Claremont School Board, Budget Public Hearing (part 2 of 2), January 3, 2018

Second of two recordings of the board's public hearing on the proposed 2018-19 budget: public testimony from sixteen residents and staff, an exchange between the vice chair and the chair over how the board's budget directive was handled, and the business administrator's account of the district's retained fund balance. The page is built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript; no agenda, packet or minutes survive in the district's online shares. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6), holding the budget hearing for the March 2018 annual meeting
Date
Wednesday, January 3, 2018
Start time
Continues part 1 without a break: Andrea Wilson, who was speaking when part 1 ended, is still speaking at 0:00:00. The chair announces the deliberative session and calls a short break before the regular meeting at 0:58:01; the transcript runs 0:58:08. No clock time is stated.
Location
Not stated in available records. A teacher says she teaches "here at Stevens High School" (0:13:38) and the chair says the deliberative session will be "Here in this. Room." (0:57:55), which points to the Stevens High School auditorium.
Recording
Cablecast: Part 2 of 2 - SCHOOL BUDGET HEARING OF 1-3-18 (transcript length 0:58:08). A Ward 3 resident says the hearing was not televised live (0:31:37).
Minutes
None located. MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting: neither district share holds a year folder older than 2022, and the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023 (checked 9/26/26). Minutes of the hearing were written and taken up for approval at the January 31, 2018 meeting (Cablecast show 9586); no copy is public now.
Board composition
Seven members: Brian Rapp (chair), Chris Irish (vice chair), Alex Herzog, Michael Petrin, Michelle Pierce, Frank Sprague and Rebecca Zullo, all of whom vote by roll call at the regular meeting that follows. In this part only the chair, the vice chair and one member (probably Zullo) speak.

