Claremont School Board, December 17, 2025

Regular meeting, six of seven members present, at which the administration first showed the FY 2026-27 budget: $44,861,008 (up 3.89%) for a four-school model the interim superintendent recommends, or $43,968,104 (up 1.83%) for a three-school model, against $43,179,564 this year. No decision was taken; about eighteen members of the public spoke against more school moves, and the comment period was extended. The board also accepted ski-program gifts, set tuition rates, accepted five retirements, restored two Stevens High School positions, adopted two policies, raised the clerk's stipend and met in nonpublic session under a defective citation. Built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript, the agenda, the approved and nonpublic minutes, the packet and Drive file metadata. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6)
Date
Wednesday, December 17, 2025 (agenda, minutes; the chair opens "the December 17th Claremont School Board meeting", 0:00:00)
Start time
Agenda: 6:30 p.m. The minutes record no actual start (flag 3). Nonpublic session 9:24 to 10:22 p.m. (minutes), entered at 2:53:47 of the recording and excised from it; "Consent adjournment at 10:31pm" (minutes). The recording runs 3:03:45 by the last dialogue row (the Cablecast API refuses this environment), which matches 6:30 to 10:31 p.m. less the 58-minute nonpublic session.
Location
Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center, Claremont (agenda and minutes). Carried on CCTV Channel 8.
Recording
Cablecast: Claremont School Board: 12/17/25 (show 17046; runs 3:03:45, nonpublic session not recorded)
Minutes
12.17.25 Approved CSB Meeting Minutes (Google Doc); 10. DRAFT 12.17.25 CSB Meeting Minutes.pdf (PDF, in Drive by 10:05 p.m. December 22, 2025, the third business day); 12.17.25 CSB Nonpublic Meeting session minutes unsealed (PDF, created December 26, 2025; see flag 2).
Board composition
Seven members: Heather Whitney (chair), Michael Petrin (vice chair), Arlene Hawkins, Candace Crawford, William Madden, Frank Sprague, Loren Howard (agenda masthead). Six present; Petrin absent (minutes). Clerk Noelle Kronberg present.

