerings." (0:25:31). Approved as amended by voice vote (0:26:05).OBSERVATION
0:26:33Public comment: LownieSpeaking as a summer-camp operator: parents keep asking the last day of school; "the fact that this question is coming up over and over again from parents" points to "a communication gap" (0:27:02).
0:28:13Finance report (read by the chair)As of April 10, "The district had a bank balance of $5,930,734." and "Our loan balance with Claremont Savings Bank is zero." Revenues through March $35,601,097.63, with $4,113,466 (10.36%) still to collect (0:28:45). Expenditures $24,665,436; then "Encumbrances were a 7,223,276, and the amount for of appropriations remaining is 3,825,000 851, or about 9.63%." (0:29:49). The expenditure report and the minutes give encumbrances of $11,223,276.10 and $3,825,851.34 remaining; only the $11.2 million figure reconciles to the $39,714,564 appropriation, so the spoken "7,223,276" is a misreading or an ASR error. Estimated year-end deficit "between 1 million and 1.6 million", down from $5 million (0:29:49, 0:30:29). The chair: "I think we're going to be okay. I mean. But don't quote me." (0:31:23).OBSERVATION OBSERVATION
0:32:25Deficit questionsWhitney: "it's a big jump from we're going to be zero to possibly 1 to 1.6." The chair on one surprise expense she cannot share publicly: "it was a past due bill that wasn't paid. Right? Right. That wasn't in the ledger. And they didn't know about it." (0:34:00). Whitney: "I think it was a 1.2 million surprise last year right at the end of the year." (0:34:27). On the opening balance, the chair: "the auditors have told us that they would have a, a reliable, verifiable figure for the start of 2000 for July 1st, 2025, by July 1st this year." (0:34:52).OBSERVATION
0:36:16Testing opt-outs; diploma of distinctionHerrington: "So out of 109 juniors, you've had four people opt out." (0:36:47); none on the 27-credit track: "there's no one on the 27 track that's not taking state taxes [tests]." (0:37:52). Juniors who score proficient may skip finals (0:39:11).
0:39:55SAT preparationA semester sophomore course split between English and math, but not next year: "So for that to have happened it would have had to be in the course of studies." (0:40:53). A member asks about a VLACS option (0:41:24; the dialogue file labels the question Rapp, the minutes Petrin). Possible return of the sophomore PSAT (0:41:50); Whitney recalls a free Dartmouth SAT course (0:42:40).OBSERVATION
0:43:43Anticipated vacanciesThe interim superintendent lists openings at CMS, Stevens, Disnard and Maple Avenue, some restoring positions cut by last year's reduction in force. The chair: "It's a list of the 19 riffs in the first round and then the 20 in the second round." and "out of the 39, there were three reinstated during the year." (0:45:49); Kennedy: "Technically four." (0:46:16). Whitney asks how many vacancies are real against "the one that outlines 25 vacancies" (0:46:26) given the deficit; "There's a hiring freeze right now." (0:47:59). A member: "Let's wait until contracts have to be back. Then we'll have hard data." (0:51:04; labeled Rapp in the dialogue file, Lavalette in the minutes).OBSERVATION
0:51:41Right-to-Know workloadKennedy: "there are currently 61 completed right to know requests since November 1st"; "11 are in progress and those are very in depth." (0:52:01); "So some have all 8000 emails to be reviewed." (0:52:19); four staff handle them; "Over $10,000 of requests from legal fees and things too. So this is not insignificant." (0:53:54); "you have five days to get the information or at least respond with, you were going to need a 30 day extension" (0:54:13).OBSERVATION
0:54:59Publishing Right-to-Know costsLavalette: the state Department of Safety page "says the department may charge fees to recover actual costs"; the city's page has a posting "that shows everyone who who's requested it, the date, what they requested, staff time spent and legal fees." (0:55:17); "if there's a cost and it's substantial, the public deserves to know that." (0:55:46). No action taken.OBSERVATION
