Claremont School Board, August 5, 2020

Regular meeting, mostly in person with one member by telephone and the public by phone and CCTV, devoted to the administration's fall reopening plan (the Cablecast listing titles it "Fall 2020 Back to School Plan"). The superintendent and assistant superintendent present a phased hybrid model (two days in school, three remote, cohorts of about twelve), health screening, masks all day with supervised breaks, and bus limits; district counsel explains liability. A motion for a full-open option plus a remote option, without a hybrid, fails; the board then votes 5-2 to support the administration in developing a hybrid schedule with metrics for changing phase. Two parents speak by phone and three letters are summarized. Built from the CCTV recording's dialogue transcript; no agenda, packet or minutes survive in the district's online shares. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
Claremont School Board (Claremont School District, SAU 6)
Date
Wednesday, August 5, 2020 (the chair: "It is 631 August 5th, 2020." at 0:01:07)
Start time
6:31 p.m. by the chair's spoken clock time at the call to order (0:01:07). The recording's last motion, to adjourn, is at 3:42:39; the dialogue transcript runs 3:42:47. The chair mentions a tape change near the end (3:42:22).
Location
Not stated in available records. Most members and administrators are in one room, masked (0:28:30); the superintendent says "We have a washing machine here in the tech upstairs." (1:25:12), which suggests the Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center. Carolyn Towle participates by telephone (3:37:40); district counsel and the Stevens principal are heard remotely. The public joins by phone ("we have over 30 callers", 0:18:26) and watches on CCTV.
Recording
Cablecast: SCHOOL BOARD MEETING - 8-5-20 Includes "Fall 2020 Back to School Plan" (transcript length 3:42:47; the Cablecast API returned 403 on 2026-10-02)
Minutes
None located. MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting (no share holds a year folder older than 2022; checked 9/26/26). Minutes were drafted: on September 2, 2020 the board tabled them, a member citing discrepancies (September 2, 2020 page).
Board composition
Seven members, all participating: Frank Sprague (chair), Heather Whitney (vice chair), Rebecca Zullo, Jason Benware, Rob Lovett Jr., Michael Petrin, and Carolyn Towle by telephone.

Participants

Everyone heard or addressed on the recording. There are no minutes to check spellings against; names rest on the clerk's roll call as transcribed, self-identification, the project roster and the attribution report. Students are not named.
NameRoleParticipation
Frank SpragueChairCalls the meeting to order at 6:31 (0:01:07); decides the minutes vote need not be by roll call (0:04:12); reads three letters into the record (2:40:12); argues that a full opening would make teachers "frontline workers" (2:23:45); moves the hybrid motion after saying "The chair doesn't usually make motions." (3:35:38).
Heather WhitneyVice chairQuestions all-day masks (0:41:17), the safety gain of the hybrid model (1:44:26) and its effect on disadvantaged families (2:00:36); proposes "a full open with a full remote" (1:47:58); asks what metrics would trigger a change of phase (3:15:31). Votes yes on both motions.
Rebecca ZulloMemberRelays that callers cannot hear (0:28:17); argues the board should stop the mask debate (0:52:00) and voices concern for staff who must return (3:11:02). Seconds the hybrid motion (3:36:16). Votes no, then yes.
Jason BenwareMemberQuestions screening temperatures (0:11:54), cohort splits (0:35:30), adequacy aid for remote students (0:37:57), masks and distance (0:43:38) and the parent survey (2:17:08); moves "a full open option and a remote learning option and not a hybrid option" (3:10:20). Moves the agenda, the June 3 minutes, the face-shield gift and adjournment.
Rob Lovett Jr.MemberSupports the phased approach: "what we're trying to do is tiptoe back into that water." (2:09:17); asks what happens if the union refuses a full opening (2:51:40). Votes yes on the hybrid motion.
Michael PetrinMemberSeconds Benware's motion (3:10:34); cites the parent survey split (2:14:19); asks about mask laundering (1:24:57) and liability waivers (1:51:19); moves the school calendar (3:40:35). Votes yes, then no.
Carolyn TowleMember, by telephoneReports she cannot hear the clerk (0:02:36); later speaks for a phased opening: "I would rather go in as a hybrid face and then slowly open up to a full time." (2:58:11). Votes no, then yes.
Mary WoodmanClerkCalls the rolls (0:02:14, 3:34:34); says of the hybrid motion, "I'm going to have to talk to him after the meeting to get the full content of that motion" (3:37:29).
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Presents the reopening plan (0:04:44 onward) and answers members; transcribed as "Mr. Dempster" by one member (2:27:44).
Donna MagoonAssistant Superintendent, SAU 6Presents the health screening rules (0:13:17), quarantine decisions (0:22:45), parent training (1:32:04) and the calendar (3:39:44).
Richard SeamanBusiness administrator, SAU 6Asks whether running in-person and remote classes at once needs more staff (3:22:15); attribution medium.
Matt UptonDistrict counsel, Drummond WoodsumRelays through the chair a concern about public audio (0:32:39); explains discretionary function immunity (1:48:39) and the limits of liability waivers (1:52:03).
Patricia BarryPrincipal, Stevens High SchoolExplains why the task force chose the hybrid: "We can open and go back to 100%, but we cannot also meet the CDC guidelines." (3:00:21). Transcribed as "Principal Bailey" and "Patricia Berry".
Jeff Small (uncertain)Director of Technology, SAU 6Manages the phone line and audio (0:18:26, 2:33:04); the attribution report rates the identification low to medium.
Patrick AdrianPublic commenter by telephone, Ward 1Speaks "as a parent" (2:33:15) on the Wednesday learning day, remote instruction and phase metrics.
James WardPublic commenter by telephoneSelf-identifies (2:37:09) and asks the board to weigh working families' finances (2:38:42).
Letter writersRead or summarized by the chairKip Ryan (Ward 2), Mike Demers, and a "former board member Steve Ski" (name as transcribed; the attribution report suggests, unverified, Steve Horsky) (2:40:12 to 2:44:23).

