Claremont School Board, FY25 Budget Public Hearing, January 3, 2024

The board's public hearing on the fiscal year 2025 budget, followed by a short regular meeting. Business Administrator Mary Henry presents a proposed operating budget of $36,313,408 and a default budget she states as $406,634 lower; Superintendent Michael Tempesta presents the Claremont Middle School schedule change behind most of the staffing cuts; no member of the public speaks; the board takes no vote on the budget and sends its questions to the Finance Committee meeting of January 5. Built from the Cablecast recording's attributed dialogue, the agenda, the budget memo, the summary page, the presentation slides and the approved minutes. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (seven members), sitting first as the governing body holding the budget hearing and then as the board
Date
Wednesday, January 3, 2024
Start time
Agenda: hearing 6:30 p.m., board meeting 7:03 p.m. The approved minutes record the hearing closing and the board meeting opening at 7:13 p.m., and closing activities at 8:04 p.m. On the recording the chair calls the meeting to order at 0:00:04, closes the hearing at 0:41:49 and adjourns by consent at 1:33:12. From a 6:30 call to order those positions fall at about 7:12 and 8:03 p.m., which agrees with the minutes.
Location
Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center, Claremont (agenda and minutes)
Board composition
Present (minutes; roll at 0:00:36): Heather Whitney (chair), Frank Sprague (vice chair), Bonnie Miles, Whitney Skillen, Jennifer Gallagher, Arlene Hawkins. Absent: Candace Crawford. The roll is almost entirely untranscribed; Skillen never speaks on the recording.
Recording
Cablecast: School Board Meeting 1/3/23 (the gallery title carries the wrong year; the meeting is January 3, 2024). Observed extent 1:33:20, taken from the last row of the dialogue file; the Cablecast API refuses requests from the build environment, so the run time was not confirmed. Runs from the call to order through adjournment.
Minutes
1. Approved minutes 1.3.24 CSB Public Hearing Agenda.pdf (Meeting Minutes share, created January 18, 2024); draft draft minutes 1.3.24 CSB Public Hearing (1).pdf, filed in the 2. CSB 1.17.24 packet folder on January 16, 2024 (see flag 4). Submitted by Noelle Kronberg, school board clerk.

