| 0:00:04 | Call to order, pledge, roll | Whitney: "I'm calling the January 3rd, 2024 Claremont School Board meeting and, public hearing meeting into order". Sprague leads the pledge; the clerk's roll (0:00:43) survives only as "Here, here. Jennifer Gallagher, present. Eileen Hawkins here." ("Eileen" is the standing ASR rendering of Arlene). | |
| 0:01:44 | Budget process | Henry: "it's the first time I built the Claremont budget", thanking the administrative team, the board and "especially Frank, who has all of his knowledge". The administrative team met with principals and with the Finance Committee. | |
| 0:02:56 | Benefits and contracts | Health insurance up 8.8% for paraprofessionals, maintenance and secretaries, 5.7% for teachers; dental up 4.7% (0:03:21). Contract steps: teachers' year two "$573,097 per year", the Claremont Administration Association $51,736, paraprofessionals' year three $109,376 (0:03:48). "These items will be on the default budget". | |
| 0:04:14 | School-by-school changes | A social worker added at Disnard, Maple Avenue and Bluff at $91,696 each; a reading specialist at Maple at $110,534 (0:04:47); behavior support specialists removed (one at Disnard, three at Maple, three at Bluff, one at Stevens, three ESSER-funded at the middle school). At the middle school (0:05:46, 0:06:08): add one science teacher, a campus monitor/assistant athletic director and an ARC coordinator; reduce math by 0.6, English by two, social studies by three, guidance by one; remove two campus monitors, two academic deans and one English teacher "previously funded by Esser". Henry: "it's more of a it's a restructure" (0:06:38). At the tech center a new health teacher at $96,621 plus $3,000 of supplies (0:07:57). | |
| 0:08:29 | The $688,426.17 line | Henry: "We had a line item that was labeled board voted expense reductions. It was reduction of $688,426.17 sitting on the budget. So it's it is funds that have not been allocated back to lines that they probably belonged. This was uploaded before my time." "I left that item there instead of trying to guess where that allocation belonged" (0:09:26); "your bottom line budget is what you voted" (0:09:49). | MEDIUM |
| 0:10:09 | District-wide changes | The behavior analyst moves from ESSER to the district budget at "109,000 521" [$109,521] (0:10:28); the ESL teacher is recoded to function 1260; the substitute line drops by $125,000 (memo); PD coaches move from ESSER at "$208,388", an added technology position at $57,644 (0:11:46); a year-round secretary that "should have been in 24" (0:12:23). | |
| 0:13:32 | Middle-school schedule | Tempesta: core teachers would teach "five core academic classes, but they still have a sixth class that is either an enrichment or a win class" (0:15:18), for "332 students" in regular-education classes; substitute-coverage savings of "about $14,000" (0:20:36); "the most fiscally responsible thing to do for the whole district" (0:20:57). Koski: "we haven't been able to fully staff the schedule for the past three years" (0:21:31); "I just don't see us being able to hire more teachers next year" (0:22:26). | |
| 0:24:24 | Comparison with Stevens | Whitney asks whether the change aligns middle-school workloads with Stevens. Tempesta: Stevens teachers teach six classes; "Mr. Pratt wanted to keep the eight blocks for the flexibility" (0:24:55); tech-center classes get 90 minutes (0:25:22). | |
| 0:27:30 | Default budget | Henry, from a handout passed down the table: "the total reductions from the fiscal year 24 budget would be $3,445,245", then contractual additions "for a total addition of 4,471,000" (0:28:22); "our projected default budget would be 35,000,960 774 [$35,906,774], but the proposed budget is 36 million. The one we have in front of us that I spoke about earlier is 36,000,313 408, which means right now our proposed budget is 406,634 over default" (0:29:01); "if default is voted ... We will have to look for that money" (0:29:34). | OBS POSITIVE |
| 0:29:51 | Tax impact of the gap | Sprague asks what the $406,000 means on the tax rate. After searching her spreadsheet (0:30:06), Henry: "So it would be so yeah $0.08 per thousand. So times that." (0:31:06); "Would be $32 on 100,000." (0:31:13). The minutes record "approximately 32 cents per thousand". | OBS |
| 0:32:05 | Valuation, fund balance and the state tax | "Residential went up by 42%. Commercial went up by 23%" (0:32:05). Fund balance returned to taxpayers: "This year we only returned $316,566 back to the taxpayers on unassigned fund balance" (0:33:19); for fiscal 2023 "we gave back 1.2 million $85,605" (0:33:56); "We're not your bank" (0:34:46). The statewide education property tax ("your sweat tax" [SWEPT]) and its effect (0:35:12); "your tax rate dropped, but you're still raising the same amount" (0:37:21). | |
| 0:37:58 | Union and the schedule | Gallagher: "Has the teachers union had a chance to review and respond to the schedule?" Tempesta: "we feel everything in here meets the language. But if the if they view it as a change. They we would have to impact bargain that" (0:38:20). | |
