Claremont School Board, October 4, 2023

Regular meeting of the Claremont School Board, Chair Heather Whitney presiding, Candace Crawford absent. The board holds a brief nonpublic session under the tuition-contract exemption and seals its minutes for 20 years; drops the scheduled budget-surplus vote; discusses how the FY2025 budget will be built and whether budget subcommittee meetings should be televised; votes one by one on the NHSBA's proposed resolutions; adopts policy GBE on second reading; and hears the Capital Improvement subcommittee's Stevens High School findings. Built from the Cablecast recording's attributed dialogue, the agenda and packet, and the minutes. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (seven members)
Date
Wednesday, October 4, 2023
Start time
Agenda 6:30 p.m.; the minutes record "Meeting called to order by Chair Heather Whitney at 6:30PM" and give no times for the nonpublic session or adjournment. The recording opens on the call to order at 0:00:03, passes over the nonpublic session between 0:03:02 and 0:03:24, and ends on adjournment by consensus at 1:25:50.
Location
Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center, Claremont (agenda)
Board composition
Present (minutes and the roll at 0:00:36): Heather Whitney (chair), Frank Sprague (vice chair), Bonnie Miles, Whitney Skillen, Jennifer Gallagher, Arlene Hawkins. Absent (minutes): Candace Crawford, whose name is called without an answer. No student board member yet; the district clerk seat was vacant, and Ben Nester calls the roll.
Recording
Cablecast: Claremont School Board 10/4/23 (observed extent 1:26:05 from the last row of the dialogue file; the Cablecast API refuses requests from the build environment, so the run time was not confirmed). Complete from call to order to adjournment, except the nonpublic session.
Minutes
15. CSB Meeting Minutes 10.4.23 (Meeting Minutes share, created October 17, 2023). Draft copies draft CSB Meeting Minutes 10.4.23.docx (2).pdf and draft CSB Meeting Minutes 10.4.23.docx.pdf were both created on Drive Monday, October 16, 2023 (see flag 2). Submitted by Chelsea Weatherford.

Participants

Names follow the agenda masthead and the minutes. Where the dialogue file renders or attributes a name differently, the row says so.
NameRoleParticipation
Heather WhitneyChairPresides; announces the agenda changes and the expanded nonpublic session (0:00:48); corrects the September 20 minutes on the GBE motion (0:01:44); moves to leave nonpublic (0:03:24); proposes CCTV filming of budget subcommittee meetings (0:17:16); moves the GBE second reading and adoption (0:55:04); opposes resolutions 16 and 19 (minutes); asks for a staff protocol against verbal abuse by parents (1:00:17); adjourns by consensus (1:25:50). Rendered Heather. Wendy. in a roll call.
Frank SpragueVice chair; NHSBA delegateMoves the nonpublic session (0:02:36); describes the budget subcommittee model (0:07:47) and past double entries (0:10:11); leads the NHSBA resolutions and moves on each (0:21:04 to 0:44:27); proposes a CHINS resolution for next year (0:58:23); asks for a pre-K model and assessment (1:06:50). Rendered Greg in a roll call.
Whitney SkillenMember; Policy subcommittee chairAsks for principals' budget summaries (0:13:56) and for every member to have the information before budget votes (0:18:44); reports the Capital Improvement tour of Stevens (0:45:07 to 0:54:24); seconds resolutions 15, 16, 17 and 19 and the GBE adoption (minutes). Rendered Skilling.
Arlene HawkinsMember (also SAU 6 board chair)Recalls budget questions she asked as a citizen that "were not answered" (0:20:05); moves to leave nonpublic (minutes; on tape the chair moves, 0:03:24); seconds resolutions 8, 10, 12 and 14 (minutes); asks about pre-K assessment (1:12:23), summer-program results (1:16:06) and a sooner date for minimum-standards input (1:17:12).
Jennifer GallagherMember; ad hoc disruptive behaviors and curriculum chairAnswers Present (0:00:39); moves the 20-year seal (minutes); seconds resolutions 9, 11 and 13 (minutes; "Seconded by Jen" at 0:34:03); reports the disruptive-behaviors committee's second meeting and asks what the board wants from it (0:57:26); the curriculum committee "didn't meet yet" (1:01:20).
Bonnie MilesMember; Capital Improvement chairAnswers the roll calls (0:00:39, 0:02:53). Missed the Stevens tour (Skillen, 0:45:07). No other turn is attributed to her.
Candace CrawfordMemberAbsent (minutes).
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Reports the fields agreement sent to counsel Matt Upton and the school law conference (0:04:26); will share the conference handouts (0:05:57); supports principals presenting their budgets (0:14:17).
Mary HenryBusiness AdministratorLeads item 3 on the budget process (0:06:49 to 0:20:39); offers budget books with a summary of changes (0:19:28).
Ben NesterDirector of Special EducationCalls the roll; asks for a deadline on the disruptive-behaviors committee so recommendations reach the budget (1:01:27); describes last year's pre-K analysis (1:12:41 to 1:13:37).
Mike KoskiAssistant SuperintendentSummer-program results will compare spring and fall i-Ready scores (1:16:24, 1:16:46).
Citizens' commentsNone"Seeing no citizens comments" (0:02:18).

