Claremont School Board, May 6, 2020

First recorded Claremont board meeting held remotely during the COVID-19 closure, by video conference and telephone. The superintendent opens an organizational meeting at which Frank Sprague is re-elected chair and Heather Whitney elected vice chair, both unanimously. Two public hearings: an $8,877.67 New Hampshire Charitable Foundation gift to the Stevens library and a $325,000 transfer from the Special Education Trust Fund for an autism program and social workers. The board sets the last day of school at a half day on June 5 (5-2), rejects a raise in the clerk's meeting pay (2-5), and hears that the FY2018 audit is still unfinished. Built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript; no agenda, packet or minutes survive in the district's online shares. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6)
Date
Wednesday, May 6, 2020 (the superintendent welcomes viewers to "the May 6th Claremont school board meeting" at 0:01:37)
Start time
Not stated in available records. The recording opens at 0:01:29 with the superintendent starting the organizational meeting. The chair calls the regular meeting "of May 6th, 2020 to order" at 0:29:59. Adjournment is voted at 2:22:42; the dialogue transcript runs 2:23:31.
Location
Remote. Members join by video ("the Hollywood Squares", 0:04:34) and the public by telephone; each member states that no one else is in the room with them (0:09:30 to 0:10:59). The technology director says "I'm at the tech center". Governor's Emergency Order #12 (March 23, 2020) waived the physical-quorum requirement during the state of emergency.
Recording
Cablecast: SCHOOL BOARD Hearing & Meeting of 5/6/20 (transcript length 2:23:31; no speech between 0:15:07 and 0:19:41 while audio problems were fixed; the Cablecast API returned 403 on 2026-10-02)
Minutes
None located. MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting (no share holds a year folder older than 2022; checked 9/26/26). Minutes were made: the board approved them with corrections on June 3, 2020 (June 3, 2020 page).
Board composition
Seven members, all present: Frank Sprague (chair, re-elected), Heather Whitney (elected vice chair, succeeding Rebecca Zullo), Rebecca Zullo, Jason Benware, Rob Lovett Jr., Michael Petrin and Carolyn Towle.

Participants

Everyone heard or addressed on the recording. There are no minutes to check spellings against; names rest on self-identification, the roll calls as transcribed, the project roster and the attribution report. Students are not named.
NameRoleParticipation
Frank SpragueChair (re-elected this meeting)Elected chair by roll call (0:04:34 to 0:05:09), then takes over: "Wait a minute. I'm running the meeting now." Runs both hearings, calls every roll himself, moves the clerk's raise to $85 (1:41:03) and arranges to sign vouchers in person (2:14:46).
Heather WhitneyMember; elected vice chairNominated by Lovett (0:05:56); elected unanimously (0:07:00 to 0:07:27). Asks about attendance data, energy savings, Chromebooks, the funding lawsuit (1:01:33), summer school, grading (1:25:16), the Abbey Group contract and NECC paraprofessional qualifications (2:10:03). Abstains on the March 4 minutes, saying "I don't believe I was there"; the March 4 roll records her present.
Rebecca ZulloMember (vice chair until this meeting)Declines the vice-chair nomination and supports Whitney (0:06:11). Abstains on the March 4 minutes (0:34:48). Argues that remote learning is uneven for families (1:16:20) and votes against the June 5 end date and the clerk's raise.
Jason BenwareMemberNominates Sprague for chair (0:03:58) and Zullo for vice chair (0:05:33); moves the agenda, the February minutes tabling, the March 4 minutes, the policies, the handbooks, the teacher nominations, the library gift and adjournment. Opposes ending school early (1:20:29).
Rob Lovett Jr.MemberNominates Whitney for vice chair (0:05:56); asks for data before deciding on the school year (1:22:14); votes against the June 5 end date and the clerk's raise (1:41:00).
Michael PetrinMemberAnswers rolls as "Mike patron" [Petrin]; votes no on the clerk's raise (1:42:19). No cluster of his own in the dialogue file; his answers were reassigned from other clusters.
Carolyn TowleMemberAsks that members state who is with them under the governor's order (0:07:51); asks for a capital improvement committee session (1:07:35); volunteers to sign vouchers (2:14:16) and reports graduation planning (2:18:08).
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Opens the organizational meeting (0:01:37); presents the trust-fund transfer (0:21:59) and his report (0:43:20); answers the public commenter (0:26:37).
Donna MagoonAssistant Superintendent, SAU 6Insists on roll-call votes (0:02:17); presents the 990-hour calculation for the last day of school (1:10:42), the suicide-prevention policy (1:33:05) and the handbooks (2:02:42). Transcribed as "Donna McGowan" (0:10:24).
Richard SeamanBusiness Administrator, SAU 6Presents the clerk-pay proposal (1:35:50), the food-service update (1:42:52) and the audit update (1:58:51).
Matt UptonDistrict counsel, Drummond WoodsumAdvises on the governor's order (0:08:19) and on roll-call votes (0:04:29).
Jeff SmallDirector of Technology, SAU 6Monitors the phone line for public comment (0:12:04); announces "we are back online with, CCTV" (0:20:18).
UnidentifiedSAU administrator (male)Reports that extended school year for special education will run remotely (1:07:12) and that NECC paraprofessionals need not hold bachelor's degrees (2:10:33). The attribution report rates the identity low confidence.
Patrick AdrianPublic commenter by telephone, Ward 1Identifies himself as "Patrick. Adrian. Ward one. Eagle times reporter." and questions the trust-fund use for social workers (0:26:11).
Student representativeStevens High SchoolGives the student report and comments on remote learning (0:35:36, 1:21:18). Not named on this page.
Mary WoodmanClerkNot heard. The chair calls the rolls himself (0:30:39). Her meeting pay is the subject of a vote (1:35:50).