Order of business (reconstructed)

No agenda survives. The chair refers to "an agenda in front of us tonight" (0:03:08) and, after the hybrid vote, says "We have other things on the agenda." (3:38:56); the list below is reconstructed from the recording. The superintendent says the presentation and backup documents were posted on the district website (0:08:21).

Items in the order taken up, with disposition as heard. Two votes are by roll call; the rest are voice votes.
Taken upItemWhat happened
0:01:07Call to order; Pledge; roll callClerk's roll (0:02:14); Towle by phone cannot hear it (0:02:36).
0:03:08Approval of the agendaBenware moves; an unidentified member seconds (0:03:23); voice vote, "Aye aye aye." (0:03:29). See flag 1.
0:03:29Approval of the June 3, 2020 minutesBenware moves, Whitney seconds per the chair (0:03:54); voice vote. The chair: "No, not roll call. Because we're all here, Carolyn. Except for you." See flag 1.
0:04:21Superintendent's report: Fall 2020 reopening planPresentation and board discussion, about 2:40. Counsel on liability at 1:48:39.
2:32:45Public comment by telephone; lettersTwo callers (2:33:15, 2:37:09); the chair summarizes three letters for the minutes (2:40:12). See flag 6.
3:10:20Motion: full-open option and remote option, no hybridBenware moves, Petrin seconds (3:10:34). Restated at 3:33:40; roll call 3:34:34 to 3:35:18. Heard: Whitney yes, Zullo no, Benware yes, Petrin yes, Towle no; Lovett asks to be called last and his and the chair's answers are not distinct. No result is announced. Treated as failed, since the board proceeds to the alternative. See flag 4.
3:35:38Motion: support a hybrid schedule with metrics for changes in phaseMoved by the chair, Zullo seconds (3:36:16); roll call 5-2: Whitney, Zullo, Lovett, Towle and Sprague yes; Benware and Petrin no (3:37:51 to 3:38:48). The chair: "Most passes, motion passes."
3:38:56Acceptance of donated face shieldsBenware moves to accept "all those really nice face shields"; Whitney seconds per Petrin (3:40:16); voice vote (3:40:17).
3:39:17School year calendarThree professional-development days added at the start and early-release Fridays moved to Wednesdays; school opens September 3 (3:40:08). Petrin moves (3:40:38); voice vote (3:42:32).
3:42:39AdjournmentBenware moves; voice vote (3:42:41).

Discussion timeline

Times are taken from the dialogue transcript (Dialogue/10942 SchoolBoard080520.mp4.CSV) and link into the recording.

