Claremont School Board Finance Committee, January 5, 2024

A televised working session of the board's three-member Finance Committee two days after the budget hearing. The business administrator reports that she has spread the unexplained $688,426.17 reduction back across salary and benefit lines, with $16,830 she could not place; the members trade one proposed elementary social worker for an instructional coach, work through middle-school and Stevens staffing line by line, and leave the $36,313,408 total unresolved. They schedule a further meeting for Wednesday, January 10 at the superintendent's office, of which this corpus holds no record. Built from the Cablecast recording's attributed dialogue; no agenda, notice or minutes were found. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board Finance Committee (Frank Sprague, chair; Heather Whitney; Candace Crawford), a committee of the board and a public body under RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d)
Date
Friday, January 5, 2024
Start time
10:00 a.m., as announced by the board chair at the January 3 meeting; no agenda or notice was found. Sprague opens at 0:00:01 and closes "for the good of the order" at 1:51:22. The recording's observed extent is 1:51:32.
Location
Not stated in available records. The members discuss holding the next session "At the Dow building" or in the superintendent's office (1:50:52, 1:51:05).
Attendance
All three committee members present. Business Administrator Mary Henry arrives after the start (first heard 0:24:16). Special Education Director Ben Nester joins by video from a conference at 0:47:28 and has left by 1:11:46. The business administrator's question at 1:05:19 ("Mike, are you still on Mike?") suggests the superintendent took part remotely; that is not proven.
Recording
Cablecast: School Board Finance Meeting 1/5/23 (the gallery title carries the wrong year; the meeting is January 5, 2024). Observed extent 1:51:32, from the last row of the dialogue file; the Cablecast API refuses requests from the build environment, so the run time was not confirmed.
Minutes
None found. MAP.md records no packet or minutes for this meeting in either district share (checked 2026-08-28; searches of these shares are unreliable for negatives).

Participants

Committee membership as read into the record on November 30, 2023 and restated by the board chair on January 17, 2024. Speaker labels come from the dialogue file; voices not named on the recording stay Unidentified.
NameRoleParticipation
Frank SpragueCommittee chair; board vice chairOpens the session (0:00:01); presents the patterns he found while hunting for the $688,000, such as lines that are zero in the current year and restored in the proposal (0:22:28, 0:23:41, 0:38:27); "This is not your fault" to the business administrator (0:26:47); questions the extended-school-year line (0:43:05); asks what increase the board would accept (1:32:21, 1:33:01); raises the mayor's email on direct certification (1:45:47); closes the session (1:51:22).
Heather WhitneyCommittee member; board chairProposes funding an elementary instructional coach (0:00:49); asks how many positions are new since ESSER (0:10:26); proposes trading a social worker for the coach (0:16:33); reads the middle-school and Stevens staffing from her notes (1:14:56); argues the committee is "being defensive of the budget" so the public sees it as "legitimate and transparent" (1:25:15); asks whether the next meeting should be televised (1:42:26); asks for all grant-funded positions (1:43:51).
Candace CrawfordCommittee memberSupports the coach (0:03:29); says she needs confidence in what the numbers represent before adopting a budget (0:22:09); diffs successive budget drafts and traces a $240,000 drop in the alternative program (0:47:55, 0:48:32, 0:50:34); questions the middle-school position list line by line (1:05:55, 1:07:13, 1:10:24); asks for year-to-date actuals (1:31:32); proposes a 3.75% ceiling (1:34:36, 1:35:33); asks whether the members accept "36 million 318" (1:39:28).
Mary HenryBusiness AdministratorExplains how she reallocated the $688,000 (0:27:12–0:30:04); reconciles the special-education salary lines (0:36:27, 0:36:43); answers on paraprofessional and behavior-specialist counts (0:59:07, 1:01:40); "This is my document. So I apologize for that" on a mislabeled position (1:08:03); undertakes monthly year-to-date reports (1:31:53); gives the separate warrant-article amounts (1:38:36).
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Describes the middle-school academic resource center and in-school suspension room (0:07:56, 0:09:06); suggests two elementary social workers instead of three to fund a coach (0:12:58, 0:14:17); explains "letter of agreement" positions (1:20:01). Possibly remote (see facts).
Mike KoskiAssistant Superintendent, SAU 6"the reason we didn't ask for it is we were trying not to ask for too much" on the elementary coach (0:02:26); describes coaches' two roles (0:19:04) and gains under the new reading program (0:20:47); asks for a percentage target at the start of the next budget cycle (1:49:10).
Ben NesterDirector of Special Education, SAU 6 (remote)Explains the alternative-program location code and three self-contained rooms, one eliminated and one possibly moved to the Stevens budget (0:50:51, 0:51:14); "All behavior specialists have been zeroed out" (0:54:26); estimates their cost at "42,500 times eight" (1:00:36).
UnidentifiedStaff and members (71 short rows)Backchannel fragments and sub-second onsets the diarizer could not assign, concentrated in the staffing exchanges; none carries substantive content attributed on this page.