Order of business (reconstructed)

No agenda survives. The chair refers to "an agenda in front of us" (0:31:11) and members work from a packet posted on the SAU website (0:50:11); the list below is reconstructed from the transitions on the recording.

Items in the order taken up, with disposition as heard. All votes after the organizational meeting are by roll call.
Taken upItemWhat happened
0:01:37Organizational meeting: election of chair and vice chairRun by the superintendent. A first motion, "We elect the chair and vice chair.", is followed by an attendance roll that the superintendent briefly takes for a vote (0:03:42); Benware: "Wait, wait. We haven't actually made that nomination yet." Benware nominates Sprague, Lovett seconds (0:04:04); roll call 7-0. Vice chair: Benware nominates Zullo, Lovett nominates Whitney, the chair seconds; Zullo supports Whitney and the chair treats Benware's nomination as rescinded (0:06:44); roll call 7-0 for Whitney.
0:07:51Members identify who is with themAt Towle's request and on counsel's advice "just as a precaution", each participant states that no one else is present.
0:11:10Public hearing A: $8,877.67 donation to the Stevens libraryOpened at 0:11:10; no public comment (0:12:04). Re-opened at 0:20:48 after the CCTV feed rejoined; "Seeing nothing here. Frank."
0:12:12Public hearing B: transfer from the Special Education Trust Fund to the FY2021 budgetOpened at 0:12:12 and re-opened at 0:21:38. One telephone comment (Patrick Adrian, Ward 1). Hearings closed at 0:29:59.
0:29:59Call to order; Pledge; roll callAll seven members present.
0:31:11Approval of the agendaBenware moves (0:31:38); Zullo seconds per the chair (0:31:54). A voice vote is redone by roll call: "every vote tonight has to be roll call." 7-0.
0:32:50Minutes: February 23, 2020 retreat; March 4, 2020Retreat minutes tabled again: Benware moves, Whitney seconds, 7-0 (0:33:31 to 0:34:18). March 4 minutes approved: Benware moves, Towle seconds (0:34:25); 5 ayes, Zullo and Whitney abstaining (0:34:48, 0:35:11).
0:35:17Student representative reportNo action.
0:41:26Superintendent's reportRemote operations, the school-funding lawsuit, the middle school as a COVID-19 testing site, strategic plan delay, hiring. No action.
1:09:56Discussion and action: last day of schoolSet at a half day on June 5. Motion attributed to Benware (1:31:21), Towle seconds; roll call 5-2, Zullo and Lovett nay: "High passes 5 to 2." (1:32:20). See flag 4.
1:30:43Policies JLDBB and JLDBBR (suicide prevention)Listed as a first read; moved to third and final read on Benware's motion, Whitney second; roll call 7-0 (1:34:35 to 1:35:22).
1:35:43School board clerk compensationChair moves $85 an hour instead of $75, Whitney seconds (1:41:03); fails 2-5, Sprague and Benware aye: "5 to 2 against. So it's $75. It stays."
1:42:43Food service updateBusiness administrator. No action.
1:58:37Audit updateBusiness administrator. No action. See flag 1.
2:02:29Parent-student handbooksBenware moves "the preschool, the elementary school, the middle school and high school handbooks as written." Zullo seconds; the chair names Whitney as seconder (2:04:29). Roll call; not every answer is audible (2:04:53 to 2:05:31). Treated as approved.
2:06:07Teacher nominationsThree high school nominations; Benware moves, Whitney seconds; roll call 7-0 (2:08:01 to 2:08:25).
2:08:31Acceptance of the $8,877.67 library donationBenware moves, Zullo seconds; roll call, all aye (2:09:06 to 2:09:32).
2:09:32Transfer of $325,000 from the Special Education Trust Fund to the FY2021 budgetWhitney moves, Towle seconds (2:11:40, 2:11:51); roll call, "Passes unanimously."
2:13:07VouchersNo vote. The chair and Towle are to sign in person. See flag 5.
2:15:21Future agenda itemsRetreat date, distance learning, nominations, the Abbey Group contract, graduation, capital improvement.
2:22:18AdjournmentBenware moves, Lovett seconds (2:22:25); roll call (2:22:42).