Participants

Names follow the agenda masthead and the approved minutes. Speaker labels come from the dialogue file; where a voice is not named on the recording it stays Unidentified.
NameRoleParticipation
Heather WhitneyChair; Finance Committee memberCalls the meeting to order (0:00:04), reads the hearing agenda (0:00:53), closes the hearing (0:41:49) and runs the consent agenda (0:42:45); explains that the Finance Committee would not yet endorse the budget and that its meetings are televised (0:43:15, 0:43:40); asks the board what the committee should examine (0:47:53); asks for an overview of grant and state money (1:21:59); adjourns by consent (1:33:12).
Frank SpragueVice chair; Finance Committee chairLeads the pledge (0:00:21); asks the tax impact of the $406,634 gap (0:29:51); asks about the alternative-support-programs line (0:39:03); puts the question of why the budget is not simply cut to the default, for the record (0:44:56); presses the business administrator on the unallocated $688,000 line until she agrees to reallocate it (1:01:37, 1:02:44, 1:05:41); points to a Title I social-worker entry keyed as 67,000 instead of 6,700 (1:07:43); describes a part-time social worker he arranged at Stevens (1:14:12).
Bonnie MilesMemberRelays the Claremont Middle School teachers' objections from the December 20 meeting and asks whether the schedule change will cost the district teachers (0:48:20, 0:52:05). The chair names her at 0:51:31.
Whitney SkillenMember; Policy chairPresent per the minutes; her roll answer is not separately transcribed and she makes no recorded remark.
Jennifer GallagherMember; Curriculum and Ad Hoc Disruptive Behaviors chairAsks whether the teachers' union has reviewed the schedule and whether it must be bargained (0:37:58); asks about the removal of behavior support specialists (0:40:34), the $208,000 of PD coaches moving off ESSER (0:54:30), the $212,000 change in the special-education line (0:59:39), social-worker staffing (1:07:18), and whether a class-size change from 18 to 16 matters (1:16:18); asks for the proposed bell schedule (1:29:02). Says the disruptive-behaviors committee did not meet that day (1:30:47).
Arlene HawkinsMember (also SAU 6 board chair)Asks that elementary field trips stay in the budget, that an elementary instructional coach be funded, and that paraprofessionals get professional development (1:19:25, 1:19:44, 1:20:05); asks that the middle-school model be kept in view (1:20:35); thanks the Finance Committee for its televised meetings (1:31:33).
Candace CrawfordMember; Finance Committee memberAbsent (minutes)
Nicole Bouchard, Kylee PlummerStudent representativesListed on the agenda masthead; not heard on the recording and not mentioned in the minutes.
Noelle KronbergSchool board clerkReads the roll (0:00:43); submits the minutes.
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Opens the administration's presentation (0:01:17); presents the middle-school schedule change and its staffing effect (0:13:32–0:20:57); compares it with the Stevens schedule (0:24:55); says the union will receive the schedule and that the district would have to impact-bargain it if the union treats it as a change (0:38:20); answers on behavior specialists, social workers and class size.
Mike KoskiAssistant Superintendent, SAU 6Gives the middle school's staffing history (0:21:31); answers on instructional coaches (0:55:13, 0:55:46) and class-size research (1:18:40); announces the January 13 job fair (1:32:18).
Mary HenryBusiness AdministratorPresents the budget process and the memo's changes (0:01:44–0:12:23), the default budget (0:28:22–0:29:34), and tax and valuation background (0:32:05–0:37:43); explains the $688,426.17 unallocated line (0:08:29) and agrees to reallocate it for the January 5 meeting (1:05:51); raises the condition of the middle school's gym-entry restrooms (1:24:42).
Unidentified administratorStaff table; special-education portfolioTakes over when the business administrator stops on the alternative-support-programs line and explains the autism and PRIDE program rooms and the closing of one room (0:39:18–0:39:51). Not named on the recording. Special Education Director Ben Nester is listed on the masthead and the superintendent refers to him as present (1:13:29), but this page does not name the voice.
UnidentifiedStaff or board tableOne line explaining why the disruptive-behaviors committee did not meet (1:30:57).
Unidentified member of the publicAudienceThe chair asks whether he wishes to comment before closing the hearing (0:41:49); he does not speak on the recording. The minutes record "No members of the public present for comment".

Agenda

Items as printed on the posted agenda (1.3.24 CSB Public Hearing Agenda.docx.pdf), with the disposition from the recording and the approved minutes.
Taken upItemAgenda text / disposition
0:00:04Hearing I. General businessAgenda: "Secretary Roll Call of Attendance of Board Members". Roll at 0:00:36; six present, Crawford absent (minutes).
0:01:17Hearing II. Overview of Fiscal Year 2025 BudgetHenry's memo walk-through (0:01:44–0:12:23), then Tempesta and Koski on the middle-school schedule (0:13:32–0:26:52). Presentation only; no motion.
0:27:30Hearing III. Overview of the 2025 Default BudgetHenry presents a handout not in the posted folder: reductions of $3,445,245, contractual additions, a projected default she reads as "35,000,960 774" and a proposed budget of "36,000,313 408", "406,634 over default" (0:29:01). See flags 2 and 3. Questions on tax impact, valuation, the union and the schedule follow.
0:41:49Hearing IV. Citizens' comments; V. Closing of public hearingThe chair asks one audience member whether he wishes to comment, then closes the hearing. Minutes: closed at 7:13 p.m., "No members of the public present for comment".
0:42:45Board I–II. Call to order; roll; agenda and December 20, 2023 minutesNo separate call to order or second roll on the recording; the minutes repeat the hearing's attendance. The chair asks for changes to the agenda or minutes, "Seeing none", and moves on. Minutes: "consent to approve both the agenda and minutes". No motion or vote.
0:42:45Board III. Citizens' commentsNone ("we have no citizens citizens here to comment").
0:43:15Board IV.A. Fiscal 2025 Budget ApprovalNot acted on. The chair reports that the Finance Committee "didn't feel like we could officially endorse the budget as proposed" and that it meets Friday at 10:00. The board discusses the default budget, the $688,000 line, coaches, social workers, class size and grant funding, and reaches consensus that the business administrator reallocate the $688,426.17 line (1:06:31). No motion or vote.
1:32:18Board V. Closing activitiesJob-fair announcement; adjourned by consent at 1:33:12 (minutes: 8:04 p.m.).