Participants

Everyone heard or addressed on this recording. There are no minutes to check spellings against; names follow self-introductions as transcribed, corrected to the project roster where the roster has a verified spelling. Where a spelling rests only on the transcript, the participation cell says so.
NameRoleParticipation
Brian RappChairRuns the speaking order and allows a second round once everyone has spoken once (0:07:43). Answers a commenter on why the board left the cuts to the administration (0:39:52) and explains the health-insurance refund (0:50:14). Announces the deliberative session (0:57:36).
Chris IrishVice chairAnswers John Young for "The four of us that supported that budget on the 20th" (0:21:38); says the chair "was not there" when members met (0:40:49); cites about $2.2 million returned to the general fund over four years (0:42:36). Identification rests on content and on a commenter addressing him as Chris (0:46:38).
Rebecca Zullo (uncertain)MemberA member who says she did not support "the 1.7 million increase" and urges people to read the budget line by line (0:23:28). Richard Seaman then addresses her as Rebecca about "the kind of numbers that you were throwing out there" (0:36:08), which supports the attribution; it is not confirmed by voice.
Middleton McGoodwinSuperintendent, SAU 6Answers Joe on whether board and administration worked the budget together: "So the answer to your question is no." (0:39:26).
Michael O'NeillBusiness administrator, SAU 6Answers questions on the roof and paving money (0:11:34, 0:12:03) and on the retained fund balance (0:47:29 to 0:52:20). David Putnam's and Ellie Filene's remarks refer to him (Filene: "Mr. McNeil", 0:30:06).
Andrea WilsonCitizens' comments, Ward 1Continues from part 1. Tells the chair "We did not put you as the chair." (0:01:01) and praises teachers; asks about the English positions at Stevens.
Debbie LaffanCitizens' comments, Ward 1"Good evening. I'm Debbie Laffan from Ward one." (0:03:11; spelling as transcribed). Speaks for the Claremont Adult Learning Center and against cutting its director's position.
UnidentifiedCitizens' comments, Ward 1; Stevens High School school counselorLives on Park Avenue, in her second year as a counselor at Stevens (0:08:19); name not audible. Speaks against cutting the crisis counselor.
Jeremy (surname transcribed Zulu)Citizens' comments, Ward 3"Jeremy Zulu Ward three." (0:10:58). The dialogue file labels him Jeremy Zullo; that spelling is an inference from the roster's garble pattern for Rebecca Zullo and is unverified. Questions the roof and paving money and says there is "plenty of line items" to cut (0:12:30).
Larissa CahillCitizens' comments, Ward 2; Stevens High School teacher and parent"Larissa Cahill, Ward two I am a teacher here at Stevens High School." (0:13:38; spelling as transcribed). Speaks against losing the world language (German) teacher.
Marion LovettCitizens' comments; Stevens graduate and former student representative to the board"Hello, I'm Marion Lovett" (0:17:46; other project files spell the first name Marian). Cites online school ratings and the crisis counselor's role with bullying.
John YoungCitizens' comments (ward not stated)"I'm John Young. I spoke at the last meeting" (0:20:56). Asks why members who did not want the cuts did not support the first budget.
David PutnamCitizens' comments, Ward 2; former board chair"I did it for 17 years. It was my practice as school board chair" (0:25:50). Advises consensus before breaks, line items for known repairs, and a capital improvement plan; questions how retained funds are controlled (0:46:38).
Ellie FileneCitizens' comments, Ward 2; Maple Avenue School teacher"My name is Ellie Filene I am I live in Ward two" (0:28:51; spelling as transcribed). Says she is "appalled at the behavior by some of these adults in this room."
Nick (surname not audible)Citizens' comments, Ward 3"Nick Ward three" (0:31:11). Objects that the hearing was not televised and thanks a commenter for "trying to maintain decorum".
Jessie BurrillCitizens' comments, Ward 3; Stevens staff"I'm not a registered voter, but my name is Jessie Burrill. I live in Ward three." (0:32:39; spelling as transcribed). Repeats an invitation for members to shadow students at Stevens.
Richard SeamanCitizens' comments, Ward 3; former board member"Richard Seaman, Ward three, I believe." (0:34:04). Asks whether the budget is driven by savings or by need, and asks the board to hold an information session identifying the line items members believe can be cut (0:36:49).
Joe (probably Joe Osgood)Citizens' commentsHis self-introduction is transcribed "Good word to." (0:37:41), and the vice chair answers "To get to your point, Joe" (0:40:49). Joe Osgood of Ward 2 spoke in part 1, which makes him the likely speaker, but the recording does not confirm it. Asks whether board and administration ever went through the budget together, and suggests quarterly line-item reports (0:43:33).
Carolyn TowleCitizens' comments, Ward 1"Carolyn Tull, Ward one." (0:44:56); spelling per the project roster. Asks to see a spreadsheet of the savings the board majority proposed.
Derek Ferland (as transcribed)Citizens' comments, Ward 3"Derek Ferland, Ward three." (0:51:51); the name is unverified. Asks how much of the returned money was the one-time health-insurance refund and whether $1.7 million could come out of the roughly $8 million not tied to personnel.
UnidentifiedCitizens' comments; works in adult educationName not audible (0:55:29). She describes being a Stevens student in the 1970s and working at Claremont Adult Ed, which matches the River Valley Community College instructor who spoke in part 1, but the two cannot be tied together from the recordings.

Order of business (reconstructed)

No agenda survives; the list is reconstructed from the chair's transitions. Andrea Wilson says the three-minute limit appeared in the agenda for this meeting (0:00:18).

Items in the order taken up on this recording
Taken upItemWhat happened
0:00:00Public testimony, continuedAndrea Wilson finishes; the chair says that "after everyone's had a chance to speak once people will be allowed to speak again." (0:07:43). About fifteen further speakers follow, with answers from the superintendent, the business administrator and two members.
0:44:32Second round"Anybody else that wants to speak?" (0:44:36). Towle, Putnam (second time), Derek Ferland and an adult-education worker speak.
0:57:36Deliberative session announced; hearing endsThe chair's announcement is transcribed "47 for deliberative." and then "7th February." (0:57:50), "Here in this. Room." The regular meeting's agenda lists the session for Wednesday, February 7. The chair calls a quick break before the regular meeting (0:58:01). No formal close of the hearing is heard.