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/10842 SchoolBoard050620.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

Topics in recording order. Snippets expand on hover or keyboard focus.
TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:01:37Organizational meeting opened by the superintendentTempesta asks "I'd like to have a motion for the election of chair and vice chair." A voice vote is stopped by the assistant superintendent: "I think we have to do a roll call." Counsel: "Roll call. Mike. All of them." After an attendance roll the superintendent announces "So the chair is is Frank Sprague."; Benware objects that no nomination has been made (0:03:47).POSITIVE
0:03:58Chair and vice chair electedBenware: "I'd like to nominate Frank Sprague for chair." Roll call, all yes (0:04:34 to 0:05:09). For vice chair, Benware nominates Zullo; Lovett: "I'd like to nominate Heather Whitney." Zullo: "I was going to nominate Heather." "I'm not really sure if I'm going to be running again next year." Roll call, all yes (0:07:05 to 0:07:27).
0:07:51Who is in the roomTowle: "we all have to, announce that we are meeting by ourselves." Counsel first says "I don't believe you have to do that anymore", then advises "just as a precaution, why doesn't everybody announce who's with them". Each participant does (0:09:44 to 0:10:59).POSITIVE
0:11:10Hearing on the library donationTempesta: "we have a donation from 8000 for $8,877.67 for the Stephens High School library from the New Hampshire Charitable Foundation." Small: "I do see one phone call out there, but they are on mute."POSITIVE
0:12:40Trust-fund transfer explained (first pass)Tempesta: the NECC autism program contract "is a 190 zero.", "a approximately 20,000 of other materials", two paraprofessionals, and "two additional school social workers, one at the elementary level and one at the middle school level level." "We only want to access 325,000, which is half of the money." Speech stops at 0:15:07.
0:19:41Audio failure; hearings re-openedSprague: "we are experiencing some technical difficulties with the audio for everyone". Counsel: "an alert that the community TV has just joined." Sprague: "I'm wondering if we should repeat the two, open the two public hearing agenda items back up, just in case." Counsel: "I think that would probably be smart." The library hearing is re-run (0:20:48): the chair notes "Given the size of the donation, it requires having a public hearing before the board can act on accepting that donation."POSITIVE POSITIVE
0:21:59Trust-fund transfer explained again"we're proposing to move the sum of $325,000 to, the FY 21 budget from the Educational trust that was established back in the fall." The NECC contract with its teacher "is 190,000" plus "$20,000 for supplies and equipment"; the rest funds two social workers; Courtney Porter moves to the high school. "If we don't use all of that, we will give a complete accounting".OBSERVATION POSITIVE
0:25:39Public comment by telephoneAdrian: "when this money was appropriated, there was never any mention about social workers." "Is that an issue like where essentially you're using money for positions that was not part of the original description to the voters?" Tempesta: the autism program "is definitely what we presented to the, to the voters specifically"; "All we're really going to need is $60,000 for, for one social worker at the elementary"; the middle school position replaces a contracted social worker. Hearings closed (0:29:59).OBSERVATION
0:29:59Regular meeting; agenda by roll callAll seven present. A voice vote on the agenda is redone: "We have to do all every vote tonight has to be roll call."POSITIVE
0:32:50MinutesTowle on the retreat minutes: "I never did I never did get back to Mary." Tabled 7-0. March 4 minutes approved with Zullo ("I abstained I wasn't there") and Whitney abstaining; Whitney answered the March 4 roll (March 4, 2020 page).
0:35:36Student representative reportThe technical center cancels its summer camp; adult education continues; "remote learning is not easy, and it's not for everybody." Meals are available at all schools "from 9 to 12 every day."
0:43:20Superintendent's reportRemote operations and Chromebook distribution to bridge "the digital divide". The district "did officially join the Carnival lawsuit for school funding and equity" [ConVal, per the attribution report]. Breakdown of the transfer: "the contract was 190 and then 10,000 for equipment and furniture and other odds and ends. 152 paraprofessionals, 60,001 elementary social worker for 60,000." The middle school is a COVID-19 testing site with the National Guard (0:51:02). Hiring is ahead of schedule (0:54:30).OBSERVATION
0:55:26Questions: attendance, savings, Chromebooks, lawsuitNo attendance numbers yet (0:55:57). On closure savings, Seaman: "I really can't quantify it just yet." Chromebooks will stay with students (0:58:56). On the lawsuit, Tempesta: "there's no cost to us or anything like that. It's not going to hit the taxpayers." Whitney: "I guess I brought it up for transparency".
