Claremont School Board, December 6, 2023

A short regular meeting chaired by Vice Chair Frank Sprague in Chair Heather Whitney's absence: a nonpublic session on a pupil-tuition contract with Croydon, sealed for six months; a vote to open negotiations to become Croydon's anchor school; adoption of the Stevens High School program of studies in block and period versions; and subcommittee reports, chiefly on the FY2025 budget review. Built from the Cablecast recording's attributed dialogue, the agenda and the draft and approved minutes. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (seven members)
Date
Wednesday, December 6, 2023
Start time
Agenda: 6:30 p.m. Minutes: discussion items reached 6:35 p.m., other business 7:20 p.m., adjournment 7:22 p.m.; the minutes give no times for entering or leaving the nonpublic session. The chair calls the meeting to order at 0:00:04; the nonpublic session falls between 0:02:53 and 0:03:16 of the recording. A 6:30 to 7:22 p.m. meeting is about 52 minutes against about 35 minutes of recording, so roughly 17 minutes (the nonpublic session) are not on the tape.
Location
Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center, Claremont (agenda and minutes masthead)
Board composition
Seven members: Heather Whitney (chair), Frank Sprague (vice chair), Bonnie Miles, Whitney Skillen, Jennifer Gallagher, Arlene Hawkins, Candace Crawford. Six present; Whitney absent (minutes), so Sprague presides. Clerk Noelle Kronberg. Student members Nicole Bouchard and Kylee Plummer absent (minutes).
Recording
Cablecast: School Board Meeting 12/6/23 (observed extent 0:35:06 from the last row of the dialogue file; the Cablecast API refuses requests from this environment, so no run time was read from it). A separate recording, show 15452, holds the Finance Committee session held earlier the same day.
Minutes
20. Approved CSB minutes 12.6.23.pdf (created on Drive January 2, 2024); draft: CSB draft minutes 12.6.23 (1) (2).pdf, in the 12/20/23 packet folder (created on Drive December 19, 2023). The two texts are the same apart from the DRAFT/approved heading. Submitted by clerk Noelle Kronberg.

Participants

Names and attendance follow the agenda masthead and the minutes. Where the dialogue file's speaker label differs from the minutes, the row says so.
NameRoleParticipation
Frank SpragueVice Chair; presidingCalls the meeting to order (0:00:04) and runs the agenda. Moves entry into nonpublic session (0:02:03) and the return to public session (0:03:16); seconds the six-month seal. Describes himself as chair of the Finance Committee and asks members to bring budget questions to him first (0:12:33). Asks how auditors' references to missing required policies reach the policy committee (0:27:11).
Heather WhitneyChairAbsent (minutes). Her name is read at each roll call with no answer from her.
Bonnie MilesMember; Capital Improvement chairRoll answers; reports that the Capital Improvement Committee has not met recently (0:10:26).
Whitney SkillenMember; Policy chairSeconds the return to public session (minutes; the chair says "Second by Whitney" at 0:03:16). Moves adoption of both program-of-studies versions (0:09:33). Presents the policy committee's audit of the policy manual (0:20:59). The dialogue file also gives her the Croydon motion at 0:05:05, which the minutes attribute to Jennifer Gallagher (see next row).
Jennifer GallagherMember; Curriculum and Ad Hoc Disruptive Behaviors chairAnswers the roll Present. Per the minutes, seconds entry into nonpublic session, moves to proceed with Croydon negotiations, seconds the program of studies and moves adjournment. The dialogue file labels the Croydon motion (0:05:05) Whitney Skillen and the adjournment motion (0:34:56) Unidentified; this page follows the minutes. Reports for the disruptive-behaviors committee (0:30:23). The curriculum report at 0:29:10 is labeled Unidentified and is left so.
Arlene HawkinsMemberAsks that the November 15 minutes record a one-year seal motion for their first nonpublic session (0:01:05). Seconds the Croydon motion (minutes; 0:05:18). Asks to know what a staff reduction would mean for teachers and students before she votes (0:17:49); explains the NHSBA priority, recommended and optional policy categories (0:26:18).
Candace CrawfordMember; Finance CommitteeMoves the six-month seal (0:03:35). Gives the Finance Committee report (0:10:40), describing the administrator interviews and warning that last year's figures carry "a lot of anomalies" (0:18:50).
Noelle KronbergSchool Board ClerkReads the four roll calls (0:00:36, 0:02:35, 0:03:25, 0:03:44); submitted the minutes.
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Explains Croydon's request for an anchor school (0:03:57); answers Skillen on building administrators' part in budget building (0:13:48); describes the disruptive-behaviors committee's next step (0:32:36).
Mary HenryBusiness Administrator, SAU 6Says the budget will "take another year to really get it" in order (0:20:40); dates the last audit "2021 I think or 2020" (0:27:25); says she has policies "written that I need to pass along to the committee" (0:28:34).
Mimi RhinesSchool counselor, Stevens High SchoolPresents the 2024–25 program of studies (0:05:57).
Dr. Michael HerringtonAssistant Principal, Stevens High School (agenda)Welcomed by the chair (0:05:31, transcribed "Doctor Michael Harrington"); no speech is attributed to him.
Nicole Bouchard, Kylee PlummerStudent board membersAbsent (minutes).
UnidentifiedVarious32 rows, mostly short responses, ayes and seconds; also the curriculum report at 0:29:10.