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/15505 SchoolBoard010324.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:04Call to order, pledge, rollWhitney: "I'm calling the January 3rd, 2024 Claremont School Board meeting and, public hearing meeting into order". Sprague leads the pledge; the clerk's roll (0:00:43) survives only as "Here, here. Jennifer Gallagher, present. Eileen Hawkins here." ("Eileen" is the standing ASR rendering of Arlene).
0:01:44Budget processHenry: "it's the first time I built the Claremont budget", thanking the administrative team, the board and "especially Frank, who has all of his knowledge". The administrative team met with principals and with the Finance Committee.
0:02:56Benefits and contractsHealth insurance up 8.8% for paraprofessionals, maintenance and secretaries, 5.7% for teachers; dental up 4.7% (0:03:21). Contract steps: teachers' year two "$573,097 per year", the Claremont Administration Association $51,736, paraprofessionals' year three $109,376 (0:03:48). "These items will be on the default budget".
0:04:14School-by-school changesA social worker added at Disnard, Maple Avenue and Bluff at $91,696 each; a reading specialist at Maple at $110,534 (0:04:47); behavior support specialists removed (one at Disnard, three at Maple, three at Bluff, one at Stevens, three ESSER-funded at the middle school). At the middle school (0:05:46, 0:06:08): add one science teacher, a campus monitor/assistant athletic director and an ARC coordinator; reduce math by 0.6, English by two, social studies by three, guidance by one; remove two campus monitors, two academic deans and one English teacher "previously funded by Esser". Henry: "it's more of a it's a restructure" (0:06:38). At the tech center a new health teacher at $96,621 plus $3,000 of supplies (0:07:57).
0:08:29The $688,426.17 lineHenry: "We had a line item that was labeled board voted expense reductions. It was reduction of $688,426.17 sitting on the budget. So it's it is funds that have not been allocated back to lines that they probably belonged. This was uploaded before my time." "I left that item there instead of trying to guess where that allocation belonged" (0:09:26); "your bottom line budget is what you voted" (0:09:49).MEDIUM
0:10:09District-wide changesThe behavior analyst moves from ESSER to the district budget at "109,000 521" [$109,521] (0:10:28); the ESL teacher is recoded to function 1260; the substitute line drops by $125,000 (memo); PD coaches move from ESSER at "$208,388", an added technology position at $57,644 (0:11:46); a year-round secretary that "should have been in 24" (0:12:23).
0:13:32Middle-school scheduleTempesta: core teachers would teach "five core academic classes, but they still have a sixth class that is either an enrichment or a win class" (0:15:18), for "332 students" in regular-education classes; substitute-coverage savings of "about $14,000" (0:20:36); "the most fiscally responsible thing to do for the whole district" (0:20:57). Koski: "we haven't been able to fully staff the schedule for the past three years" (0:21:31); "I just don't see us being able to hire more teachers next year" (0:22:26).
0:24:24Comparison with StevensWhitney asks whether the change aligns middle-school workloads with Stevens. Tempesta: Stevens teachers teach six classes; "Mr. Pratt wanted to keep the eight blocks for the flexibility" (0:24:55); tech-center classes get 90 minutes (0:25:22).
0:27:30Default budgetHenry, from a handout passed down the table: "the total reductions from the fiscal year 24 budget would be $3,445,245", then contractual additions "for a total addition of 4,471,000" (0:28:22); "our projected default budget would be 35,000,960 774 [$35,906,774], but the proposed budget is 36 million. The one we have in front of us that I spoke about earlier is 36,000,313 408, which means right now our proposed budget is 406,634 over default" (0:29:01); "if default is voted ... We will have to look for that money" (0:29:34).OBS POSITIVE
0:29:51Tax impact of the gapSprague asks what the $406,000 means on the tax rate. After searching her spreadsheet (0:30:06), Henry: "So it would be so yeah $0.08 per thousand. So times that." (0:31:06); "Would be $32 on 100,000." (0:31:13). The minutes record "approximately 32 cents per thousand".OBS
0:32:05Valuation, fund balance and the state tax"Residential went up by 42%. Commercial went up by 23%" (0:32:05). Fund balance returned to taxpayers: "This year we only returned $316,566 back to the taxpayers on unassigned fund balance" (0:33:19); for fiscal 2023 "we gave back 1.2 million $85,605" (0:33:56); "We're not your bank" (0:34:46). The statewide education property tax ("your sweat tax" [SWEPT]) and its effect (0:35:12); "your tax rate dropped, but you're still raising the same amount" (0:37:21).
0:37:58Union and the scheduleGallagher: "Has the teachers union had a chance to review and respond to the schedule?" Tempesta: "we feel everything in here meets the language. But if the if they view it as a change. They we would have to impact bargain that" (0:38:20).
