Participants
Names and attendance follow the agenda masthead and the approved minutes. Where the dialogue file or a speaker's own introduction renders a name differently, the row says so; one surname is spelled differently in every record and is not printed as fact.
| Name | Role | Participation |
| Heather Whitney | Chair | Presides; seeks consensus to take public comment before business (0:09:12); moves out of nonpublic (minutes); seconds the seal and the para agreement; speaks for the finance process (1:01:56). |
| Frank Sprague | Vice chair; Finance Committee chair | Moves entry into nonpublic (0:07:46), the 50-year seal (0:08:50), the para agreement (0:53:53), the calendar (0:59:49) and the budget to hearing (1:05:15); presents the custodial agreement as the board's negotiator (0:44:34); abstains on the secretaries' agreement (0:50:59; minutes). |
| Candace Crawford | Member | Questions whether the para negotiation is complete (0:01:45, 0:53:22); moves the secretaries' agreement (0:50:49) and, per the minutes, the custodial one; votes to move the budget "simply to move it forward" (1:05:36). |
| Jennifer Gallagher | Member | Arrived 6:34 p.m. (minutes); seconds the nonpublic entry, both bargaining agreements, the calendar and the budget motion (minutes). |
| Bonnie Miles | Member | Present per the minutes; not separately identified on the recording. |
| Whitney Skillen | Member | Absent (minutes) |
| Arlene Hawkins | Member | Absent (minutes) |
| Nicole Bouchard, Kylee Plummer | Student board members | Not present. The agenda and minutes body name "Nicole Bouchard and Alex Barney"; the masthead names Plummer. |
| Noelle Kronberg | School Board Clerk | Calls the roll for the nonpublic votes (0:07:57, 0:08:33); submitted the minutes. |
| Michael C. Tempesta | Superintendent, SAU 6 | Adds the para ratification (0:01:21); presents the secretaries' and para agreements (0:49:09, 0:51:11). |
| Mike Koski | Assistant Superintendent | Calendar change (0:59:26). |
| Mary Henry | Business Administrator | Tax impact of the custodial agreement (0:47:43) and the secretaries' scale (0:49:51). Her monthly financial report was removed for time. |
| Matt Upton | Board counsel | Presents on non-CTE uses of the technical center (0:24:52 to 0:43:23), citing calls with the state CTE director (rendered Jeffrey Beard and Jeffrey Baird on this recording; spelling unresolved). |
| Hope Damon | Citizens' comments; state representative | "I'm Hope Daimon, state representative for Sullivan district eight." Legislative update (0:03:24). |
| Alex Hill | Citizens' comments, Ward 3; CMS teacher | Opposes the five-to-seven class change (0:10:41). |
| Sarah Ferland | Citizens' comments, Ward 3; CMS school counselor | Opposes the schedule; predicts departures (0:12:33). The minutes call her a CMS teacher. |
| Tom Smith-Knox (minutes) | Citizens' comments; CMS music teacher, unified arts team leader | Introduces himself on the recording as Tom Smith (0:15:29); opposes the schedule on behalf of colleagues. |
| Rebecca (surname unresolved) | Citizens' comments, Ward 1; CMS sixth-grade science teacher | Speaks at 0:16:44; her surname is not audible. The approved minutes print Vendesco, the dialogue file labels her Rebecca Duska, and other district records use other spellings; the project does not print one as fact. |
| Russ Ferland (minutes) | Citizens' comments; CMS civics teacher | Introduces himself as Russ Fernald on the recording and in the dialogue file (0:19:40); twenty years teaching in Texas. |
| Katie Smith-Knox | Citizens' comments; CMS sixth-grade ELA teacher | Staffing consistency and retention (0:21:56). |
| John Lambert | Citizens' comments, Ward 2; property owner, substitute teacher | Speaks in support of "Doctor Herzog"; the chair: "We can't speak to that." (0:23:28) |
| Unidentified | Board members and staff | 53 rows, mostly roll answers, seconds and a member's comment on higher-needs paras (0:55:31). |
Agenda
Official agenda items in order, with the time each is taken up on the recording and its disposition. The board took items out of order after the nonpublic session.