Agenda

Items follow the posted agenda (CSB Agenda 12.6.23.docx (1).pdf); dispositions follow the approved minutes and the recording.
Taken upItemAgenda text / disposition
0:00:04I. Call to order, PledgeScheduled 6:30 p.m.
0:00:36II. Roll callMinutes: present Sprague, Miles, Skillen, Gallagher, Hawkins, Crawford; absent Whitney.
0:00:49Consent agenda: agenda approval; minutes of 11.15.23Hawkins asks that page 2, II of the November 15 minutes read "motion to seal for one year. Made by Frank Sprague, seconded by Heather Whitney. And the roll call vote was unanimous" (0:01:05). The minutes record the correction and "No discussion, unanimously approved". On the recording the chair asks for objection and takes a voice vote (0:01:37).
0:01:47Citizens' comments; student board member reportThe chair calls for comments (0:01:47) and says "Seeing none" (0:01:52). Minutes: comments "None"; student members absent.
0:02:03III.1 Non-Public SessionAgenda text: "Non-Public Session RSA91-A:,II (k) Consideration of a school board of entering into a student or pupil contract authorized by RSA 194 or RSA 195-A". Minutes: Sprague moved entry "under RSA91-A:II(k)", Gallagher seconded, roll call all present yes; Sprague moved to come out, Skillen seconded, roll call all yes; Crawford moved to seal the nonpublic minutes for six months, Sprague seconded, roll call all present yes. See flag 1 and flag 2.
0:03:57III.2 Croydon Tuition Agreement (Discussion/Vote)Tempesta explains the anchor-school request. Minutes: "Jennifer Gallagher makes motion to proceed with negotiations to accept becoming Croydon's anchor school, Arlene Hawkins seconded; no further discussion; unanimously approved". Chair on tape: "Opposed? Passes unanimously" (0:05:25).
0:05:31III.3 SHS Program of Studies 2024, Schedule and Preliminary Staffing RequestRhines presents block and period versions; the only new courses are three drama courses. Minutes: Skillen moved to accept both versions, Gallagher seconded, unanimously approved (0:09:33). No staffing request is presented on the recording or recorded in the minutes.
0:10:12III.4 School Board Sub-Committees(a) Capital Improvement: no meeting (0:10:26). (b) Finance: report by Crawford (0:10:40). (c) Policy: the listed presentation "Operational Guide and Delegation of Policy Audits" is deferred to January; Skillen gives an activity update instead (0:20:59). (d) Curriculum: draft in January (0:29:10). (e) SRVRTC Visioning: not met; SREB report expected in March (0:29:37). (f) Ad Hoc Disruptive Behaviors: report by Gallagher (0:30:23). No votes.
0:34:03V. Other Business; VI. Future DatesHawkins adds the SAU 6 meeting of December 7 at 6:00 p.m. (minutes list it first). Minutes: other business "none".
0:34:53IX. AdjournmentMinutes: Gallagher moved, Skillen seconded, unanimously approved; 7:22 p.m.