1:02:15Summer school; extended school yearTempesta expects any summer work to be "more, more, virtual than, than anything". A male administrator: extended school year for special education will run remotely (1:07:12).
1:07:35Capital improvement committeeTowle asks for a remote committee session; the chair: remote meetings let others observe, "we wouldn't be in the danger of a quorum or something."
1:10:42Last day of school: the 990-hour calculationMagoon: "the high school has 5.92 hours of instructional time a day." "And if I times that by 165.5 school days, that gives me 991.60 hours of construction time. And according to the state, we need 990." [5.92 x 165.5 = 979.76; the 167.5 days she gives next yields 991.6.] "we would be done school with a half day on June 5th." A Department of Education contact "approved" the method.
1:13:18Waiver debateZullo asks about waivers; Magoon: no waiver is needed because the district exceeds 990 hours (1:13:54). Zullo: "I would definitely be fine with ending school tomorrow." Benware: "I don't really feel the need to punish those who are excelling with it either." Lovett asks for data first (1:22:14); Magoon: a waiver request "would need to be in by Friday." Grade promotion: elementary and middle school students "will not be held back."
1:30:43Vote on the last day of schoolThe chair: "I'm not sure we need a vote, but I thought it was more of an executive decision." Magoon: a vote is needed "because the school calendar was voted by the school board." Towle: "Jason's got a motion." No motion text is heard. Roll call 5-2, Zullo and Lovett nay (1:31:52 to 1:32:20).OBSERVATION
1:32:28Suicide-prevention policiesMagoon: the policy is required because "Senate Bill 282 has said that we need to adopt this policy, adopt this policy by July 1st", with staff training "by April 1st of next school year." Moved from first to third and final read; 7-0 (1:34:52).
1:35:50Clerk's meeting paySeaman: the clerk "is currently paid $75. Per hour", a rate "set at $75.10 and a half years ago" [$75, ten and a half years ago]; he recommends "95 or to $100 for the meeting". Zullo: "Just tough when you say out loud, $95 an hour." The chair moves $85, Whitney seconds; fails 2-5 (1:42:28). Zullo asks for "a conversation about doing something special for her."
1:42:52Food service during the closureSeaman: "We're doing about 500, a little bit more, both breakfast and lunch today, so close to 1000 meals per day." Under the state waiver all meals are reimbursed; April "reimbursements were actually $8,037 greater than what the cost was". Benware: "So we're making money giving free lunches." Seaman: reimbursement "for a lunch of $3.50 and for a breakfast of $2.23"; at the high school "maybe 200 meals that will do there out of the 600 plus kids." The contract with Abbey Group is a "break even contract"; the meal-debt collection issue remains (1:52:55).
1:58:51Audit updateSeaman: "Right now we are working with Nick on our fiscal 18 audit." The firm is remote and cannot pull invoices on site. "the 18 hour 19 needs to be completed by September 15th, and especially the single audit, which needs to be delivered to the federal clearinghouse on our on our federal grants." "which will be the first time that we will have met that in a number of years."HIGH
2:02:42HandbooksMagoon: the handbooks came in earlier than usual at the board's request. The chair thanks administrators because last year the board got them "at about the same time that they would have been distributed".
2:06:07Teacher nominationsTempesta nominates a guidance counselor and biology and English teachers for the high school (2:06:10); elected by roll call, 7-0.
2:08:31Library gift accepted; trust transfer approvedBenware moves "that we accept the donation of 88, 77, 67." [$8,877.67]; all aye. Whitney asks whether NECC paraprofessionals need bachelor's degrees; an administrator: "No, they don't have to have a bachelor's." Transfer moved by Whitney (2:11:40), amount supplied by Benware: "It's 325,000." Unanimous (2:13:03).POSITIVE OBSERVATION
2:13:07Vouchers during remote operationMagoon: these are "the vouchers that you guys would normally sign at our meetings". Seaman: "maybe we just wait until we've got more normal times." "we will actually need to have two board members, I believe, sign". The chair will sign in person and Towle offers to sign; no vote designates the signers.OBSERVATION
2:15:21Future agenda itemsNext meeting "on June 3rd"; retreat scheduling; the Abbey Group contract "That's up in June at the end of June."; graduation planned for June 11 (2:18:08).
2:20:18Staff appreciation; adjournmentMagoon marks teacher and staff appreciation week. Benware moves to adjourn, Lovett seconds; roll call (2:22:42).