| Taken up | Item | Agenda text / disposition |
| 0:00:02 | I. Call to order, Pledge | 6:30 p.m. (minutes). |
| 0:00:34 | II. Roll call | Three Here answers are audible; minutes list five present, Gallagher from 6:34. |
| 0:00:55 | II. Consent Agenda "(vote required)": 1. agenda amendments; 2. Minutes Approval 12.6.23 | "There's been no request to amend the minutes." Para ratification added "to item two" on the chair's call for objections (0:01:27): "So we have just approved adding a ratification of the Paraprofessional Collective Bargaining agreement to item two." No motion or vote on the consent agenda or the minutes. See flag 4. |
| 0:02:24 | II. Citizens Comments | Chair reads the comment rules; Hope Damon (0:03:24). |
| 0:07:26 | IV.1 Non-Public Meeting Session "RSA 91-A:3,II" (agenda quotes (a) and (c)) | Sprague moves "under the gist of that" (0:07:46); minutes: Gallagher seconded, roll call all yes, 6:39 p.m. Return: minutes: Whitney moved, Sprague seconded, all yes, 9:08 p.m. Seal 50 years: Sprague moved (0:08:50), Whitney seconded, all yes. See flags 1, 2. |
| 0:09:12 | Public comment on a future agenda item (by consensus) | Six speakers on the CMS schedule and one on the technical center director, 0:10:41 to 0:24:20. |
| 0:24:34 | IV.3 Potential Consequences of Placing Non-CTE Programs at SRVRTC (Upton) | Taken ahead of IV.2. Presentation and questions to 0:44:11. |
| 0:44:15 | IV.2 Ratification of CAS & CAMCE Contracts (Vote), plus the added para agreement | CAMCE: motion and second at 0:48:51; voice vote, no opposition (0:49:03); minutes: Crawford moved, Gallagher seconded, unanimous. CAS: Crawford moves (0:50:49), second (0:50:53); Sprague Aye or abstain.; minutes: four in favour, Sprague abstained. Paraprofessionals: Sprague moves (0:53:53), Whitney seconds; voice vote, no opposition (0:58:29). |
| 0:59:04 | IV.4 Monthly Financial Report | Removed by consent "for the sake of time" (minutes). |
| 0:59:26 | IV.5 School District Calendar Change (Koski) | January 16 and 23 swapped for the primary. Sprague moves (0:59:49); minutes: Gallagher seconded; unanimous (0:59:58). |
| 0:59:10 | IV.6 Sub-Committee reports a, c to f | Bypassed for time, except finance. |
| 1:00:20 | IV.6(b) Finance Subcommittee: "Presentation of Finance Subcommittee Recommendations" | Sprague moves "the budget in the amount of $36,313,407.97 to the budget hearing scheduled for January 3rd" (1:05:15); minutes: Gallagher seconded; voice vote, none opposed (1:05:59). |
| 1:05:59 | V. Other Business; VI. Future dates | None. |
| 1:06:26 | IX. Adjournment | By consent ("Is there any objection to adjourning the meeting?"); minutes 9:52 p.m. |
Discussion timeline
Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/15483 SchoolBoard122023.mp4.CSV). Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.