Participants

Everyone heard or recorded. Spellings follow the approved minutes; where the transcript or dialogue file differs, both are shown. Students are not named on this page, and retirees are not listed by name because the transcript's renderings of their names are unverified.
NameRoleParticipation
Heather WhitneyChairPresides; reads policy BEDH (0:02:30); follow-up items (0:18:59 to 0:20:57); asks about reserves and building risk (1:27:54); seconds the nonpublic motion (2:54:06); presents the clerk stipend (2:54:42). Moved the nonpublic-session authorization recorded in flag 2.
Michael PetrinVice chairAbsent (approved minutes; the nonpublic minutes list six members present). The transcript's roll reads the name with no answer (0:00:40). The dialogue file labels one short remark at 0:29:10 as possibly Petrin; that label conflicts with the minutes and is not followed here.
Arlene HawkinsMember; Policy subcommittee chairAdds follow-up items, asks about preschool services (0:22:33); moves the ski donations, retirees, extension of comment, policies and clerk stipend; asks the cost of keeping the current configuration (1:23:21). Authorized in nonpublic session to negotiate the administrators' agreement (flag 2).
Candace CrawfordMember; Finance Subcommittee chairReads the budget premises (0:36:33 to 0:43:45); explains the budget layout (1:15:00); moves the tuition rates (2:29:24).
William MaddenMemberPresents policy IKC (2:43:51); asks to separate presentation from vote (2:40:20); superintendent-search report (2:50:28); other business (3:00:24, 3:02:46). Labeled William 'Bill' Madden in the dialogue file.
Frank SpragueMemberAsks about the encumbrance (0:18:42), revenues (1:20:37) and restored support staff (1:26:25); moves the SHS positions (2:38:02) and the nonpublic session (2:53:47).
Loren HowardMemberReports public preference for K-5 schools (1:21:37); asks whether the default budget is the status quo (2:17:36); seconds tuition and SHS motions.
Noelle KronbergSchool board clerkCalls the roll (0:00:40); keeps time on public comment (2:03:46); produced the minutes and nonpublic minutes.
Kerry KennedyInterim Superintendent, SAU 6Ski program and CMS band gift (0:23:21, 0:29:41); presents the models (0:45:14); Bluff School concept (1:11:34); retirees (2:32:20); NHDOE advisory (2:56:31).
Matt AngellInterim Business Administrator, SAU 6 (agenda: Senior Comptroller/Interim Business Administrator)Finance update (0:16:56); budget calendar (0:32:04); budget totals (1:09:47); default budget (2:17:55); tuition rates (2:27:32).
Michael HerringtonPrincipal, Stevens High SchoolCurrent Stevens enrollment (0:56:31); requests the two SHS positions (2:34:47 to 2:39:12). ASR renders the name Harrington.
Don LavaletteCitizens' comments, Ward 2Superintendent model (0:05:29 to 0:07:21).
Matt BeanCitizens' comments, Ward 1; coach and special-education teacherStipends and treatment of staff (0:07:47 to 0:10:02); against grouping self-contained programs (2:09:10 to 2:09:45).
Erica AbbyCitizens' comments, Ward 3Tech program funding (0:10:22); inclusion of special-education students, speaking of her own child (1:52:25 to 1:54:48, 2:13:57). Minutes give the full name; the dialogue file labels her Abby.
Kara GirardiCitizens' comments; district staffAsks the board to resign; insurance (0:11:01, 0:11:31); interjects during board responses (2:25:16, 2:26:48). Minutes spell Kara Girardi; she introduces herself as "Karen Girardi" on tape and the dialogue file has Karen Gherardi.
Shaylor DuranleauCitizens' comments; temporary plumbing and heating teacher, SRVRTCCBA pay scale (0:12:08 to 0:13:49); one-time costs and reserves (1:49:20 to 1:50:12). Name per minutes; tape and dialogue file: Shayla Duran.
Cassandra EdwardsCitizens' comments, Ward 3; Disnard teacher, SREA building representativeDental insurance (0:14:20); staff stability (1:50:50 to 1:52:06).
Rebecca (surname printed Vinduska in the approved minutes)Citizens' comments, Ward 1; CMS sixth-grade teacher and SREA building representativeThanks the CMS PTO (0:15:07); certification limits on redeployment (2:06:18 to 2:08:38). The project prints no spelling of this surname as fact pending a ruling; the dialogue file gives the first name only.
Tammy YatesCitizens' comments; Maple Avenue teacher, SREA presidentResearch on school moves (1:36:46 to 1:39:38).
Michelle Springer-BlakeCitizens' comments, Ward 2Behavioral supports, alternative programs (1:39:56 to 1:42:39). Dialogue file: Michelle Springer.
Molly DeLucaCitizens' comments, Ward 1; Superintendent Advisory CommitteeAsks the board to slow down (1:43:10 to 1:46:01).
Leslie PeabodyCitizens' comments, Ward 1; Stevens science teacher and parentMulti-year plan (1:46:21 to 1:49:06).
Sam TorresCitizens' comments, Ward 1Playgrounds and enrollment decline (1:55:09 to 1:57:32).
Michelle BeatonCitizens' comments, Ward 2Preschool data, staff turnover, secretaries, sixth-grade science (1:57:45 to 2:00:48). Name per minutes, and Sprague refers to "Mrs. Beaton" (2:19:11); she is Michelle Bian in the transcript and dialogue file, and the chair says Miss Beam.
Mimi RhinesCitizens' comments, Ward 1; Stevens staffRenovation money, board visits (2:01:00 to 2:03:30).
TylerCitizens' comments; district substituteRestructuring and Bluff (2:04:12 to 2:05:36). First name only in tape and minutes.
Amanda BartonCitizens' comments, Ward 2; parent and teacherPause restructuring a year (2:10:05 to 2:11:01).
Ken LownieCitizens' comments, Ward 2; Superintendent Advisory CommitteeAsks for a current-configuration option (2:11:32 to 2:12:23). Minutes spell Lowney; dialogue file Lownie; unresolved.
Cameron LownieCitizens' comments, Ward 2Burden of proof for change (2:12:53, 2:13:04). Minutes: Cameron Lowney; dialogue file: Camron Lownie; unresolved.
UnidentifiedAudience member; former SAU special-education office employee (self-described)Brief remark on how the proposal was worded (2:14:40, 2:14:40). Not named on tape or in the minutes.
Alicia SiminoCitizens' comments; Maple Avenue first-grade teacher, formerly at BluffRepeated moves for young students (2:14:57 to 2:16:45). Name per minutes; tape Alicia Seminole; dialogue file Alicia Simoneau.
UnidentifiedAudience memberDisputes a quoted Kearsarge tuition figure (2:31:03).

