Participants
Names follow the agenda masthead and the packet documents; there are no minutes for this meeting. Where the dialogue file renders a name differently, the row says so. Three members' voices (Miles, Skillen, Gallagher) are not separated by the diarizer and are listed as unplaced.
| Name | Role | Participation |
| Frank Sprague | Vice chair; presides to 0:10:28 | Calls the meeting to order (0:00:02) and asks Ben Nester to call the roll (0:00:29); takes the agenda and minutes "item by item" rather than as a consent agenda (0:01:06); proposes tabling the August 16 minutes (0:03:15) and rewording their Facebook-page entry (0:05:34); takes citizens' comments and hands the gavel to the chair (0:10:28, "turn the meeting over to heaven" in the transcript). Asks Pratt to "Get us a student rep for the board" and about the eight-period day (0:39:04). Rendered Greg Sprague in the roll. |
| Heather Whitney | Chair; presides from 0:10:37 | Takes part in the minutes discussion (0:04:32); opens the superintendent's report by telephone (0:10:37); introduces Pratt (0:13:33) and Nester (0:46:58); asks about next year's pouch costs and the dropout rate (0:39:26, 0:40:21), middle-school alignment and a Yondr grant for the middle school (0:41:06, 0:41:55), and Chromebooks (0:46:06); asks Nester to paraphrase the board's written questions for the public (0:48:34). |
| Arlene Hawkins | Member (also SAU 6 board chair) | Asks whether the chair wants a consent-agenda motion (0:01:02); moves the August 9 minutes (0:01:50); raises corrections to the August 16 minutes, including that a handbook motion's amendments "are never identified" (0:03:22), and agrees to send them to Chelsea (0:06:19). The roll at 0:00:36 carries her here; the vice chair's "seconded by Alain" at 0:01:22 is most likely her name. |
| Candace Crawford | Member | Reports unsolicited community approval of the phone policy (0:37:25); suggests offering the Yondr experience to Plymouth or Keene teacher-education programs as a case study (0:44:39). Rendered is Crawford in the roll. Submitted written questions for Nester (packet). |
| Bonnie Miles | Member | Answers the roll (Bonnie Myles here, 0:00:36). Her voice is not otherwise separated by the diarizer; she is one of three members whose turns are listed below as unplaced. |
| Whitney Skillen | Member | Answers the roll (rendered "with me still here", 0:00:36). Not otherwise separated by the diarizer. |
| Jennifer Gallagher | Member | Her name is called at 0:00:36; no answer is audible, and no turn on the recording is attributed to her. Attendance unconfirmed. |
| Unidentified members (Miles, Skillen or Gallagher) | Members, not separable | Move the agenda (0:01:18); say the phones had changed the lunchroom and ask whether any classes were dropped (0:37:49, 0:38:12); recall teaching "20 years ago" (0:42:52); propose contacting WMUR (0:43:27) and an NHSBA white paper on the Yondr rollout (0:43:58). The dialogue file does not name these voices and this page does not either. |
| Michael Tempesta | Superintendent, SAU 6 (by telephone) | Joins by phone after connection trouble (0:11:26); thanks the administrative team for the school opening and says "We've done an amazing job on hiring"; apologizes that he cannot attend in person (0:12:14); credits the principals' hiring (0:12:39). |
| Chris Pratt | Principal, Stevens High School | Answers the board's written questions (0:13:55 to 0:36:50): ASL enrollment, free and reduced lunch outreach, the Yondr pouches, the dropout rate, building heat, staffing, scheduling and an eight-period day; adds IXL (0:45:06, Excel in the transcript) and Chromebooks (0:46:24). |
| Ben Nester | Director of Special Education, SAU 6 | Calls the roll (0:00:36); reports the alternative program ("the academy") operational and answers the written questions about the new charter school (0:47:09 to 0:52:15). The recording ends during his report. Rendered Mr. Nestor. |
| Andy (surname not spoken) | Citizens' comments; chair of the SRVRTC visioning committee | Updates the board on the Southern Regional Education Board (SREB) study of the tech center (0:06:32 to 0:09:52). The September 20 minutes name the visioning committee chair "Mr. Lafriene"; the 2/8/23 minutes print "Lafreniere". Neither spelling is confirmed on this recording, so the page gives only the first name. |
Agenda
Items and wording from the posted agenda (created on Drive August 31, 2023); dispositions from the recording only, since there are no minutes. Items after IV.2 fall beyond the end of the recording.