| Time | Topic | What was said | Flags |
| 0:00:55 | Minutes and agenda | "Minutes for approval for December 6th, 2023. Is there any request from the board?" then "There's been no request to amend the minutes." Tempesta: "One addition is the ratification also of the power professional contract." Crawford: "I don't think we were ready for the ratification." Tempesta: "Go to nonpublic. Will give the update." | MEDIUM OBSERVATION |
| 0:03:24 | Hope Damon | House resumes January 3 with "about 20 education related bills"; HB 268 (background checks for nonpublic providers taking public funds), HB 601 (Medicaid direct certification for free and reduced meals), and bills she co-sponsors on voter-registration education, media literacy and an eating-disorder helpline on student IDs. Chair: "I'm sorry we can't give you more time." | |
| 0:07:26 | Into nonpublic | "At this time, we are moving into nonpublic session for RSA 91. Dash a colon three comma two. Do you want me to read this completely out or we would." Sprague: "I make a motion that we move into nonpublic under the gist of that." Roll by the clerk. | MEDIUM |
| 0:08:23 | Out of nonpublic; seal | Return motion and roll; Sprague: "I like to make a motion to seal the minutes for 50 years." Whitney seconds; five Yes answers (0:09:03 to 0:09:12). No finding stated. | MEDIUM |
| 0:09:12 | Comment taken early | "Thank you for your patience, everyone. We apologize for the long pause in the meeting." The chair asks consensus to take comment "so these folks can get back to their families and get some sleep for work tomorrow" and invites people to stand in support rather than repeat. | POSITIVE |
| 0:10:50 | Alex Hill | "if we were to go from a five class to a seven class schedule, that would go from a 55 minute class to a 45 minute class, and over the course of a one quarter, which is where I see most of my classes, that is ten minutes times 45 days, which is 4450 minutes of instruction time lost." [ten minutes times 45 days is 450 minutes] | |
| 0:12:33 | Sarah Ferland | "I have not spoken to one teacher who I have felt is in favor of this proposed schedule." "There are no deans to deal with some of the behaviors that are going on. One less counselor." "I think it would be more like a bleed out." | |
| 0:15:29 | Tom Smith-Knox | "My colleagues and I are here this evening to express our strong disagreement concerning the proposed schedule and staffing changes at Claremont Middle School." | |
| 0:16:46 | Rebecca, Ward 1 | On the principal: "when he gets put in a position to have to come back to us to say this was not something that I chose, but there are positions on the line here". "I am telling you, you have 11 teachers here now." "You will lose. I would say at least half of your teachers right now." | |
| 0:19:40 | Russ Ferland | From Texas: "I was teaching last year six classes in high school, 48 minute classes. I can tell you that at the end of the school day, we were whipped." | |
| 0:21:56 | Katie Smith-Knox | "the biggest problem that they faced is a lack of consistency in staffing". "this is probably the most that I, I have worried about it in the years that I've been here". | |
| 0:23:28 | John Lambert | "I'm here to express my support for Doctor Herzog's as the director of the school." Chair: "We can't speak to that." | |
| 0:24:52 | Counsel on non-CTE uses | Upton: "I've come to the conclusion that yes you can." Limits: non-CTE programs "can't supplant hinder other CTE programs" and may sit in "what I would call vacant space". Grant risk: "if you've got a lot of non CTE programing in this building, you run the risk of creating the impression or the inference that there's not the need for the space." The exclusivity rules "are all state requirements", not Perkins V conditions. | POSITIVE |
| 0:38:06 | How much is too much | "Like if you add 5% to 10% of the use of this facility for non CTE uses, I don't know that that would draw much attention. I think once you get above 10% and start to move 20, 30, 40% of the facility is being used. I think it would be pretty significant." Whitney asks about joint use funded by the city's workforce grant (0:38:59); Upton suggests a community preschool and lab school (0:41:00). | |