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on May 6, 2020, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule settles the point.

HIGH The FY2018 audit was still unfinished in May 2020, past the federal single-audit deadline, and the business administrator said the district had not met that deadline "in a number of years"

Seaman told the board "Right now we are working with Nick on our fiscal 18 audit." (1:58:51) and that the FY2019 single audit "needs to be delivered to the federal clearinghouse on our on our federal grants", adding that meeting the deadline "will be the first time that we will have met that in a number of years." (2:00:35). Under 2 CFR 200.501(a), an entity that "expends $750,000 or more during the non-Federal entity's fiscal year in Federal awards must have a single or program-specific audit conducted for that year", and under 200.512(a)(1) the audit and reporting package must be submitted "within the earlier of 30 calendar days after receipt of the auditor's report(s), or nine months after the end of the audit period" (regulation text).

For the fiscal year ended June 30, 2018 the nine-month date was March 31, 2019. OMB Memorandum M-20-17 (March 19, 2020), item 13, let entities that had not yet filed and had fiscal year-ends through June 30, 2020 delay submission "to six (6) months beyond the normal due date" (memo text); for FY2018 that is September 30, 2019, already past when the memo issued. On the administrator's own account the FY2018 audit was at least thirteen months overdue at this meeting, and the district had missed the deadline in earlier years.

Two cautions. The page assumes the FY2018 audit is a single audit; Seaman ties the single audit expressly to FY2019, and the district's federal spending (school meals, Title I, special education) makes FY2018 very likely to cross the $750,000 threshold, but the record here does not state it. And the delay was the district's and its auditor's together; Seaman says the district is pushing the firm. The audit firm is named only as Nick and "Platnick" in the transcript; the attribution report identifies it, as a hypothesis, as Plodzik & Sanderson.

Sources: 2 CFR 200.512(a)(1) (2019 annual edition): report due earlier of 30 days after auditor's report or nine months after period end; 2 CFR 200.501(a) (2019 annual edition): single audit at $750,000 federal expenditures; OMB M-20-17 (Mar. 19, 2020), item 13: six-month single-audit extension

MEDIUM No agenda, packet or minutes for this meeting survive in any district share

MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting. The recording is the only public account of the officer elections, the $325,000 trust-fund transfer and the school-year vote. RSA 91-A:2, II (in force from January 1, 2019) requires minutes with "the names of members, persons appearing before the public bodies, and a brief description of the subject matter discussed and final decisions", the names of "the members who made or seconded each motion", and public inspection "not more than 5 business days after the meeting" (statute text).

MEDIUM, not HIGH, because the record mitigates the gap: the assistant superintendent says the meeting packet "is on the Saw website in the school board" (0:50:11), and the board approved these minutes with corrections on June 3, 2020 (June 3, 2020 page). The clerk was not heard at this remote meeting, so the minutes must have been drawn from the recording.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification; source note ends 2018, 244:1)

OBSERVATION A caller asked whether trust money could pay for social workers; the trust's stated purpose is not in the record, and the cost breakdown was given three different ways

RSA 198:20-c, I lets a district create expendable trust funds "for specific purposes" and provides that "Expenditure from such trust funds shall be made only for the purpose for which the trust fund was established" (statute text). Adrian asked whether the district was "using money for positions that was not part of the original description to the voters" (0:26:11). The superintendent answered that the autism program matches what voters were told and that only "$60,000 for, for one social worker at the elementary" is new (0:27:56), but he had described the social workers as serving "the entire school population at each level" (0:14:16). Whether that falls within the purpose voted in the fall of 2019 turns on the warrant article's wording, which this recording does not contain.

