Claremont School Board, Budget Public Hearing (part 1 of 2), January 3, 2018

First of two recordings of the board's public hearing on the proposed 2018-19 budget and warrant articles: the superintendent's presentation, the business administrator's warrant-article and revenue reconciliation, and the first hour of public testimony, during which four board members voted to overrule the chair's call for a break. The page is built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript; no agenda, packet or minutes survive in the district's online shares. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6), holding the budget hearing for the March 2018 annual meeting
Date
Wednesday, January 3, 2018
Start time
Not stated in available records. The chair calls the hearing to order at 0:00:14 and apologizes, "Sorry. We got a late start." (0:00:45). The board's regular meeting had already opened with a roll call and gone into nonpublic session before the hearing (see the regular meeting, part 1). This recording ends during Andrea Wilson's testimony; the transcript runs 1:05:49, and the hearing continues in part 2.
Location
Not stated in available records. The superintendent speaks of "most of us in this auditorium" (0:05:02); in part 2 a teacher says she teaches at Stevens High School, speaking of it as here, and at the January 31, 2018 meeting a member refers to the auditorium as it was set up for the public hearing, which points to the Stevens High School auditorium.
Recording
Cablecast: Part 1 of 2 SCHOOL BUDGET HEARING 1-3-18 (transcript length 1:05:49; continues in part 2). The chair tells viewers the hearing was not carried live (0:00:51).
Minutes
None located. MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting: neither district share holds a year folder older than 2022, and the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023 (checked 9/26/26). Minutes of this hearing did exist: at the January 31, 2018 meeting the chair takes up the minutes of the public hearing and corrects a speaker's name on page seven before they are approved (Cablecast show 9586).
Board composition
Seven members (a member: "the board is made up of seven people", 0:55:44). The seven who vote by roll call at the regular meeting that follows are Brian Rapp (chair), Chris Irish (vice chair), Alex Herzog, Michael Petrin, Michelle Pierce, Frank Sprague and Rebecca Zullo. Only the chair is identifiable by voice in this part.

Participants

Everyone heard or addressed on this recording. There are no minutes to check spellings against; names follow self-introductions as transcribed, corrected to the project roster where the roster has a verified spelling, and the participation cell says where a spelling is unverified.
NameRoleParticipation
Brian RappChairCalls the hearing to order (0:00:14), explains the missing live broadcast, sets a three-minute limit for speakers (0:31:22) and recognizes commenters. Heather Irish addresses him as Brian (0:52:14). When he calls a break during Matt Bean's testimony, members vote to overrule him; a member says "We run the meeting, not Mr. Roth" [Rapp] (0:55:01).
Board members (not individually identifiable)MembersBoard-table voices object to the time limit ("We do not agree to his time.", 0:52:52) and move and vote to overrule the chair (0:54:21 to 0:55:44). The diarizer merges these voices with the chair's, and the attribution review left all of them Unidentified.
Middleton McGoodwinSuperintendent, SAU 6Introduces himself (transcribed "Middleton Goodwin", 0:01:31) and gives the budget presentation: state cost shifts, the board's directive, student-outcome goals, the December 20 budget and tax effects. Answers the question about teaching positions and lists the reductions (0:36:30 to 0:44:22).
Michael O'NeillDirector of business and finance (business administrator), SAU 6"I'm Mike O'Neill, director of business and finance." (0:24:10). Walks through a handout of warrant-article totals and estimated revenues, and answers the food-service question (0:35:18).
Jason BenwareCitizens' comments, Ward 1Introduces himself as "Jason Ben Ward one" (0:29:28); spelling per the project roster, which records him sworn in as a board member on March 21, 2018. Speaks twice: on the lost tax decrease, and later questioning the superintendent's presentation and asking about the psychologist and crisis-counselor positions.
Joe OsgoodCitizens' comments, Ward 2"Joe Osgood, Ward two." (0:32:02; spelling unverified). Speaks for low-income and elderly taxpayers and argues that a one percent reduction can be found.
Carolyn TowleCitizens' comments (ward stated as Ward 1 in part 2)Introduces herself (transcribed "Carolyn tall", 0:34:26); spelling per the project roster, which records her sworn in as a board member on March 21, 2018. Asks about the food-service line.
UnidentifiedCitizens' comments; Stevens graduate (class of 1979), teaches at River Valley Community CollegeHer name is not audible (0:35:54). Asks whether teaching positions will be cut, then argues against cutting English positions and for growing the tax base.
Heather IrishCitizens' comments, Ward 3; former board member"Hi, I'm Heather Irish, Ward three. I sat on this board for several years" (0:48:57). Supports the board's reduction and criticizes the administration's presentation.
Matt BeanCitizens' comments, Ward 2Self-introduction transcribed "I'm at being War two" (0:52:58); the name rests on the attribution review's match with a Ward 2 speaker at the December 20, 2017 meeting who also defended the crisis counselor, so it is uncertain. His testimony is interrupted by the dispute over the break.
UnidentifiedStevens High School administrator; former selectman in another town"I was a selectman in my town for six years" (1:00:58). Says the administrators' lists were answers to the board's number, not recommendations. At the January 31, 2018 meeting the chair corrected the hearing minutes to name a Patty Harrison of Wethersfield, Vermont, as a speaker; this speaker's out-of-town civic role fits, but nothing on this recording confirms it, so the page does not name her.
Andrea WilsonCitizens' comments, Ward 1Recognized by name at 1:04:44 (the words sit at the end of the previous speaker's row) and gives "Ward one" (1:05:05). Criticizes the superintendent for not following the board's directive; her testimony continues in part 2.