| Taken up | Item | Agenda text / disposition |
| 0:00:02 | I. Call to order, pledge | Called to order by Vice Chair Sprague. |
| 0:00:29 | II. General business: roll, consent agenda | Agenda: "Secretary Roll Call of Attendance of Board Members"; "Consent Agenda 1. Amendments and Final Approval of board agenda 2. Minutes Approval- 8.9.23 & 8.16.23". Nester reads the roll. Sprague says "We'll just do item by item" (0:01:06). Agenda approved on a voice vote; mover unidentified, second credited to Alain (0:01:22). August 9 minutes: Hawkins moves, approved by voice vote (0:01:50; seconder not named). August 16 minutes tabled after Hawkins raises corrections (0:03:15). |
| 0:06:20 | II. Citizens' comments, non-agenda items | One speaker, Andy, on the SREB tech-center study. Sprague asks for other speakers and closes the period at 0:10:28. |
| 0:10:37 | III. Superintendent report | By telephone; school opening and hiring. |
| 0:13:33 | IV.1 Stevens High School Update | Agenda: "Stevens High School Update Mr. Pratt, SHS Principal". Pratt works through the written questions in the packet document Questions for C. Pratt CSB Meeting 9.6.23.pdf. No action. |
| 0:46:58 | IV.2 Alternative Program Update | Agenda: "Alternative Program Update Mr. Nester, Director of Special Education". Nester answers the questions in Questions for B. Nester CSB Meeting 9.6.23.pdf. The recording ends mid-sentence at 0:52:47. |
| Not recorded | IV.3 Optimizing Board Effectiveness | Agenda: "Optimizing Board Effectiveness and Collaboration/Communication with Administrative Team (See Exhibits A-E) (Discussion) led by Chair H. Whitney Review of School Board Retreat Goals Exhibit F". No record of what was said. |
| Not recorded | IV.4 Volunteers for Collective Bargaining Units | Agenda: maintenance and custodial employees "(mid- September)" and secretaries. No record. |
| Not recorded | IV.5 School Board Sub-Committees | Agenda: "Reports by subcommittee chairs if available". No record. |
| Not recorded | IV.6 Athletic fields license | Agenda: "Non-Exclusive License Agreement With City of Claremont for Use of Athletic Fields Introduction presentation by Mr. Tempesta, Superintendent (Exhibit H)". No record. |
| Not recorded | IV.7 Nonpublic session | Agenda: "Non-Public Session, RSA 91-A:3, II (c)" (reputation of a person other than a board member). No record of the motion, the roll-call vote, the session or any sealing vote. See flag 1. |
| Not recorded | V. Other business; VI. Future dates; adjournment | The agenda's future dates include the 9/20 budget-calendar meeting, a September 7 listening session with Fred Bramante, an NHSBA-facilitated board self-evaluation on 10/11, the budget hearing 1/3/24, ratification 1/17/24 and the deliberative session 2/7/24. No record of the discussion. |
| Not on agenda | Policy BEDH, second reading (packet Exhibit G) | The packet holds Exhibit G- BEDH Public Comment and Participation -Second Read.pdf, but the agenda text names Exhibits A-F and H and no BEDH item. The district's adopted policy dates its "Second reading/adopted: September 6, 2023". No vote is on the recording. See flag 2. |
Discussion timeline
Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/15286 SchoolBoard090623.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.