Topics in recording order. Snippets expand on hover or keyboard focus.
TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:01:07Call to order and roll call"I'd like to bring the Claremont School Board meeting of August 5th, 2020 to order." The clerk calls "Carolyn. Tall. Is she. She's here. She's here." [Towle]; Towle, by phone: "I can't hear her at all." The chair: "We just did attendance, Carolyn. And we marked you as here."HIGH
0:03:08Agenda and June 3 minutes by voice voteAgenda: "All those in favor? Aye aye aye." Minutes: Towle asks how she votes; the chair: "No, not roll call. Because we're all here, Carolyn. Except for you."HIGH
0:04:44Opening of the presentationTempesta thanks residents for "a 20 or 30 at least over the past couple of days" letters. He explains "Sunday's meeting": the board "used Sunday, which was a regularly scheduled to be months ago." as a retreat to review the plan, and "We weren't we weren't on TV."OBSERVATION
0:07:37A phased hybrid model"what we have put forward in what you're going to see soon is a hybrid model similar to many other districts, but a phased model." An advisory committee of "as well as a 70 folks" in seven subcommittees, including "I think there were six students", parents, teachers and Dartmouth-Hitchcock staff, drafted recommendations.
0:11:54Screening and exclusion rulesBenware asks why there are two temperatures; Magoon: the guidance "comes from Doctor Chan's presentation". A child excluded for symptoms needs a negative test: "If a parent refuses that, then it's an automatic ten days of not coming to school." Benware: the rules "would discourage self-reporting". Zullo: "we're putting a lot of faith in parents to do the right things".
0:22:45Who is quarantinedMagoon: "if we have a child that has a case, we automatically have to call the DDHS, and they will work with us to determine who should be quarantined". Remote work continues for excluded students; Tempesta: "the short answer is yes".
0:28:17Phone audio problemsZullo: "there's a bunch of messages coming in that people are having a challenging time hearing the audio". The chair relays counsel: "his concern is if the public can't hear when, then we can't have the meeting." Benware: "Hear on CCTV, though." Members adjust microphones and continue.OBSERVATION
0:31:57The hybrid schedule"our proposed hybrid model which is two full days in school in three remote." Cohorts A and B attend Monday and Thursday or Tuesday and Friday. Tempesta: "we have 1800 students." "We can get 12 in a class. That's the driver behind it." Households stay in one cohort (0:37:20).
0:37:57Remote students and adequacy aidBenware asks whether remote students would cost the district adequacy aid; Magoon: "It's not considered homeschool for for this time period". Remote options include VLACS (Black's in the transcript) and Odyssey ware (0:39:23).
0:41:17Masks all dayWhitney: "I don't remember that being an advisory task force recommendation." Tempesta: "if it's voluntary to have them, it's like not having them at all". Benware asks why six feet if everyone is masked (0:44:08). Whitney: "I am getting concerned that the education piece is getting lost." Zullo: "I think it's a waste of our time to try and debate that".
0:56:45Buses and classrooms"We only have seven drivers. We have right now. We've already lost two drivers." Bus seats are "two feet from mouth to back of head." The 2019-20 ridership was "our whole ridership of 646." Principals expect 12 to 15 students per room (1:02:53).
1:09:19Sports and activitiesTempesta: contact sports may be dropped region-wide (1:09:52); he is "not comfortable with it" risking buses for sports. Benware: "Sports are something and extracurriculars are things that kids choose to do." and suggests a revived Connecticut Valley League (1:15:22). On defining contact sports, Tempesta: "I wish I wasn't in a public meeting right now saying, I don't really have a great definition for you".
1:23:17Equipment already boughtTempesta: "Approximately five 500 and $600,000 already on equipment", mostly furniture; 1,000 donated face shields (0:55:20); cloth masks for every student and staff member (1:25:12).
1:26:27Phase indicators and staffIndicators will be reviewed monthly "to remain modify or exit phase". Tempesta: a first listening session with teachers is set for the next day (1:27:29). Magoon outlines parent training, drop-in sessions and hotlines (1:32:45 to 1:38:38).
1:43:27Vice chair's critiqueWhitney: "what percentage of gain in safety are we going with this model". "the number of viral transmission that occurs in the school is going to be directly related, and only related to the number of viral transmissions that are occurring in the community, period." She proposes "a full open with a full remote with no bussing if bussing is."
1:48:13Counsel on liabilityUpton: "one of the defenses is called discretionary function immunity." "the risk of liability to the district increases each time you are doing something that's contrary to the recommended practices". A waiver "would not be enforceable against a family member who contracted Covid." and "I don't think you could you could ask for a waiver for core education classes." (counsel's advice, reported as given).
1:57:14Equity and learning lossWhitney: families with means will use private schools or tutors, "putting our highest risk kids, the most disadvantaged kids in one of the most disadvantaged communities in the state, once again at the bottom of the pile". Tempesta: "we have to open school." Magoon: NHDOE recommends the first two weeks focus on social and emotional needs (2:05:20).
2:09:17Members divideLovett: "Now we're saying for four to to eight weeks, tops." Petrin, on the survey of about a thousand parents: "About 450 were for the reopening. About 250 were for the hybrid is 300 were for remote." Benware: "I do believe that the survey was flawed." and many working parents would be harmed by three home days (2:19:02). The chair: "it's to me unconscionable to ask them to do that with a full open."
2:32:45Public comment by telephoneAdrian (Ward 1): the Wednesday "cannot be a teacher prep day."; remote instruction must connect to class; "There's needs to be some measurable data, for how we are going to determine phases". Ward: working families face "to strip their financial security from them by not giving them." more than one option (2:38:42).POSITIVE
2:40:12Letters summarized for the minutesThe chair: "there were several individuals who had asked that they be, read or put in part of the in the minutes." He summarizes Kip Ryan (Ward 2), Mike Demers and the "former board member Steve Ski", and says "I'm going to give this to Mrs. Woodman and it'll be part of the minutes."POSITIVE
2:45:49Further board discussionWhitney: the hybrid will "transition either to full in time or full remote." Towle by phone favors a phased opening (2:58:11). Principal Barry: "So if we go back on September 3rd, 100%, there is no way in any of our buildings that we can maintain the distance." Benware: a full opening will not mean all 1,800 students (3:03:48).
3:05:07Triggers for changing phaseWhitney asks what would move the hybrid to full opening; Tempesta: "we would probably do that at a quarter or at semester" and "we would probably go right at the quarter right around Thanksgiving." The chair asks the board to "support the administration and proceeding toward that."
3:10:20Motion for full open plus remoteBenware: "I make a motion that we recommend that we have a either a full open option and a remote learning option and not a hybrid option." Petrin seconds. Lovett: "And the administration just figures it out." Seaman raises staffing cost (3:22:15); Tempesta: "If we need more staff there, it could be very, very costly, very fast." Roll call at 3:34:34; no result is announced.OBSERVATION
3:35:38Hybrid motion passes 5-2The chair: "I make a motion that we that the Claremont School Board support the administration in moving forward in the development of a hybrid schedule that contains," "Metrics or indicators for, changes in phase space." [phase] He adds that the motion expects "a timeline and metrics for changes of of basis." The clerk: "I'm going to have to talk to him after the meeting to get the full content of that motion". Roll call 5-2.OBSERVATION
3:38:56Face shields, calendar, adjournmentFace shields accepted (3:40:17); calendar approved with school opening September 3 (3:42:32); adjournment (3:42:41). All by voice vote with Towle on the phone.HIGH