| 0:44:34 | Custodial and maintenance agreement (CAMCE) | Sprague, as board negotiator: three years, raises weighted to entry-level steps "so we could attract and recruit", dental "from 750 to 1500". Henry on tax impact: "for every 100,000, it was, $0.08 on the tax rate" then "Sorry, 87,000." and "A lot, a little less than that." Separate warrant article (0:48:34). Passed without opposition. | |
| 0:49:09 | Secretaries' agreement (CAS) | Henry: "They added $1.40 to the first year and every step, and then 3% and 3% over the next two years." Crawford moves; Sprague: Aye or abstain. Minutes: Sprague abstained; no reason given on the recording. | |
| 0:51:11 | Paraprofessional agreement (Teamsters) | Tempesta: "we struck a one year deal", "basically we added two, $2 to every, every step. And for an overall increase of 189,000 in the first", with a bonus from ESSER money. Crawford: "So you don't have a contract to agree to yet because you just sent this out to them?" Tempesta: "They agreed to it. I met with them today." Whitney (0:57:23): "this was kind of an emergency situation". | OBSERVATION |
| 0:59:04 | Items dropped | Monthly financial report removed; subcommittee reports bypassed "With the exception of finance." | |
| 0:59:26 | Calendar | Koski: the primary is January 23, "so we'd like to make the 23rd the teacher workshop day and have school on the 16th." Approved. | |
| 1:00:32 | Finance Committee report | Sprague: "if anybody wants to see them, they're all televised." Whitney (1:01:56): "We have been committed to having all of our discussions in public. There has been one brief meeting, that occurred this week, and the minutes of that meeting will be on the website." | OBSERVATION |
| 1:04:01 | Which version? | Crawford: "We've had several litigations [iterations]. Each time we meet, we get a different version. And I still haven't seen the the copy that will be going to the, hearing." Whitney: "It's actually in your folder." Crawford: "So this is probably version five, right." | OBSERVATION |
| 1:05:15 | Budget moved to hearing | "I would like to make a motion to move the budget in the amount of $36,313,407.97 to the budget hearing scheduled for January 3rd to 2024." Crawford: "I'm voting in favor simply to move it forward to the hearing phase." Passed, none opposed. The packet report's grand total is the same figure, +$1,433,096.06 (4.11%) over FY24. | MEDIUM |
| 1:06:26 | Adjournment | "Is there any objection to adjourning the meeting? No." | |
Items flagged for review
These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one cites the rule it rests on as that rule read on December 20, 2023; check the recording and the primary source before relying on any of them. Severity: HIGH, a likely breach of a binding rule or a missed statutory deadline; MEDIUM, a probable process gap or control weakness; OBSERVATION, notable with no confirmed rule; POSITIVE, practice beyond the legal minimum. This page carries no HIGH flag.
MEDIUM The motion to enter a two-hour nonpublic session named no exemption
The chair announced the session "for RSA 91. Dash a colon three comma two" and asked whether to read it out; the motion that followed was "that we move into nonpublic under the gist of that" (0:07:46). RSA 91-A:3, I(b) requires the motion to "state on its face the specific exemption under paragraph II" (statute). Neither the announcement nor the motion named a lettered ground; the agenda printed the text of II(a) and II(c), and the minutes record the motion as under "RSA 91-A:3,II(a,c)". The session then ran, by the minutes, from 6:39 to 9:08 p.m. The agenda's letters probably reflect what the body meant; the recorded motion does not say it.
Sources: RSA 91-A:3, I(b) (2023 codification; source note ends 2023, 189:1, eff. Oct. 3, 2023); agenda, item IV.1
MEDIUM Nonpublic minutes sealed for 50 years with no statutory determination on the record
The seal was moved and seconded in public and carried five to nothing by roll call (0:08:50 to 0:09:12; minutes), which clears the two-thirds of members present that RSA 91-A:3, III requires. The paragraph also requires that the vote determine "that divulgence of the information likely would affect adversely the reputation of any person other than a member of the public body itself, or render the proposed action ineffective, or pertain to terrorism" (statute). No ground is stated on the recording or in either set of minutes. From October 3, 2023, RSA 91-A:3, IV also provides for review of sealed minutes no more than ten years after the vote to withhold them; a 50-year term does not displace that review.