Order of business (reconstructed)

No agenda was found. The items below are reconstructed from the chair's and members' transitions on the recording.
Taken upItemDisposition
0:00:01OpeningSprague: "the board has not approved the final number to go to, the voters at this point. We still have some unanswered questions and, and some anomalies in the budget".
0:00:49Elementary instructional coachConsensus, no vote: fund one coach by budgeting two elementary social workers instead of three (0:16:50); Henry confirms the change at 1:39:46.
0:22:28The $688,000 line and budget anomaliesHenry reports the reallocation; Sprague's other anomalies left with her to check. No action.
0:47:28Special education and behavior specialists (Nester by video)Explanations of the alternative-program, paraprofessional and behavior-specialist lines. No action.
1:05:55School staffing, position by positionMiddle school and Stevens rosters reconciled against the memo; wording corrections promised. No action.
1:32:21Size of the increase; warrant articlesMembers undecided between $36,313,408 and Crawford's $36,188,000 ceiling; Whitney: "I think we need to have a conversation with the board about that." Talking points assigned (1:40:04).
1:42:07Next stepsPresentation to the board on January 17; another committee meeting with the administration set for Wednesday, January 10, 9:00, at the superintendent's office (1:50:49–1:51:19). See flag 2.

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/15510 SchoolBoardFinance010524.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:01OpeningSprague: "welcome, everyone. To our latest edition of the Claremont Finance Committee." The business administrator "was not here yet" (0:00:36).MEDIUM
0:00:49Coach for the elementary schoolsWhitney: coaching is budgeted at the middle and high schools but "it was not built into the budget, that the elementary schools would have the same services"; she wants to find money "when we have clear evidence that our elementary schools are struggling quite a bit" (0:01:53). Koski: "we were trying not to ask for too much" (0:02:26). Crawford: "I'll find the money" (0:03:29).
0:04:06What ESSER funded, and what is newWhitney lists the ESSER-funded middle-school positions: two campus monitors, two academic deans, one English teacher, three behavior support specialists (0:04:53). Tempesta: the middle school's two rooms are "an in-house suspension behavior room, and then there's an academic center" modeled on Stevens (0:07:56); "Academic Research Room is the acronym for Arc" (0:09:06). Whitney: "it feels to me as if we're actually adding a lot of new positions in compared to pre-COVID" (0:10:53); "those are truly adding new positions to our budget" (0:11:55).
0:12:58Two social workers and a coachTempesta: "We are adding three social workers, you know, could we get by with two?" Whitney gives elementary enrollments of 176 (Bluff) and 267 (Maple) (0:15:58); Koski: a caseload of 350 (0:17:10). Crawford: "So, so, so instead of three social workers, you're going with two social workers and one coach." (0:16:50). Crawford notes the Stevens social worker spent "35% of their time" there "according to Chris" (0:17:20).
0:19:04What coaches doKoski: "instructional practice" and "implementing curriculum", with a new ELA program (0:19:04); "we've seen dramatic increases in the teachers who are implementing this new program" (0:20:47).