Items flagged for review

These flags are a reviewer's aid, not findings of violation and not legal advice. Each names the rule it rests on, as that rule read on August 5, 2020, or is labeled an observation where no verified rule settles the point.

HIGH With a member participating by telephone, five of the board's seven votes were taken by voice, and the chair said so on the record

RSA 91-A:2, III, in the text in force from January 1, 2019 to October 2, 2023, governs meetings at which a member participates other than in person, and ¶III(e) provides: "All votes taken during such a meeting shall be by roll call vote." (statute text). Emergency Order #12 waived only the physical-quorum requirement of III(b) and the audibility-at-a-location requirement of III(c) (order text); it did not touch III(e). Towle participated by telephone for the whole meeting (0:02:36, 3:37:40).

The agenda (0:03:29), the June 3 minutes (0:04:03), the face-shield gift (3:40:17), the school calendar (3:42:32) and adjournment (3:42:41) were taken by voice. When Towle asked how to vote on the minutes, the chair answered "No, not roll call. Because we're all here, Carolyn. Except for you." (0:04:12). Only the two reopening motions were taken by roll call. The statute admits no exception for a meeting where most members are in the room.

Mitigation: none of the voice votes was contested, and the outcomes are unlikely to have changed; the school calendar, though, is a substantive decision. At the fully remote meetings of May 6 and June 3 the assistant superintendent and counsel had told the board that every vote must be by roll call (May 6, 2020 page; June 3, 2020 page).