Agenda

Official agenda items (CSB 12.17.25 Agenda Final) and their disposition. Votes and movers per the approved minutes, checked against the recording.
Taken upItemAgenda text / disposition
0:00:00I. Call to order and Pledge (6:30 p.m. scheduled)Called to order by the chair; pledge led (0:00:16).
0:00:40II. Roll callSix present, Petrin absent (minutes).
0:01:10II.a Consent agenda: agenda, 12/3/25 minutes, manifestAmended to add Hawkins's follow-ups and the technical advisory as item 10; approved without objection (0:04:52). Minutes: "Consent approval".
0:04:52II.b Citizens' comments (policy BEDH)Seven speakers on non-agenda items.
0:16:42II.c Finance update (Angell)Report; cash, loan, encumbrances, possible deficit warrant article.
0:18:59II.d Follow-up items: PD, welcome to SAU, Title IX, sound in roomReport; Hawkins adds volunteer coordinator, board e-mail practice and preschool services.
0:22:55III.1 Executive summary; III.2 Donation acceptancesNo separate executive summary heard. Ski and snowboard: $4,000 Mt. Sunapee Ski Club and $3,000 Kiwanis (agenda: "$2800 Kiwanis Donation") accepted, Hawkins/Sprague, voice vote. CMS band gift ($49,775) not acted on; set for a January 7 hearing (0:31:28).
0:31:28III.3 Approval of budget calendar (vote)Amended to move the hearing to January 20; Madden/Sprague (minutes); voice vote, carried (0:36:03).
0:36:18III.4 Default budget and options summary (discussion)Presentation of four-school and three-school FY27 budgets; no default figure; no vote; public comment extended by 15 minutes (2:06:03).
2:27:01III.5 Elementary and middle-school tuition rates (vote)$15,000 elementary, $15,500 middle school for FY 2026-27; Crawford/Howard; voice vote, carried (2:31:45).
2:31:45III.6 Acceptance of retirees (vote)Five retirements accepted with regret; Hawkins/Sprague; voice vote (2:34:06).
2:34:23III.7 SHS positions: attendance secretary, restorative school day (vote)Both restored; Sprague/Howard; voice vote, carried (2:42:00); described as budget neutral.
2:42:14III.8 Subcommittee reportsPolicy: EBBCA and IKC adopted on first read, GBGBA withdrawn, each Hawkins/Sprague by voice vote. Ad hoc superintendent search: summary promised for January 7. SRVRTC: holiday kits.
2:53:28III.9 Nonpublic sessionAgenda and minutes cite "RSA 91-A:2, III"; roll call to enter and to leave; 9:24 to 10:22 p.m. (minutes). See flags 1 and 2.
2:54:42III.10 School board clerk stipend (vote)Additional $300 a month; Hawkins/Sprague; voice vote (2:56:18).
2:56:30Added item: technical advisory on recording studentsDiscussion; referred to counsel.
3:00:20IV. Other business; V. Future datesMadden's questions; adjournment (3:03:35); minutes: 10:31 p.m. Future dates read from the agenda in the minutes: January 7, 2026 meeting and the budget hearing.