Agenda

Items and wording from the posted agenda; dispositions from the recording and the minutes. Where the minutes and the dialogue file disagree on a seconder, the minutes are followed and the footer explains.
Taken upItemAgenda text / disposition
0:00:03I. Call to order, pledgeChair Whitney, 6:30 p.m. (minutes).
0:00:36II. Roll callSix present; Crawford absent.
0:00:48II. Consent agendaAgenda: "1. Amendments and Final Approval of board agenda 2. Minutes Approval- 9.20.23". Items IV.1 (Claremont Middle School update; the principal could not attend) and IV.2 (budget surplus allocation; "we're continuing to gather information") removed, and the nonpublic session expanded to "rationales for item three and item six". September 20 minutes approved with the chair's correction (0:01:44). Adopted without objection (0:02:18).
0:02:18II. Citizens' commentsNone.
0:02:36III. Nonpublic session, RSA 91-A:3, II (k)Sprague moves "under RSA 91-A colon 322 K" [91-A:3, II(k)], roll call six Yes (0:02:53). Return on the chair's motion, Sprague seconding on tape (minutes: Hawkins moved, Sprague seconded), roll call six Yes (0:03:36). Seal for "20 minutes" on tape, 20 years in the minutes; moved by Gallagher, seconded by Whitney (minutes); roll call (0:04:09). See flag 1.
0:04:19IV. Superintendent reportCity MOU and the school law conference.
RemovedIV.1 Claremont Middle School Update; IV.2 Budget Surplus Allocation (Vote)Removed at the start of the meeting. See flag 3.
0:06:34IV.3 FY 24-25 Budget Planning, Execution, Calendar, DeadlinesAgenda: "(Vote or Consensus) Discussion led by , Business Administrator Mary Henry Goal: Improving transparency and budgeting process". Consensus to keep the three-member subcommittee (Crawford, Sprague, Whitney) with all information shared with the full board, and to look into televising its meetings. No vote.
0:21:04IV.4 NHSBA Proposed Resolutions (Exhibit A)One motion per resolution, all by Sprague, voice votes. Per the minutes: 8 not supported (2nd Hawkins); 9 supported (2nd Gallagher); 10 not supported (2nd Hawkins); 11 supported (2nd Gallagher); 12 supported (2nd Hawkins); 13 supported (2nd Gallagher); 14 supported (2nd Hawkins); 15 supported (2nd Skillen); 16 supported, Whitney opposed (2nd Skillen); 17 alternative language supported (2nd Skillen); 18 no vote needed; 19 supported, Whitney opposed (2nd Skillen). On tape the chair is heard opposing 16 (0:39:36), an unidentified voice says Opposed. on 19 (0:44:26), and the result on 17 is transcribed "I without Jen passes." (0:41:22).
0:44:50IV.5 School Board Sub-CommitteesCapital Improvement (Skillen reporting); Budget: nothing to add; Policy: GBE second read and adoption, Whitney moves, Skillen seconds (minutes), voice vote, "So a policy GBE is adopted." (0:55:58); SRVRTC visioning: not met; ad hoc disruptive behaviors (Gallagher, Nester); curriculum: not met.
1:06:42V. Other businessSprague on pre-K; Hawkins on the summer program and the postponed listening session.
1:24:08VI. Future dates; adjournmentBoard retreat October 11 at the Teal Lantern facilitated by NHSBA's Barrett Christina (Christina Bear in the transcript); October 18 public hearing on the $6,000 Schwab trust donation (swab trust); November presentations on the summer program and the preschool. Adjourned by consensus (1:25:50); minutes: "No objections from any board member to adjourn the meeting."