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/15453 SchoolBoard120623.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:36Roll callThe clerk reads "Heather. Whitney." and a Here. follows that the dialogue file labels Sprague; the minutes record Whitney absent, so the answer is his, with his own name lost in the transcript. Gallagher answers Present.
0:01:05Correction to the November 15 minutesHawkins: "There was a motion to seal when we came out of that meeting. So I believe it should read motion to seal for one year. Made by Frank Sprague, seconded by Heather Whitney. And the roll call vote was unanimous." Accepted without objection.POSITIVE
0:02:03Motion to enter nonpublic sessionSprague: "I would like to make a motion to go into nonpublic session under RSA 91 at a only two. A federation of the school board of entering into a student or pupil contract authorized by RSA 194 for our say 195 to have a." [RSA 91-A:3, II(k); the transcript garbles both the citation and the statutory wording]. Roll call: all present yes (0:02:35 to 0:02:40).OBSERVATION
0:02:55Remarks at the breakLabeled Skillen: "I know we need the time we entered." and "Who made the motion? Who seconded it? Not members were present. Who else was present?" The remarks fall at the point where the nonpublic session is cut from the recording.OBSERVATION
0:03:16Return to public session; six-month sealSprague moves to come out, "Second by Whitney" (Skillen). Crawford: "I'd like to make a motion to seal the minutes for six months of the non public meeting." (0:03:35); Sprague seconds; roll call all yes (0:03:44). No reason for the seal is stated.MEDIUM
0:03:57Croydon anchor schoolTempesta: the [Croydon] superintendent, school board members and business managers "put forth a proposal. They're looking for an anchor school", which "even though it's not formally defined" is a school where a district can ensure [FAPE] "all the way up to age 22"; "Croydon has grades up to only fourth grade." Motion "that we proceed with negotiations for accepting Corden's proposal to become their anchor district" (0:05:05; [Croydon's]); carried unanimously (0:05:25).MEDIUM
0:05:57Program of studies 2024–25Rhines: program studies had not been updated "the last couple of years just due to staff turnover"; block and period versions "just because there are talks of us changing our scheduling"; "The only new ones in this are the three drama ones." Sprague recalls a year when "50 one eighth graders signed up" for math skills (0:07:28). Adopted unanimously (0:09:33).
0:10:40Finance Committee reportCrawford: the committee is Whitney, Sprague and herself; "those sessions have been recorded on CCTV"; another meeting "next week. On Wednesday"; presentation to the board "in two weeks". Sprague: "as I'm the chair of the of that committee ... ask me first", "don't email the whole group" (0:12:33).POSITIVE
0:13:18Building administrators and the budgetSkillen asks whether building administrators are present "at, like, every step". Tempesta: "I was I was also a little bit surprised" at some things presented, including "potential schedule changes"; "we know we have to tighten up some things" (0:14:21). Crawford (0:14:53): administrators "submit a budget, their budget proposals, but then they don't actually see what gets put into the budget until that point".
0:17:49Staff reduction and schedule changeHawkins, on a discussed staff reduction at one school level: "I'd like to know what that's going to look like ... before I'm asked to vote to do that"; "when it comes to budget implications of schedule changes, there are implications" (0:18:36).
0:18:50Prior-year anomaliesCrawford: the right-hand column "shows a variance. A percent variance from the year before", but "don't be focused on that percentage because ... last year's figures, there were a lot of anomalies in the way the budget was put together last year." Items "were in one category that shouldn't have been. And so they've gotten rearranged" (0:20:05). Hawkins sees "the same anomalies" in the SAU budget (0:20:21); Henry: "We'll take another year to really get it" (0:20:40).OBSERVATION
0:20:59Policy committee auditSkillen: the committee has "gone through the entire Claremont School Board Policy Manual and made a distinction as to where we are missing required policies" (0:22:50), using a shared audit tracker; a Google survey will rank recommended policies. Hawkins: the priority policies "are those that we must, under legal requirements, put into place" (0:26:18).
0:27:11Audit references to missing policiesSprague: the auditors' last report ("Was it 2020?") had "a number of references in there to policies that we are required to have that we don't have" (0:27:28). Henry: "2021 I think or 2020"; "I have a lot of them written that I need to pass along to the committee" (0:28:34). Skillen says she added Henry to the audit file that day (0:28:42).OBSERVATION
0:29:37SRVRTC visioningCrawford: the committee has not met; SREB (transcribed s reb) has its data and "it's anticipated that the report will come out in March. That which is about three months later than we hoped".
0:30:23Disruptive behaviors committeeGallagher: students "that are not yet toilet trained", "concerns about, aggressive behavior in students", and attendance; the policy chair will be invited (0:30:54). Sprague: competency-based learning forced an attendance-policy revamp because there "used to be, grade penalties associated with poor attendance" (0:31:51). Tempesta: one more meeting, then a document for the board (0:32:36).
0:34:03Future dates; adjournmentSAU 6 meeting tomorrow, "6:00. So notice the special early start" (0:34:16). Adjournment moved and seconded (0:34:56).