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/17046 SchoolBoard121725.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Discussion timeline, December 17, 2025
TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:00Call to order, pledge, rollThe chair calls the meeting to order; the clerk's roll is garbled in the transcript ("Jacob Crawford here. Hoffman here. Lauren Howard here.", 0:00:40) and the name Michael draws no answer. Minutes: present Crawford, Hawkins, Howard, Madden, Sprague, Whitney; absent Petrin.OBS
0:01:10Consent agendaAgenda amended: Hawkins adds follow-up items and a technical advisory on recording students becomes item 10 (0:04:08, 0:04:32); 12/3/25 minutes and manifest approved without objection (0:04:52). Crawford asks the public to hold budget comments until after the presentation (0:02:16); the chair reads policy BEDH (0:02:30).POS
0:05:29Citizens' comments, non-agendaDon Lavalette (Ward 2) favors a district-run search and an educator-led model (0:07:21). Matt Bean (Ward 1) answers the posting of his coaching stipends (0:07:47). Erica Abby (Ward 3) asks about the $3,000 for a tech program (0:10:29). Kara Girardi asks the board to resign and says she has no insurance (0:11:01). Shaylor Duranleau, temporary plumbing and heating teacher, says the CBA's pay scale cannot attract tech instructors (0:13:19). Cassandra Edwards (Ward 3) answers the Finance Committee's dental-insurance remark: "It's because we find better value other places." (0:14:48). A Ward 1 CMS teacher thanks the CMS PTO (0:15:07).POS
0:16:42Finance updateCash in the general ledger "just over $900,000"; "Claremont Savings Bank loan currently is at 1,917,000"; first state aid payment in early January (0:16:56). Revenues through November 18,612,000, expenditures 12,441,000 (0:17:25). "Encumbrances are $21,573,000"; a SchoolCare health assessment of "$868,000" encumbered in December (0:17:50). "a possible warrant article to fund the deficit" to be discussed next meeting (0:18:18).
0:18:59Follow-up itemsTitle IX training for principals (0:19:29); Scott Maple named attendance officer (0:20:00); room audio: an estimate of "roughly $10,000" for speakers (0:20:57). Hawkins asks whether 15 identified preschool students lack services (0:22:33).
0:22:55Ski and snowboard donationsKennedy presents the CMS program (0:23:21); Kiwanis will give 3000, making $7,000 with the ski club's 4000 (0:27:23, 0:27:35). Hawkins moves, Sprague seconds (0:28:41, 0:28:41); carried by voice, no opposition (0:29:28).OBS
0:29:41CMS band donationKennedy: the $49,775 gift was not properly warned; newspaper notice placed; tabled to January 7 (0:29:41, 0:30:51, 0:31:28).POS
0:31:28Budget calendarAngell moves the budget hearing from January 14 "to the deadline of January 20th" (0:32:04) and reads the calendar (0:32:39); deliberative session February 7, snow date February 9 (0:35:16). Madden moves, Sprague seconds per minutes; carried by voice (0:36:03).OBS
0:36:18Default budget and options: Finance chair's statementCrawford reads the premises: "no decisions will be made tonight" (0:37:27); last year's budget had "missing and incorrect data" (0:37:53); "The school board has not yet taken a position on either model." (0:38:29); no reduction in teaching staff (0:39:00); 3% for non-union staff and an 11.8% health increase, about $600,000 (0:39:38); machine tool restored, alternative programs to Bluff (0:40:37); athletics and arts restored, no money for building repairs (0:41:12); SAU staff 16 to 14 and no superintendent-search money (0:42:03); "The rest of the board did not have it until tonight." (0:43:22).OBS
0:45:14Presentation: the two modelsKennedy: "the four school model is not as schools exist today" (0:45:14). Angell: NESDEC projects "1089 students districtwide" in ten years (0:53:04). Four-school model: PreK-2 and 3-5 split between Maple Avenue and Disnard, CMS 6-8, Stevens 9-12 (0:53:50 to 0:56:57). Three-school model: PreK-2, an upper elementary 3-6 at CMS, Stevens 7-12 (1:02:27).
1:09:47Budget totalsCurrent year "$43,179,564"; four-school "$44,861,008", "3.89%", "$1,681,444" (1:09:47); three-school "$43,968,104 or 1.83% increase, or $788,580" at "$18.09 per thousand" (1:11:04). The slide gives $788,540 and a four-school rate of $18.82 (the tape renders it "$18.88 $0.82", 1:10:28).OBS
1:11:34Bluff School and next stepsKennedy: alternative education at Bluff and a regional special-education collaborative renting the building (1:11:34 to 1:12:49). Questions to Angell by December 30, answers January 7 (1:13:44, 1:14:07); $190,000 food-service line missing from the PDF (1:14:22).