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/15336 SchoolBoard100423.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:48Agenda changesWhitney: "We're going to be removing item one. Mr. Romeo is unable to be present this evening. And item two, we're continuing to gather information on that topic. Also, we're adding an additional item in our nonpublic. So the nonpublic will include rationales for item three and item six or rationale three and six."OBSERVATION
0:02:36Nonpublic and 20-year seal"Frank. Make a motion to move into nonpublic under RSA 91-A colon 322 K." Chair: "Item three under rationale three and six." (0:02:46). The session is not recorded; the tape resumes on the motion to return at 0:03:24. "And anybody like to make a motion to seal the minutes." (0:03:48) / "I'll make. Or are for 20 minutes." (0:03:52) [20 years, per the minutes]. Roll call (0:04:09).MEDIUM
0:04:26Superintendent's reportThe fields document went to counsel Matt Upton "So that should be completed shortly"; the school law conference covered "tuition agreements, charter school, obligations, transportation obligations" and leasing versus owning equipment (0:05:03). Whitney asks for a bulleted summary; Tempesta will share his handouts (0:05:57).
0:06:49How to build the FY2025 budgetHenry asks whether the board wants a committee or the full board. Sprague: the subcommittee model "has worked to a degree", but "it's perceived been perceived in the last year or two that that group is operating outside of, outside of the school board" (0:08:32); keep the committee "but have all the information that committee is getting. Have everybody get all that information." (0:09:00). His first year he and two others "found about $300,000 in double entries that had persisted" (0:10:11).
0:13:56What members want from the processSkillen asks for principals' summary presentations; members voting on line items without information: "it seems like only a few of the board members have the information necessary to make an informed vote, and some don't." (0:18:44). Hawkins: as a citizen "I felt that the questions were not answered" (0:20:05). Henry offers budget books with a summary of changes on the top page (0:19:28).
0:17:16Televising budget subcommittee meetingsWhitney asks to have the deep-dive subcommittee meetings "videotaped or filmed by CCTV so that the public can witness kind of what's going on." Sprague: "Technically, their public." Whitney: "The public cannot participate in those meetings. They can only observe. But just for transparency" (0:17:35). Sprague has no objection (0:17:50).POSITIVE
0:21:04NHSBA resolutions, one by oneSprague: NHSBA is "a lobbying group" and "past practice in the past is I've kind of just kind of gone along with what the recommendation has been" (0:21:35); now "have an up or down vote" on each (0:22:03). The continuing resolutions were not in the packet (0:23:45). Topics: curriculum challenges (8), library selection (9), food-service estimates in the default budget (10), teacher credentialing (11), parent conduct (12), election postponement in bad weather (13), building aid (14), pre-K adequacy aid (15), sustainability funding, where Sprague notes "It's very hard to teach in a room that's 96 degrees." (0:38:25) and the chair opposes as "too narrow" (16), Medicaid direct certification (17), universal school meals (19). Sprague: "I've got my marching orders for for Concord." (0:44:27).POSITIVE
0:45:07Capital Improvement: Stevens tourSkillen: two more roof sections to replace "over the next few years"; south-side classrooms "do get substantially warmer", and one teacher's paper window block made her room "significantly cooler" (0:45:48); windows left open overnight in winter (0:49:04); failed floor tiles over improperly installed subfloor, with "no recourse for the original installer" (0:52:10); the building management system "broke 3 or 4 years ago and has never been properly replaced or repaired" (0:52:54).OBSERVATION
0:54:53Policy GBE adoptedWhitney: "there were no suggested changes. So what you're seeing in your packet is the same" as on September 20; she moves the second reading and adoption (0:55:04); voice vote (0:55:38); "So a policy GBE is adopted." (0:55:58).
0:56:21Alternative program locationSprague reminds the administration of a January deadline for a plan to house the alternative program somewhere other than the tech center; Whitney: an abbreviated update next meeting (0:56:45).
0:57:26Disruptive behaviors committeeGallagher asks the board's aims. Whitney: "a unification of, discipline strategies and consequences" across schools (0:58:02) and a protocol so staff need not "sit there and and and be verbally abused" by parents (1:00:17). Sprague proposes an NHSBA resolution "asking the legislation to revisit chins petitions" (0:58:50). Nester asks for a time frame so any budget impact surfaces before the budget "goes to the boaters" [voters] (1:01:27).
1:06:50Pre-K: model and evidenceSprague cites Oklahoma's program: without a vetted approach and progress monitoring "really what you're running is, is a is daycare" (1:07:37); last year's data was dismissed as flawed and "we were never really presented with any other data" (1:08:14); "what is our philosophical approach to pre-K? ... How are we measuring success?" (1:08:47). Nester: last year's analysis of about 50 slides compared attenders and non-attenders on i-Ready and "didn't really show what we wanted it to show" (1:13:01); "we're not a research facility" (1:13:18). A presentation is set for November.
1:16:06Summer program resultsHawkins: last year "there was a problem with the data collection". Koski: this year spring scores will be compared with fall i-Ready scores, testing window to the end of October (1:16:29, 1:16:46).
1:17:12Minimum-standards inputHawkins: "I also have been told that January is probably too late" (1:17:38); Fred Bramante would come to Claremont informally. The superintendent will check availability and find the presenter another district used (1:23:58).

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one cites the rule it rests on as that rule read on October 4, 2023, the day after 2023, 188:1 and 189:1 amended RSA 91-A:2 and 91-A:3; check the recording and the primary source before relying on any of them. Severity: HIGH, a likely breach of a binding rule or a missed statutory deadline; MEDIUM, a probable process gap or control weakness; OBSERVATION, notable with no confirmed rule; POSITIVE, practice beyond the legal minimum. This page carries no HIGH flag.