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/9548 SchoolBoardBudgetHearing010318.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

Topics in the order discussed
TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:18Wilson: the chair's conduct"Is Brian, you cutting people off? You interrupting?"; "Your body language at every meeting stinks." (0:00:38); "You're elected from your board members. We did not put you as the chair." (0:01:01). She asks about the English department: "three out of the four positions that Stevens are going to be in the English department" (0:02:11).
0:03:11Laffan: the adult education director"cutting the director's position will not only hurt the students of Stevens High School, but that of many students throughout Sullivan County." The director "has helped 55 students associated with Stevens High School graduate from the Claremont Adult High School, or recover classes" (0:05:04).
0:07:43Second round promisedChair: "And after everyone's had a chance to speak once people will be allowed to speak again."POS
0:08:19School counselor: the crisis counselor"The crisis counter cut is the one that breaks my heart the most" (0:08:42); without the position "The plan is going to be basically be emergency room." (0:09:03).
0:10:58Jeremy: roof and paving moneyO'Neill: "this is the fourth year in a row, we put a warrant article out there for $100,000 to do roof repairs" (0:11:34); the $70,000 parking-lot paving "was basically part of money that we were able to save through last year's budget" (0:12:03). Jeremy: "So right then and there, you're telling me that there's $70,000 that was saved because you've over budgeted?" (0:12:11); "You're trying to scare people into cutting the budget" (0:12:30).OBS
0:13:38Cahill: losing German"there is no such thing as a small cut because that's attached to resources, it's attached to people." (0:13:58); her daughter chose Stevens because "it offered German" (0:15:13); "If I had to make the decision again for my daughter, I don't know if I would." (0:16:46).
0:17:46Lovett: school ratings"Stevens High School's rated four out of ten" (0:18:07); "Claremont is rated 130th out of 153 New Hampshire school districts." (0:18:32); on another site the teachers drew the district's best grade, a B+ (0:18:56).
0:20:56Young: why not the first budget?"If you didn't want these cuts, why didn't you support the first budget".
0:21:38Irish answers: a bottom line, not cuts"The four of us that supported that budget on the 20th firmly believe out of a $31 million budget, there's way more than 328,000 we can save in other places without touching a teacher" ; "This board has not asked them to cut one single thing. We're giving them a bottom line, which as a board is the only authority we have." (0:21:59); "it's the first time I've ever had a board that actually crafted a budget with a specific intent to try to help the taxpayer." (0:22:42).
0:23:28A member (probably Zullo): over-estimated lines"I personally did not support the 1.7 million increase"; "Maybe we don't make it so that there's so much money at the end of the year that we need to spend it down and shuffle it around." (0:24:00); "you might not need to cut a crisis" (0:24:22).
0:25:50Putnam: breaks by consensus; line items for repairs"If we wished for a break in the meeting, that I would get a consensus from the whole board." On year-end money: "we returned them as a fund balance", and a needed paving job went "on the budget as a line item." (0:26:21), "So the public was aware of what they were spending money on." (0:26:42).OBS
0:28:51Filene: conduct in the room"I am appalled at the behavior by some of these adults in this room." "you cannot make an educated decision unless you have been in the schools and see things firsthand." (0:29:54).
0:31:11Nick: not televised"I think a large mistake happened tonight." "As far as this meeting not being televised on public access. So social media is lit up right now with complaints" (0:31:37); "it would have been proper to notify people that that wasn't going to happen." See part 1, flag 6.
0:32:39Burrill: shadow a studentInvitations to members to follow selected students, for "the week of the 12th, along with the 16th and the 17th" (0:33:24).