1:15:00Board questionsCrawford explains the budget's columns and placeholder figures (1:15:00 to 1:19:28). Sprague: the totals exclude revenues (1:20:37). Howard reports public preference for keeping K-5 schools next year (1:21:37). Hawkins asks the cost of keeping the current configuration one more year (1:23:21 to 1:24:46). Sprague asks about restored secretaries and custodians (1:26:25); Angell: next year funded at pre-cut levels (1:27:22). Whitney: reserve funds depleted, no capacity for a building emergency (1:27:54, 1:28:25); Crawford: a $20 million Tech Center renovation at 75% state share under current law (1:32:23).
1:34:35Public forum and comment rulesKennedy: a public forum planned for January 5 or 6 (1:34:35). The chair sets three minutes per speaker and 30 minutes total, extendable by the board (1:36:22).POS
1:36:46Citizens' comments on the budgetTammy Yates, SREA president, asks what research supports repeated moves (1:36:46 to 1:39:38). Michelle Springer-Blake (Ward 2) on behavioral supports and alternative-program requirements (1:40:00). Molly DeLuca (Ward 1): "Urge the board to slow this process down." (1:45:39). Leslie Peabody (Ward 1) asks for a multi-year plan (1:46:41). Shaylor Duranleau asks about one-time moving costs ("It's not captured.", 1:49:37) and suggests banking savings in reserves (1:50:12). Cassandra Edwards warns of staff departures (1:51:40). Erica Abby opposes separating special-education students (1:53:05). Sam Torres (Ward 1) on playgrounds and decline (1:55:09 to 1:57:32). Michelle Beaton (Ward 2) on preschool data, staffing and secretaries (1:57:46 to 2:00:35). Mimi Rhines (Ward 1) on renovation money and board visits (2:01:00, 2:03:06). Tyler, a district substitute (2:04:12 to 2:05:36).
2:05:41Extension and further commentsHawkins moves to extend 15 minutes; carried (2:05:55, 2:06:03). A Ward 1 CMS teacher on certification limits (2:06:18); Matt Bean against one school for self-contained programs (2:09:10); Amanda Barton (Ward 2) (2:10:05); Ken Lownie (Ward 2) asks for a current-configuration option (2:11:55, 2:12:23); Cameron Lownie (Ward 2) (2:13:04); a former SAU special-education office employee, unnamed (2:14:40); Alicia Simino, Maple Avenue teacher (2:15:09 to 2:16:45).POS
2:17:16Board responsesHoward asks whether the default budget will be the status quo; Angell: "it's going to have to mirror the model to get selected" (2:17:55); Howard: "a default budget does not mean the status quo" (2:18:40). Hawkins on athletics funding (2:20:49); Angell: "I'm essentially over funding athletics" against prior years (2:22:09). Whitney and Kennedy on the alternative program, "which is out of compliance" (2:24:10, 2:24:37), and a nonprofit funding model discussed "when we had our finance meeting" (2:25:25).OBS OBS
2:27:01Elementary and middle-school tuition rates"We did discuss this at a previous nonpublic." (2:27:01). Angell recommends 15000 and 15,500 (2:27:32); comparisons read (2:30:44). Crawford moves, Howard seconds (2:29:24, 2:29:33); carried by voice (2:31:45).OBS
2:32:20Acceptance of retireesKennedy reads five retirements at year end (2:32:20 to 2:33:28). Hawkins moves, Sprague seconds (2:33:42, 2:33:48); carried "with regret" (2:34:06).
2:34:23Stevens High School positionsPrincipal Herrington asks to recall the attendance secretary and fund a restorative school day position against the departed assistant principal's salary and benefits (2:34:47 to 2:37:41). Sprague moves, Howard seconds (2:38:02, 2:38:13). Madden supports it but asks to present one meeting and vote the next (2:40:20). The chair calls it budget neutral (2:41:33); minutes: all present in favor.
2:42:14Policy subcommitteeEBBCA (AEDs) adopted on first read on Hawkins's motion, Sprague second (2:46:54, 2:48:00); IKC (academic honors) adopted on first read (2:48:29, 2:48:45); GBGBA withdrawn (2:48:58, 2:49:19). The committee now includes two building administrators (2:49:32).
2:50:10Superintendent search; Tech CenterMadden: the ad hoc committee will bring an executive summary to the next meeting (2:50:28 to 2:51:42). Crawford promotes the Tech Center's holiday kits (2:52:13).
2:53:28Nonpublic sessionSprague moves under "RSA 91, dash a colon, two comma three" (2:53:47); Whitney seconds; roll call (2:54:11 to 2:54:16). The tape resumes on the motion to return (2:54:24). Minutes: in 9:24 p.m., out 10:22 p.m.HIGH MEDIUM
2:54:42School board clerk stipendThe clerk's role expanded with no administrative assistant (2:54:42); Hawkins moves an additional $300 a month from the board's line, Sprague seconds (2:55:51, 2:56:01); carried (2:56:18).
2:56:30NHDOE technical advisory on recording studentsKennedy: a new advisory requires written parental permission for recordings, starting with the English-language-proficiency speaking test in January; districts differ on sporting events (2:56:31 to 2:58:13). The chair asks that Drummond Woodsum handle it (2:59:26).
3:00:20Other business and adjournmentMadden asks whether the attendance officer can drive homeless students; Kennedy: not now (3:00:24, 3:00:29); Madden queries a psychological-evaluation charge (3:02:46). Motion to adjourn (3:03:35); minutes: "Consent adjournment at 10:31pm".OBS