Order of business (reconstructed)

No agenda survives. A board-table voice says the three-minute limit "says so on the agenda" (0:52:44), so one was distributed. The list below is reconstructed from the chair's transitions on this recording.

Items in the order taken up on this recording
Taken upItemWhat happened
0:00:14Call to order, Pledge of Allegiance"Call the public hearing to order." The chair then tells viewers the hearing is "not live" (0:00:51).
0:01:31Superintendent's budget presentationPowerPoint on state cost shifts, the board's September 30 directive, student goals, the December 20 budget of $31,148,257 and tax effects; hands off to the business administrator at 0:23:24.
0:24:08Warrant-article totals and estimated revenuesBusiness administrator walks through a printed handout: operating budget, security upgrades, bus lease, roofing, and revenue changes; asks for questions at 0:28:57.
0:29:28Public testimonyEight speakers on this recording, three minutes each by the chair's rule (0:31:22). Testimony is interrupted at 0:52:33 by a dispute over the time limit and the chair's break, which a board majority overrules (0:54:21 to 0:55:44); testimony resumes at 0:55:58.
1:05:05Testimony continuesAndrea Wilson is speaking when the recording ends at 1:05:49; part 2 picks up with her remarks.

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/9547 SchoolBoardBudgetHearing010318.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

Topics in the order discussed
TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:51Hearing not carried liveChair: "We are not live. You probably know that because you're watching this on a tape." Viewers who ask should be told "they were not able to do it for us tonight. Something about the weather or the ice or something."; the recording would air "on a delay later tonight" (0:01:15).OBS
0:01:31Purpose of a public hearingThe superintendent contrasts a board meeting with a hearing: "in a public hearing, the board does seek public testimony" (0:02:18).
0:03:46The board's September 30 directive"They met on September 30th. That is their right, the public meeting. And they elected to arrive at a figure $1.2 million below the current fiscal year." He says he objected: "I wasn't going to be someone who would just sort of be a bobble head at that" (0:04:13), and "I believe I have a professional responsibility to say, could you would you reconsider?" (0:04:32).
0:07:44State cost shifts and adequacy aidBuilding aid's elimination meant "43 million was shifted to the property owners state" (0:08:19); for teacher retirement, "$80 million was shifted to the property taxpayers" (0:08:33). Between fiscal 2016 and 2017 "the drop was over $400,000. The impact on the tax rate was over half a dollar." (0:09:45).
0:10:28Senate Bill 193 (education savings accounts)The superintendent warns that under SB 193 school money would be "dispersed to children attending charter schools or home schooled students or private school students", about $9,000 a child by his estimate (0:11:20); "It has not been approved yet." (0:11:44).
0:12:50Budget trend"Here's a bubble 5.8%. That was the Stevens High School renovation pond." Over four years "our average annual percent change in the budget has been less than 0%." (0:14:22). He says he "had trouble" with a directive $1.2 million below the current year (0:14:51).
0:15:25Student growth and attendance goalsReading and math growth measured three times a year; a high school attendance goal of 93 percent against "a little over 91%" (0:17:33); from 2011-12 data, "130 students had ten or more tardiness as freshmen, 46 had 50 or more days tardy." (0:18:58).
0:19:40How the budget reached $31,148,257The administration presented a needs budget and a $1.2 million reduction, then "an alternative of $328,000 reductions. These were not our recommendations." After the December 20 vote, "tonight our budget is $31,148,257." (0:20:09). The board on December 20 "approved and ratified the solar [teachers'] collective bargaining agreement", about $307,000, and adequacy aid is expected to fall about $214,000 (0:21:04).
0:22:26Tax effect; default budget"The main budget as it stands now would be a reduction of $0.03 per thousand on the tax rate. If the default budget was approved, it would be an increase of $0.24." "Default budgets are supposed to be smaller. The default budget is larger because of the strategic compression". With the three special articles, "So if this remains the budget, the increase would be $0.03 per thousand." (0:23:24). The dollar amount of the default budget is not stated.OBS
0:24:10Warrant-article handoutO'Neill's handout is headed "Proposed Warren. Article totals fiscal year 18 to fiscal year 19" [warrant article totals]; copies are "right by the door" (0:24:36). Last year's operating budget "31 for 77247" [$31,477,247] (0:25:35); "This year's proposed operating budget is 31 for 55 for ten." [$31,455,410], because after the last meeting "the school board voted to ratify a CRACSEA CBA agreement. Easy for me to say the 307,153." Result: "down 21,000 837" [$21,837] (0:25:57).POS
0:26:39Special articles: security, bus lease, roofingSecurity upgrades $141,000 with no new tax effect because the same amount was raised last year; a bus lease replacing one that is paid off, since "the older busses are costing me about $30,000 in maintenance every year" (0:26:58); roofing at the middle school, "That would be this year 100,000." (0:27:19).