MEDIUM Tuition-contract nonpublic minutes were sealed for 20 years with no statutory finding, though the exemption itself requires those minutes to be published before any contract is approved

The motion named the exemption, RSA 91-A:3, II(k) (0:02:36, transcribed "91-A colon 322 K"), and the roll calls to enter and leave were taken, which satisfies ¶I(b). Three points remain. First, the seal: ¶III permits withholding only "by recorded vote of 2/3 of the members present taken in public session" that determines divulgence "likely would affect adversely the reputation of any person other than a member of the public body itself, or render the proposed action ineffective, or pertain to terrorism". The vote was unanimous among the six present, but no finding was stated on tape (0:03:48 to 0:04:09) and the minutes record only "a motion to seal the meeting minutes for 20 years". Second, II(k) carries its own disclosure rule: a negotiated tuition contract "shall be made public prior to its consideration for approval by a school district, together with minutes of all meetings held in nonpublic session". A 20-year seal on minutes the statute will require to be released before any contract is approved should at least say how the two fit. Third, ¶IV, in force from the day before this meeting, requires sealed minutes to be reviewed "no more than 10 years" after the vote to withhold them; a 20-year term does not reflect it. The chair's description of the session's scope, "rationales for item three and item six", matches no lettered exemption and no agenda item 6, and is left unexplained in the minutes. Neighbouring pages record the same pattern: a ten-year seal without a finding on September 20.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, I(b), II(k), III, IV (source note ends 2023, 189:1, eff. Oct. 3, 2023); minutes, item III; September 20, 2023 page, flag 2

MEDIUM The draft minutes first appear on the district's Drive on the seventh business day after the meeting

RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes to be "open to public inspection not more than 5 business days after the meeting", a business day being "8 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Monday through Friday, excluding national and state holidays". Counting from Thursday, October 5 and excluding Columbus Day (October 9, a federal holiday), the fifth business day ended at 5 p.m. on Thursday, October 12. The earliest copy of these minutes on the public Drive, draft CSB Meeting Minutes 10.4.23.docx.pdf, was created Monday, October 16, 2023 at 18:15 UTC, the seventh business day (the eighth if Columbus Day is counted); its file modification stamp is the same day, so it does not show an earlier version. The approved copy reached the Meeting Minutes share on October 17. Drive dates show when the public could see a document online, not whether a paper copy was available at the SAU office, which is why this is graded MEDIUM. For comparison, the September 20 draft appeared on the third business day.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2023 codification; source note ends 2023, 188:1, eff. Oct. 3, 2023); draft minutes copy (created October 16, 2023); draft minutes copy in this packet (created October 16, 2023)

OBSERVATION The FY2023 budget-surplus vote was pulled because the information was still being gathered

The agenda scheduled "Budget Surplus Allocation (Vote)", and the September 20 future-dates list had set "Vote on Budget Surplus ( if any)" for this meeting. The chair removed it: "we're continuing to gather information on that topic" (0:00:48). Two weeks earlier the business administrator had put the surplus at a little over $400,000 with the year not yet closed (September 20 page, flag 3). No rule sets a date for this vote; the observation is that by early October the board still had no closed FY2023 figure to act on.

Sources: agenda, item IV.2; September 20, 2023 minutes, future dates

OBSERVATION Stevens High School's building management system has been broken for three or four years, and its south classrooms overheat

Reporting the subcommittee's tour with maintenance director Steve Holt, Skillen said the building management system "broke 3 or 4 years ago and has never been properly replaced or repaired", forcing manual monitoring that "introduces a lot more chance for error" (0:52:54); that south-facing classrooms run hot enough that one teacher's paper window covering made a marked difference (0:45:29, 0:45:48); and that two roof sections and failed floors over improperly installed subfloor await replacement (0:45:29, 0:52:10). These match the principal's September 6 report of 90-degree classrooms. No rule was verified that the conditions breach; they are recorded as a capital-planning matter for the FY2025 budget the board was beginning that night.

Sources: minutes, item V.5(a); September 6, 2023 page, flag 5

POSITIVE The board voted openly on each NHSBA resolution, and agreed to look into televising its budget subcommittee

Instead of the delegate following NHSBA's recommendations, which Sprague said had been past practice (0:21:35), the board debated twelve proposed resolutions in public session and took eleven separate votes (one needed none), recorded with movers and seconders in the minutes, so residents can see how their delegate was instructed. In the same meeting the chair proposed having CCTV film the budget subcommittee's working sessions "just for transparency" (0:17:35), with no objection. Neither step is required by law.

Sources: Exhibit A, 2023 Proposed Resolutions (NHSBA); minutes, items V.3 and V.4

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page