| Time | Topic | What was said | Flags |
| 0:00:29 | Roll call | Sprague: "Mr. Nestor, could you roll call attendance for us, please?" The roll as transcribed: "Heather Whitney, Greg Sprague here." / "And Bonnie Myles here with me still here. Jennifer Gallagher and is Crawford here? Arlene Hawkins here." | |
| 0:01:06 | Agenda and August 9 minutes | Hawkins asks if the chair wants a consent-agenda motion; Sprague: "No, I'm looking for a motion just on old school tonight. We'll just do item by item." Agenda approved (0:01:22); August 9 minutes approved on Hawkins's motion (0:01:50). | |
| 0:02:05 | August 16 minutes tabled | Hawkins says a handbook bullet "was not completed" and that "Jen Gallagher makes a motion to approve the handbooks with the amendments that have been proposed by the school board, but the amendments are never identified." (0:03:22). Sprague, who says he missed that meeting: "let's just table that eight, 16 minutes until we know what that is." (0:03:15). He also rewords the Facebook entry: "no objections have been received regarding the removal" (0:05:34). | OBSERVATION |
| 0:06:32 | Citizens' comment: SREB tech-center study | Andy, visioning committee chair: data collection was set to end August 28; SREB estimates "approximately 70% of the data is collected" (0:08:38); next come three discussion sessions with community stakeholders and labor-market work; "Newport at this time has not indicated their willingness or not to participate in the study." (0:09:52). | |
| 0:10:37 | Superintendent's report (telephone) | After several minutes of audio trouble, Tempesta thanks the administrative team for the opening and says "We've done an amazing job on hiring." (0:11:26); notes the heat and hydrating students (0:12:39). No questions. | |
| 0:14:14 | SHS: ASL and free/reduced lunch | "we have, seven sections of American Sign Language, and we have a total enrollment of 76 spots filled out of 80." (0:14:37). Free and reduced lunch forms promoted at house meetings, on the website and Facebook, by e-mail to parents, and at the September 28 open house (0:15:45). | |
| 0:16:52 | SHS: Yondr phone pouches | A Title grant application was not approved; the company then offered the product because Stevens is "the first school in New Hampshire to undertake this" (0:17:12), "a little over $11,000" (0:17:33; the packet says "$11,500 worth of product"). Pratt gives school safety as the main reason (0:18:52, 0:19:30); "Close to 500 kids. We haven't really had any problems." (0:21:29). | OBSERVATION |
| 0:25:39 | SHS: dropout rate, nicotine program | "our numbers went down at least half of what they were over the previous year. And so that's why the state reached out to us and wanted to know if our numbers were reported accurately." A tobacco and nicotine intervention program with the TLC Family Resource Center (0:25:55). | |
| 0:26:59 | SHS: building heat | "The third floor by the windows were 110. The classrooms were 90. And that's not including humidity." Second floor "between 88 and 90" (0:27:18); "I think it's at an unsafe level right now in the building." (0:27:45). | OBSERVATION |
| 0:28:26 | SHS: barriers, eight-period day | Pratt asks the board to support "an eight period scheduled day for the 2425 school year" and names attendance and truancy as "a domino effect directly tied to student dropout" (0:28:46). Proposed shape: "eight periods 45 minutes long", two lunches, advisory (0:35:09); he would recommend students take seven of eight (0:36:01). | |
| 0:29:42 | SHS: staffing | Vacancies remain for "some power educators and some special educators" [paraeducators] and one guidance counselor. Two science positions were filled about a week before school, with River Valley Community College and Odysseyware as the fallback (0:30:33 to 0:31:52). | |
| 0:36:15 | SHS: budget | Budget requirements for a schedule change: "Not as of today. But, you know, we have time to do that." Pratt has had no budget conversations with the superintendent yet (0:36:50). | |
| 0:37:25 | Board comments on the phone policy | Crawford: community members "are delighted at the policy for the phones." Sprague asks for a student representative (0:39:04). Whitney asks about next year's pouch cost; Pratt: "no cost to the taxpayers" for the initial investment, minimal next year (0:40:01). Whitney: "the dropout rate as reported to the state is down 50%." (0:40:21). A member proposes WMUR coverage (0:43:27) and another an NHSBA white paper (0:43:58); Whitney prefers to wait for academic results (0:44:48). | |
| 0:45:06 | SHS: IXL and Chromebooks | Individualized learning plans in IXL (transcribed Excel) for English, math, Spanish and lower-level science, with a weekly ten-minute benchmark (0:45:37). Chromebooks to be fully distributed that day (0:46:24). | |
| 0:47:09 | Alternative program (the academy) | "Program we discussed several weeks back is operational." One student starting this week, roughly seven expected within two weeks; one student returning from an out-of-district placement (0:47:38); Lee Malloy's classroom set up with Alex [Herzog] (0:47:59, Li Li Malloy in the transcript). Whitney asks him to paraphrase the board's questions so the public can follow (0:48:34). | POSITIVE |
| 0:49:41 | Charter school relationship | The charter school caps itself at 20 students for lack of staff, though "licensed for 40 students grades 9 to 12", with 13 enrolled, 12 of them from Stevens (0:50:03). "the only obligation the the district has is to provide special ed services to the students in the charter school ... there is no financial obligation to to fund the school or pay tuition." (0:50:27). An MOU template from the Department of Education ("Department of Bad" in the transcript) will be signed (0:50:46). On duplication: "yes, to some degree, there's there's somewhat of a level of duplication there." (0:51:52). | |
| 0:52:15 | Recording ends | Nester is mid-sentence on assessing the academy "At the end of the first semester" ahead of the "25 budget cycle, in case there are." The file ends at 0:52:47. Items IV.3 to IV.7, other business, future dates and adjournment have no recording. | HIGH |
Items flagged for review
These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one cites the rule it rests on as that rule read on September 6, 2023; check the recording and the primary source before relying on any of them. Severity: HIGH, a likely breach of a binding rule or a missed statutory deadline; MEDIUM, a probable process gap or control weakness; OBSERVATION, notable with no confirmed rule; POSITIVE, practice beyond the legal minimum.