The figures also shift: "a 190 zero" contract with "approximately 20,000 of other materials" (0:13:08); then 190,000 plus "$20,000 for supplies and equipment" (0:23:01); then "10,000 for equipment and furniture" with paraprofessional and social-worker lines that do not sum cleanly to $325,000 as transcribed (0:47:52). The board approved $325,000 without a written breakdown on the record; the superintendent promised "a complete accounting" of any unused balance.

Sources: RSA 198:20-c, I-II (2019 codification; source note ends 2012, 219:2, 3)

OBSERVATION The school-year vote passed 5-2 on a motion whose wording is not on the recording, and the June 3 minutes had to be corrected to show it was not unanimous

The chair first doubted a vote was needed (1:31:03); the assistant superintendent said one was required because the board had voted the calendar (1:31:08). Towle then said "Jason's got a motion." (1:31:23) and the chair took a second and a roll call. No member states the motion, so the recording does not show what end date or terms were adopted beyond the half day on June 5 discussed before it. RSA 91-A:2, II requires the minutes to record final decisions and who moved and seconded (statute text).

On June 3 the chair corrected the draft minutes: the vote had been recorded as unanimous although two members voted no, and the last day was the fifth, not the sixth (June 3, 2020 page). The correction shows the minutes were checked; it also shows the draft departed from what happened on two points of this one decision.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification): final decisions; mover and seconder

OBSERVATION With the board meeting remotely, vouchers went unsigned and two signers were chosen without a vote

The assistant superintendent described "the vouchers that you guys would normally sign at our meetings" (2:13:37); the business administrator suggested "maybe we just wait until we've got more normal times" and said "we will actually need to have two board members, I believe, sign" (2:14:30). The chair and Towle agreed to sign in person. RSA 197:23-a, as in force in 2020, lets the treasurer pay out district money "only upon orders of the school board or upon orders of the 2 or more members of the school board empowered by the school board as a whole to authorize payments" (statute text).

No vote empowering particular members is taken at this meeting. A standing delegation may exist in policy or earlier minutes that are not available here; if it does not, a two-member signature would need a board vote. The record also does not show whether bills were paid while the vouchers waited.

Sources: RSA 197:23-a (2017 codification; source note ends 2015, 272:45; next amended 2021, 65:20-22)

POSITIVE Both statutory hearings were held before the board acted, and both were re-run when the broadcast feed came back

RSA 198:20-b, III(a) requires a prior public hearing for unanticipated funds of $5,000 or more, and RSA 198:20-c, II requires that "the school board shall hold a public hearing prior to the expenditure" from an expendable trust fund (statute text). The board heard the $8,877.67 gift and the $325,000 transfer before voting on either, took one telephone comment, and, after counsel reported "the community TV has just joined" (0:19:56), re-opened both hearings "just in case" (0:20:04). The chair stated the reason for the library hearing on the record (0:20:48).

Whether the seven-day newspaper notice each statute requires was published cannot be checked from the recording.

Sources: RSA 198:20-b, III (2019 codification); RSA 198:20-c, II (2019 codification)

POSITIVE The first remote meeting followed the remote-meeting rules the emergency order left in place

Emergency Order #12 (March 23, 2020) waived only RSA 91-A:2, III(b)'s physical quorum and III(c)'s audibility-at-a-location requirement, on condition that the body provide telephone access, notice of how to join, a way to report access problems, and adjournment if the public cannot get in (order text). The rest of RSA 91-A:2, III stayed in force, including III(c)'s duty for a remote member to "identify the persons present in the location from which the member is participating" and III(e): "All votes taken during such a meeting shall be by roll call vote." (statute text).

The record shows each in practice: a telephone line monitored for callers (0:12:04), a public commenter by phone (0:25:39), every participant stating who was with them after counsel's initial doubt (0:09:21), roll calls on every vote once the assistant superintendent and counsel stopped a voice vote (0:02:17, 0:32:12), and the hearings repeated when the CCTV feed returned. Whether notice of the access information was posted cannot be checked here.

Sources: Emergency Order #12 pursuant to Executive Order 2020-04 (Mar. 23, 2020); RSA 91-A:2, III(c), (e) (2019 codification)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page