0:21:26Numbers before systemsWhitney: numbers first "because Mary wasn't here". Crawford: "in order for me to adopt a budget, I need to have some confidence in what the numbers represent" (0:22:09).
0:22:28Sprague's anomalies"it's no secret that I've been kind of hung up on the, the 688, $688,000 that is in the budget that, at one point, nobody seemed to know what to do with it." He shows lines with consistent actuals, zero in the current year and restored in the proposal, such as Maple media retirement (0:23:41): "Is that really a zero or is that 8700 that should be in the budget" (0:24:19). Henry: "it's a real number because it was left out of last year's" (0:25:44); "we're going to hope that somewhere within our budget, we have $8,700 that we didn't spend" (0:26:32).OBS
0:27:12Where the $688,000 wentHenry: she compared the budget with actuals and "went back to Richard's spreadsheets" (0:27:29); "A lot of people are grant funded but were put into the budget" (0:27:47), "over a half $1 million that was in Ida alone" (0:28:16); her predecessor "didn't go back and push it back across the lines that the credit belonged on" (0:29:17); "I landed with roughly $16,000 that I couldn't find" (0:29:42), "16,830", which she took from an over-budgeted health-insurance line (0:30:04). Worked example: a special-education salary line once showing a $174,000 variance now shows about $16,000 (0:36:23, 0:36:43).OBS
0:38:27More anomalies; no actualsSprague on CMS water and sewer, Stevens substitutes and the Disnard secretary (0:38:27, 0:41:07): "It would be nice to know what the actual are", and "in my efforts to find the 688, I actually I actually found a number like, like a half $1 million of this kind of stuff" (0:40:29). Henry: a $300,000 retirement line "and nothing is against yet" (0:40:51); she has not updated payroll encumbrances for staff changes (0:44:37). Crawford: "the variance is immaterial because it's based on. Yeah. Fiction." (0:46:12).OBS
0:43:05Extended school yearSprague asks why the $75,000 extended-school-year cost is not on IDEA or ESSER. Henry: "You can't supplant certain things" (0:43:11); it was recoded to function 1260 "for state reporting" (0:43:22). No supplanting rule was verified for this page; the statement is reported as made.
0:47:28Alternative program and behavior specialistsNester joins by video. Crawford, diffing the December 18 and December 20 drafts: "I was trying to determine where the 350,000" (0:48:32); "We weren't informed that some program got cut. So you don't cut out 240,000 without." (0:50:34). Nester: three self-contained rooms, "One was at the high school and two were housed at Maple"; one eliminated, one possibly moved to a Stevens line (0:51:14, 0:51:44). "All behavior specialists have been zeroed out" (0:54:26); Henry: "No more letters of agreement" (0:54:34). Henry: eight behavior specialists were locally funded and three ESSER-funded; "We removed eight of them and inserted 5 or 5 and a half, whatever paras into the budget" (1:01:40).
0:54:37Psychologist lineCrawford sees about $100,000 leave the district-wide psychologist line (0:55:25); Whitney points to a $25,000 increase in district-wide psychological services. Crawford: "I will double check that."
1:05:55Middle-school positionsCrawford: "How can you add a position that's already in the budget." Henry: "it's the wording. It's not an addition" (1:07:31); "This is my document. So I apologize for that." (1:08:03). Math, English and social studies "Everything's going to four"; guidance: "that's a misnomer if you ask me" (1:10:24). Henry notices Nester has dropped off (1:11:46).