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one cites the rule it rests on as that rule read on December 6, 2023; check the recording and the primary source before relying on any of them. Severity: HIGH, a likely breach of a binding rule or a missed statutory deadline; MEDIUM, a probable process gap; OBSERVATION, notable with no confirmed rule; POSITIVE, practice beyond the legal minimum. This page carries no HIGH flag.

MEDIUM Nonpublic minutes sealed for six months with no statutory determination on the record

RSA 91-A:3, III requires nonpublic minutes and decisions to be disclosed within 72 hours "unless, by recorded vote of 2/3 of the members present taken in public session, it is determined that divulgence of the information likely would affect adversely the reputation of any person other than a member of the public body itself, or render the proposed action ineffective, or pertain to terrorism." The vote itself meets the statute: a roll call in public session (0:03:44), all six members present voting yes. What is missing is the determination. Crawford's motion (0:03:35) states only a duration, and the minutes record "seal the minutes of the non-public session for 6 months" with no ground. In a tuition negotiation the "render the proposed action ineffective" limb is the obvious candidate, and the board may well have meant it, but nobody said so. RSA 91-A:3, II(k) adds its own release rule for this kind of session: a negotiated contract "shall be made public prior to its consideration for approval by a school district, together with minutes of all meetings held in nonpublic session". So the six-month seal gives way to the earlier of its own expiry or the contract coming forward for approval.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, II(k) and III (2023 codification; source note ends 2023, 189:1, eff. Oct. 3, 2023); approved minutes, item III.1

OBSERVATION The nonpublic citation drops the section number, and the agenda's paraphrase drops "tuition"

The agenda heads the item "Non-Public Session RSA91-A:,II (k)" and the minutes record the motion as made "under RSA91-A:II(k)". Both omit the section, 91-A:3. The agenda's paraphrase, "Consideration of a school board of entering into a student or pupil contract", also omits the word that limits the exemption: II(k) reaches "a student or pupil tuition contract authorized by RSA 194 or RSA 195-A, which, if discussed in public, would likely benefit a party or parties whose interests are adverse to those of the general public or the school district". The motion on tape (0:02:03) is too garbled to show what was said. RSA 91-A:3, I(b) requires the motion to "state on its face the specific exemption under paragraph II". The paragraph letter was stated and fits the subject, a Croydon tuition arrangement, so the defect is one of form; it is an Observation because the exemption relied on is identifiable from the record.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, I(b) and II(k) (2023 codification); agenda, item III.1

OBSERVATION The nonpublic session is cut from the recording, and the minutes give no times for it

The roll call to enter nonpublic session ends at 0:02:40 and the motion to come out is made at 0:03:16, about 23 seconds of tape later. The minutes put the call to order at 6:30 p.m. and adjournment at 7:22 p.m., about 52 minutes, against about 35 minutes of recording, so roughly 17 minutes are missing, which is the nonpublic session. Cutting a nonpublic session from a broadcast is expected. The consequence for a reader is that recording positions after 0:03:16 are not clock times, and the public minutes record no time of entry or exit; a voice at the break (0:02:55) remarks "I know we need the time we entered." No statute located for this page requires those times in the public minutes, so this is an Observation.