HIGH No minutes exist for this meeting, and the recording stops before most of the agenda, including a nonpublic session
RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes of every meeting, "including nonpublic sessions", with "a brief description of the subject matter discussed and final decisions", the names of movers and seconders, and public inspection "not more than 5 business days after the meeting" (2022 codification, in force on this date). No minutes of September 6, 2023 have been found: the Meeting Minutes share skips from August 16 to September 20, and the September 20 agenda and minutes carry "Minutes Approval- 9.6.23 (Postponed)" with no later approval found. The recording ends at 0:52:47 during item IV.2 of seven. Everything after that point has no public record of any kind: the board-effectiveness discussion, bargaining volunteers, subcommittee reports, the athletic-fields license, the policy action the district dates to this meeting (flag 2), and a nonpublic session noticed under RSA 91-A:3, II(c). For the nonpublic session, RSA 91-A:3, I(b) requires a motion naming the exemption and a roll-call vote in public, and ¶III requires its minutes to be disclosed within 72 hours unless sealed "by recorded vote of 2/3 of the members present taken in public session"; none of those steps can be checked. Severity limb under the project's rule for missing records: the meeting was noticed and packeted, which ordinarily points to MEDIUM, and the September 20 "(Postponed)" note is a mitigation. HIGH is applied because the minutes are not the only gap: the recording is also cut short, so for more than half the agenda neither record exists, the postponement was never followed by approval, and the statutory five days expired more than three years ago.
Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2022 codification; minutes contents, movers and seconders, 5 business days); RSA 91-A:3, I(b), II(c), III (2022 codification; nonpublic motion, roll call, 72-hour disclosure, sealing); agenda, items IV.3 to IX; September 20, 2023 minutes, "Minutes Approval- 9.6.23 (Postponed)"
MEDIUM Policy BEDH is dated as adopted on this date, but the agenda lists no BEDH item, no vote is recorded, and the adopted text differs from the second-read exhibit
The district's policy document BEDH APPROVED Public Comment and Participation 9.6.23 records "First reading: May 17, 2023" and "Second reading/adopted: September 6, 2023". The packet holds the second-read text as Exhibit G (created on Drive August 30, 2023), but the agenda, created the next day, refers to Exhibits A-F and H and has no BEDH item. Nothing about BEDH is on the recording before it ends at 0:52:47, and there are no minutes to show a motion, a seconder, a vote or any amendment. The adopted text is also not the posted text: paragraph 7 of Exhibit G ends with two sentences on remote comment ("When the technology is available the Board will provide the opportunity for citizens to make public comments remotely. The Board cannot and will not assure that in all cases the technology will/can function adequately."), and the adopted policy omits both. If the board amended the policy on the floor, RSA 91-A:2, II required the minutes to record that final decision and who moved and seconded it; no such record exists. BEDH has governed public comment at every Claremont meeting since, so the gap concerns a rule the public relies on. The May 17, 2023 first reading also has no minutes in any share (project notes), so neither reading of this policy is minuted.