| 0:39:03 | Alternative support programs | Sprague asks about the line on the summary sheet (down $257,108.45 on the summary page). Henry starts, then an unidentified administrator explains the autism room and a behavior-focused PRIDE room that "Lived under a different budget code" (0:39:29): "We reduced it by one room which included the staff and the teacher" (0:39:51). | |
| 0:40:34 | Behavior support specialists | Tempesta: there are 11 "throughout the district"; "we're getting rid of those and we're, we're replacing them with paraprofessionals" so there is one group with a "more robust, less turnover" contract (0:41:06). Koski and Tempesta: all 11 are to be replaced, "it's a shift". | |
| 0:41:49 | Hearing closed; consent agenda | "I'm going to officially close the public hearing." The consent agenda passes without a vote (0:42:45). | |
| 0:43:15 | Budget not endorsed; televised committee | Whitney: the Finance Committee "didn't feel like we could officially endorse the budget as proposed", meets "Friday at 10:00", and "this year we are televising, recording and televising all of our finance subcommittee meetings for complete and utter transparency" (0:43:40). | |
| 0:44:47 | Why not budget at the default? | Sprague asks the question "that I know the answer to". Henry: the default is "a safety net for the district" covering contractual obligations (0:45:09); "that default budget is going to stay at what it is right now. The 35 million" (0:46:22). Sprague says negotiated agreements become void under the default; Henry corrects him: existing contracts stand and new ones are separate warrant articles (0:46:54). | |
| 0:47:53 | What should the committee examine? | Miles relays the middle-school teachers' concerns from December 20 (0:48:20, 0:52:05). Tempesta on parity between five and six classes in one bargaining group (0:49:12). Koski: the two schedules differ by "6 or 7, maybe eight minutes" but "every student will have a teacher in every class" (0:52:49). | |
| 0:54:30 | PD coaches | Gallagher on the "208,000 expense under the general budget" (0:55:04). Koski: no added cost expected; a third, elementary coach was ESSER-funded and never filled, "that money is running out" (0:55:46). Sprague credits Disnard's results to its principal (0:57:18); Koski: "There's rumored state money that we haven't seen it yet" (0:58:13). | |
| 0:59:39 | Special education line | Gallagher asks about the "$212,000 increase" (the summary page shows a $212,168.56 decrease). Henry ties it to the $688,000: money "should have been allocated in there. And it's all sitting in regular instruction under district wide" (0:59:53); "again, I wasn't here, so I can't" (1:00:50). | MEDIUM |
| 1:01:03 | Debt service | Henry: "a big chunk of almost $400,000"; Sprague: "that's the Johnson Controls"; Henry: "That'll be done in fiscal year 26" and she will provide a bond and lease schedule (1:01:22). | |
| 1:01:37 | Reallocating the $688,000 | Sprague: "So why can't we make that go away." Henry: "I can make it go away" (1:02:48); she would not adjust it "without asking you permission to do so first, because it's 688,000" (1:03:19); "You'll see where I've done it, because you'll see the journal entries on an amended budget line" (1:04:03); "You're still not changing your bottom line" (1:04:24). The chair: "I think we have consensus" (1:06:31). Henry: "Dave Jack actually looked at it for me ... Didn't know either" (1:06:40). | MEDIUM |
| 1:07:18 | Social workers | Tempesta: social workers today at the high school and middle school only (1:07:22). Sprague: a Title I share "was entered in last year's budget is 67,000 instead of 6700" (1:07:43). Tempesta credits Courtney Porter (1:12:21); Sprague recalls a part-time social worker at Stevens through the Orion House (1:14:12). | |
| 1:16:18 | Class size | Gallagher asks whether 18 to 16 matters. Tempesta: "I think it's negligible" at the middle level (1:16:50). Koski: "There's a window of between 12 and low 20s that has no impact" (1:18:40). | |
| 1:19:25 | Hawkins's requests | Elementary field trips "because of an earlier conversation that we had about schools inequity"; an elementary coach "through grant money or whatever it may be" (1:19:44); professional development for paraprofessionals (1:20:05); the New England League of Middle Schools (1:22:30). | |
| 1:21:59 | Grant funding overview | Whitney asks for an overview of all funding, not just local dollars. Henry: for fiscal 2024 "just over $1 million in title one money and just over half a million in Ida [IDEA]" and "1.7 million in funds from grants" (1:23:01). | |
| 1:24:04 | Facilities aside | Henry confirms the facilities director's request is in the budget, then describes the middle school's gym-entry girls' room as "so dated and so old" (1:25:08) against the renovated Stevens restrooms (1:25:28). | |
| 1:27:06 | Tech-center health course; bell schedule | Tempesta on a general health course, with respiratory therapy considered (1:27:14). Gallagher asks for the actual middle-school bell schedule (1:29:02); Tempesta: "at one point Frank said, well just tell me what you want to make" (1:29:19). | |
| 1:31:01 | Closing remarks; job fair | Hawkins on unified arts, then: "those televised meetings were so helpful" (1:31:33). Koski: HR job fair at the tech center, "January 13th ... nine to noon" (1:32:18). Adjourned by consent (1:33:12). | |