0:39:03Alternative support programsSprague asks about the line on the summary sheet (down $257,108.45 on the summary page). Henry starts, then an unidentified administrator explains the autism room and a behavior-focused PRIDE room that "Lived under a different budget code" (0:39:29): "We reduced it by one room which included the staff and the teacher" (0:39:51).
0:40:34Behavior support specialistsTempesta: there are 11 "throughout the district"; "we're getting rid of those and we're, we're replacing them with paraprofessionals" so there is one group with a "more robust, less turnover" contract (0:41:06). Koski and Tempesta: all 11 are to be replaced, "it's a shift".
0:41:49Hearing closed; consent agenda"I'm going to officially close the public hearing." The consent agenda passes without a vote (0:42:45).
0:43:15Budget not endorsed; televised committeeWhitney: the Finance Committee "didn't feel like we could officially endorse the budget as proposed", meets "Friday at 10:00", and "this year we are televising, recording and televising all of our finance subcommittee meetings for complete and utter transparency" (0:43:40).
0:44:47Why not budget at the default?Sprague asks the question "that I know the answer to". Henry: the default is "a safety net for the district" covering contractual obligations (0:45:09); "that default budget is going to stay at what it is right now. The 35 million" (0:46:22). Sprague says negotiated agreements become void under the default; Henry corrects him: existing contracts stand and new ones are separate warrant articles (0:46:54).
0:47:53What should the committee examine?Miles relays the middle-school teachers' concerns from December 20 (0:48:20, 0:52:05). Tempesta on parity between five and six classes in one bargaining group (0:49:12). Koski: the two schedules differ by "6 or 7, maybe eight minutes" but "every student will have a teacher in every class" (0:52:49).
0:54:30PD coachesGallagher on the "208,000 expense under the general budget" (0:55:04). Koski: no added cost expected; a third, elementary coach was ESSER-funded and never filled, "that money is running out" (0:55:46). Sprague credits Disnard's results to its principal (0:57:18); Koski: "There's rumored state money that we haven't seen it yet" (0:58:13).
0:59:39Special education lineGallagher asks about the "$212,000 increase" (the summary page shows a $212,168.56 decrease). Henry ties it to the $688,000: money "should have been allocated in there. And it's all sitting in regular instruction under district wide" (0:59:53); "again, I wasn't here, so I can't" (1:00:50).MEDIUM
1:01:03Debt serviceHenry: "a big chunk of almost $400,000"; Sprague: "that's the Johnson Controls"; Henry: "That'll be done in fiscal year 26" and she will provide a bond and lease schedule (1:01:22).
1:01:37Reallocating the $688,000Sprague: "So why can't we make that go away." Henry: "I can make it go away" (1:02:48); she would not adjust it "without asking you permission to do so first, because it's 688,000" (1:03:19); "You'll see where I've done it, because you'll see the journal entries on an amended budget line" (1:04:03); "You're still not changing your bottom line" (1:04:24). The chair: "I think we have consensus" (1:06:31). Henry: "Dave Jack actually looked at it for me ... Didn't know either" (1:06:40).MEDIUM
1:07:18Social workersTempesta: social workers today at the high school and middle school only (1:07:22). Sprague: a Title I share "was entered in last year's budget is 67,000 instead of 6700" (1:07:43). Tempesta credits Courtney Porter (1:12:21); Sprague recalls a part-time social worker at Stevens through the Orion House (1:14:12).
1:16:18Class sizeGallagher asks whether 18 to 16 matters. Tempesta: "I think it's negligible" at the middle level (1:16:50). Koski: "There's a window of between 12 and low 20s that has no impact" (1:18:40).
1:19:25Hawkins's requestsElementary field trips "because of an earlier conversation that we had about schools inequity"; an elementary coach "through grant money or whatever it may be" (1:19:44); professional development for paraprofessionals (1:20:05); the New England League of Middle Schools (1:22:30).
1:21:59Grant funding overviewWhitney asks for an overview of all funding, not just local dollars. Henry: for fiscal 2024 "just over $1 million in title one money and just over half a million in Ida [IDEA]" and "1.7 million in funds from grants" (1:23:01).
1:24:04Facilities asideHenry confirms the facilities director's request is in the budget, then describes the middle school's gym-entry girls' room as "so dated and so old" (1:25:08) against the renovated Stevens restrooms (1:25:28).
1:27:06Tech-center health course; bell scheduleTempesta on a general health course, with respiratory therapy considered (1:27:14). Gallagher asks for the actual middle-school bell schedule (1:29:02); Tempesta: "at one point Frank said, well just tell me what you want to make" (1:29:19).
1:31:01Closing remarks; job fairHawkins on unified arts, then: "those televised meetings were so helpful" (1:31:33). Koski: HR job fair at the tech center, "January 13th ... nine to noon" (1:32:18). Adjourned by consent (1:33:12).