0:34:04Seaman: savings or needs?"I don't understand whether or not this budget is driven by savings, or whether this budget is driven by this is the proper amount of money" (0:34:40). To the member who cited over-budgeted lines: "Rebecca, I would like I have looked through the budgets here many, many times and was not able to identify the kind of numbers that you were throwing out there." (0:36:08); "please have an information session sometime over the next week or two." (0:36:49).
0:37:43Joe: did anyone go line by line together?"Did either one of you at the after this proposal was made say, hey, let's roll up our sleeves, let's go down through this line by line". Superintendent: "The school board school board gave a directive in early October. I felt it was mistake and I asked them to reconsider." (0:38:32); "The board has for the past couple of years, had the desire to meet alone, without administration and do the work." (0:38:59); the reduction came "on September 30th, 2017, when they met in the community center in the afternoon. So the answer to your question is no." (0:39:26).OBS
0:39:52Chair and vice chair disagreeChair: where members said cuts could be found, "there really wasn't anything offered at these meetings." The cuts were therefore "given back to the administration" (0:40:25). A second voice: "I respond to that because that is not even close to true." Irish: "Mr. rap [Rapp] was not there. So he has no idea what this board has been doing when we've met together because he has not been there." (0:40:49); "We were not given a budget until December." (0:41:44); "we were told that budget was prepared two hours before the meeting." (0:41:48); "We gave a directive. It was ignored." OBS
0:42:36Irish: money returned each year"How much money has has the school returned over the course of the last four years?" "roughly $2.2 million. So we've averaged $500,000 a year being returned to the general fund, not to the taxpayers, to the general fund each year." "We will probably cut 300 zero zero and still return $200,000 at the end of the year." (0:43:22).OBS
0:43:33Joe: quarterly reports"I'm going to make a suggestion that you ask for at least quarterly the the budget, so you can go down through line for line and see where the money is."
0:44:56Towle: show the savings"I would like to see to the public a spreadsheet of what was proposed." She says a member's attempt to discuss line items at a budget meeting "was shut down".
0:46:38Retained fund balancePutnam: money left over "becomes a fund balance" and cannot be held over "unless it's within certain, legal, situations." O'Neill: "the Claremont School voted to allow a carryover of 2.5% of fund balance under RSA 198 20" [the retention statute is RSA 198:4-b], "which is about $600,000" (0:47:29); 2014 had "a $1.8 million surplus, mainly driven by health insurance savings", of which "we returned 1.2 to the taxpayers and we retain 600,000"; then "in 2015 is we returned 584, 480, and then in 2016 we returned 326 through 29", with "$175,000" still carried over (0:47:56). The money can be used "only with the approval of the drey [DRA] and the Doe" or "to offset taxes in future years, which is the only purpose that we've been using it for." (0:48:35).OBS
0:50:08Chair: the health trust refund"a large portion of that health insurance money" came back "because there was an order from the Supreme Court" (0:50:14). Putnam asks the board to revisit how it handles year-end balances and to tie retained money to a capital improvement plan (0:50:35, 0:51:07).
0:51:51Ferland: one-time money and the 25 percent questionO'Neill: "Most of that was health care." (0:52:20). Ferland: "that doesn't speak to a systemic problem of over budgeting" (0:52:38); with personnel fixed, "that only leaves roughly 8 million as discretionary"; absorbing about $1.7 million there is "roughly a 25% cut to what's left in the budget" (0:53:25).
0:55:29Adult education workerMany adult-ed students attend "because it is a requirement of their probation, or because they did not graduate from high school" (0:56:20); the director "has to know what she's doing. It's not something you can punt."
0:57:36Deliberative session announcedTranscribed as "47 for deliberative." then "Six six, the clock. 7th February." (0:57:50). The regular meeting's agenda lists Wednesday, February 7; MAP.md dates the deliberative session's recording February 8, 2018, and this page does not resolve the difference.