0:28:02Estimated revenuesTuition revenue up $50,000 after the board cut the rate "from 18,000 to 14 five". Adequacy "for the current year is 12 million 341 for 91" and "for next year is 12 million 077963, a reduction of 263,000 528", driven by "the reduction of the stabilization grant by the state, which is going to be 225,000 a year for 20 years." (0:28:28). "So overall revenues are projected to decrease by 213, 528" (0:28:57).OBS
0:29:28Benware: the tax decrease is goneWhere "several people thought there would be a 47 decrease in the tax rate", he says, "What we're looking at then, as it sits right now is a 30 cent increase, 33 cent increase." (the administration's figure is three cents). "Something to think about food for thought for all these seniors out there who barely can pay their taxes." (0:30:19).
0:31:22Three-minute limitChair: "We'd like to keep it to three minutes and let everybody get a chance to get their comments and questions in."OBS
0:32:02Osgood: low-income taxpayers"Ten times 46 is $460 on their taxes." (0:32:26); "1% in a $31 million budget should be able to be found." (0:33:50).
0:34:26Towle: food service line"I'm soon going to be 71 years old, and I am working full time". O'Neill: food service "is basically a break even program where we taken $650,000 of revenue" and spend the same, outside the general fund (0:35:18).
0:35:54Which positions would be cutQuestion: "are there going to be teaching positions eliminated and if so, what department?" (0:36:10). Superintendent: "we are projecting there will be a four positions at Stevens High School in elementary school position." (0:36:30); "the orange that we've been squeezing is dry." (0:36:56); personnel "represents over 75% of the budget." (0:37:18). His list: technology "a little under $1 million" (0:38:48), a psychologist, a crisis counselor, an assessment coordinator, a special education teacher, the adult education director, paraprofessionals, textbooks and maintenance; "That list represented about a half million dollars." (0:41:19).
0:44:35RVCC instructor: do not cut English"you absolutely cannot afford to cut teaching positions." She sees "students from Stevens who are less well prepared than their counterparts from Fall Mountain or Lebanon or Keene." (0:44:59), and favors "not not reducing taxes, but increasing the tax, the tax base." (0:47:08).
0:48:57Heather Irish: support for the board"So now the taxpayers are asking you a favor, and what I'm hearing is a board that wants to do that and administration that does not." (0:49:24); "These people have asked for something. And what I'm hearing instead are threats." (0:51:18); to the chair, "I love how you always do that with somebody who doesn't agree with you, Brian." (0:52:14).
0:52:33Dispute over the time limitHeather Irish: "I didn't see three minute limit." (0:52:35); a voice: "It says so on the agenda." (0:52:44); a board-table voice: "We did not time as the board. We do not agree to his time." (0:52:52).OBS
0:52:58Bean: vouchers and the crisis counselor"So vouchers are literally about to gut the public school system." He told the board "two weeks ago that that job saves children's lives".
0:53:49Board majority overrules the chair's break"Had just said, Brian, he has the right." "Our job is to sit and listen to the public." (0:53:55); "Was going to have to take a break." (0:54:04); "I make a motion. We overrule the chair." (0:54:21); "The chairman is leaving the meeting." "Four members have voted in the permanent. We run the meeting, not Mr. Roth." (0:55:01); "We just overruled your decision." (0:55:30); "On the board is made up of seven people. Not one. Four of us just voted." "Roberts rule says majority rules." (0:55:44). No break is taken.OBS
0:55:58Bean finishes"should be investing in our children and not cutting away from them." A voice then says "Sit down. Or are you going to walk away?" (0:56:20).
0:56:23Benware: second turn"Have you started the timer yet? Time me." (0:56:30). "I think the budget cut as they have presented it will not harm our children significantly or at all" (0:57:14). He asks whether "The psychologist position that people are concerned about getting cut, that is going to be supplemented by contracted services. Correct?" (0:57:42) and is told Correct. (0:57:58); on the crisis counselor, "the board as far as I know, did not suggest or request that they were cut." (0:58:06); "So my point is $32,500, one tenth of a percent of the total budget." (0:59:07).
0:58:28Superintendent: the board's instructionDescribing what the board told the administration: "You do the heavy lifting. Administration. This is our cut. You figure out how it's going to happen."
1:00:58Stevens administrator: "Sophie's Choice""I was a selectman in my town for six years". The administrators' lists were not recommendations: "none of what we gave you were recommendations." (1:01:16); "They were an answer to a request by the board to meet a certain number." (1:01:45); "What it felt like was Sophie's Choice." (1:02:06); "days and days, hours and hours of meetings were set with administration in closed rooms" (1:02:59).
1:05:05Andrea Wilson: the directive"I think by not following a directive that your board gives you is, just is not a use of school." She continues in part 2.