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid. They are not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each names the rule it rests on, or says that none was verified.

MEDIUM A $688,426.17 reduction sat unallocated in one district-wide salary account, and no one could trace it

The business administrator's memo for this hearing states that account 100.40.1100.113.5.00000, "Board Voted Expense Reductions for FY24 ($688,426.17)", "should have been allocated out to the salary and benefit lines that it belonged" (memo, quoted as written). On tape she says the amount was "uploaded before my time" (0:08:29), that she does not know where it belongs (0:09:26), and that David Jack of MRI, who had covered the business office, "Didn't know either" (1:06:40). The board's own questions show the effect: a member reads the special-education line as up $212,000 when the summary page shows it down $212,168.56 (0:59:39), and the vice chair warns that "there could be a quarter of a million over here that that's in both places" (1:03:06). The fiscal 2024 bottom line was not affected, as Henry says (0:09:49), but the function totals in the fiscal 2024 column the board was comparing against were skewed by it, as she also says ("it's really skewing some of our district wide numbers"). The NH Financial Accounting Handbook's chart of accounts is guidance, which Rev 1102.03 ranks as "other guidance", so this is a control and presentation weakness rather than a breach of a binding rule. The board responded on the record: it reached consensus that the amount be reallocated by journal entry before the January 5 Finance Committee meeting (1:04:03, 1:06:31).

Sources: Claremont School Board Budget Memo 1.3.24; NH Financial Accounting Handbook for Local Education Agencies (chart of accounts; guidance); N.H. Admin. Rules, Rev 1102.03 (accounting hierarchy)

OBSERVATION The default budget was presented from a handout that is not in the posted packet, and the spoken figure is transposed

Henry presents the default budget from a sheet "which I didn't pass out to you" (0:27:30); no default budget form is among the seven documents in the hearing's packet folder. RSA 40:13, XI(a) requires the governing body to complete a default budget form that identifies changes "by account code" with reasons. The form may exist elsewhere (the deliberative-session packet would be the place to check), so this records only that the hearing's public folder does not carry it. The spoken default, "35,000,960 774" (0:29:01), does not reconcile with the stated $406,634 gap: $36,313,408 less $406,634 is $35,906,774, the figure the deliberative session later used. The transcript's 960 is a transposition of 906, whether by the speaker or the ASR.