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on December 17, 2025, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.

HIGH The motion to enter nonpublic session cited RSA 91-A:2, III, which holds no exemption, and the agenda and minutes attach different texts to the same letters

RSA 91-A:3, I(b): "Any motion to enter nonpublic session shall state on its face the specific exemption under paragraph II which is relied upon as foundation for the nonpublic session." On tape, Board Member Sprague moved "We go to nonpublic session under RSA 91, dash a colon, two comma three, for the purpose of discussing, a matter of which the public body has supervision, control and so on." (2:53:47). No lettered exemption is spoken, and RSA 91-A:2, III is the electronic-participation paragraph ("A public body may, but is not required to, allow one or more members of the body to participate in a meeting by electronic or other means"). The paperwork compounds it. The agenda heads the item "RSA 91-A:2, III" and then quotes, as (a), the collective-bargaining exclusion from the definition of a meeting in RSA 91-A:2, I(a) ("Strategy or negotiations with respect to collective bargaining"), followed by the tuition-contract exemption that is actually RSA 91-A:3, II(k). The approved public minutes record the motion as "under RSA 91-A:2, III (a & k)" but print under the heading the text of RSA 91-A:3, II(a) (dismissal, promotion, compensation or discipline of an employee). So the same (a) means collective bargaining in the agenda and employee compensation in the minutes, and the cited paragraph contains neither. In mitigation, the separate nonpublic-session form ticks RSA 91-A:3, II(a) and II(k) correctly, the entry vote was by roll call as I(b) requires (Yes six times, 2:54:11 to 2:54:16; minutes: "Roll call vote taken by Noelle Kronberg, all present voting in favor"), and the matters recorded (personnel, board-clerk compensation, administrators' negotiations) fit II(a) at least in part. Two further points from the nonpublic minutes: no tuition-contract matter is recorded despite the II(k) tick, and "administrators' negotiations" is collective-bargaining strategy, which RSA 91-A:2, I(a) removes from the definition of a meeting rather than listing among the II exemptions. Graded HIGH because the motion as made and as minuted does not state an exemption under paragraph II, which is the requirement I(b) puts on its face.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, I(b), II(a), II(k), III (nonpublic sessions: motion must state the exemption; 72-hour disclosure); RSA 91-A:2, I(a), II, III (collective-bargaining exclusion; minutes contents as amended 2025, 112:1; electronic participation); CSB 12.17.25 Agenda Final (1).pdf; 12.17.25 Approved CSB Meeting Minutes; 12.17.25 CSB Nonpublic Meeting session minutes unsealed

MEDIUM A decision taken in nonpublic session was not reported in public, and the earliest public copy of the nonpublic minutes found is dated nine days later

The nonpublic minutes record: "Heather Whitney made a motion for the Board to authorize Arlene Hawkins to negotiate the CAA agreement, Frank Sprague seconded the motion", carried on a roll call. On return to public session the chair moved straight to the clerk's stipend (2:54:42); no decision was announced, and the approved public minutes do not mention it. RSA 91-A:3, III: "Minutes and decisions reached in nonpublic session shall be publicly disclosed within 72 hours of the meeting, unless, by recorded vote of 2/3 of the members present taken in public session" the body seals them on a stated ground. No seal vote was taken in public (the tape shows none, and the form's sealing section is blank). The deadline was therefore Saturday, December 20, 2025. The only public copy found, a PDF titled "12.17.25 CSB Nonpublic Meeting session minutes unsealed", was created in Drive at 10:36 p.m. Eastern on December 26, 2025 (UTC timestamp 2025-12-27, 03:36), nine days after the meeting; its title calls it "unsealed" although nothing was sealed. Drive creation dates show when a file reached that folder, not whether the minutes were disclosed earlier in some other way, so this is graded MEDIUM rather than HIGH.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, I(b), II(a), II(k), III (nonpublic sessions: motion must state the exemption; 72-hour disclosure); 12.17.25 CSB Nonpublic Meeting session minutes unsealed; 12.17.25 Approved CSB Meeting Minutes