Sources: Policy BEDH as adopted (District Policy History block); Exhibit G, BEDH second read (paragraph 7); agenda; RSA 91-A:2, II (2022 codification; final decisions and movers recorded in minutes)
OBSERVATION The board itself found that the August 16 minutes record a handbook approval "with the amendments" without saying what the amendments were
Hawkins pointed out that the draft August 16 minutes record Gallagher's motion "to approve the handbooks with the amendments that have been proposed by the school board, but the amendments are never identified." (0:03:22), and that another handbook bullet "was not completed" (0:02:29). Neither she nor the presiding officer, who said he missed that meeting, could recall the wording, and the minutes were tabled to check the video (0:03:15). RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes to describe "final decisions"; a handbook adopted with unspecified amendments leaves the adopted text undefined. The board caught this before approving the minutes, which is the review working as intended. Whether and how the August 16 minutes were later corrected is outside this page's sources.
Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2022 codification; minutes contents); draft August 16, 2023 minutes in this packet
OBSERVATION A vendor's product grant of about $11,500 was reported to the board, with no board acceptance on the record
Pratt reported that after a Title grant application was refused, Yondr supplied the pouches and equipment because Stevens was the first New Hampshire school to adopt them, "a little over $11,000" (0:17:33); the packet answer gives "$11,500 worth of product". RSA 198:20-b, as amended by 2023, 38:1 (effective July 18, 2023, before this meeting), lets a school board accept and expend unanticipated money from a private source, requires a prior public hearing at $20,000 or more, and below that requires notice in the agenda and minutes and acceptance "in public session of any regular school board meeting." The statute speaks of money; whether it reaches an in-kind gift of product is not settled by its text, so this is not graded as a breach. No acceptance vote appears on the recording, and the meeting has no minutes. Pratt also says the first year came at "no cost to the taxpayers" (0:40:01) while next year's cost is still to be worked into the budget (0:39:34).
Sources: RSA 198:20-b (source note ends 2023, 38:1, eff. July 18, 2023); Questions for C. Pratt, Yondr answer
OBSERVATION The principal described classroom heat he considered unsafe, and the board took no action on the record
Pratt reported measured temperatures of 110 by third-floor windows and 90 in classrooms, 88 to 90 on the second floor, with fans and windows open (0:26:59, 0:27:18), and said "I think it's at an unsafe level right now in the building." (0:27:45). The superintendent also mentioned hydrating students (0:12:39). No board member asked about it before the recording ends. No New Hampshire classroom-temperature standard was verified for this page, so this is an observation only. The October 4 minutes record the Capital Improvement subcommittee discussing room temperatures on the south side of the building and solar film for the windows.
Sources: the recording at the times shown; October 4, 2023 minutes, item V.5(a)
POSITIVE Board members' written questions and the administrators' written answers were posted in the public packet before the meeting
Board members submitted questions to the high school principal and the special education director in advance, and both sets, with the answers, sit in the public packet folder (Questions for C. Pratt CSB Meeting 9.6.23.pdf, Questions for B. Nester CSB Meeting 9.6.23.pdf). The chair then asked Nester to paraphrase the questions aloud "I think it's important that the community here is what said yes" (0:48:34), and Pratt read each question before answering (0:14:14). No statute requires board members' questions to be published; doing so lets the public see what the board asked as well as what it was told. Nothing in either document identifies a student.
Sources: Questions for C. Pratt CSB Meeting 9.6.23; Questions for B. Nester CSB Meeting 9.6.23
Appendix: source files
Official and public sources
Project files
Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.
Dialogue/15286 SchoolBoard090623.mp4.CSV (257 attributed rows; the basis of this page)
Input/Videos/15286 SchoolBoard090623.mp4 (local copy of the recording)
Input/Transcripts/15286 SchoolBoard090623.mp4.json (diarized transcript)
Input/SupportingDocuments/MAP.md, section 204 (video-to-document map)
Laws and rules cited on this page
- State, as codified for the meeting date: RSA 91-A:2, II; RSA 91-A:3, I(b), II(c), III (the 2023, 189:1 amendment took effect October 3, 2023, after this meeting); RSA 198:20-b (as amended by 2023, 38:1, eff. July 18, 2023)
- District policy: Claremont policy BEDH, Public Comment and Participation