Sources: RSA 91-A:3, III and IV (2023 codification)
MEDIUM Nearly half of the budget increase sent to hearing is the reversal of a $688,426.17 credit no one can allocate
The packet's budget report (printed 12/20/2023 2:06 p.m.) totals $36,313,407.97, an increase of $1,433,096.06 or 4.11% over the FY 23-24 budget column of $34,880,311.91, the figure moved at 1:05:15. Page 44 of the same report carries account 100.40.1100.113.5.00000, "Board Voted Expense Reduct", at ($688,426.17) in the FY 23-24 budget column and $0.00 proposed, an increase of $688,426.17. That one line is 48% of the total increase. Two days earlier the business administrator told the Finance Committee she did not know what the credit was allocated to and that her predecessor's spreadsheets "don't match up" with the budget (December 18 page). RSA 32:5, IV requires the budget form to carry comparative columns of prior-year appropriations and expenditures, and this report does; but a comparison column that balances only through an unallocated credit makes the reported line increases, and the share of the increase that is new spending, unreliable. Nothing said on the recording explains the line to the board or the public before the vote. The board's later reduction of the figure after the January 3 hearing is the statute working as written (RSA 32:5, I) and is not part of this flag.
Sources: Updated Claremont School District Budget 12.20.23, pages 44 and 55; RSA 32:5, I and IV (2023 codification); Finance Committee, December 18, 2023, flag 3
MEDIUM A consent agenda marked "vote required" with no vote, and minutes approved without a motion
The agenda lists the agenda amendments and the December 6 minutes under "Consent Agenda (vote required)". On the recording the chair notes no request to amend the minutes (0:01:07), adds the para ratification on a call for objections, and announces "So we have just approved adding" it (0:02:08); no motion, second or vote is taken on the consent agenda or the minutes. The approved minutes record only "No corrections" for the December 6 minutes. No statute requires a vote to approve minutes, so this is graded as a process gap against the board's own agenda: the December 6 minutes stand as approved by the board without any recorded action approving them.
Sources: agenda, item II; approved minutes, item II
MEDIUM Draft minutes reached the public share on the seventh business day
RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes "open to public inspection not more than 5 business days after the meeting" (statute; drafts suffice). Five business days after Wednesday, December 20 ran to Thursday, December 28, 2023 (December 25 a holiday). The draft minutes were created on Drive on January 2, 2024, in the January 3 hearing folder, which is the seventh business day; the approved minutes followed on January 4. The Drive dates show when the public could see the document, not when it was written. Graded MEDIUM because the meeting was noticed and packeted and the minutes exist.
Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2023 codification; source note ends 2023, 188:1, eff. Oct. 3, 2023)
OBSERVATION Finance Committee minutes said to be online, and one session this week said to be unrecorded
The approved minutes record under the Finance Subcommittee report: "Subcommittee meetings and minutes are available online for people to review" (minutes' wording). On the recording the chair goes further: "There has been one brief meeting, that occurred this week, and the minutes of that meeting will be on the website" (1:01:56). No Finance Committee minutes for December 2023 have been found in either district share, and no record of a second session this week (the committee's televised December 18 session ended with the chair saying the members needed to caucus) has been found. The December 18 page carries the HIGH flag for the missing record; this flag notes the board's own statement about it.
Sources: approved minutes, item IV.6(b); RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d); Finance Committee, December 18, 2023, flag 1
OBSERVATION The minutes and the recording disagree on times and names
The recording runs about 58 minutes from the return to public (0:08:23) to the adjournment (1:06:26), while the minutes give 9:08 p.m. for the return and 9:52 p.m. for adjournment, 44 minutes; the minutes' 9:50 p.m. for Other Business fits a return near 8:52 p.m., so the 9:08 entry is the likelier error, which would make the nonpublic session about two hours and thirteen minutes. The agenda and minutes body list the student members as "Nicole Bouchard and Alex Barney" while the masthead lists Kylee Plummer. Two speakers introduce themselves differently from the minutes (Tom Smith and Russ Fernald on tape; Tom Smith-Knox and Russ Ferland in the minutes), and one speaker's surname is spelled differently in every record. The minutes call Sarah Ferland a teacher; she says she is the CMS school counselor. This page follows the minutes for spellings and says so.