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, III(a), (e) (2019 codification; source note ends 2018, 244:1; next amended 2023, 188:1); Emergency Order #12 (Mar. 23, 2020): waives III(b) and part of III(c) only

MEDIUM No agenda, packet or minutes for this meeting survive in any district share

MAP.md records no Drive material for this meeting. The recording is the only public account of the reopening decision. RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes with "the names of members, persons appearing before the public bodies, and a brief description of the subject matter discussed and final decisions" that are "open to public inspection not more than 5 business days after the meeting" (statute text).

MEDIUM, not HIGH, because the record mitigates the gap: the chair works from an agenda (0:03:08), the superintendent says the presentation and backup were posted on the district website (0:08:21), and draft minutes existed by September 2, when the board tabled them (September 2, 2020 page).

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification)

OBSERVATION The reopening plan was first presented to the board at an untelevised Sunday retreat, a session outside this corpus

The superintendent said the board "used Sunday, which was a regularly scheduled to be months ago." to review the plan, adding "We weren't we weren't on TV." (0:06:10, 0:06:52); members refer back to what was said "on Sunday" (2:17:08). On September 2, 2020 the board approved minutes of an August 2, 2020 retreat as amended (September 2, 2020 page), which identifies the session; the June 3 board had set its retreat for August 9 (June 3, 2020 page), so the date moved.

A retreat of a quorum of the board is a meeting under RSA 91-A:2, I, with notice and minutes required; nothing requires it to be televised. Minutes were made, but neither they nor any notice is online, and the corpus holds no recording. For the public the record of the plan's first presentation is therefore the account given here.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, I-II (2019 codification): meetings; notice; minutes

OBSERVATION The record of the two reopening votes is incomplete: the first result was never announced, and the clerk said she lacked the text of the second

On Benware's motion the roll call (3:34:34 to 3:35:18) captures Whitney, Benware and Petrin yes and Zullo and Towle no; Lovett asked to be called last, and his and the chair's answers dissolve into overlapping No responses. No tally or result is stated before the chair moves the alternative (3:35:38). The hybrid motion was framed in pieces (3:35:38, 3:35:57, 3:36:51), and the clerk said "I'm going to have to talk to him after the meeting to get the full content of that motion" (3:37:29). RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes to record "final decisions" and "The names of the members who made or seconded each motion" (statute text).

On September 2, 2020 a member asked to table these minutes, saying there were discrepancies, and the board did (September 2, 2020 page). The chair also made the main motion himself; no statute bars that, and he noted it was unusual (3:10:08).

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2019 codification): final decisions; mover and seconder

OBSERVATION Counsel warned that the meeting could not continue if the public could not hear it, and the board continued on the strength of the CCTV feed

Phone callers reported poor audio (0:28:17); the chair relayed counsel's view, "his concern is if the public can't hear when, then we can't have the meeting." (0:32:39), and members answered that the CCTV broadcast was clear (0:32:58, 0:33:05). Emergency Order #12 conditions its waiver on telephone access and on adjourning "if the public is unable to access the meeting" (order text). Because a quorum was physically present here, the board was not relying on that waiver, and RSA 91-A:2, III(c) requires audibility "at the location specified in the meeting notice" (statute text).

Whether the noticed location admitted the public cannot be told from the recording; the chair later invites anyone {Q(776, "in the community or on the phone")} to speak ({T(776)}). The board fixed its microphones and kept going rather than recessing. A reader should weigh this alongside flag 1: the meeting's remote side was handled less carefully than its in-room side.

Sources: Emergency Order #12 (Mar. 23, 2020): conditions of the waiver; RSA 91-A:2, III(c) (2019 codification)

POSITIVE The board took public comment by phone before voting and put requested letters into the record

No statute required a public comment period in 2020 (RSA 189:74 dates from 2022). Before the reopening votes the chair asked whether anyone "in the community or on the phone" wished to speak; two parents did (2:33:15, 2:37:09), and members responded to both on the record (2:47:40). The chair then summarized three letters whose writers had asked that they be read or entered, and said he would give them to the clerk "and it'll be part of the minutes." (2:41:24). On a decision that drew, by the superintendent's count, dozens of letters in a few days (0:05:13), this went beyond what the law then required.

Sources: RSA 189:74 (2022, 333:1, eff. Sept. 6, 2022; not law in 2020)

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page