0:56:22By-laws review by counselThe chair relays counsel's estimate: "his goal would be to get it done by the middle of May, and it would be ten hours or less. He guesses that it would an estimate of 3 to $5000." (0:57:01). Lavalette moves: "we are not in a position to operate without school board bylaws, so we don't really have a choice, I think." (0:57:22). Howard asks for "a limit of 15 hours before we get a report back from him" (0:58:09); the chair's restatement: "if it expands more than ten, I'm going to say more than ten hours. That he must notify us of whether to continue." (0:59:08). Carried by voice vote; the minutes record Rapp against.
0:59:52RealignmentPre-K to grade 2 at [Disnard] and grades 3 to 5 at Maple Avenue; transportation and staggered start times go to the superintendent's council on the 20th. The self-contained programs: K-2 at Disnard and 3-5 at Maple; the report's "2-3" is an error (1:01:43, 1:02:24).
1:02:39Bluff as a backup buildingHoward asks whether Bluff should be compared with the other buildings. Petrin: "My understanding is that we can't do bluff because the we voted to sell it, right." (1:03:45). Rapp: "The voters overwhelmingly approved to sell it. I have no interest in that." (1:07:37). Lavalette, Whitney and Petrin agree; Petrin: "We're not looking at any sort of three school model for next year." (1:09:13).
1:09:27Nonpublic sessionThe chair: "I would entertain a motion to go into nonpublic under RSA 91 a three part two sets a C." Roll call, all yes (1:09:58). The tape resumes at 1:10:23 with the motion to return and a second roll call, all six yes (1:10:31).OBSERVATION
1:10:38Staff rehire listWhitney confirms these are contracts offered, not yet accepted (1:11:27); Kennedy: contracts will "definitely be out before next Friday" (1:11:17). A member: "And I'll be abstaining from Mrs. Robb." (1:11:45; the minutes: Rapp, as to his wife's nomination).OBSERVATION
1:11:49Staff appreciationHoward and Lavalette will organize, coordinating with the PTA (1:12:46; labeled Lavalette in the dialogue file, Petrin in the minutes). The chair: "given their financial situation in the district, I cannot justify taking money out of the district funds. So we as in as members, we will make contributions." (1:13:35).OBSERVATION
1:14:04Unity withdrawal"The essay [SAU] six will continue. It will just be a Claremont, of school district in the six." The chair and the Unity chair will meet counsel on Unity's withdrawal agreement: "It's it's pretty standard. There's nothing here that is unusual." (1:14:49). The minutes: "it will only be Claremont in the SAU as of July 1, 2026".
1:15:34Subcommittee reportsPolicy: four policies next meeting, including one the district lacks and a dress code (1:17:05). Whitney: "I also spoke to Mr. Bonneville about creating a folder for our subcommittee so that all the artifacts will be readily available for the public to review." (1:16:09). Howard has contacted [NH Listens] (ASR "Nelson's") about a community event (1:17:48).
1:18:37Packet deadline and noticeThe chair wants to "get the agenda out seven days prior, regardless of whether it's vacation week or not." (1:19:25). Whitney: the state law mandate is "24 hours. But we have practice." (1:20:02); the board's agenda "Policy actually has a seven day to allow board members to have that time" (1:20:05).POSITIVE
1:20:21Goal setting; future itemsPolicy requires a goal-setting meeting by the second meeting in May, so "we have got to schedule a goal setting meeting for the board." (1:20:21). Future items: stipends, bus contract, commercial broker RFP, board training (1:21:10).
1:21:42Other businessLavalette: an NHSBA Right-to-Know session online, "So May 13th from 12 to 2." Petrin proposes "maybe creating a school board educator of the year type of award" (1:22:18); Lavalette: "I had talked about a Hall of Fame." (1:22:50). Early release Friday (1:23:06).
1:23:37Filming subcommittee meetingsHoward proposes members "volunteering yourself to set a camera up on a tripod and film the committee meetings." and "I bet we could get some local collaboration with CCTV just to, you know, simple training" (1:23:58). Listed in the minutes as a future agenda item.