1:14:56Stevens positions; "letters of agreement"Whitney reads the Stevens roster from her notes. Tempesta: "The term letter of agreement is it's a general term used for people who are not in a contracted in a CBA" (1:20:01). Henry: "even after the budgets passed, I will go through. And for next year, I will break people into where they need to go" (1:24:40).
1:25:15Explaining the budget to the publicWhitney: "we're being defensive of the budget, right? Meaning we're looking as a committee to say we want the the community to see this budget as as legitimate and transparent and specific and and no funny money is being switched." Henry: "it's a learning process. I'm new." (1:25:35).POSITIVE
1:31:32Year-to-date actualsCrawford: "Mary, I would love to have you add another column year to date calculation." Henry: "We are going to have monthly year to date updates, which I have not done yet" (1:31:53).OBS
1:32:21How large an increase?Sprague: the latest copy shows "an increase of of 4%"; "what do they see acceptable as a, as an increase is 4% okay?" (1:33:01). Henry: the increase includes the teachers', administrators' and paraprofessionals' contract steps, "almost, what, $700,000" (1:33:40). Crawford: 34,880 thousand times 1.0375 "I get 36188" (1:34:36); "If we could cut 130,000" (1:35:14). Whitney: "roughly 700,000 increase above and beyond the contracted obligations" (1:36:21); Henry: "400,000 alone in social workers" (1:37:05). Crawford: "are you okay with the 36 million 318. Or do you want to see that reduced to 36188?" (1:39:28).
1:38:36Warrant articlesHenry: "189 for the Paris? Is it 158 for the Secretary's? I think. And it's just almost a 160 for the for the maintenance". Crawford: keep them separate from the operating budget, "don't mix messages there" (1:40:17).
1:41:12SAU assessmentHenry: Claremont's share of the SAU budget shifted because "Your property values went up and unities did not" (1:41:24); "Unity has not been reevaluated yet" (1:41:43).
1:42:07Next meeting: televised or not?Whitney: two presentations, one to the board for approval on the 17th. "do we want to have this the powwow meeting be televised as well, or is that something we can do at the essay [SAU] at the." (1:42:26). Sprague: "A work session?" (1:42:48); Crawford: not "Introducing new topics". Henry must enter the budget for DRA posting "by the 24" (1:43:33).MEDIUM
1:43:51Grant-funded positions; Maple reading specialistWhitney wants "all the positions that are being funded by grants and the whole budget". Henry: no positions in the budget should be on grants, "I went through line by line" (1:44:54); the Maple reading specialist enters the general budget because "title one funds shifted" (1:45:28). Sprague raises an email from Mayor Dale Girard on direct certification through Medicaid for free and reduced meals (1:45:47).
1:49:10Targets for next yearKoski: "if we could get targets at the beginning of the budget process. So if you say we want a 3% increase, we want a 4% increase. It'd be much nicer process to have that target."
1:50:15SchedulingAfter Monday and Tuesday are ruled out: "9:00 on Wednesday" (1:50:51), "At the Dow building" (1:50:52), then "We could meet and Mike's officers. There's small enough number of us." (1:51:05); "So I'll show up at the office at 9:00 on Wednesday?" (1:51:13); "The 10th." (1:51:19). Closed at 1:51:22.MEDIUM