OBSERVATION The approved minutes carry the agenda's scheduled "6:30 PM" but no actual call-to-order time

Since 2025, 112:1 (eff. Aug. 22, 2025), RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes to include "the start time and end time of the meeting, and name of the person who produced the minutes". The approved minutes give the end time ("Consent adjournment at 10:31pm") and the producer ("Respectfully submitted by Noelle Kronberg, school board clerk"), and they reproduce the agenda's printed schedule, including "6:30 PM Call to Order", but they record no actual start. The recording supports a start close to 6:30: the motion to enter nonpublic session falls at 2:53:47 of tape against the minuted 9:24 p.m. entry, which puts the call to order at about 6:30 p.m., and 6:30 p.m. to 10:31 p.m. less the 58-minute nonpublic session is 3 hours 3 minutes, against a recording that runs 3:03:45. The gap is one of form, so it is an observation. The minutes otherwise name every mover and seconder, as the statute requires.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, I(a), II, III (collective-bargaining exclusion; minutes contents as amended 2025, 112:1; electronic participation); 12.17.25 Approved CSB Meeting Minutes

OBSERVATION The "Default Budget" item produced no default-budget figure, and the business administrator's account of the law is narrower than the statute's text

Agenda item 4 was "Default Budget & Options Summary". No default-budget amount was stated. Asked whether the default would represent the current five-school budget, the interim business administrator said "when I reviewed the laws, it's going to have to mirror the model to get selected. So if the school board decides that it's going to do a for school model, I have to do a for school default budget." (2:17:55). RSA 40:13, IX(b) defines the default budget as "the amount of the same appropriations as contained in the operating budget authorized for the previous year, reduced and increased, as the case may be, by debt service, contracts, and other obligations previously incurred or mandated by law, and reduced by one-time expenditures contained in the operating budget and by salaries and benefits of positions that have been eliminated in the proposed budget." The chosen model can move the default through the eliminated-positions clause, but the statutory starting point is last year's appropriations, not the chosen model. Board Member Howard drew the practical conclusion that "a default budget does not mean the status quo" (2:18:40) and asked for a current-configuration option (2:19:00). The budget hearing was later moved to January 20, 2026 (0:32:04), the third Tuesday in January and the last day RSA 40:13, II-a allows.

Sources: RSA 40:13, II-a, IX(b) (budget hearing by the third Tuesday in January; default budget defined); CSB 12.17.25 Agenda Final (1).pdf

OBSERVATION Board members received the 200-page budget the night of the meeting, and the public packet copies went up the next morning

Finance Committee chair Crawford: "It is about a 200 page budget. I have had it. I've gone through it. I do have some questions. The rest of the board did not have it until tonight." (0:43:22). The two operating-budget PDFs and the presentation slides were created in the packet folder at about 9:30 a.m. on December 18, 2025, the morning after; the final agenda PDF was created at 5:10 p.m. on December 17, eighty minutes before the meeting. Small inconsistencies show the pace: the operating-budget file names are dated 12.16.2026 and the slide deck "12/17/26"; the tape gives the three-school increase as "$788,580" (1:11:04) where the slide and the arithmetic ($43,968,104 less $43,179,564) give $788,540; and a $190,000 food-service contribution was missing from the PDF budget because of a system setup problem (1:14:22). No decision was taken on the budget that night, and members were asked to send questions by December 30 for written answers on January 7 (1:13:44), which mitigates the late delivery.