Sources: RSA 40:13, XI(a) (default budget disclosed at the first hearing; default budget form contents); packet folder 1. CSB FY25 Budget Public Hearing 1.3.24

OBSERVATION Two different tax-rate figures for the $406,634 gap

Asked the tax impact of the gap between the proposed and default budgets, Henry says "$0.08 per thousand" (0:31:06) and then "$32 on 100,000" (0:31:13). Those are inconsistent: 8 cents per thousand is $8 on a $100,000 property, while $32 on $100,000 is 32 cents per thousand. The approved minutes record "approximately 32 cents per thousand", which matches the second figure. A viewer of the broadcast heard both; the minutes resolve it only in one direction and do not mention the correction. No rule is engaged; this is noted for accuracy of the public record.

Sources: approved minutes, January 3, 2024 (section III)

OBSERVATION The draft minutes reached the public share on the eighth business day

RSA 91-A:2, II (as in force in January 2024) requires minutes to be "open to public inspection not more than 5 business days after" the meeting; the fifth business day after Wednesday, January 3 was Wednesday, January 10. The draft minutes were created in the 2. CSB 1.17.24 packet folder on January 16, 2024, 15 seconds after the folder itself, which is the eighth business day (January 15 was Martin Luther King, Jr. Day). The file's modifiedTime is the same morning, so it does not show an earlier existence. The statute requires availability for inspection, not online posting; the minutes may have been available on request at the SAU office earlier, and nothing here shows otherwise. The Drive date is the only evidence available from here, so this is an observation, not a finding.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2023 codification; minutes open to inspection within 5 business days); draft minutes 1.3.24 (Drive metadata)

OBSERVATION No notice of the hearing was found; the statutory calendar was otherwise met

RSA 32:5, I requires public notice of the budget hearing at least 7 days in advance, and RSA 40:13, II-a sets the second Tuesday in January (January 9, 2024) as the last day to post notice of budget hearings. No notice is in the hearing's packet folder, which was created on January 2. The hearing was announced as a future date at the December 20 meeting (December 20 draft minutes, "Budget Public Hearing 1.3.24"), but that is an announcement, not the posted or published notice the statute contemplates. A newspaper or posted notice may exist outside the district's Drive shares. The other calendar requirements are met on the record: the hearing was held before the third Tuesday in January (January 16) as RSA 40:13, II-a requires, and 31 days before the February 3 deliberative session, more than the 25 days of RSA 32:5, I.

Sources: RSA 32:5, I (2023 codification; hearing at least 25 days before the meeting, 7 days' notice); RSA 40:13, II-a (January calendar for budget hearings); draft CSB meeting minutes 12.20.23

POSITIVE The default budget was disclosed and questioned at the first hearing, and a line-item budget with prior-year columns was posted beforehand

RSA 40:13, XI(a) requires the default budget to be "disclosed and presented for questions and discussion at the first budget hearing". The agenda gave it its own item and Henry presented it with its components (0:28:22–0:29:34), followed by questions on its tax effect and its purpose (0:29:51, 0:45:09). The packet folder, created the day before, carries a 56-page line-item budget (Updated Claremont School District Budget 12.20.23.pdf) whose columns include fiscal 2022 and 2023 actual expenditures, the fiscal 2024 budget and the fiscal 2025 proposal, and a one-page summary with the same comparisons, which is what RSA 32:5, I (sub-account detail available at the hearing) and IV (comparative columns) ask for. The chair also notes that every Finance Committee meeting this cycle was televised (0:43:40).

Sources: RSA 40:13, XI(a); RSA 32:5, I and IV (2023 codification); Updated Claremont School District Budget 12.20.23.pdf

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page