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on January 3, 2018, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.

MEDIUM No agenda, handout or minutes for this hearing survive in any district share

MAP.md records no Drive material: the district's shares hold no year folder older than 2022, and the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023. The agenda that printed the three-minute rule (0:52:44) and the warrant-article handout distributed at the door (0:24:36) are both gone, so the recording is the only public account of this hearing. RSA 91-A:2, II, in the text in force for all of 2018, required minutes that "shall include the names of members, persons appearing before the public bodies, and a brief description of the subject matter discussed and final decisions", open to public inspection "not more than 5 business days after the meeting". This page applies the MEDIUM limb of the project's severity rule because the record mitigates the gap: minutes were written, and the board took them up on January 31, 2018, when the chair corrected a speaker's name on page seven (Cablecast show 9586). Whether they were available within five business days cannot be tested. What is missing is any public copy now.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2017 codification; source note ends 2017, 165:1 and 234:1, eff. Jan. 1, 2018, so this is the 2018 text)

OBSERVATION Four members voted to overrule the chair's break during public testimony; the vote cannot be reconstructed from the recording

The chair set a three-minute limit (0:31:22), which a voice says was printed on the agenda (0:52:44). Board-table voices objected to his timekeeping ("We do not agree to his time.", 0:52:52). When the chair then called a break during Matt Bean's turn (0:54:04), a member moved "We overrule the chair." (0:54:21), and members then announced "Four members have voted" and "We run the meeting, not Mr. Roth" [Rapp] (0:55:01) and "Four of us just voted." (0:55:44). Someone says "The chairman is leaving the meeting." (0:55:01), but the chair is presiding again in part 2. The mover, the seconder, the members voting and the form of the vote are not discernible: the diarizer merges the chair and several members, and the attribution review left the passage Unidentified. The project has found no statute governing how a school board chair runs a budget hearing; a member invoked "Roberts rule" (0:55:44), and the board's own rules are not in the record. The rule that does apply is the minutes requirement: RSA 91-A:2, II required minutes to record "final decisions", so the January 3 minutes, which are not public, are the only place this vote could be documented. The 1/31/18 recording shows those minutes were approved with one unrelated correction.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2017 codification, in force for 2018: minutes include final decisions)