Sources: CSD FY 26-27 Budget Presentation.pdf; CSB 12.17.25 Agenda Final (1).pdf; RSA 40:13, II-a, IX(b) (budget hearing by the third Tuesday in January; default budget defined)

OBSERVATION The Kiwanis gift was noticed on the agenda at $2,800 and accepted at $3,000

RSA 198:20-b, III(b): for unanticipated funds under $20,000 the "school board shall post notice of the funds in the agenda and shall include notice in the minutes of the school board meeting in which such funds are discussed." The agenda lists "$2800 Kiwanis Donation"; the interim superintendent reported that Kiwanis "is going to donate 3000" (0:27:23); the motion and the minutes accept "$3000 from the Kiwanis". Both amounts are well under $20,000, the minutes carry the notice, and the change was stated openly, so this is a record discrepancy, not a missed hearing. RSA 198:20-b, I conditions the board's authority on a district enabling vote, which was not checked for this page.

Sources: RSA 198:20-b, III (unanticipated funds: hearing at $20,000 or more; agenda and minutes notice below); CSB 12.17.25 Agenda Final (1).pdf; 12.17.25 Approved CSB Meeting Minutes

OBSERVATION The tuition rates were said to have been discussed at an earlier nonpublic session

Introducing the elementary and middle-school tuition rates, the chair said "We did discuss this at a previous nonpublic." and referred to "the discussion that we had in the previous nonpublic about the, stratification of our tuition" (2:27:01). The board then set $15,000 (elementary) and $15,500 (middle school) for FY 2026-27 in public, on Crawford's motion seconded by Howard (2:29:24, 2:29:33); minutes: "Voice vote taken, all present voting in favor". RSA 91-A:3, II(k) allows nonpublic consideration of "entering into a student or pupil tuition contract", and the same paragraph requires that the contract and "minutes of all meetings held in nonpublic sessions" on it be made public before approval. Setting a general rate is not obviously entering into a contract, and which earlier nonpublic session is meant, and whether its minutes were disclosed, is not established from this record.

Sources: RSA 91-A:3, I(b), II(a), II(k), III (nonpublic sessions: motion must state the exemption; 72-hour disclosure); 12.17.25 Approved CSB Meeting Minutes

OBSERVATION The chair and the interim superintendent described the alternative program at the Tech Center as out of compliance, without naming the rule

Summarizing the administration's Bluff School concept, the chair described "the alternative program that exists at the tech right now" and added "Right, which is out of compliance." (2:24:10, 2:24:37); the approved minutes attribute the same point to the interim superintendent ("it exists at the tech and is out of compliance right now"). Neither identified the standard. At the December 12 Finance Committee session the administrators said the program's staff had no budget line. A program the district itself calls noncompliant, carried into a budget year with its location undecided, is worth a reviewer's attention; the record does not say which rule it fails.

Sources: 12.17.25 Approved CSB Meeting Minutes; Finance Committee, December 12, 2025, flag 3

POSITIVE A $49,775 gift was held back for a noticed public hearing rather than accepted the same night

The interim superintendent reported grant funding of 49,775 toward restoring the middle-school music program and said "I thought I had put it on the agenda to be warned it was not a sufficient enough and I apologize. We have gotten since put it out to make sure it's in the newspaper as well. And so we are now actually tabling it until the January 7th one." (0:29:41, 0:30:51). RSA 198:20-b, III(a) requires, for $20,000 or more, a prior public hearing with newspaper notice "at least 7 days before the meeting is held"; the minutes record that it "Will be warranted for a public hearing during next agenda since it is over $20,000". The district caught its own notice gap and deferred acceptance to meet the statute.

Sources: RSA 198:20-b, III (unanticipated funds: hearing at $20,000 or more; agenda and minutes notice below); 12.17.25 Approved CSB Meeting Minutes

POSITIVE Public comment ran well past the statutory minimum, with a vote to extend it

RSA 189:74 requires a public comment period of "no less than 30 minutes". The board held two periods: seven speakers on non-agenda items before the business (0:05:29 to 0:16:33), and, after the budget presentation, a 30-minute period on the agenda item that the board extended by 15 minutes on Hawkins's motion (2:05:55, 2:06:03), followed by the board's responses, as policy BEDH provides. About eighteen people spoke on the budget, several of them twice. The chair also stated the policy's rules at the outset (0:02:30 to 0:03:36).

Sources: RSA 189:74 (public comment period of no less than 30 minutes); Claremont policy BEDH (public comment and participation)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page