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid. They are not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each names the rule it rests on, or says that none was verified.

MEDIUM No notice, agenda or minutes were found for this committee meeting

The Finance Committee is a committee of the school board, and RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d) makes "any committee, subcommittee, or subordinate body thereof" a public body, so RSA 91-A:2, II's notice and minutes duties apply to it: notice at least 24 hours ahead, excluding Sundays and holidays, and minutes open to inspection within five business days, recording the members present, persons appearing, a brief description of each subject discussed and final decisions. MAP.md records no packet or minutes for this meeting in either district share (checked 2026-08-28), and none was found for this page. Grading under the project's severity rule: this is the MEDIUM limb, not HIGH, because the record mitigates it. The board chair announced the meeting on the televised January 3 hearing ("Friday at 10:00", show 15505), the board's December 20 draft minutes state that subcommittee "meetings and minutes are available online", and the whole meeting was recorded and published, so the public can see what was said. That last point does not supply minutes: the recording is not a substitute the statute recognizes, and the December 20 statement about minutes is not borne out by any share searched. The decisions reached here (the social-worker-for-coach swap at 0:16:50, the January 10 meeting at 1:51:13) exist only on tape.

Sources: RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d) (committees are public bodies); RSA 91-A:2, II (2023 codification; notice and minutes); draft CSB meeting minutes 12.20.23

MEDIUM A further committee meeting was set for January 10 at the superintendent's office; the corpus holds no recording, notice or minutes of it, and the budget changed by $196,001.10 before the next public meeting

The chair of the board asks whether the next committee meeting should "be televised as well" (1:42:26); the committee chair answers "A work session?" (1:42:48), and the three members agree to meet at 9:00 on Wednesday, January 10, in the superintendent's office because "There's small enough number of us" (1:51:05, 1:51:13). A meeting of all three members of the committee to discuss the budget is a meeting of a public body under RSA 91-A:2, I, whatever it is called; a "work session" label does not change that. This page found no notice, minutes or recording of a January 10 session: the Cablecast archive as mapped in MAP.md carries none between this show and the January 11 SAU 6 meeting. The documents point to it having taken place: the January 17 board packet carries Exhibit D- Claremont FY25 Proposed Budget Updated 1-10-24 Finance Committee (1).pdf, printed January 10, 2024 at 1:17 p.m., and Exhibit E- Claremont Summary Page 1-10-24 (1).pdf, whose operating budget is $36,117,406.87, down $196,001.10 from the $36,313,407.97 on the table at this meeting. Following the project's rule, this page does not infer what was decided off camera; it records that the figure changed between two public meetings, and that a scheduled committee session sits in the gap with nothing public to show for it. It is graded MEDIUM, not HIGH, because the session's occurrence rests on document titles and print stamps rather than on a record of the meeting itself. On January 17 the board chair told the board that "Our finance subcommittee meetings were videotaped and televised live" (show 15531); if the January 10 session was held off camera, that statement was incomplete.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, I and II (2023 codification; what a meeting is; notice and minutes); RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d); Exhibit D, 1-10-24 Finance Committee; Exhibit E, Summary Page 1-10-24

OBSERVATION The $688,000 was reallocated by judgment, $16,830 was not located, and the committee worked without current-year actuals

Henry's account is that the $688,426.17 credit offset grant-funded staff her predecessor had budgeted locally, and that she has now moved it into the salary and benefit lines it belonged to, "based on the information that I had" (0:29:42), leaving $16,830 she could not place and took from an over-budgeted health-insurance line (0:30:04). The committee chair says he found "like a half $1 million" of similar entries (0:40:29), the business administrator says payroll encumbrances have not been updated for staff changes (0:44:37), and monthly year-to-date reports have "not done yet" (1:31:53). A member calls the resulting variances Fiction (0:46:12). None of this changes the bottom line voted, as Henry stresses, and no statute or rule verified for this page requires a board to receive year-to-date actuals during budget preparation; GASB's budget-to-actual requirements govern the annual financial statements, not budget drafts. The point for a reader is that the line-item comparisons the committee was using to judge the fiscal 2025 proposal were, on the business administrator's own account, unreliable in places, and that the fix was a reallocation she made on her own analysis and offered to document by journal entry.

Sources: no rule verified; see NH Financial Accounting Handbook for Local Education Agencies (chart of accounts; guidance) for the account structure being discussed

POSITIVE A committee working session recorded and televised in full

RSA 91-A requires notice and minutes; it does not require a committee to be recorded or broadcast. This session, including a member's challenge to the business administrator's figures and her answers, was recorded and published by Claremont Community Television (CCTV) / Claremont Community Media Center (CCMC). Members also asked for redacted position detail (0:37:42), all grant-funded positions (1:43:51) and year-to-date actuals (1:31:32), and the board chair framed the committee's job as making the budget "legitimate and transparent" to the public (1:25:15). This credit is limited by flags 1 and 2.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (minimum requirements: notice and minutes)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page