OBSERVATION The default budget was disclosed by its tax effect only; its dollar amount is not on the recording

RSA 40:13, XI(a), as it read before the August 2018 amendments, provided: "The default budget shall be disclosed at the first budget hearing held pursuant to RSA 32:5 or RSA 197:6." This appears to be that first hearing. The superintendent said that if the default budget were approved "it would be an increase of $0.24" per thousand, and explained why it was larger than the proposed budget (0:22:26, 0:22:59). The default budget's dollar amount is not read aloud during the hearing, and the handout that may have carried it does not survive. The figure was stated later that night at the regular meeting, where the transcript renders the figure as 35,111,787 and the business administrator puts it about $191,000 above the operating budget. Whether the disclosure at the hearing met XI(a) depends on what the handout showed. The superintendent's two tax figures also differ in sign: "a reduction of $0.03" for the main budget (0:22:26) and "the increase would be $0.03" with the special articles (0:23:24).

Sources: RSA 40:13, XI(a) (2017 codification; source note ends 2014, 7:1-4 and 190:1-3, 8-10, so in force until August 2018)

OBSERVATION The projected loss of adequacy aid follows the statutory phase-out of the stabilization grant

The business administrator projected adequacy falling from "12 million 341 for 91" to "12 million 077963" [$12,341,491 to $12,077,963], a reduction "driven by the reduction of the stabilization grant by the state" (0:28:28). RSA 198:41, IV(d), as it read in 2017, set a stabilization percentage that "shall be 96 percent for fiscal year 2017, and shall be reduced by 4 percent" for each fiscal year thereafter. The revenue loss the superintendent described as the State "downshifting" is in this respect a scheduled reduction written into statute. The page cannot verify Claremont's grant amount or the "225,000 a year for 20 years" figure; the transcript's numbers are internally consistent ($12,341,491 less $12,077,963 is $263,528, and $263,528 less the $50,000 tuition increase is the $213,528 decrease he cites at 0:28:57).

Sources: RSA 198:41, IV(d) (2017 codification; source note ends 2016, 8:4, 5 and 85:9, eff. July 18, 2016)

OBSERVATION The hearing date met both statutory windows

For an official-ballot district voting in March, RSA 40:13, II-a(c) required budget hearings "on or before the third Tuesday in January", which in 2018 was January 16. RSA 32:5, I, in the text then in force, required the hearing "not later than 25 days before each annual or special meeting", with notice "at least 7 days in advance". The first session was announced for Wednesday, February 7, 2018 (see part 2), 35 days after this hearing. The posting of the seven-day notice cannot be checked because no notice survives.

Sources: RSA 40:13, II-a(c) (2017 codification); RSA 32:5, I (2017 codification; source note ends 2014, 190:7, in force until Aug. 11, 2018)

OBSERVATION The hearing was not carried live, and residents who planned to watch from home could not

The chair announced that the hearing was "not live" and blamed the weather or ice (0:00:51); a Ward 3 resident said in part 2 that social media had lit up with complaints from people who stayed home expecting to watch. The project has found no rule that required a broadcast; the hearing itself was held in person and open to the public. The gap matters because the recording is now the only public account of the hearing (flag 1). At the January 31, 2018 meeting the assistant superintendent reported that CCTV had obtained equipment for a live feed from the auditorium for the deliberative session. Claremont Community Television (CCTV) / Claremont Community Media Center (CCMC), whose operation is the subject of this flag, made this recording and publishes these pages; see the footer.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2 (2017 codification, in force for 2018)

POSITIVE A written reconciliation of every warrant article and its tax effect was handed to the audience and walked through

The business administrator distributed a printed sheet of "Proposed Warren. Article totals fiscal year 18 to fiscal year 19" with estimated revenues on the back, made sure attendees had copies (0:24:36), and went through each article's amount and tax-rate effect, including the change in the operating budget from last year (0:25:35 to 0:28:57). RSA 32:5, I required a hearing, not a handout; giving the public the figures in writing at the hearing goes beyond that minimum. The sheet itself was not preserved in any public share (flag 1).

Sources: RSA 32:5, I (2017 codification)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page