Sources: approved minutes; agenda
OBSERVATION A paraprofessional agreement added the same night, briefed in nonpublic session, and ratified as "what we sent to them"
The para ratification was not on the posted agenda; the superintendent added it at 0:01:21, saying the update "just happened today" and would be given in nonpublic session (0:01:58). RSA 91-A:2, I(a) excludes collective-bargaining strategy and negotiations from the definition of a meeting, while the nonpublic motion was taken under a paragraph II ground (II(a) and (c), per the agenda and minutes), and RSA 91-A:3, I(c) confines a nonpublic session to the matters in the motion; the record does not show what was discussed. In public, Crawford asked whether there was an agreement at all ("So you don't have a contract to agree to yet because you just sent this out to them?"), and the superintendent described the document as "what we sent to them that we sent out", agreed by the union's representatives that day and going to the membership the next week (0:53:25, 0:53:35). The board ratified a one-year deal adding $2 per step, about $189,000 in the first year, with a retention bonus from ESSER funds. The public-employee bargaining framework, RSA chapter 273-A, sends the cost items of a negotiated agreement to the legislative body; the recording does not say how this one-year agreement will reach the warrant.
Sources: RSA 91-A:2, I(a); RSA 91-A:3, I(c); RSA chapter 273-A
OBSERVATION The budget the board moved to hearing was posted the day after the vote, and a member had not seen it
The packet folder and agenda went up on December 19 (about 9:04 a.m. Eastern). The budget report the board voted on was printed at 2:06 p.m. on December 20 and reached the packet folder at 10:43 a.m. Eastern on December 21, the morning after the vote, as a scanned copy. Crawford said at 1:04:01 that she had not seen "the copy that will be going to the, hearing" and was told it was in her folder. RSA 91-A:2, II's notice duty covers the meeting, not its documents, and the public hearing on January 3 is where RSA 32:5, I gives the public its say on the budget, so no rule is shown breached. The public watching the vote could not see the figure's composition.
Sources: 28. CSB 12.20.23 folder (Drive creation times); RSA 32:5, I (2023 codification)
POSITIVE Public comment taken early for staff who had waited two hours, and counsel's advice given in public
After the nonpublic session the chair apologised for the wait and asked the board's consent to hear comment before the business so staff could go home (0:09:12); seven speakers were heard and the chair twice invited anyone else to speak or stand (0:19:32, 0:24:09). Together with Hope Damon's update this gave about 18 minutes of comment; RSA 189:74 requires a period of no less than 30 minutes, but nobody was turned away and the text does not settle whether the floor is on time used or time offered. Counsel's analysis of non-CTE use of the technical center, including a concrete threshold and the grant risk, was given in public session rather than as privileged advice (0:24:52), and the tax impact of the custodial agreement was stated before the vote (0:47:43).
Sources: RSA 189:74 (public comment period; 2022, 333:1)
Appendix: source files
Official and public sources
Project files
Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.
Dialogue/15483 SchoolBoard122023.mp4.CSV (334 attributed rows; the basis of this page)
Input/Videos/15483 SchoolBoard122023.mp4 (local copy of the recording)
Input/Transcripts/15483 SchoolBoard122023.mp4.json (diarized transcript)
Input/SupportingDocuments/MAP.md, section 219 (video-to-document map)
Laws and rules cited on this page
- State, as codified for the meeting date: RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d); RSA 91-A:2, I(a) and II (2023 codification); RSA 91-A:3, I(b), I(c), III and IV (2023 codification); RSA 32:5, I and IV (2023 codification); RSA 189:74; RSA chapter 273-A
- Session laws mentioned for dating only: 2023, 188:1 (RSA 91-A:2) and 2023, 189:1 (RSA 91-A:3), both eff. Oct. 3, 2023