Sources: approved minutes (6:30 call to order, 7:22 p.m. adjournment); Dialogue/15453 SchoolBoard120623.mp4.CSV

OBSERVATION Audit references to missing required policies had not reached the policy committee

Sprague says the auditors' last report carried "a number of references in there to policies that we are required to have that we don't have" (0:27:28). Neither he nor the business administrator could say which year's audit it was ("Was it 2020?"; "2021 I think or 2020", 0:27:25). Mary Henry says she has "a lot of them written that I need to pass along to the committee" (0:28:34), and Skillen says Henry was added to the policy audit file only that day (0:28:42). The record does not show which policies the auditors named or whether they concern federal awards, so no rule is applied here. The audit report and its management letter for the year in question would settle what was found and what was done about it.

Sources: Dialogue/15453 SchoolBoard120623.mp4.CSV; approved minutes, item III.4(c) ("Mary Henry has policies from the previous audit to send to policy committee")

OBSERVATION Members told not to rely on the budget's prior-year comparison column

Crawford tells the board that the binder's percent-variance column should not be the focus "because ... last year's figures, there were a lot of anomalies in the way the budget was put together last year" (0:18:50), and that items "were in one category that shouldn't have been" and have been rearranged (0:20:05). Hawkins reports "the same anomalies" in the SAU budget (0:20:21). RSA 32:5, IV requires budget forms to carry comparative columns, so the prior-year comparison is the one the statute makes the public rely on; reclassifying lines between years makes that comparison harder to read unless the changes are disclosed with the budget. No figure in this meeting's record shows a misstatement, so no rule or accounting standard is applied. The binder was not placed in the packet; the 12/20/23 packet's Updated Claremont School District Budget 12.20.23.pdf is the document to check.

Sources: RSA 32:5, IV (2023 codification; comparative columns); Dialogue/15453 SchoolBoard120623.mp4.CSV

POSITIVE Minutes name every mover and seconder, and a member corrected the prior minutes to record a seal vote

RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes to include "the names of members, persons appearing before the public bodies, and a brief description of the subject matter discussed and final decisions", and since January 1, 2019 "The names of the members who made or seconded each motion shall be recorded in the minutes." The December 6 minutes name the mover and seconder of every motion, including all three nonpublic-session motions, and say each roll call was taken by the clerk with all present voting yes. Hawkins also had the November 15 minutes amended (0:01:05). The November 15 draft recorded a one-year seal only for that night's later nonpublic session under II(a) (moved by Whitney, seconded by Sprague); its earlier session under II(c), on page 2, item II, showed entry and exit but no seal vote. Hawkins's correction adds that second seal with its mover, seconder and unanimous roll call. Where the dialogue file's speaker labels disagree with the December 6 minutes on two motions, the minutes are the better evidence.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2023 codification; mover and seconder clause from 2018, 244:1, eff. Jan. 1, 2019); approved minutes

POSITIVE The Finance Committee's budget interviews were televised

Crawford reports that the committee's line-by-line sessions with administrators "have been recorded on CCTV" (0:11:06), and Hawkins says she watched them (0:17:27). RSA 91-A requires a committee of the board to meet in public and keep minutes; it does not require recording or broadcast, so televising the sessions goes beyond the minimum. The limit of that practice is the other side of the same record: no minutes of any of these Finance Committee sessions have been located in either district share (MAP.md sections 213, 216 and 218 and the finance-committee pages), so the recordings are the only public account of them.

Sources: RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d) (a committee of a public body is itself a public body); RSA 91-A:2, II (2023 codification)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page