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each one names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on January 3, 2018, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule applies.

MEDIUM No agenda or minutes for this hearing survive in any district share

MAP.md records no Drive material: the district's shares hold no year folder older than 2022, and the Meeting Minutes share starts at 2023. RSA 91-A:2, II, in the text in force for all of 2018, required minutes that "shall include the names of members, persons appearing before the public bodies, and a brief description of the subject matter discussed and final decisions", open to public inspection "not more than 5 business days after the meeting". With sixteen speakers, several of them unnamed or only partly named on the recording, the minutes' list of persons appearing is the record that would settle who spoke. This page applies the MEDIUM limb of the project's severity rule because the record mitigates the gap: the minutes were written and the board took them up on January 31, 2018 (Cablecast show 9586). What is missing is any public copy now.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2017 codification; in force Jan. 1 to Dec. 31, 2018)

OBSERVATION The retained-fund account given at the hearing does not match the retention statute's terms

The business administrator said voters had authorized "a carryover of 2.5% of fund balance under RSA 198 20", about $600,000 (0:47:29), and that it could be spent "only with the approval of the drey [DRA] and the Doe" or used to offset taxes (0:48:35). The citation is as transcribed; the retention authority that matches his description is RSA 198:4-b, II, which in the 2017 text let the legislative body authorize the district "to retain year-end unassigned general funds in an amount not to exceed, in any fiscal year, 2.5 percent of the current fiscal year's net assessment", for "emergency expenditures and overexpenditures under RSA 32:11" or as a revenue source to reduce the tax rate. Two points differ from what was said: the cap is measured against the net assessment, not the fund balance (Putnam understood it as a percentage of the budget, 0:48:21), and the statute names the two uses rather than an agency approval. His statement that tax relief is "the only purpose that we've been using it for" fits the statute. The vice chair's figure of about $2.2 million returned over four years (0:42:36) is answered on the same recording: most of it was a one-time health-insurance refund (0:52:20).

Sources: RSA 198:4-b, II (2017 codification; source note ends 2014, 190:6; 2.5 percent of net assessment until 2020, 38:25)

OBSERVATION A $70,000 paving job was paid from savings in the prior year's budget rather than a line item or article

The business administrator said the parking-lot paving "was basically part of money that we were able to save through last year's budget" (0:12:03). A resident read that as over-budgeting (0:12:11); the former board chair said his board would have put a known repair on the budget "as a line item" so the public knew (0:26:21). RSA 32:10, I, in the text in force before August 15, 2017, allowed the governing body to transfer an unexpended balance to an appropriation that needed more money, provided total spending stayed within the total appropriated, and required records detailed enough that a citizen asking under RSA 91-A:4 "may ascertain the purposes of appropriations to which, and from which, amounts have been transferred". A transfer of this kind is lawful. The transfer records were not produced at the hearing and are not public now, so the page cannot say which appropriation the paving was charged to.

Sources: RSA 32:10, I(a)-(b) (2016 codification; source note ends 2004, 113:1, in force until Aug. 15, 2017)

OBSERVATION Members describe budget work "without administration"; the record does not show how those sessions were noticed

The superintendent said the board had "the desire to meet alone, without administration and do the work" (0:38:59), and that the $1.2 million directive came "on September 30th, 2017, when they met in the community center in the afternoon" (0:39:26); in part 1 he called that session "the public meeting". The vice chair said the chair "has no idea what this board has been doing when we've met together because he has not been there" (0:40:49). Under RSA 91-A:2, I, as it read in 2018, a meeting is "the convening of a quorum of the membership of a public body"; four of the seven members are a quorum, and RSA 91-A:2-a, I required public bodies to deliberate "only in meetings" held under the statute. The September 30 session appears to have been a noticed public meeting. Whether the other occasions the vice chair describes were noticed meetings, gatherings of fewer than four members, or the board's own public sessions is not in this record, and the page draws no conclusion.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, I (2017 codification, in force for 2018); RSA 91-A:2-a, I (2016 codification; source note 2008, 303:4, unamended)

POSITIVE Every resident who wanted to speak was heard, and a second round was offered

Despite the disorder in part 1, the chair kept taking speakers until no one else came forward, promised that "after everyone's had a chance to speak once people will be allowed to speak again" (0:07:43), and opened a second round (0:44:36). Residents' questions were answered on the spot by the superintendent, the business administrator and members. RSA 32:5, I required a hearing at which the public could testify; offering a second round and answering questions goes beyond that minimum.

Sources: RSA 32:5, I (2017 codification; in force until Aug. 11, 2018)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page