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on April 15, 2026, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.

OBSERVATION Minutes of the 17-minute nonpublic session were not located, and no vote to seal them was taken

The board entered nonpublic session on a roll-call vote (1:09:58) and returned on another (1:10:31); the approved minutes record 7:40 to 7:57 p.m. under RSA 91-A:3, II(b), the hiring exemption, which fits the rehire vote that followed in public. On tape the chair's motion request is transcribed "part two sets a C" (1:09:27); the agenda and minutes both say II(b), and this page follows them. Neither the recording nor the minutes shows a vote to withhold the nonpublic minutes, so RSA 91-A:3, III required them to be "publicly disclosed within 72 hours of the meeting". This run did not find them: the approved public minutes summarize only the two motions, and a Drive search of the district's "2026 Non-Public" folder returned nothing. Drive searches in this project are known to miss files that exist, so this is reported as an observation, not a missed deadline. The roll-call requirement of RSA 91-A:3, I(b) was met on tape.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, I(b) and III (roll call; nonpublic minutes disclosed within 72 hours unless sealed by a 2/3 recorded vote); 4.15.26 approved minutes

OBSERVATION An unpaid prior bill "wasn't in the ledger", and the board still did not know its July 1, 2025 opening balance

Explaining why the deficit estimate rose from zero to $1 million to $1.6 million, the chair described a sizable surprise she could not detail publicly: "a past due bill that wasn't paid. Right? Right. That wasn't in the ledger." (0:34:00); Whitney recalled a "1.2 million surprise last year right at the end of the year" (0:34:27). Governmental funds recognize expenditures on the modified accrual basis when the liability is incurred (GASB 34, ¶79); a bill for goods or services received in an earlier year that was never recorded is the kind of error GASB 100 requires to be corrected by restating beginning fund balance, with note disclosure. The chair also said the auditors would produce a "reliable, verifiable figure" for the July 1, 2025 starting balance only by July 2026 (0:34:52), nine and a half months into the year. The record does not give the bill's amount, period or vendor, so no GASB departure can be tied to a figure here; the FY2025 audit report and any restatement note would settle it. The audit-filing deadline of 2026 N.H. Laws ch. 272 (nine months after year end) took effect July 1, 2026 and did not apply on this date; RSA 21-J:19's audit timing is permissive.

Sources: GASB 34, ¶79 (modified accrual in governmental funds); GASB 100, ¶12, ¶25-28 (error corrections restate beginning balances); N.H. Admin. Rules, Rev 1102.03 (districts follow GASB GAAP); RSA 21-J:19 (audits; permissive timing)

OBSERVATION The approved minutes misstate one revenue figure, call a vote with an abstention unanimous, and differ from the dialogue file on three speakers

The minutes' text of the finance report gives "Medicaid revenue of $33,866.97" (the chair read the same figure, as "Medicare", at 0:28:45); the packet's March revenue report prints $33,886.97 for the Medicaid line, so the written report transposed two digits. On the rehire list the minutes record Rapp's abstention and then "The motion passed unanimously". The minutes and the dialogue file disagree on who spoke at three points: the VLACS question (0:41:24: dialogue Rapp, minutes Petrin), the suggestion to wait for returned contracts (0:50:47: dialogue Rapp, minutes Lavalette) and the PTA caution (1:12:46: dialogue Lavalette, minutes Petrin). The dialogue file's labels for Rapp and Lavalette come from merged voice clusters, so this page names both sources and picks neither. None of these touches a statutory element: RSA 91-A:2, II requires the members, persons appearing, subject matter, final decisions, start and end time, author, and movers and seconders, and the minutes carry the movers and seconders for every motion.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (minutes contents, as amended 2025, 112:1, eff. Aug. 22, 2025); CSD 03.31.2026 Revenues.pdf (Medicaid Reimbursement line); 4.15.26 approved minutes

OBSERVATION Right-to-Know compliance costs cannot be passed to requesters beyond copying; a public cost log is lawful but not required

The interim superintendent reported 61 completed and 11 pending requests, some involving 8,000 emails, and more than $10,000 in legal fees (0:52:01, 0:53:54). Her account of the timing rule matches RSA 91-A:4, IV(b): within five business days the body must make the record available, deny the request, or give a written statement of the time reasonably needed. Lavalette's comparison with state agencies that "may charge fees to recover actual costs" (0:55:17) needs a limit stated: RSA 91-A:4, IV(d) allows only "the actual cost of providing the copy" and provides that "No cost or fee shall be charged for the inspection or delivery, without copying, of governmental records". Staff search, review and redaction time and legal fees therefore fall on the district. Publishing a log of requests and their costs, as he proposed, is not required by RSA 91-A and not barred by it; requesters' identities would need the same review as any other record.

Sources: RSA 91-A:4, IV(b) and IV(d) (five business days; copy cost only; no fee for inspection; note ends 2024, 49:1, 2, eff. Aug. 13, 2024)

POSITIVE The chair announced the split superintendent vote on camera, named the two dissenters, and said the nonpublic minutes were public

The board's choice of a superintendent was made on Monday, April 13, a night the chair ties to a nonpublic session. Two days later the chair told the televised meeting that "it was a 5 to 2 vote", named herself and Howard as the votes against (0:17:02), and said the nonpublic minutes "are public now" (0:16:35). RSA 91-A:3, III requires nonpublic minutes and decisions to be disclosed within 72 hours unless sealed; announcing the tally and the names on the broadcast goes beyond that minimum. This page did not open the April 13 minutes and does not vouch for their content.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, III (disclosure of nonpublic minutes and decisions within 72 hours)

POSITIVE Notice went up a week ahead, and a member stated the 24-hour statutory floor correctly

The Public Notice 4.15.26 was created in the packet folder at 10:50 a.m. on April 8, seven days before the meeting, against the 24-hour minimum (excluding Sundays and legal holidays) of RSA 91-A:2, II. Whitney described the rule accurately: "24 hours. But we have practice." (1:20:02). The agenda document itself was created at 9:38 p.m. on April 12 and edited until 12:44 p.m. on the meeting day, so the board's stated seven-day agenda practice was met by the notice, not by the agenda, at this meeting.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (24-hour notice); Public Notice 4.15.26 (Drive metadata)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page